Commr. Of Customs v. M/S Oswal Paper & Allied Industries

  
   
 

  !

"#$ %$&'(')* +


 
     

          

   
 * ,-  
 - ,-  
   .$($)#* . )(/01")
/2."3%4&"#$ .#/$"22$55")#  . "')"')%$."')'3%4&"#$ .#/$.$(2)%$)#( "6$(/')%"5  /$.$4$)0$/"( '5$%#/$2.$($)#"22$"5"7"')(##/$.%$.%"#$%



3  2"(($%  89  #/$ 
0(#1(3   :&'($  ")%  $.4'&$  ":  22$55"#$ .'80)"53$; $5/'3;/'&/;"("%1'##$%) <

< .&)('%$."#')

#/$ 55;')7(08(#")#'"5=0$(#')( 5";* > "!

?/$#/$.#/$(086$&#7%(&05%8$&) '(&"#$%0)%$.

$&#') ! #/$
0(#1(&#3+ )4'5"#')

&)%'#')( '12.#89#/$.$(2)%$)#(@

8!

?/$#/$.#/$
'(60(#'

'$%')"55;')7#/$"22$"5

   #/$.$(2)%$)#(89/5%')7#/"#$:$12#'))#' '&"#')  A+BC
0( 3%"#$%B  ++B3'("($5 &)#"')$%&%$ ")%'#1$)#')(8$)$ '#(385'7"#')(")%&'.&01(#")&$( ")%)"&#')0#('%$#/$)#'

'&"#')'("##."&#$%")% &"55$% .').$7".%#'12.#(1"%$")%3/$)&$3($##')7 "('%$#/$&) '(&"#')")%'12('#') 2$)"5'#'$(@

&!

?/$#/$.  #/$  $:$12#')  )#'

'&"#')    A+BC
0(3 %"#$%  B  ++B3  /"(  8$$)  '((0$%  0)%$.  #/$  2;$.( &) $..$%  89  (08C($&#')  !    $&#')  B    #/$
0(#1( &#3+ ")%3 #/0(3 ")9)#'

'&"#') '((0$% 0)%$.#/$2;$.(%$.'4$% .1#/$
0(#1(&#'(2".# ")%2".&$5 #/$5$7'(5"#'4$2.4'(')( #/$
0(#1( &#0)#'5.0)5$((")9&)#.".92.4'(')(A$:25")"#')A &)%'#')/"(8$$)1"%$0)%$.(0&/)#'

'&"#')')#$.1(  (08C($&#')

! $&#') B #/$
0(#1(&#3 + @D -$".)$%&0)($5 .#/$.$(2)%$)#((081'##$%#/"#"(($#( #/$ .$(2)%$)#C&12")9;$.$#"E$)4$.89#/$ ')")&'"5')(#'#0#')")%/"4$ 8$$)(5%3/;$4$.3#/$("5$'(0)%$.&/"55$)7$ ) "&#3#/$.$(2)%$)#C &12")9'(59')7&5($%  -$".)$% &0)($5  .#/$ "22$55")#3;/'5$ .$ $..')7 # .%$.

%"#$%F <

32"(($%89),85$#/$02.$1$
0.#')
'4'522$"5(

<+C

FF

FG
11'((')$. 
$)#."5:&'($3"720.4 H'%".8/"

H$)$$.)%0(#.'$(-#% ")%#/$.(3(081'##$%#/"#')4'$; #/$"

.$("'% %$4$521$)#3#/$2.$($)#"22$"51"98$%'(2($% "##/'((#"7$3/;$4$.3 ;'#/  5'8$.#9  #  #/$  %$2".#1$)#  #  7$#  #/$  ("1$  .$4'4$%3  ')  &"($  #/$

I .$(2)%$)#C&12")9(0&&$$%(')&/"55$)7$##/$("5$ "(($#(")%.$4'4$( '#(80(')$(( .%$.$%"&&.%')759

"6$(/')%"5!

0%7$  ".')%$.')7/'%/0!

0%7$  +

 1E ?/$#/$.(2$"E')7A.$"()$%*

$(A ?/$#/$..$2.#"85$*

$(A