High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/305/2021allowed

Punjab State Grain Procurement Corporation Limited And Others v. M/S Gill Rice Mills

2025-10-28Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal22 pages

!!"!#$%&' $%$(%)!#$%&'

+'' *

& , - ./ 0-

%& '

) &'

* &'

& + , -!./-.01 +

, -22-.0

"*& '

3&'

*&'

"*&'

3 &'

& + , -22-.01 +

, -!./-.4 -566-.20

% &'

7(&'

& +

, -566-.20 111

./ 0-2 7"("+ # &

- (

# '

) + & #& "

+ -!./-. 8( '

+ +(

(

" )

& "

(

)

+8 " '

( #

(

)

&' "&-#+"

& #

+9:

& +

#&+#+'

)

# & "

; <

& #

)

< + (

" &

+ &

#+ # " =+ &++

+ & +

+ "

& + #

&7 &>

344!@0(

$)(!5!%6 7!%)8@B '

! . !/...

< +"(

# .-! ) (

# " .-!& '

C .2 ."++

&94'

++ & D "&

"+ "

.-( &(

! . 8( '

.-!

/ !/...< "

+ # =

< '#

& 3 + " (

" "

(

C6.!! 2.< & #+2/5# :

+ " #

(

& ( '

9 +:,+ &?@0 # # (

" :

# # + 9:& ( "'

+ +

E . .!& +

( # +E2/6!#+"(

< "&

( 3 "&

E . .!

D C!

. .! .! (

' 7 &>

5.E45.

) + # &( F-6..!-.!+ "

# "

#+ "

D + (

( . .2 .!&+

(' (

+ : &

(

AF- 2/C-.!B&

3#( +

# '

+ +

) (

( +'

2 . .!&(

# ## ' ,0 > "

& &( ( # (

(

3 + -+# < " (

" > "

& &

2 . .!&

. .5

+#&#

GG '

" 3

;

+&E2&/6!#,/2&!/5 ./< 0 .

6 . .5( "

7 -.!!-.5F-6..!-.!&

# 73 "

,-/.5-.50 ( + "

# " #

6 . .5& ( ( +(

' " 3

+ "+#

)

' ( (+

' (+

6 . .5,F-6..!-.!0 #

/ (

# (

. .C .5 H'

(

( '

!. .C .5 < "&' , -...CE-.50(+ "

"+ /&&...

-#(

I6J

: ( &# #

!. .C .5, F-6..!-.!0&-C6-.5(+ "

&(( '

.6 .5 )

' ( ( + &( ( '

.6 ./ ./ 5 "&

.5 "

+ C+

& + /!5/!C -(+ / # #

.6 .5& -C6- .5&

.6 ./ ./

' ( &

+ -2ECE-2ECC-./&(

(

" 8@

# + +

E :

" 8@

& + 3+" (

( + &.!&5/&.EE - C H'

( "

"+# ' , .

./0 6

6 +

4 & 22E ,+ & ?69! **: )6@0 ( + "

5 . .E&

( #"

( &

# +

(

)

+ +

' , E .60 #

"+ 6&C&!&/ -#(

I6J :

' +(

# '

' '

# & +

+ #

: +

(

3++"

5 .5 .2 +

(

, -!5.6-.20(

," D 4 ' 0&( ( '

! ./ .2

' ( , - -.- .20(+

' (+

! ./ .2&( "

7 '

.6 .C .2 !

