High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/243/2021dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Monu And Others

2024-02-16Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh,Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger18 pages

!"# $% & & '( #*+ +$%

,& & -('( '!.'%'

&&&&&& //00'%( 1! 2 $%2 $(3!

&&&&&& /$%#%( 45 &

- - - 45 &

- -

! %( !& '%+ 3 '#6'07 '!.'%'

)$!

'//00'%(-('(& !& "%( -+%83 '90'7 #"$*'(

)$!

! /$%#%( $&

& !& '!#/ :2;'!

'/!+'7 #"$*'(

)$!

! /$%#%( $& & !& /'< :2;'!7 #"$*'(

)$!

! /$%#%( $& & & & - 7

& 3 +% ('%( '//0+*'(+$% <+%8 0'"

($ '//'0 + /!)!!# '8'+% ( =2#8;%( #'(#

>& & 7 /' # 9.

0'!%# ##+(+$%'0 - +$%

2#8

?*02 +"

$2!(7

3'=='!7 63!9.

! /$%#%( 3'"

9% '*@2+((# *3'!8 2%#!

-*(+$% >,A , 2%#!

-*(+$% , !$(*(+$% 3+0#!% )!$;

-?2'0

))%* *(7

+% 3$!( 4 -

*(4&

& 1+# $!#!

#'(# A& >& 7 5$6!

$2!( *$!# *'00# )$!&

3 ';

!*+"# $%

& &

& 3 /!$ *2(+$% *' 7 '

*$;/0'+%( *$;/0'+%'%(

)'(3!

"+*(+; + (3'( 6$!<+%8 +% -2% 8!$ B+% "(& 5(#

'*($!.

+% :'90'%'

'0$%86+(3 3+ )';+0.

! +#+%8 +% ';

)'*($!.&

( ('(# 9.

*$;/0'+%'%( (3'( 3'# (6$ #'283(!

$% $% 3+ 0#!

#'283(!

(2#.+%8 +%

(3 *0'

3+ .$2%8!

#'283(!

"+*(+; (2#.+%8 +% (3 *0'

+% && -%+$!

-*$%#'!.

-*3$$07 32/'%+'

2 # ($ 8$ ($ 3!

*3$$0 9.

*3$$0 92 &

( ('(# (3'( $% & & >7 3+ #'283(!

"+*(+; 6%( ($ *3$$0 9.

*3$$0 !(2!%# 3$;

(3!')(!7 *3'%8# 3!

*3$$0 2%+)$!;&

( (3'( (+;7 (3.

6$!<+%8 +% )'*($!.&

( ('(# (3'( '( '9$2(

& 7 3+ #'283(!

"+*(+; 0)( 3!

3$2 &

3 *$;/0'+%'%( '008# (3'( (!+# 3+ 0"0 9 ( ($ '!*3 3+ #'283(!

"+*(+; $% 3+ $6%7 92( *$20# %$( 2**#&

( '008# (3'( *$%)+%# 9.

$;$% '( $;

*!( /0'*&

**$!#+%80.7 /!'.# (3'( 3+ #'283(!

'!*3# 08'0 '*(+$% ('<% '8'+% ( *20/!+(& & ' # 2/$% ')$! '+# *$;/0'+%(

?&C7 '

)$!;'0

> #'(# & & >

?&CD !8+ (!# 2%#!

-*(+$% , '( $0+* -('(+$%

3'=='!

+%" (+8'(+$% *$;;%*#&

2!+%8 +%" (+8'(+$%7 ;#+*$ 08'00.

?';+%#7 "+# 5

?&C ('(;%( 2%#!

-*(+$%

, !&&&

?&C !*$!##&

3 *!(+)+*'( #'( 9+!(3

?&C '0 $ ('<% +%($ /$ +$% 9.

/$0+*&

3!')(!7 '**2 # 6!

'!! (# +%(!!$8'(#&

2!+%8 +%(!!$8'(+$%7 ! /$%#%( '**2 # '#;+((# (3+!

