High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/34349/2018dismissed

Rajender Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana

2018-08-10Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal5 pages

#$%&'%()*)+,

#-%+'% )+./#+'#+$/% %$)$)+% 0% *1*

$#$%&# 2#+# %*3+'%+$ #4, 5 6 %*%+$, %% #-#'#08 '0(#$%& $/%3%$)$)+% * /)+'% )+.//#/#98 '0(#$%& $/%(439#)+#+$

/)* 3%$)$)+ /#* :%%+ &)9%' :2$/%3%$)$)+% **%%;)+.

#+$)()3#$ 2:#)9)+(#*%<'#$%' <

%'1+'% *%($)+& (/%'19%'#*$%* #+' (/%'19%' ):1$%* %0%+$)+&

$ ()$)%*" ($8 )+*/ $ ($"#$9)(% $#$)+#$1*#+#8 %=# ) ++%>1 % " /%(#*%#.#)+*$$/%3%$)$)+% *)* %'+$/%(439#)+$ :2+% #+$ #'#1./$% &#+'#4:%9+.)+.$*(/%'19%'(#*$% 3% $/%#99%.#$)+*#.#)+*$$/%3%$)$)+% *8&#$/% &$/%(439#)+#+$=#* =+% &$=/1*%*0% 39$* #+' /%3%$)$)+% */#'$ )%'$

$#;%& ():9%3**%**)+&$/*%/1*%*/% %8)+$/%2%# &#$/% &$/%(439#)+#+$/#'#339)%'& '%4# (#$)+&/)*3 3% $2 %*19$#+$928'%4# (#$)+&$/%*#)'39$*=#* '192(#

)%'1$)+$/% %*%+(%&$/%39)(% .#)+)+$/%2%# 8$/%3%$)$)+% *$ )%'$$#;% & ():9%3**%**)+&$/%*#)'39$* %0% #9(439#)+$*=% %4#'%$$/% 39)(%=%0% 8+#($)+=#*$#;%+%%9)+.#..

)%0%'8$/%(439#)+#+$ /#'&)9%'#()0)9*1)$#.#)+*$$/%3%$)$)+% *0%+$/#$=#*#99=%'0)'% -1'.4%+$'#$%'

?/%#33%#9#.#)+*$$/%-1'.4%+$&)9%':2$/% *=#*#9*')*4)**%'+ ? .#)+*$$/#$8$/%3%$)$)+% /#'&)9%'%.19# %(+' 33%#98=/)(/*$#+'*#'4)$$%'=%0% 8$/% % )*+3*)$)0% '% )+&#01 &$/%3%$)$)+% *)+$/#$*1)$%>(%3$$/% '% & .#)+$/%3%$)$)+% */#'$ )%'$%+( #(/13+$/%3 $)+ &1*% #+'#$$%43$%'$$#;%3**%**)+&$/%*#)'/1*% .#)+ #*1)$=#*&)9%'#.#)+*$$/%3%$)$)+% *=/)(/=#*'%()'%')+/% &#01 )+ $/%2%# /% %#&$% 8$/%3%$)$)+% *$ )%'& (43 4)*% $=#* &1 4%+$)+%')+$/%(439#)+$$/#$$/%3%$)$)+% */#0%& ():92 #)*%'

(+*$ 1($)+ 0% 3# $ & $/% 39$* & $/% (439#)+#+$ 7/%+ $/% (439#)+#+$$ )%'$(+*$ 1($/1*%0% 3# $&39$ 8$/%+$/%2')'

+$#99=/% $ #)*%(+*$ 1($)+ $$/)*$)4%8$/%3%$)$)+% */#'&)9%'# *1)$#.#)+*$$/%(439#)+#+$ =%0% 8$/#$*1)$=#*#9*')*4)**%'+

< %*3)$%$/#$8$/%3%$)$)+% *# %3 (9#)4)+.$/#$$/%2=19'

;%%3$/%(439#)+#+$)+090%')+9)$).#$)+*$/#$$/%2(19'& (%$/% (439#)+#+$$4).

#$%& 4$/#$39#(%$=#*&1 #99%.%'$/#$$/% *# % (+*$#+$92/# #**)+.#+'$ $1 )+.$/%(439#)+#+$ /% * /#0%%+( #(/%'13+ %*)'%+$)#9/1*%&$/%(439#)+#+$8 (#1*%')+-1 )%*$$/%(439#)+#+$#+'/% :

$/% #4 )+./#+'/)*=)&% /#+' %0)#+'#:1*%'$/%4)+$/%+#4%&$/%) (#*$% $=#*&1 #99%.%'$/#$)+#( )4)+#9(#*%8$/%3%$)$)+% =% %(+0)($%'0)'%-1'.4%+$'#$%' </% %#&$% 8$/%3%$)$)+% #.#)+$ )%'$3 %**1 )@%$/%4$%+$% )+$(43 4)*%/%4#$$% =#*

%3 $%'$$/%39)(%:2$/%(439#)+#+$8$/% %83 (%%')+.*1+'%

%($)+ ?A < &$/% =% %1+'% $#;%+%+(%8)$=#*#99%.%')+ $/%(439#)+$$/#$+92$=/1*%*&*(/%'19%'(#*$%*%>)*$#'-#(%+$$$/% /1*%* & $/% 3%$)$)+% * #+' $/%2 # % (+*$#+$92 /# #**)+. $/%4 $ %**1 )@%$/%4$4).