, -6C-.20(+ #

8( '

&" &

+ # +

+:&

' #

2 .C .2&

& 8@

"++# # #

< +

( &++

) ' +

" +' %# ,% >' 0& &' #

2 .C .2

"+ /&E2&..&52 2( #( +

I6J

+ +

G )

( "(

(

/&5&!&/ -$ ; * % "3!< $= 69! >?$"! #3)(3$%2 69! @!!%6>@@!>43@>648>44$<!#>%#@>648#353!# <369@$@$63$%>6!)$669$(79$(69!!@$%#!%6 3 !%6364!# 6$ !)$"! 2+2 2 A =$5 69! >@@!44>%6 ?!3%7 69! #3==!!%)! ?!6<!!% 69! >)6(>4 ">4(!$=69!6$)B>">34>?4!3%69!5344>%#69!>5$(%6 #!@$36!#?8>@@!44>%63%69!!7368$=$%,?4! @!C )$(6 9! !@$%#!%6 3 >4$ !%6364!# 6$ !)$"!88!>48@$=36>669!>6!$=+2+2'+'+A @! 8!> =$5 69! >@@!44>%6 =$5 A*A 634 AA *!3>4$!%6364!#6$!)$"!3%6!!6>6 69!>6!$=*D@!>%%(5=$569!#>6!$=>))(>4$= )>(!$=>)63$%3! A*A 634469!#>6!$=#!)!! 3!*AEA *<369=(6(!3%6!!6>669!>6!$=:D @! >%%(5 6344 69! !>43F>63$% $= >5$(%6 3% G(!63$%HI / :

# '

+ & "

)

+ " "# , D ! '

5 .5 .2&' (

3++ D "&'

. .6 .2& + (

(

8( '

& < "&

(

# (

> # + # & (#

3#++

+ :+

3#++ + #& ('

(

+ +

8( '

& &

+ '(&

(

" # ( #"

3++"

# + +

3#++

" 8

+ '

6+ 22E (+ +

8 +

6+ 22E

+ &

( +

" '

+ (

&+ &+#

22E & (

(+ & "

3++ +

(

# 8@

+: A $%6>)6%#3> "6-6#"/9>5>%B>%=>6()6(! "6-6# >%#$69!2 * 3"34+* 8

# ( "

)

7 ( #"

( #

' ( !.

( " 8@

+:& '

"+ (

# (

3#++ (

" 8@

8( '

& +

" ( # ' "

3#++

7 < "" +

' (

3++

(

'+=

6 + +'

&2.6,+ & ? @0

( (

( + 8

&' ( (

3++& :

+ 8@

!9>J" >4B39>%

9$(79 $@$!#- $93%32 E'K 6)$5 !)9%$4$73!-6#" 9(%><>4> $>%#$69!2 '

: :*K9>%634>4(4>?)9>%# (69>">6>%73%!!3%7>%#-$)$5$63"!

$-6#>%#>%$69!2 +*:K L$4?> " /!9>$>%#$69!2 '

E:*K (49>% /(5> " 9> >%!J>2 :

3"34:K56>%3/((5"56/>%)9>%!"3>%#$69!2 : EK >4!5#"$)>6! >$)3>63$%2>534>#(2" %3$%$= %#3>2K A$%6>)6%#3> "6-6#"/ 9>5>%B>%=>6()6(! "6-6#>%#$69!2 * 3"34 +* K/>34>9" >B9(>%#$69!2++ K >>5J36 3%79>%#>%$69!"(J363%79>%#>%$69!2 + : 3"34 E'+K<>%>5>%#$69!" >35>4>52 3"34:K

>4>8>4>5 4>%6>63$%-6# " 6>6!$=/!>4>>%#>%$69!2 +'EK 36>53%79""6>3%792 * 3"34* K%3$% $=%#3>"?>935##3%>%#>%$69!2 ' +' !!