82+0(&

/$%#%( '**2 # 6!

'0 $ 8$( ;#+*$

08'00.

?';+%#7 "+# 5

?&C >7 ?&C >7 ?&C ?&C ! /*(+"0.&

)(!

*$;/0(+$% +%" (+8'(+$%7 )+%'0 !/$!( 2%#!

-*(+$%

> !&&& /! %(# 9)$!

$2!(&

3!')(!7 ! /$%#%( '**2 # 6!

*3'!8 3(# )$!

*$;;+ +$% $))%* 2%#!

-*(+$% >,A , 2%#!

-*(+$% , -

*(7 7 ($ 63+*3 ! /$%#%( '**2 # /0'## %$( 82+0(.

*0'+;# (!+'0&

A& 2!+%8 (!+'07 /!$ *2(+$% ?';+%# 6+(% 7 %';0.

C 7 *$;/0'+%'%()'(3!

C7 ;$(3!

C7 +< 37 '0<'

'(6'!+7

'+(/2!

C7 (& 1+<!';

CA7 '!#/7 '0<'

'(6'!+7 '3'#2!8'!3

C,7 - :20#/

C>7 - '%9+!

-+%83

CD !& -'"+('7 & & &&

3'=='!

C7 (& '"%

C 7 -'%#/

C 7 -%3 5'('7 ;9!

3'=='!

C 7 - '< 3 :2;'!

C 7 -'%#/ -3'!;'7 $#'0

))+*!7 0+'%*

C A7 $3(' 3 -3'!;'

C ,7 !& %2!'87 & & &&

3'=='!

C >7 -$%2

C D7

6%!

"3+*0 $& 5D

C 7 % /*($!

-$;"+!

C 7 !& 93+;'%.27 & & &&& %+( 3'!<3+ '#!+

C 7 !& $3+( :2;'!7 $#'0

))+*!7 3'!(+'

+!(0 5(#&

C 7 -3!+ %+0 :2;'!7 0'!%# '8+ (!'(

C !"+%# '!6'07 -('(+ (+*'0 0!<

C& ,& % 2//$!( +( *' 7 /!$ *2(+$% 3'# '0 $ /!$#2*# #$*2;%('!.

"+#%* +% )$!;

?&C

5 "+*(+;7 ?&C

))+#'"+( !& -'"+('7 ?&C

))+#'"+( (& '"%7 ?&C

+ *0$ 2!

-('(;%( '**2 # $%27 ?&C

;'!*'(+$% ;$ '( +% ('%* '**2 # $%27 ?&C

+ *0$ 2!

('(;%( '**2 # '%<'=7 ?&C

;'!*'(+$% ;$ '( +% ('%* '**2 # '%<'=7 ?&C ?&C

*$"!.

;$ 7 ?&C

*$"!.

;$7 ?&C

+ *0$ 2!

-('(;%( 1+<' 7 ?&C

;'!*'(+$% ;$ '( +% ('%* '**2 # 1+<' 7 ?&C

+ *0$ 2!

-('(;%( '**2 #

+(%#!7 ?&C :

;'!*'(+$% ;$ '( +% ('%* '**2 #

+(%#!7 ?&C 5 ?&C

*$"!.

;$ 7 ?&C

$2% 00+%8 /$!(7 ?&C

7 ?&C

%#$! ;%(7 ?&C ,

//0+*'(+$%

$!;7 ?&C ,

//0+*'(+$%

$!;7

?&C >

5 '**2 # '%<'=7 ?&C >

5 '**2 # $%27 ?&C > ?&C >

))+#'"+( !& %2!'87 ?&C

-2/!#'!+

!#!7 ?&C

5 '**2 # 1+<' 7

?&C

5 '**2 #

+(%#!7 ?&C

))+#'"+( !& 93+;'%.27

?&C

//0+*'(+$% ;$"# )$!

