High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/747/2003dismissed

Madan Pal & ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2019-11-27Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

! "# $ %%!! &#' (")*#+ $ % # # % #) ,"-. #"%%!!

# &/# 01-%'+.2 #!- *#+

#!+-"%#%#' #+ #"

#0! ,5"6!"5 %# ,+!%'# 0#+!1# ,#,# 7 * 8 " 0%! 6" 9- 1#"# #0 9+ !5#!, , "0# %#0#+!8"+5#, ,.!!,6'#!8"#5

0 15 "50#+!85"!1 , "#

#1' .!!,6'#!-' ! *#"

6'0#". ,%!%%#"#8 !#" #0" ,"0 ""-5"#*#"6'0## "" , #0 "1/- !."5##-5 "01+*#"6'0#8#1 ," #0# #"! 5#"!""9''1" "1' "

!!5 8"0%! 6"9#'""#' "!! ,"! -" 1""':! # 5+ #0"%! ,5""##%.5% 8.#!"# %# ,"#"%-"5.# #0''01" 9'# "%! ! ;#!# "+#- ' " ' 9'# #0- #% 5"" #0 !"1 #,# 1""'5# , #!

(" ' 5# 0! 5# #0 # " # -"+"00"0'## #" %!%#+-5""5% ,

#1+ , ,/ 51'"'## #""%

("0%! 6"9,"0 ##5"" %!#-5"#0/ , #0 "0 #'<"%! #0!=>7

# " '

> ?"#0 5#,# !) "" ("> ., , # / % " #0-1! #"-

0%+##,"!! !.##,#%#%# ,! %#!"#.# 00 ("> ., , # %#%# <'#%#5"#,#'

'#!" #0

*,"%0#0@0 ' "1+

(51'!!5##.##0"1+- #'!%0#0@0

)'"1'!!! ,5"0%! 1! "##!5#" .#" %! ("#5#"! ""###% , " 9'# (" '## 5,%",#%" !%! " 5,%#%# " " ' 5# ## ##,

%# 6"9A0%! ""0 0%#0 '

#) ";. %'#' "#-' B!,#.#%!

?1##0"'15!!-5"""1 / % .C'#00 '*#"6'0#", #.#'

#+0%!#0"' #"! ' ("%! "%!#.#+5#%#%#

'# ,"'# ., -"##0#.##0" '-"0%+"!! !.##,5# =)B

""%!5#'

1 5#/ , 0%+ "!!5'

".1 ##0"%!#.##0 !

#0%! ., "##0!-

"!! , "'5%#%# ! "'# D'!,#=#!-=#1

%# "!! " '# D'!

,#=#!-=#1-"'%%!%'0 #!'% ""!! 1""'# %#. '

# ) #

(" , " '

# )

> @!'.!+ #1! 1+ " '# ) -!# D'!,#>!-=#1." ##

00""'#!# ) D',-=#1-#05"#5 #'"'# !# !) D',-=#1

E" "5#. "'#!# !) D',-=#1-" ,"%#0 "#,#" '

#5") > ?"#05!-"#,"1"" '# ,!+-5""-"+%! ,'!+ !0 #!

("5" @#. "%#'

'# , " '# . - " %#'

@0 0 +"# 5 E6"#9- E 9+ !- E # )'"#6"'# - E"'.) ,"- 5#- E? 1!0#) ,"- EF)".6'0#-"!0- E)> 0 - E4*)"#) ,"- E 1!)'/"1#) ,"- E 1! )'/ # ) ,"- E> %# " B!- E 2'!1)"#0 E ) 9+

? E"""%#' . !

)0 "'5###'

- 5""!!" #0 ,#'0 %%# , , '" ' 5# %' "0- 1' "+ " !!, , " "+ 5#

8 #0 5

#'#0 !"# "5 ,#! #' #0 ! .#''# "0 + 08""+ "1 !!+0%! " > . -"'"@0 E * &9+ ) ,"- E * 6'0#- E 1! 9 #6'0#-E&% -E? 1!)#5 6'0# EF 1!""

# "# , #,'0 - !# #! '# . 9',0 4

. 1" " ' # " '

#5") > ?" #0 .##

-"+5# '

) 5#

#5") > >0%# 0 #! %+ -

:" '! %+0 '#"# '

#, #,#'0%# 0 #%# +#

?#0 >0%# 0 # "#+# %+ ?

: "

'!%+0 '#"# '

#,#,#'0%# 0 # %#"#0 "

F "" 5####'

'## !+

("9',0 ##!"': . ,,#. "+".!"%# %%!- 5""

5,. ")

E ". "# !# '

! # " %%!! ' . !# )'

!1, ,"#',"

"## *#1"""+5 " E 6"9 E 9+ !".'%%#"%#' #+ 0#!% !"',"1"" E5##@0 ! ," 1"!"'1'"+'/"#,' '! 1 "# + 0#! % 5 0 # .# "#0 ,"#0# "#1'

'#'# %5#%#% - 1#. # . .#'%# ! '!%00#+'%,0 ("

1 ! ," " # %# ". , .#1! 00#C ". #!+#"# "5 !%%5%!#,# ,"0 '! , %'<' 0#/.#"#1!+ #'"'!

