High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/36370/2013allowed

Rajesh Dhingra & ANR v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-12-03Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain4 pages

!"#

#$%&% '( #$#)*#+ , - !"#

#$%&% '( #$#)*#+ , - !.#&/ /%'0+! !'1 !'

22222222#"%"% '#+& 3#+&4& 5"!"#

4'.!* !'1 "/#+& 222222#&6 '1#'"& ( ( ( ( 7 8 52 5 5

7 8 52 5 5

+#&#'"

+#&#'"( +2 5/!) 8!9 /!99!, 1:

$!"#

+ "/# 6#"%"% '#+&2 +2 252 5#;/ ',

4'.!*2 +2 %'#&/ +#/!', 1:

$!"#

+ +#&6 '1#'" #&6 '1#'" 2 %' 6#+& '2 <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<<

#"%"% '#+& /!:# %9#1 "/%& 6#"%"% ' 4'1#+ 5#$"% ' =

"/# 1#

+%)%'!9 + $#14+#, >

+ ?4!&/%'0

2 1!"#1

, 4'1#+ 5#$"% '& , , =,

"/# '1%!' #'!9 1#, = 77

+ &/ +", +#0%&"#+#1 !" 9%$# 5"!"% ' %:%&% ' 2 3!+1/)!', 841/%!'!

%"@, %&"+%$" 841/%!'! !'1 !99 $ '&#?4#'"%!9 6+ $##1%'0& !+%&%'0 "/#+# ), ' "/# *!&%&

)%&#2 8#!+'#1 $ 4'&#9

+ "/# 6#"%"% '#+ !& A#99 !& 9#!+'#1 4'&#9

+ +#&6 '1#'" /!:# &4*)%""#1 "/!" 6!+"%#& /!:# !)%$!*9@ &#""9#1 "/#%+ 1%&64"#2 3%1# +1#+ 1!"#1 -2 , "+%!9 4+" A!& 1%+#$"#1 "

+#$ +1 "/# &"!"#)#'"&

"/# 6!+"%#& !'1 &#'1 %"& +#6 +" A%"/ +#0!+1 "

0#'4%'#'#&&

"/# $ )%&# #

#$"#1 *#"A##' "/# 6!+"%#&2

' 64+&4!'$# "

"/# &!%1 +1#+, +#&6 '1#'"

!66#!+#1 *#

+# "/# "+%!9 4+" !'1 )!1# "/#

A%'0 &"!"#)#'"( B5"!"#)#'"

)69!%'" !+*/!.!' C!4+ AD 8"2 4+$/!+!' 5%'0/ +D 4&# , 5#$"

+*!' &"!"#, !)!964+, 841/%!'!2 /!" /!:# $ )%&# "/# )!""#+ A%"/ !.#&/ /%'0+! !'1 5!/%9 /%'0+! %' "/%& +#0!+1 A# /!:# !9+#!1@ #E#$4"#1 '# $ )%&# 1##1, "/# +%0%'!9 )%&# 1##1

A/%$/ 69!$#1 ' +#$ +1 %' "/# '7*9# %0/ 4+"2 /!:# &##' "/!" $ )%&# 1##1 E2 , %' "/# 4+", A/%$/ *#!+& )@ &%0'!"4+#&2

"/ "/# 6!+"%#&, "/%& $ )%&# %& *%'1%'0 46 ' 4&2 /!:# &%0'#1 "/%& $ )%&# 1##1 :

94'"!+%9@ A%"/ 4" !'@ 6+#&&4+# ) !'@ &%1# !'1 4"

)@ A'

+## A%992 /!:# '

*.#$"% ' %

"/# 2D

4'1#+ 5#$"% D=DD

, 25 %:%&% ' '

2, 841/%!'! +#0%&"#+#1 !0!%'&" !.#&/ /%'0! !'1 5!/%9 /%'0+! %& ?4!&/#12F 1!@, +#&6 '1#'" 2 %& 6+#&#'" %' 6#+& ' !'1 /!& 69!$#1 ' +#$ +1 "/# 6/ 6@

/#+ !1/!!+ !+12 5/# /!& !1)%""#1 "/# !$"4)

)%&#1 *#"A##' "/# 6!+"%#& !'1 /!& &"!"#1 "/!" &/# /!& '

*.#$"% ', % "/# %' ?4#&"%

+1#+#1 "

*# ?4!&/#12 5/# /!& "#'1#+#1 ' +#$ +1 /#+

%1!:%" %' "/%& +#0!+12 8#!+'#1 5"!"# $ 4'&#9 /!& &4*)%""#1 "/!" !