!*$!#+%8 ('(;%( 2%#!

-*(+$%

, !&&&7 ?&C

!(+)+*'( + 2# 9.

0'!%# '8+ (!'(7 ?&C

+!(3 !(+)+*'( "+*(+;7 ?&E

-5 !/$!( ?&

!/$!(& >& 3 #)%* #+# %$( 0'# '%.

$!'0#$*2;%('!.

"+#%* +% 2//$!( +( *' & D& )(!

*$%*02 +$% (!+'07 (!+'0 $2!( '*@2+((# ! /$%#%( '**2 #&

& 3 8!$2%# *$% +#!# 9.

(!+'0 $2!( )$!

'*@2+((+%8 ! /$%#%( '**2 # *'% 2;;# 2/ '

2%#!

C 63% (//# +%($ 6+(% 9$?7 %$63!

('(# (3'( '**2 # 3'# %(+*# 3!

(3!')(!

?2'00.

' '20(#!'/# 9.

(3;

++ ('(# (3'( 3'# 8$% ($ ;( + (!

;$(3!

'( ' ';

6+(3$2( +%)$!;+%8 3!

)';+0.

+++ ($ /!$"

;+%$!+(.

$% #'( $**2!!%*7 /!$ *2(+$% /0'*# $% !*$!# /3$($*$/.

9+!(3 *!(+)+*'(

?&C7

+ 2# 9.

8+ (!'!

+!(3 '(3 7 2%+*+/'0 $!/$!'(+$%7

';2%'

'8'!7

'8'#3!+7 92( $!+8+%'0 *!(+)+*'( + 2# 9.

'2(3$!+(.

%$( /0'*# $% !*$!# 9.

/!$ *2(+$% %$ /!;+ +$% ('<% 9.

/!$ *2(+$% )$!

0'#+%8 *$%#'!.

"+#%* !8'!#+%8 /3$($*$/.

*!(+)+*'( #'( 9+!(3 (3!)$!7 ';

+ +%'#;+ +90 +% "+#%*

+" C

!"+%# '!6'07 -('(+ (+*'0 0!< 3'# 9!$283( $!+8+%'0 !8+ (!

/!('+%+%8 ($ %(!.

#'( 9+!(3 '

>& & & $6"!7 '#;+((# (3'( %';

+ 6!+((% +% #+))!%( +%<

" /!$ *2(+$% ?';+%# 6+(% ';$%8 ( 63$;

*$;/0'+%'%(

C 6!

('!

;'(!+'0 6+(% ($ *'

/!$ *2(+$%7 92( (3.

*$20# %$( 2//$!( *'

/!$ *2(+$% (2!%# 3$ (+0 *'(8$!+*'00.

#%+# (3'( '**2 # 6!

/! $% 63$ 3'# ('<% '6'.

*$;;+((# !'/ 2/$% 3!&

"+ C

;$(3!

"+*(+; '0 $ #+# %$( ('( '%.(3+%8 +%*!+;+%'(+%8 '8'+% ( '**2 # ( (+)+# (3'( $% & & >7 3!

32 9'%#

;'# '

;+ +%8 !/$!( ($ /$0+*

?&C7 92( 3!

#'283(!

3'# 8$% ($ ;( 3!

+ (!

'( ' ';

6+(3$2( +%)$!;+%8 (3;&

2!+%8 3!

*!$ ?';+%'(+$%7 *'(8$!+*'00.

('(# (3'( '**2 # #+# %$( *$;;+( '%.

$))%* '8'+% ( 3!

#'283(!&

& !8'!# -5 !/$!(

?&E !/$!(

?&7 (!+'0 $2!( !(2!%# )$00$6+%8 )+%#+%8

( !)' * +,- . /&0 #

"$ % &"#'! !(

) ! "* % &"# '! !+) ! ,&"#'! !