" *&

#- +

" 8

7 &' (

3# ++ ( &

+ "& 8@

"( #

' ( (

3 ++ !5

< '

(

' ( &

" 8@

+: '

(

+ < '

& + "

"( # "

3++ : +

( +

$@! 4>%6>63$%-6#">4(B->%#

$>#2 *** *K.>J!%#>%" (9>55!#/(%932 E++EK $3#!!%/$8>"$"6$=/!>4>2+ ' :K>F3 $9>5!#" />5>4>2 %43%!:E:K >9>"3 3%79 " >!99>%#>2 *K !9>J " >4B39>%2 E'K6)$5!)9%$4$73!-6#" 9(%><>4> $2 '

::* - !/ :'

" +

!E +

+ & (

" ' 6+ 22E "(

$- ;'

$<! 6$ !=! @>63! 6$ >?36>63$% <9!! 69!!3>%>?36>63$%>7!!5!%6M N J(#3)3>4 >(69$3682 ?!=$! <93)9 >% >)63$% 3 ?$(796 3% > 5>66! <93)9 3 69! (?J!)6 $= >% >?36>63$% >7!!5!%6 9>442 3= > @>68 6$ 69! >?36>63$% >7!!5!%6$>%8@!$%)4>353%769$(79$(%#! 9352$>@@43!%$64>6!69>%69!#>6!$=(?53663%7 93=366>6!5!%6$%69!(?6>%)!$=69!#3@(6!2 69!%2%$6<3696>%#3%7>%8J(#75!%62#!)!!$$#! $=69!(@!5!$(6$>%8$(62!=!69!@>63! 6$>?36>63$%(%4!36=3%#69>6@35>=>)3!%$">43# >?36>63$%>7!!5!%6!C36O

9!>@@43)>63$%!=!!#6$3%(?!)63$% 9>44%$6?!!%6!6>3%!#(%4!363>))$5@>%3!#?8 69!$373%>4>?36>63$%>7!!5!%6$>#(48)!63=3!# )$@869!!$=& N $"3#!#69>6<9!!69!$373%>4>?36>63$% >7!!5!%6$>)!63=3!#)$@869!!$=3%$6>">34>?4! <36969!@>68>@@483%7=$!=!!%)!6$>?36>63$% (%#! (?!)63$% 2 >%# 69! >3# >7!!5!%6 $ )!63=3!#)$@83!6>3%!#?869!$69!@>686$69>6 >7!!5!%6269!%269!@>68$>@@483%79>44=34!()9 >@@43)>63$% >4$%7 <369 > )$@8 $= 69! >?36>63$% >7!!5!%6>%#>@!6363$%@>83%769!$(66$)>44 (@$% 69! $69! @>68 6$ @$#()! 69! $373%>4 >?36>63$%>7!!5!%6$36#(48)!63=3!#)$@8?!=$! 69>6$(6O

$6<3696>%#3%769>6>%>@@43)>63$%9>?!!% 5>#! (%#! (?!)63$% >%# 69>6 69! 3(! 3 @!%#3%7?!=$!69!J(#3)3>4>(69$3682>%>?36>63$% 5>8 ?! )$55!%)!# $ )$%63%(!# >%# >% >?36>4 ><>#5>#!I =

::: +

$- ;0366!%6>6!5!%62!6$==>%#)$(%6!)4>35 0366!% 6>6!5!%6M9! !=!%#>%6 9>442 <3693% 69368 #>8 =$5 69! #>6! $= !"3)! $= (55$%$%9352@!!%6><366!%6>6!5!%6$=93 #!=!%)!&

$"3#!#69>6<9!!69!#!=!%#>%6=>346$=34! 69!<366!%6>6!5!%6<3693%69!>3#@!3$#$=69368 #>829!9>44?!>44$<!#6$=34!69!>5!$%()9 $69! #>82 > 5>8 ?! @!)3=3!# ?8 69! $(62 =$ !>$%6$?!!)$#!#3%<363%72?(6<93)99>44%$6 ?!4>6!69>%%3%!68#>8=$569!#>6!$=!"3)!$= (55$%O CCC CCC CCC N $"3#!#69>6<9!!69!#!=!%#>%6=>346$=34! 69!<366!%6>6!5!%6<3693%69!>3#@!3$#$=69368 #>829!9>44?!>44$<!#6$=34!69!<366!%6>6!5!%6 $%()9$69!#>82>5>8?!@!)3=3!#?869!$(62 =$!>$%6$?!!)$#!#3%<363%7>%#$%@>85!%6 $=()9)$6>69!$(6#!!5=362?(6<93)99>44 %$6?!4>6!69>%$%!9(%#!#6<!%68#>8=$569! #>6!$= !"3)! $=(55$% >%# $% !C@38 $=$%! 9(%#!# 6<!%68 #>8 =$5 69! #>6! $= !"3)! $= (55$%269!#!=!%#>%69>44=$=!3669!37966$=34! 69!<366!%6>6!5!%6>%#69!$(69>44%$6>44$< 69!<366!%6>6!5!%66$?!6>B!%$%!)$#OI