#$%& 4$/#$39#(%+$/)*(439#)+$40%':2$/% (439#)+#+$8$/%#:0%*#)'=#* %'1+'% %($)+&$/% #+' ($8 7/)9% # .1)+. $/% (#*%8 (1+*%9 & $/% 3%$)$)+% * /#* *1:4)$$%'$/#$+(#*%1+'% %($)+&$/% #+' ($)*4#'%1$ $=#*&1 (+$%+'%'$/#$$/% %)*+#99%.#$)+)+$/%8=/)(/ #$$ #($*$/%3 0)*)+*& %($)+&$/% #+' ($/%(439#)+#+$ /#*9%0%99%':#9'#99%.#$)+#.#)+*$$/%3%$)$)+% *-1*$$*%$$9%$/%*( %)+

$/% (#*%*$)*&1 (+$%+'%'$/#$$/% %# %0# )1*()0)99)$).#$)+* =/)(/# %3%+')+. '%()'%':2')&&% %+$1 $*#+' 4*$&$/%()0)9 9)$).#$)+*# %&()0)9+#$1 %'#$%839#(% $)4%&#99%.%'((1

%+(% /#*:%%+4%+$)+%')+$/%/%)*$$#992*)9%+$#:1$#+2*1(/ )+()'%+$=/)(/#$$ #($*$/%( )4)+#99)#:)9)$2$=# '*$/%3%$)$)+% *1+'%

($$=#*&1 (+$%+'%'$/#$)+$/%%# 9)% (#*% %'

1+'% %($)+*#+'<&$/%8#$$/%)+*$#+(%&$/%(439#)+#+$8 $/%3%$)$)+% *=% %#(B1)$$%')+#33%#9:2$/%1 $& '')$)+#9 %**)+ 1'.%8%=# )+ C%+(%8$/%3 %*%+$/#*:%%+9'.%'+92 $*%$$9%$/%*( %:2$/%(439#)+#+$ #0)+./%# '$/%9%# +%'(1+*%9& $/%3# $)%*8$/)*1 $ '%* +$ &)+' *1:*$#+(% )+ $/% # .14%+$* & 9%# +%' (1+*%9 & $/% * %($)+

&$/% ($8*3%()&)(#992:# *%+$% $#)+)+.& #339)(#$)+* & #+$)()3#$ 2 :#)9 )+ (#*% & &&%+(%* 1+'% $/)* ($

9$/1./8$/% %# %-1'.4%+$*$$/%%&&%($$/#$)&+&&%+(%1+'%

($ )* 4#'% 1$8 $/% 1 $ (#+ *$)99 (+*)'% $/% (#*% & .

#+$)+.

(+(%**)+&#+$)()3#$ 2:#)9=%0% 8)+$/%3 %*%+$(#*%8)$(#++$:% *#)'$/#$+3 )4#&#()%(#*%)*4#'%1$#.#)+*$$/%3%$)$)+% *1+'%

'4)$$%'928 $/% % /#0% :%%+ ()0)9 9)$).#$)+* :%$=%%+ $/% 3# $)%* =%0% 8$/%()0)99)$).#$)+*/#0%:%%+'%()'%':2$/%1 $*

< #.#)+*$$/%3%$)$)+% */%3 3% $2/#*:%%+/%9'$:%:%9+.)+.$$/% (439#)+#+$ %*3)$%$/#$)$)*((13)%':2$/%3%$)$)+% *+$/)*(#*%8)$ (#++$:%*#)'$/#$3 0)*)+*&$/% #+' ($# %+$#$$ #($%')+#+2 4#++% +0)%=&$/%#:0%8$/)*1 $'%*+$&)+'#+2.

1+'$ )+$% &% %)+$/%4#$$% 8& .

#+$&(+(%**)+&#+$)()3#$ 2:#)9$$/% *D '%*3)$% $/% :# ( %#$%' :2 %($)+

& $/% ($ /% %8$/%)+*$#+$#339)(#$)+& .

#+$&#+$)()3#$ 2:#)9)*')*4)**%'

7/%$/% *3%#;)+.A %#*+%'%*A 7/%$/% %3 $#:9%E%*A