(" 0 # .# # #"#, "5 " " 5 ".% '#! #'"'!0

!/ '#5 5"+ %##!/0

# E %# "%1""5 1 '#! %#11!

,. 1+1""015#"+#! >" 5 " 1 %# "%-"+'! ". %1!+1 0%#"%! "#0 ##5" '""#0 (" "%# "%#' #+"/ %!

-5"#"%!"##."%-##0 6" ! 5"""",. !.# "

0 ,9+ !1" +5 -"0 5 0%! (" #0 > ., , #5%% #'<5 "%!

5" H "'#" ("0%! ". , "'

,#'0 0'## " 1#"# 5'! ". 1 '

# #0 '"/ "+ , #"1+#00 !. ,"1+"# "0!#'" ,"%! !,#%##,# ,"

1#01 '

'#! ' ='#"#0#-.#'%%!#.#' ' # 0

# ("',"6"91 !#%# 2.# 0 #.-1'"1+!

0 ""5@%#'""%!

#" 5"!1 , "/". , '

0'## " 1#"# '

#, , #'0 @%#

("##-"0%! ""#5 #0 ," % # " , , " %!

00!+ 0/"#%# "%'1'!

4 ='#"#0#-50, ' 5" %#

" 1'5# ,!+ +5 - '!#'"5 -5""9'!"#!1#"# #+,. , ! " %# "1#" %!5" H"'#"

B# '

!#"%%!! "#,'""# # 15 "#!'!# 0!. 0'"# ,"%#' .# -" " / %!

8"5.#-5" %0#0 @0 5 ' "1+ #0 " .#++

-"1+5'

"..!% #,#0#!!.#"1+ ("#"% "" %#"!%15 " %0#055" "'#-5"#15 9'#+ "55" 50 '

B# '

!#"%%!! "#,'"

# I ! D'#%#' (@!,+-

0%##, #,#0#''!!+!#5"#+ #"# > -"''!'# #,#0# 4 "'# 5 # 4 F"'# '00# *" "1#. "'"#+ , #!-#,#0#

5"'##"-5!!.!%#0"

1'5!."'# # ,"0-51! 0'## 6"

! 9+ !" "0 "+" .!." ' "1'% !+ ("#,#0#1#.

"1+"5""0'##"1 000'"

#!#0+1 "%#.' ,"-"##-"%# " % +5 10 '1'!- 5"" ! " # " " " / %! " 0 ',,1+"%#'

""#" -!# )'

!"'

# "#,'0 ,""+5 "." #@0 <'5!! "#5 # #"0 .!."' "!!+ ='#"#0#- , #,# 0# % '% .#' # !' , 5"# "'" ("##-"%# #,#0# "1+ # #"%#' #+ '

#'5#"+

#"# ,"#.! -5 " "+5 '

" ,. 1+5 "1

1#'"'! 5#"+#! %%# %%# #,#0#% ,'% .#'#-

1%#'0""""/ %! "'#%## "@0 "1+ ""%!1+"# %##0 ,%0#0@0

>0+10 "#"0%! 6"9 ". ,!"#!1#"#5'!".1 "!%# #+ # "'!'!%# .!."' "!!+ !5+"# .'#'"!#!.

'#""%# #% 1!#,#'0 " # # 1#'," 1/ %'

" '1!+ #"# "

0% ,"!"'!'!%# .!.0

%# "%!5"' +#"+0##

E "", . ,'!#. .!1! "!'!+##1#1+0!. (" '#!#!+

5""#0 7 ? =)B#%###+## ##%#''

& !

'()

!* ("'-%#% "' "

1!" ("> ., , #" # .!." ' "5# ,!+-"!! "0!!+#% , "0'#"# .

("0.#" 5 !#!+ "# '

%#.' 0+ 15 " %#

(" 9',0 . ## %1+"#!'##5!!# -1'% %#%# %%#! %%# . ## #%# !5 ("# !!,!+# #0+"#

> 0+ 1 0 "# " %%!! :': . ! " @%# '# , " % +"%%!

("##-%%! ! 1+"0 1- 5"# " %%! ! 1+ %%!! :': . *#"6'0# 0

%%!! :': .*#"6'0#1 1!,# "01+"'#5"!'% ,"

* 1! !! " D'! ,#- =#1 #'##5## ,"0##00!+ 0/"0'

#,"#0 ,

!"# E""#%/ ,:#

J:7 E""#%#1! J:7