5 !6

+ 6 + 22E (

+ +

!2 D(

3 ( 5.

) '

"## 6+ 22E (

6 + +

# +

: +>9638>@>6 37>5-3536!#>%#>%$69!" A.!5>>%@$6$5@>%82:

E E2 8@

+:( ;# (

+#+

" +#+

: &

(

": D#

&(( K

3#& ## & & ++ #

) "& ( (

+ ## + #

(

# +#+' " +

": D# +

6+ 22E (

" +

+ &

)

(

" 8@

+:# +#+

" 3 +

( ;

L+

M 6,0+ 22E

- # ( ;

M :

( ( "

" "

+ " :

(

+ "

": D# ( "#

+ # & +

" '

6+ 22E

+ &

( + (

& (

+ 5 ) '+=

:::

"&(

# 7 +

+: +!9>J" >4B39>% !># 69$(79@$@$!#4!7>4!@!!%6>63"! $93%32 E'

(

"+# (

+2." -

) 8@

+: ;

(

# + # +

( ++#+ (

( #'

" 6,0

" ("(

" 8( '

& ( #'

" " E+

'+=

::: ( "& #

" "+# (

) 8@

E # +

(

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

$)!#(!2 *' 3% 36 >@@43)>63$% 6$ )$55!)3>4 #3@(6! 9! @$"33$% $= 69! $#! $= 3"34

$)!#(!2 *' $= *'9>4423%69!3>@@43)>63$% 6$>%8(363%!@!)6$=>)$55!)3>4#3@(6!$=> @!)3=3!# .>4(!2 6>%# >5!%#!# 3% 69! 5>%%! > @!)3=3!#3%69!)9!#(4!

$55!)3>4 3"33$% >%# $55!)3>4$(69>44=$44$<69!@$"33$%$=69! $#!$=3"34 $)!#(!2 *' $= *'2>>5!%#!# ?8 693 )62 3% 69! 63>4 $= > (36 3% !@!)6 $= > )$55!)3>4#3@(6!$=>@!)3=3!#">4(!

09!!>%8@$"33$%$=>%8(4!$=69!

J(3#3)63$%>4379$(6$>%8>5!%#5!%66$69! $#! $= 3"34 $)!#(!2 *'2 ?8 69! 6>6!

$"!%5!%633%)$%=43)6<36969!@$"33$%$=69! $#!$=3"34 $)!#(!2 *' $= *'2>>5!%#!# ?8 693 )62 69! @$"33$% $= 69! $#! $= 3"34

$)!#(!>>5!%#!#?8693)69>44@!">34P !%)!2363)4!>69>6@$6)$53%73%6$=$)!$= 69! >=$!>3# )62 69!! >! 6<$ !735! $= )3"34 @$)!#(!09!!>)$55!)3>4#3@(6!N>#!=3%!# (%#!!)63$% )$=69!$55!)3>4$(6)62 O >! 7$"!%!# ?8 69! > >5!%#!# ?8 !)63$% :$=69!>3#)6K>44$69!%$%)$55!)3>4 #3@(6!=>44<3693%69!>5?36$=69!(%>5!%#!# $ $373%>4@$"33$%$= 9!J(#75!%6$= B(!)9 (@>!43!#(@$% 69!4!>%!#3%74! (#7!3%$#$(?67$$#4><2> !)!%648(@9!4#?8693$(63%$%6>)6%#3>