-. ) ! / ,

##+,-

# 2

## # # #

# "

## 1 " #"

# ( &' !)' 3

# &4

5 6 "7

)

" 0

0 " &' + # '

#" # # ## 6"

# # # 6#- # 6 ( &'

)' 1 3 ## #3 #3 # #

6 3 ##

" #8

& &

" *

# +,-

# # 29:&:

# #

* " $;2<= 0 6&: 2&>:>- "

& 5'!%# -('( *$2% 07 63+0 ' '+0+%8 =2#8;%( '*@2+(('07 /' # 9.

(!+'0 $2!(7 6$20# '!82 (3'( $%* 3'# 8$( 3!

('(;%( !*$!## 2%#!

-*(+$%

, !&&& 9)$!

-3!+ %+0 :2;'!7 0'!%#

7 63!+% *'(8$!+*'00.

#/$ # (3'( !'/# 9.

! /$%#%( '**2 # '8'+% ( 3!

6+00 $% #+))!%( $**' +$% 7 63+*3 )2!(3!

*$!!$9$!'(# 9.

-5 !/$!( !/$!(7 (3!

%$ $**' +$% )$!

(!+'0 $2!( ($ #+ *'!# /!$ *2(+$% *' &

5'!%# -('( *$2% 0 29;+((# (3'( $%* ;% #(*(# $% *0$(3 "+*(+;7 3'# ;'(*3# 6+(3 /!$)+0 ! /$%#%('**2 #7 %';0.7

+(%#!7 (3!

%$ 8!$2%# ($ 3$0# (3'( /!$ *2(+$% 3'# )'+0# ($ /!$"

+( *'

'8'+% ( ! /$%#%( '**2 # /*+'00.

63% 3'# 9% +% *2 ($#.

! /$%#%('**2 # /! $% )!$;

& & > 2/($ ,& & >&

( + 29;+((# (3'( "% '

?&C7 +( $/+%# (3'( /$ +9+0+(.

?2'0 +%(!*$2!

*$20# %$( !20# $2(&

!8'!# 5 ! /$%#%( '**2 #7 +( 3'

*$;

$% !*$!# (3'( (3!

%$ )+%#+%8 288 (+"

(3'( '**2 # 6!

%$( *'/'90 #$+%8 ?2'0 +%(!*$2! &

( + )2!(3!

29;+((# 9.

0'!%# -('( *$2% 0 (3'( (!+'0 $2!( 3'

6!$%80.

30# '

;'=$!7 63!'

+( #20.

/!$"# (3'( (3'%

.'!

'8 '( (+;

+%*+#%(&

( + 7 (32 7 *$%(%## (3'( (3!

2))+*+%( "+#%* ($ ('90+ 3 82+0( ! /$%#%( '**2 #7 3$6"!7 (!+'0 $2!( 3'

%$( '//!*+'(# "+#%* 3'

'*@2+((# ! /$%#%( '**2 #&

& )(!

3'!+%8 '!82;%( '#"'%*# 9.

0'!%# *$2% 0 '//'!+%8 )$!

! /*(+"

/'!(+ 2/$% *$% +#!+%8 ;'(!+'0 '"'+0'90 $% !*$!#7 )$00$6+%8 + 2 6$20# '!+ )$!

*$% +#!'(+$% 9)$!

(3+ $2!(

' C3(3!

('(;%( 2%#!

-*(+$%

, !&&& 9)$!

0'!%#

*'% )$!;

$0 9' + )$!

3$0#+%8

! /$%#%( '**2 # 82+0(.

*$;;+((+%8 '008# $))%*7 ;$! $ 63% '

600 '

$(3!

;'(!+'0 6+(% +&& *$;/0'+%'%(

)'(3!

"+*(+; ;$(3!

3'"

%$( 2//$!(# /!$ *2(+$% ($!.

& 3 /2!/$!( "'02 -*(+$%

, !&&& *$% +#!# 9.