"#+ %':#&"%0!"%

"/# $!&#, $!'$#99!"% ' +#6 +" /!& *##' 6+#6!+#1

' !$$ 4'"

)%&# *#"A##' "/# 6!+"%#&2

& 6#+ "/# 499 #'$/ .410)#'"

"/%& 4+" %'

C49A%'1#+ 5%'0/ !'1 "/#+& :&2 5"!"#

4'.!*, C49A%'1#+ 5%'0/ !'1 "/#+& :&2 5"!"#

4'.!*, +%)%'!9 - +%)%'!9 - +%)%'!9 - +%)%'!9 - , %0/ 4+" /!& 6 A#+ 4'1#+ 5#$"% ' =

+222 "

!99 A "/# $ )6 4'1%'0

'$ )6 4'1!*9#

#'$# !'1 ?4!&/ "/# 6+ &#$4"% ' A/#+# "/# %0/ 4+"

#9" "/!" "/# &!)# A!& +#?4%+#1 "

6+#:#'" "/# !*4&#

"/# 6+ $#&&

!'@ 4+"

+ "

"/#+A%&# &#$4+# "/# #'1&

.4&"%$#2 /%& 6 A#+

?4!&/%'0 %& '

" $ %'#1 "

)!"+%) '%!9 1%&64"#& !9 '#2 '7*9# "/# 6#E 4+" %' "/# $!&#

%!' 5%'0/ :&2 %!' 5%'0/ :&2 %!' 5%'0/ :&2 %!' 5%'0/ :&2 5"!"#

4'.!* !'1 !'

5"!"#

4'.!* !'1 !'

5"!"#

4'.!* !'1 !'

5"!"#

4'.!* !'1 !'

+92 -

+92 -, /!& /#91 !& 4'1#+( B-2 /# 6 &%"% ' "/!" #)#+0#& ) "/# !* :# 1%&$4&&% ' $!' *# &4))!+%&#1 "/4&( "/# 6 A#+

"/# %0/ 4+" %' ?4!&/%'0 ! $+%)%'!9 6+ $##1%'0 +

+ $ )69!%'" %' #E#+$%&#

%"& %'/#+#'" .4+%&1%$"% 1%&"%'$" !'1 1%

#+#'"

) "/# 6 A#+ 0%:#' "

$+%)%'!9 $ 4+"

+ $ )6 4'1%'0 "/#

#'$#& 4'1#+ 5#$"% '

"/# 1#2 '/#+#'" 6 A#+ %&

A%1# 69#'%"41# A%"/ '

&"!"4"

+@ 9%)%"!"% ' *4" %" /!& "

*# #E#+$%&#1 %' !$$ +1 A%"/ "/# 04%1#9%'# #'0+!

"#1 %'

&4$/ 6 A#+ :%GH % "

&#$4+# "/# #'1&

.4&"%$# + %% 6+#:#'" !*4&#

"/# 6+ $#&&

!'@ 4+"2 ' A/!"

$!&#& 6 A#+ "

?4!&/ "/# $+%)%'!9 6+ $##1%'0 )69!%'"

+ 22 )!@ *# #E#+$%&#1 A/#+# "/#

#'1#+ !'1 :%$"%) /!:# &#""9#1 "/#%+ 1%&64"# A 1#6#'1 ' "/# !$"& !'1 $%+$4)&"!'$#&

#!$/ $!&# !'1 '

$!"#0 +@ $!' *# 6+#&$+%*#12 A#:#+, *#

+# #E#+$%&#

&4$/ 6 A#+, "/# %0/ 4+" )4&" /!:# 14# +#0!+1 "

"/# '!"4+# !'1 0+!:%"@

"/# $+%)#2 #%'

4& !'1 &#+% 4&

#'$#&

)#'"!9 1#6+!:%"@

#'$#& 9%;# )4+1#+, +!6#, 1!$ %"@, #"$2 $!''

" *#

%""%'09@ ?4!&/#1 #:#' "/ 40/ "/# :%$"%) + :%$"%)I&

!)%9@ !'1 "/#

#'1#+ /!:# &#""9#1 "/# 1%&64"#2 54$/

#'$#& !+# '

" 6+%:!"# %' '!"4+# !'1 /!:# &#+% 4& %)6!$"

' & $%#"@2 5%)%9!+9@, !'@ $ )%&# *#"A##' "/# :%$"%) !'1

#'1#+ %' +#9!"% ' "

"/#

#'$#& 4'1#+ &6#$%!9 &"!"4"#& 9%;# +#:#'"%

++46"% $"

+ "/#

#'$#& $ ))%""#1 *@ 64*9%$ &#+:!'"& A/%9# A +;%'0 %' "/!" $!6!$%"@ #"$H $!''

