Rama Krishna Rice And General Mills Through Its Partner Narinder Kumar Nayyar And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!
"#$ %& $'()(%*
+,+
"-"
./()0*"
('$ "*1 $*$/"2 (22)
0/%340 (#) "/#*$/ "/(*1$/ .3-"/ "55"/ "*1 #0$/)
6$#(#(%*$/)
7$/)3)
8#"#$ %& 3*9":
"*1 #0$/)
6$);%*1$*#)
< = +
8
8 =
! " # $ "%&
' ( ) * + ! % , $ -
! / $ "0
'
! 1 "#
2
( ! 3 4 "" "%
8 =>
+ /"2
?@
( 6 ) * + ! % , $ - ( 7 '%8# '%8% ((9 : 7
'6 (
*
"
( ##4 * + : #3 "# #0"- 7 "#& 8( 03 0# #0#0 7 "3& #1 "0 #0#0 7 #0&
#
9 6 (( (6 6 (( 6 6 9 6 ) * + (( 9 9 (( (( 9 (( 6 (6 6 ) * +
%
) 6 #0"-#0 9 (( 6 ( 6 9 ((
; #0"- 9 (( < ! #0"- ( (6 ) * + ( ( ( = 9 ) * + ( & 9 ( ( = 9 >( ( ( = ( 9 ) * + ((9
9 ( = 9 ( ( :9
= ( 9(6 (6 ( >& ! / 7 9 ( ( ( '( < '
< & 6 9 '
< 6 6 * (( (6 6 #0"-#0& ( #0 (6
) * +& (( (: ( (( ) * + 9 (( ( * (( ' ?;&
) * + ( 6 6 6
+ ) * + (: (( ) * + 0% "# #0"- 7 ,& ( = * 6 (: (( ( = ( *
9 ( 6 (6 ( + (( 9 6 ( (
( = 6 (
@
(6 6 ( (6 ( 9 ( 9 ( : ( 9
= ( 6 > 9 ( > :9 * ' 9 (
9 6 6 ( 9 ( 9 (: ; ((
/
= ( ) * + ! % , $ -
( ( ! " # $ "% ( 7 9 6 9 ( 6 6 ( 6 6 : ( ( ( ( ( ( @; #0#0 9 ( ; #0"- 9 9 ( = 8 ( (
+ ( ( 9 (
(6 ( + 9 7 9 ) * + > ) * + 9 9 6 9(
,
9 @ 2 A; ( *
> 8 ,
( ( ( : 9 *( * ( 7
!
" # $ %# $ &'( ) )* '!!
+, - ./ %./
'#( )00*1'!!230, #4% #4 4 56 !7! 4 ( 882*1'!! 331, ' 9 '%' :
& ' 9 ' (
* )'!!08+ 8'!!;4'! 20,
" ' <
2 6666 6666 6666
'/
+
6 / ' " '
/ ' / ' ! '
" 6
,
= = = : = !
" 6 =/ % ! #4% #4 4 56!7! 4 ( 882*1'!!331,6 !':
& #>. ! ( * 4 %' :
& # > . ! ( *4 ( ))+*+'!!
, '!! 2 #4% #4 4 56 !7! 4 ( 882*1'!! 331,
) "= / =
" 2 ' ' / "!? ' '
6666 6666 6666
' ' # @' ( '/ A ':
& %'/A ' :
& ( )) * '!!
)) '!!(4>'*02 ,* @ ' '
?
< "= ! ! B CD (E + 9 ( (
A; ( * C & & C ! (* > (6 9 ( (6
-
9
( (( (6 9 > ((6 ( 9
( ( (6 '!@5$:45E;.$54 A5.;E.
!5 / $ ! ! C (E!
* $ ! > C / E!
!C.
C E!
6666 6666 6666 6666
6 6 7;
E!
/ C " <
7;
<E!
6 B "0
*( #0 (6 >
) * + 6 (: 6 (( (( (( ( ) * + ( 0% "# #0"- 7 ,& (: (( ( = 9 ( #3 "# #0"- 7 "#& ) * + 9 ((6 (:
( = 9 > (( 6 9 ( * ' ((6 (: ( 7 ( 0% "# #0"- #3 "# #0"- (9 =$##$/ 1"#$1 + + ?
DE! $; 9B F &$-)<( *9/< )- 8 $
) "7 C(.* E! .;(&
* !
' 4/. '4 9! 9C' )- 8 ' C ' 4 "/ '49(9G@* 6666 6666 6666 6666B =$##$/ 1"#$1 @+ + ?
DE! '1 - !B F 3+ $
) "$C E $; C<EH<9< ' $ !C. )- 8& / C EH9 ' & !C.9C' )-
8& 6666 6666 6666 6666 '
F ; 4/ F . 56
' 4 9&
23
1 ' 4 . F $
3+
2 ' 4 ' .
3 ' 4 9 . "
3)
+ ' 4 . 9.
1
7
0 ' 4 :
' 4 9 .
)
) ' 4 ' '/ . 7 C
3+ 18 ' 4 : .
32 ' 4 7A I .
32 ' 4 9" . C
33 11 ' 4 $
+ 12 ' 4 C . C
13 ' 4 " # .
$ 1)2 1+ ' 4 "
0 10 ' 4 I.. $
+ 1 ' 4 ' 7 F/ . ;
13 1) ' 4 '/ . 7 C 182 28 ' 4 I&' : . & 4 0 ' 4 $ . 7 C
+2 ' 4 C . 01
= 6 !C. & /
.; E ! 9C' )- 8 & = " / ( * & 6666 6666 6666 6666B ""
) ( ( ) * + ((6 (: (( ( = ( + ) * + 9 ( ( ( = 9 ( 9 7 ( * ' ( ( = ) > 9 ( (
( = * ' 6 9 ( ( ( = = 0% "# #0"- ) * + (: ( * 9
9 ( (6 ( ( = ( ( (6 : 9 ( & 9 6 ( > ( + ( (9 6
@
6 6 ( (9 ( ( "3 * + + 9 6 8 (( (6 6 ( 6 6 9 ( ( ( 9 6 6 ( * ' 6 ( 6 9
: 6 ( 6 (
6 : F
"#
9 @ 2 A; ( * ! " " # $ % &'&( )) 9 ( + 6 + = ? =;&
( : > (6 A; ( * 9 += ( 9 9 (6 6 A * A; ( * 9 (6 ( ( (( 9 6 ( ( "3 * + ( 7
D$
6666 6666 6666
6666 6666 6666
)
7 4 & ' :/ = J'K
! 4 &!4 6 7 " E 6' 6 !K #45 I" 7 4K JK6 &!
4 7 4K @#I " !
+ !
F J K 6
2 ! &!4 @#I " - &!4
@#I 7 " C&F76
; 7 4 @ C&F7 " &!4 6 7& &!4 &!4 C&F7 " &!4 D@ KB ; 7 46=
6
,
&!4 " 6 :
7 4 @#I &!4 "
C&F7 " &!4 @#I 7 4K 7 4@#I
2> 6666 666666666666 !
+ (*=
= &!4 @ 8)
88+ "%
* (( (6 (
A; ( * C & &C ! 4 (* 7 4 (* *
((9 > (6 ((9 9 ( > :9 6 9( :9
8 =
+,+ C9
/< L<F
L<F