$%490 -2/!;

$2!( +% ) ))

> - >7 63!+% +( 30# '

2%#! 27- #

# 29

"# ? "

@ -6.77 #:

$;25 A6#'" # ##

"" #

# #

29 :&:

" "#A ; 4

" #

29 :

@ -6.

= $ #:

2%5 A% #

# "" "

# ## #

29-

29 :

)5 (% ". 0 ) !

0 0 #12 333 )'

4 5*6 333 #12 )47 5/*8

# 4 ! 4 9 2 : & #% 1

;

0 #12 5

4 53 65

#12)47 2 %;

/-#' # 29:&: 7;$

" #

## :

# 29:&: 7;$

# A ;3

# 29

:&:

7;$#'

# 29

C 3

# 29D8

& % +% ('%( *' 7 ('(;%( !*$!## 2%#!

-*(+$%

, 9)$!

0'!%#

?&C 7 63% (!'% 0'(# +%($ %80+ 37 !'# '

2%#!

# 29:&:

& #E #

& F6., ;=9== ; $926&:

&11. & "

@ +

>- G 4 #C - 6 # " # # G= 4 #C - 6## ' > &' +

" # '

#( ?

'# # # " &' + "

#" ##

3 "( ?

, #

# # 5$ -(

##'"

# 3 "" # - #

( H

#"#

3""# ( ""

( "

'# : ## "# ## #*

"#( "#*'

" "

&' +

"# #

# * '#''

F &'

+ ## #* " #

"6 )' ## " # ## *## ## # "

6 @ '

## # 1 '# #

## # '#

' .

# #0 "

## #6

# H

< < & - @ # +<1 (" 6 :

A& $6"!7 63% ?';+%# #2!+%8 *$2!

(!+'07 ;'# )$00$6+%8 #/$ +(+$% 6 "7:

"0 0 "&' +

# '

#" # # ## 6 "

## # I# - #6 ( &'

)' 13 ## #3 #3 # #

6 3 ##

" # - " &&

& &

#*.E

JJJJJJJ, @ # & &

#/&4<- )

6 #'

6 6

" 0

# (

## " 2%7 ; '# ( ' #

# (

)&' 6 ##

'"4!

' #

#! 9<7#

6 &' + " # '

( ?

'# ##

"#&'

+ "#

# "

# # ## 6 # #

# #

# # ## 4!

' $ $! 9<7=#

6 ( ?

# #

$ #

# # #

6 # "#

# ( ""# ( H

": ( ## # " # 4!

' 4 4!

9<7=#

6 ( H # #

## # " (

" "

&' + ## # '"#'' #

@0: 6

&' + ## # "# )'

. :

## #'"#&

# '"

.#0

@ ," ?# ## @ '

' & & ! 9<7=#

1'#

1 #

#"# 6 #1 #" 2 .

# . ""#.

= < '#

+ === ;6 0 ".

" # .

## '#0.

' . .

## # "#"# # " 29 %979 # # ==== ;

" # .

= <6

1 4!

' 9 9! 9<7=#

6 6"

# #

""'"

# .

@ '

# # ## #" # 4!

' > >!

9<7=#

- "

" #

# 29:&: 3 #

#3# "

# /&4<0

# "

# ' # # ##

" "" # #

" )

6 # # /&4<0

## # ' #6 6 # "

#: *

6 " "" ## #" # ## # # '# 6 "

## # I#- # ## #6 " "" 6# " # # # /&4<- #

6 " "" 6# #/&4<-/&4<0

6 " "" 6 #'

#/&4<0 29:&:

6 " "" 6 # " # # 29:&:

6 " "" 6#

" # JJJJJJJ

6#"" #

6 ##

" #6 6 " '"#

# .

" #8 /!2 '0 '9$"

?(!'*(# #/$ +(+$% 9)$!

(!+'0 $2!( !"'0 (3'( 3'

%$( 2//$!(# /!$ *2(+$% *'

!8'!# 3!

('(;%( 2%#!

