High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6937/1998allowed

Ramesh Chand Sharma v. State Of Haryana Through The Commissioner Cum Secy. And ORS.

2023-05-26Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur9 pages

! "

!

! "

#

$ %& $'()*+& ,- ./ +,%/

++. %0- &0 1 2% *13% 3!

&% 0 24%52 " &0& 62 % 7

& & 62% &%8 9 2% !# '

# 7 #

8 !3 % 3 : !

!/!!7

! 2; 1

#1

<%= >? 7 8" !

8 7!

=#" !

# 1 !

# 8" # '

> <%=?#8" # ' 7 8" ##3 #!8"

1

8 / 8!

! !

6 # '/ 1 53 +11 # >*8@3!$!!# ##

> ! *8 @3! $!! 1 8"

68 @3!$!! ! 32 < !

! 3! ? 3

2#

71

3 1!

! "$!!7 7

738#83! !33 " " ! ! "2 #3 # ! ;

#83 ! ! " $!! 7 3 *8 @3! $!!2 #

#

3 1 ! ! " $!! !

2

2#

731 3 !

!.1 ! "$!!2 72

1! ! " $!! 7

7 !

>

$

2# 'A3 33"7

91

# ##3 ! # '2 1

B #

$!!.

# 1

! # 'A8 7

73 !!

" 3" !

1

7

3 7 83 !

# ! *8 @3!$!!$A

2

1 # '!=

3"!

3 #3 #9 7

# !! 7! A

8 33

3 3"1 #

1 8" # '

73 8!! 3"!337382 86

72 3

8" # '2 !

8 7

11 " 7!

! # ! ## 3

> %1

2

!3 "# :##327 3

> # 8" # ' %11 1

>2 #

##

8" 7" ! 7 #

*3##1!

73

!

8 7

31";"#1 13 "!" 2#3"3"1#3!

##

!*8@3!$!! !

7 .1 43# $!! 7

# 7 3 1 2 3##!

##

!!!1 ## *8 @3! $!! .

7 1 3 1 ! .1 43# $!! 7 3 7 #

@3!$!!%# 3!

327 !

@3! $!! 7 12 8! #1 ! # 1

@3!$!!2 8!!

17 ## 9 183## "!!1 3! 1

## 8 9 1 C

1 3 # " #

=# 7

# !

*8 2 " 727 3 1

!

2

1

8!7

8 # 7 97

# D # ##3 !

*8 2 " 7 9 8! 1 !

2

383 8 / 7 !

1

##3 #! 8"

1

78"3"1# 3 %!

32 #3

#81*8@3!$!!78 #!"

=#

3 3"

!!# 7

# !

*8 27 3

A

#3 3"11

!

#! ! ! " .143# $!! $!!

!#8"

# 73 /" 2 78 #

# 9###3!

*8

2 "8!11 3 1

!3 8

8

/ 731

7 # $!!

7 8 *8 @3! $!! ! 2 7 1 3 1! $!! A 2 & 0 & 62 3 % 8" &

& 6&%8 9 2% ##1!# ' 73 1

1

7 33" ## *8 @3! $!!2 7 1 .1 43# $!!7!

C;

7## *8@3!$!!27 !3

%= :27 7 3"

*8 2 " %= : !2

8 *8 @3! $!! 1 .1 43# $!!2 3 !

3 ##383 / 7!

1

# 3!

##

>21

#8 "#2

# "

8"11

B 3"3

!

!2 !

1

3" 8 # 7

8" 11

B / 7 1

# 3 !

##

>2"# 2!!; 7 " " 18 7

#

"#31

2 11 2#

1 2

86

1

383 !

# 2 33 8 ! 3 8 !

&114 !

#3"#"

!

%8 338!381

# .

7

1

3!8 ##

7 #

3! 83/ 73 1

33"

7 # ! .1 43# $!!

71

#"32

72 3 " 7 8 !

1 3" !

7 A

7! A

.

8*8@3!$!! ##

73" # ! .1 43# $!! ## ! C;

# ! *8 @3! $!!2 7 ## 73"

*8 2 " / 3 3 !

# #

## 89 %

3"2

7 ## *8 $!! ##

>

1

3 1!

! " $!! 3

%# ! 11 3 12

73.1 ! "$!!!!

.

# 3 8" 7 1 .1 43# !! C;

7 ! *8 @3! $!! !!

72

3

!337 1 3 !

## 3

11

#27 7## =

3"3

!27; 812#3

!

##

3!2

#3 #8 #

##3:# #!8"

76

1

#

# ! .1 $!!2 7 7 3 ! 3 % ! 68 @3! $!!

3 < 3! ?27 # @3!$!! #!"

" 3"

# 7

##!

5 2 7 3 3 31

!

7 112 " ##

3%8 !

##

/ 7 3 3

7 31

# ! *8 @3! $!!2 73 818"

3! @

##33

" !3 ##

!

3 1 7 1

8

91!

27

1 ! # $!! '33"#3" # 37"

#3"27 3712 9

1

#2 # ! 83/ #3" # # 8

1!

! 68# 7 1 81 +

1 818"3 % ##1!# '

9!

738!

!33"8 883 83

! > !

7 2 7

" 2 8" 913!

##

2!

79 ! "2 7

" #3 1 .

3!3 !33##3! 36 %

# !

87

3! 738##383

!#

27 8## *8@3!$!!3

>

7

1 .1 43# $!!2 7

"2 3

!

## 3

2 7

! ## *8 @3! $!!28

93" E/

#!

2

# 8337 3!

##

>

! ## *8@3!$!!27

"

3 1

!

## 3 33"8"1 1

3 # $!!#31 7

C;

-1

31"2 !

31 3

# ! *8 @3! $!! # ## 3

2 9731 8"

# 2 3 8 31 ##

%8 /91! 3!

##

8"

# 27 3 3 "2 83 8"

#

32 8#

.

83!

;".

3! 27 73

8##383#

##

2 818"

#

3 3!

3! ;

! # 338#1

@3!$!!7

11

8!7 ## 8 9 3381 83 ## " ! 3! / !

#

# !

*8 ; ! # ! " #

.

3 # ! 3 ! 3 #

>

!

" ""

### $ %

! " " " "

"

"

& '

" ( ((

"

')

" ( *

" (( + "

"

"

,

"

"

-

"

-

" ,

" "

"

"

.

""

/0 1 #

38371 3

$

"11

3! 73 8##383

8 8*8@3!$!! 1

$!!2 72

2 !

8 8"913!

## 3

!

!*8@3!$!!/! !

9!1

3! ##383

81 $!!2

##3 ! 3 6 73 !! 2 7 1 8 83 3"12!

8 7

31;"7

1 7 .

7 !

8 3" 23

"

" 4!55

"

"

/555

" $

" % $44567 331 7 8:331 : 12 !

8 % # ! " !12 7 #

337 ; 3"

<%=>?

><%= ? )" 72 #

1

1 ! #

7338 8 !

! 7338

3 33 38!

73

8

3 2 8 #

1

1 ! # #2 1 "2 3 2 # 3 3.

38!

83

3383

7

#!

!

!# ! !#" !

# ! $%&'&(& 96F @

#91: G:' @

# 83 G:'