6+ :%1#

+ !'@ *!&%&

+ ?4!&/%'0 $+%)%'!9 6+ $##1%'0& %':

9:%'0 &4$/

#'$#&2 4" "/# $+%)%'!9 $!&#& /!:%'0 :#+A/#9)%'09@ !'1 6+#1 )%'!"%'09@ $%:%9 9!:

4+ &"!'1 ' 1%

#+#'"

"%'0

+ "/# 64+6 &#&

?4!&/%'0, 6!+"%$49!+9@ "/#

#'$#& !+%&%'0 ) $ ))#+$%!9, %'!'$%!9, )#+$!'"%9#, $%:%9, 6!+"'#+&/%6 + &4$/ 9%;# "+!'&!$"% '& + "/#

#'$#& !+%&%'0 4"

)!"+%) '@ +#9!"%'0 "

A+@, #"$2 "/# !)%9@ 1%&64"#& A/#+# "/# A+ '0 %& *!&%$!99@ 6+%:!"# + 6#+& '!9 %' '!"4+# !'1 "/# 6!+"%#& /!:# +#& 9:#1 "/#%+ #'"%+# 1%&64"#2 ' "/%& $!"#0 +@

$!&#&, %0/ 4+" )!@ ?4!&/ $+%)%'!9 6+ $##1%'0& %

%' %"& :%#A, *#$!4&#

"/# $ )%&# *#"A##' "/#

#'1#+ !'1 :%$"%), "/# 6 &&%*%9%"@

':%$"% +#) "# !'1 *9#!; !'1 $ '"%'4!"%

$+%)%'!9 $!&# 491 64" !$$4&#1 "

0+#!"

66+#&&% ' !'1 6+#.41%$# !'1 #E"+#)# %'.4&"%$# A 491 *# $!4&#1 "

/%) *@ '

?4!&/%'0 "/# $+%)%'!9 $!&# 1#&6%"# 499 !'1 $ )69#"# &#""9#)#'" !'1 $ )%&# A%"/ "/# :%$"%)2 '

+1&, "/# %0/ 4+" )4&" $ '&%1#+ A/#"/#+ %"

491 *# 4'

!%+ + $ '"+!+@ "

"/# %'"#+#&"

.4&"%$# '"%'4# A%"/ "/# $+%)%'!9 6+ $##1%'0 '"%'4!"%

"/# $+%)%'!9 6+ $##1%'0 A "!'"!) 4'" "

!*4&#

6+ $#&&

9!A 1#&6%"# &#""9#)#'" !'1 $ )%&# *#"A##' "/# :%$"%) !'1 A+ '01 #+ !'1 A/#"/#+ "

&#$4+# "/# #'1&

.4&"%$#, %" %& !66+ 6+%!"# "/!" $+%)%'!9 $!&# %& 64" "

!' #'1 !'1 % "/# !'&A#+ "

"/# !* :# ?4#&"% '& %& %'

%+)!"%:#, "/# %0/ 4+" &/!99 *# A#99 A%"/%' %"& .4+%&1%$"% ' "

?4!&/ "/# $+%)%'!9 6+ $##1%'02F 5%'$# "/# 6!+"%#& /!:# !++%:#1 !" ! $ )%&# !'1 /!:# 1#$%1#1 "

9%:# %' 6#!$#, '

4&# 49 64+6 &# A 491 *# &#+:#1 %' !99 A%'0 "/# $+%)%'!9 6+ $##1%'0& "

'"%'4#2

$$ +1%'09@, "/%& 6#"%"% ' %& !99 A#12 2 1!"#1

, 4'1#+ 5#$"% '& , , =,

, +#0%&"#+#1 !" 9%$# 5"!"% ' %:%&% ' 2 3!+1/)!', 841/%!'!

%"@, %&"+%$" 841/%!'! !'1 !99 "/# $ '&#?4#'"%!9 6+ $##1%'0&, !+%&%'0 "/#+# ), !+# ?4!&/#12 5

#$#)*#+ , - #$#)*#+ , - #$#)*#+ , - #$#)*#+ , - )!/!:%+