-*(+$%

, !&&&

?&C 9)$!

0'!%# '8+ (!'(7 ('(# (3'( 2%#!

/! 2!

(2($!# 9.

/$0+*&

/'!( )!$;

"+*(+;7 "% *$;/0'+%'%()'(3!

C '

600 '

;$(3!

C #+# %$( 2//$!( /!$ *2(+$% *' & ( + '

600 ((0# 0'6 (3'( ('(;%( '

/!$ *2(!+?

!*$!## 2%#!

-*(+$%

, !&&& + $%0.

*$!!$9$!'(+"

+% %'(2!

3'"+%8 *$!!$9$!'(+"

"'02 ';

*'%%$( (!'(# '

29 ('%(+"

"+#%*&

,& 32 7 $%* '

600 '

$(3!

;'(!+'0 6+(% 3'"

)'+0# ($ 2//$!( /!$ *2(+$% *'

%+(3!

+( 3'

9% /!$"# $% !*$!# (3'( '( (+;

$**2!!%*7 ;+%$!7 %$ )'20( *'% )$2%# 6+(3 )+%#+%8 !(2!%# 9.

(!+'0 $2!(&

**$!#+%80.7 + 2 + #*+## +% %8'(+"&

>& % *!+;+%'0 '//'0 '8'+% ( '*@2+(('0 63'( //00'( $2!( 3'

($ ?';+% + 63(3!

)+%#+%8 0'!%# $2!( 90$6 + /!"!

/!+;'

)'*+ +008'0&

%* //00'( $2!( *$;

($ )+%#+%8 (3'( 8!$2%# $% 63+*3 =2#8;%( + 9' # + %$( /!"! 7 *$/ '//'0 '8'+% ( '*@2+(('0 + 0+;+(# *$% +#!+%8 )'*( (3'( 08'0 /! 2;/(+$% '9$2( +%%$*%* '**2 # + )2!(3!

(!%8(3%# 9.

)+%#+%8 *$2!(&

( (3+ /$+%(7 +( + +;/!'(+"

($ *$% +#!

#*+ +$% $%490 -2/!;

$2!( /' # +% *'

)

3 A -

7 63!+% +( 30# '

2%#!

*":

E :

8 % *'

? K )

I &

- A +% /'!'

%$& >A7 $%490 -2/!;

$2!( !+(!'(# ')$! '+# "+6 $9 !"# '

)$00$6 ;% 3 :

" #

-E :

D& 32 7 '% $!#!

'*@2+(('0 + ($ +%(!)!# 6+(3 $%0.

)$!

*$;/00+%8 29 ('%(+'0 !' $% &

% *'

$!#!

+ *0'!0.

2%!' $%'907 +( + '

*$;/00+%8 !' $% )$!

+%(!)!%*&

2( 63!

(3!

+ %$ /!"! +(.

+% )+%#+%8 +;/28%# =2#8;%( '*@2+(('07 //00'( $2!( ;2 ( %$( ('< '

#+))!%( "+6 $%0.

9*'2 '%$(3!

"+6 + /$ +90&

( + 9*'2 (!+'0 $2!( 3'

/!+"+08 +%8 #;'%$2!

6+(% '%#7 (3!)$!7 +( #*+ +$% ;2 ( %$( 2/ ( +% '9 %* (!$%8 *$;/00+%8 8!$2%# &

& % "+6 '9$"7 #$ %$( )+%# '%.

+008'0+(.

/!"! +(.

+% )+%#+%8 !*$!## 9.

(!+'0 $2!(& **$!#+%80.7 /! %(

'//0+*'(+$% + #+ ;+ # 0'"

($ '//'0 + #*0+%#& & 00 /%#+%8 '//0+*'(+$% 7 +) '%.7 3'00 '0 $ ('%# *0$ #&

- -

,& &

=< C3(3!

/'<+%8!' $%#

$ C3(3!

!/$!('90