High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17025/2019allowed

Amit Kumar v. Goodyear India Ltd

2024-04-01Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

!"#$%$%

& '()$ * )* )) ( ****

!" #

$ %

!"

$!

&

!" !" #

*+#!

,"-!. /0 $ '()

* & "#+ ,

!- " ./0 +

+

- 1 # "

2 "2 3 (4/5(4 2

' 6

() " .785.07 + % 22 09 (( 07(/' 6

0) :+ 2 ,!

; "2 ! %" ,

# "

2 '0)

< # # " # "

"2 ;" 2

=

+ %

%

# 2 < + 2 %

0> (7 077/#22% , #*

2 "

%

7( 07(0 , " ?

,2 % , 2 #

# " "" , # "2 ;" 2 @ " "2 2 "22 " 2 " # A% "

"2

- 2 - #2#22 22; #3 <

% %

, 3 * - 6

2# , "" ,% 22% 2

22

2 *

;" #

22 !"

"2 # (/ >/ >075;

2 2 2

"2 , #

2"

(.

07(.' 6

.)#22% ,

2 (0 07(4 A 1 # "2 ;" - B'C)' 6

8) *

;" 2 " ;,2 #2 +!2 3 (4(4507(4 #

"!

# (( 9> (9D5;

A% % %" &

7/ 7/ 07(/, 2+!2:

'

E! ) 2' 6

9) '>)

*

#

;+

% #2 "

2"2 1 (7 07(4 22

2

#

;" "

!

# ,

"

2 "2 " ! 09 (( 07(/ ' 6

0) " 22 # "

2 ".78F.07 + '.)

" 2# " %

2 2 #

;+ % &,

,2% 2"22 " 2 # 2 % &,

,2"22 " 2 "

# " # "% !

"

- 3 - -%2

# , 2 @ % 2

,2# , "22 "" # - '4)

## "

".78 .07 + # !

"2

2 2 "

, #

2 " %"

% "

"

, # !

"

# " A #

1 # ,

# " ,

# %2 !

" ,

;" " 2

"" %

"

"

%

1 2 , , @ %" # 2 " # !

2 !

22

- 2 "

07(> 22 " 07(. -

#

;" 2

"2 '8)

B 2

" 2#

;" #2

2 %

,

!

- , ## # # % "22 " # 2" A %"%

% ?E , % "

%22 % @ %22 !

%

2 2#

, @

07(> " 07(. % @ E , # "2

"

- 4 - %

, , !

,

& @ "" '9)

$ %

!" ,

$!

&

!

2

E , 2 % "2 + "

!

- % , 2

# "2 +

#

"2 + %"

,2 # " , 2

2 ,2 # - # !

" -%# " # "2 1

% - ! % 207(. - * % , " " , "2 , " " !

5,2 ,

'/)

2

" 2 #

" 'D)

# ,!

" "

,

"!

"22 %

;" 2 #

, " % # % 2 "

%

1

, !

% 2

1

,

, #

;"

@ '(7)

@!

" # % - 2

2 52" %" !

!

2

" !2!

, " -

2

" !2!

"

" " !

- 5 - -%2

#"

2 52"# " B " 2" # ,

;" 2 "

" 6

>%" (.

07(>%" 1!" 22 - "2

2" #

;"

%22 " "%"" , 2 , 2

# 2

% - "

, # ,

*

! # 2 (.

07(> #

;" 22 2

,

;

! !

"

# $ $

%

!

! &

$

% ! ! '

! $

$ (

$ !

)

*

(

$

% !

(

!

'(()

2 "!2 #2 ,

;

"

-

"!

# (( 9> (9D5; 2 %

2# ,

+!2+

# , "

# "

#

- 6 -

&

7/ 7/ 07(/

;"2 52 ### 2 !

# " ;

!

# !

%%

22

!

!

# 2

"2 "

!

,

;2 ## %" %

!

; * ,

# ".78 .07 + 2" , , !

, %"

;

" ,2 " 2 ,

! '(0)

# " # % #+

;2 ###2 #

"!

# (( 9> (9D5; % "

% ; "2

"!

# (/ >/ >075; ##

"

#, 22

22 ,2 ,

"!

2 - ##

,

62

;2 ## '(>)

"2

""

!

2

"2 #

"!

2

,

;" 2# ,

#, # 2 , "" " "

% "" %

#

;" # #2 "

2"2

'(.)

% 22 2 "

2 "" , # #

- ! !

%

- 7 - 2 !

"" *

& " # + " ./0 +

+ %

, ,

" 2 " 2

"

2 "!2

"!

,

, !

"

2"2 ,

;" &

*

;

" % ##2 2 ""

# #&

# +!2 + % " , #22 %

"

2 "

%

# %"

;" , "" ,2 #"""

!

"

2 "

*! %#

# "# 6+

'(4)

" &

, +!2 + #

"!

#2

;+ ,

" 7/ 7/ 07(/ %

,

09 (( 07(/

" # +!2 +

;+ # " ""2 09 (( 07(/

,

;+ ""

2 # " # +!2 +

, 2

, %;, "

# 2 % * ""

#

;+ 2

" ,2 " ; " , 22% - + # &" 2 # 2

- 8 - '(8)

2 "

" , 2 "

!"#$ % &'(!

)" *+ , %

, 6+ 2 , ; +, - )

!

#

$

% $ .

%

$

/ #

$ ! !

! $

'(9)

*

% "

#+ "./0# +

+ !

% 22-% % 22

"

#

)& - .!/ +,,

+

0 %

,% 2 % " ./0+

+"2, "

, # "

# " % "

#&"

%

22

G # - # "

! 2 # " " ## "

- " ""

!

" !

22

5 !

G "

"22 " # - "

'(/)

G

,!

22% "2 3 (4/5(4 ' 6

() % 22 09 (( 07(/ , :+ 2 "2

,1 '(D)

+ # " "!2 #

"!

#2 ,

;2 ##% %" # # 2

"

- 9 -

"

,2"2

!

(( 9> (9D5;0 1234345637

!

%

8 # !

2 H %"

;

" 2

"2 22

%" %

#, # 2 # !2, +!2+ " H ,

,& "

2 # ##" 2#

;

+ %" " " " "2 % # "

;" ""2""

# "# 2 # "!2 , #

" 2 2 ! ,2 ""2

"

2 " ,

2

% 2 !

,

;" & 2 2

!

'07)

A ! !

#2" ,!

" #" %

2 "

, '0()

*

#

1 # " ""#

,

% !

6 #""

2 2# ", #

+ "

"

;" 22 "# (2 -#%" 47 7775; 22, " # 2

%" % # "

,

;+ # &" 2 "

#2 % # 2 , 47 7775; 22, # % 2#

#2 + " .9 +

- 10 - '00)

" "

%0# #

#"

# "# 2 "

, #

+ # # " '0>)

"" 2 7( 7.

070. 99

*+#!

,"-!. /

-!.

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No