"6-6#"/9>5>%B>%=>6()6(! "6-6#2 * 3"34+*& *:* ?(636 >63$)$%)!%3%769!5>%#>6$8%>6(!$=69!635!43%! @!)3?!#=$=343%7$=<366!%6>6!5!%6>%#69!4>)B $= #3)!63$% <369 $(6 6$)$%#$%! >%8 #!4>8 3 >@@43)>?4! $%48 6$ )$55!)3>4 #3@(6!2 > 69! J(#75!%6<>(%#$(?6!#48!%#!!#3%69!)$%6!C6$= >)$55!)3>4#3@(6!G(>69!>5!%#!# #!'2(4!

I D "& 8@

+:( #

# +6)$5!)9%$4$73!-6#" 9(%><>4>

$>%#$69!2 '

::*& '+=

:::

6 5!

# + + & + # + + +

. .2 .6 D (

+ / . .6 = / . .6& ) ( E .6+ +#+(

9 & (

( + &

(# .5 . .2+ +#+(

=.5 . .2&

6+ 22E (+ &

( .! .2 + +# +

" ( " + .! .2

( 2 .! .2 =

6+ 22E (

( &

::: ( '

3#++ ) &+

+ + (

&(( '

5 .5 .2

"# # 8@

+ : +

3++ 5/ :

+ &

#& # +

5E )

, -!5.6-.20( "

7 (

" 8@

' ( 7" &

& 8@

A ,0-6C-.2B$- ;%"3!<$=63>4)$(69>"3%7@>!#69!#!)!! $%*E *269!@!6363$%!9>!5!#8$==343%7>% >@@!>4>7>3%669!>3#$#!44G(!63$%>3!# ?!=$!693$(69>44?!$@!%6$?!>3!#3%>@@!>42 3==34!#036969!>=$!>3#$?!">63$%2693@!)3>4 4!>"!@!6363$%9>446>%##3@$!#$=

!%#3%7>@@43)>63$% 9>446>%##3@$!#$=I 5C )

" "+

# +

3#++

& (

" +

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

=$ 69! >@@!44>%6 =$ %$6 =343%7 <366!% 6>6!5!%6 <3693% 69! @!)3?!# 635! 9! >@@!44>%6 <!! !G(3!#6$!5>3%"3734>%6<369!7>#6$69!34!7>4 37966$=34!<366!%6>6!5!%6?!=$!69!!C@38$=69! 6>6(6$8@!3$#>%#69!8)>%%$6?!>44$<!#6$6>B! ?!%!=36$=69!3$<%4>@!%69!!)3)(56>%)!2 693)$(63$=69!)$%3#!!#$@3%3$%69>64!>%!# 4$<!)$(69>3796486()B$==69!#!=!%)!$=69! >@@!44>%6"3#!$#!#>6!#+A+A *I :

& ;

( #"

"## "

D & (

( + 8( '

# # (

+ E .6 .5 .2 .2+ +#+ (

(

6+ 22E ( # )

& '

+ +

' 9 "&.2 8( '

( # "(

)

" '

3++ ) '

(

" "

) '

" )

( 3

) # " +

# " +

3#+ & '+

# & ( ( # + # "

"& +

(

(++

# (

(

3++& "

(# + '

/ ) # &( '

"& '+

+ ( + ' &

# ++

"& '

+ # /!

" : ' (+

# + 8@

"# $$ %$ & $ !

# ( + < +

/5 :' (+ +

+ & - !./-.( &(

-22-. ) # #

< "& -566-.2

2 .5 .2&' (

3++&

// #"&

+ +

#'# " + (

( ( /E +

+#+ &

3 ++ (

+ "

/C # ,0&+"& +

./ 0-

)6$?!'2

$ N F

$ N