← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7728/2023dismissed

Surender Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-01-29Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri5 pages

      ! "  ###

"$%&'("&)*+*',- - ./0&,1&02/3$0 -----&%*%*',&0 4&0+/+ .%$%&'($05$,$$,1'%6&0+ ----- &+7',1&,%+  8 9 - . . .  0&+&,% 0-2$0$,.*,:6;1<')$%& ('0%6&7&%*%*',&0- 0-2$7*= $,+$=;";$05$,$- 0->6*+6&?'&=;1<')$%&('0 0--.-.$*,*;1<')$%&;

('00&+7',1&,%'+- - 0- '6$,2/3$0;1<')$%&;

('00&+7',1&,%'-- ####

. .   ;   9 6&70&+&,%@0*%7&%*%*',6$+>&&,(*=&1/,1&00%*)=& A '(%6&',+%*%/%*','(,1*$('0*++/$,)&'($@0*%*,%6&,$%/0&'()&0%*'0$0* ('0B/$+6*,:%6&*37/:,&1'01&01$%&1 --,,&C/0& 7$++&1 >50&+7',1&,%'-<*1&@6*)6%6&7&%*%*',&06$+>&&,%0$,+(&00&1(0'3%6& '((*)& '(  /,*)*7$=  '07'0$%*',;  $0*1$>$1  %' %6& '((*)&  '(  /,*)*7$= '33*%%&&; '6*,1&0:$06  @6*)6  *+  /%%&0  <*'=$%*',  '(  =$/+&   '(  %6& 0$,+(&0'=*)51$%&1--,,&C/0& @*%6'/%)'37=&%*,:%60&& 5&$0+'(+&0<*)&'(7&%*%*',&0$+))'/,%$,%$%/,*)*7$='07'0$%*',;

$0*1$>$1- - 9&$0,&1)'/,+&=('0%6&7&%*%*',&0+/>3*%%&1%6$%%6&7&%*%*',&0



@$+%0$,(&00&1<*1&*37/:,&1'01&01$%&1 --,,&C/0& (0'3 %6&'((*)&'(/,*)*7$='07'0$%*',; $0*1$>$1%'%6&'((*)&'(/,*)*7$= '33*%%&&;'6*,1&0:$06$,16&6$1+&0<&1$%%6&'((*)&'( $0*1$>$1',=5 ('0$7&0*'1'(%@'5&$0+$,1*,%&03+'(%6&0$,+(&0'=*)5,,&/C0&

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

%6&0&7=56&+/>3*%%&1%6$%%6&3$*,:0*&<$,)&'(%6&7&%*%*',&0*+%6$%%6& %0$,+(&0  '01&0  @$+  *,  <*'=$%*',  '(  %6&  0$,+(&0  '=*)5 ,,&C/0&    @6&0&$+  *%  6$+  >&&,  +7&)*(*)$==5  +'  +%$%&1  *,  %6&  0&7=5  (*=&1  >5  %6& 0&+7',1&,% .%$%& %6$%%6&  0$,+(&0 '=*)5 ,,&C/0&  *+ $, ,=*,& 0$,+(&0'=*)5$,1*%6$+,'%>&&,&<&,*37=&3&,%&1%*==1$%&-&(/0%6&0 +/>3*%%&1%6$%%6&0&@$+,'B/&+%*','(<*'=$%*','(0$,+(&0'=*)5@6*)6 @$+',=5$,,=*,&0$,+(&0'=*)5$,16$+,'%>&&,*37=&3&,%&1$,1+' ($0$+%6&*37/:,&1'01&0,,&C/0& *+)',)&0,&1;*%@$+,'%*, 7/0+/$,)&'(%6&,=*,&0$,+(&0'=*)5>/%@$+*,7/0+/$,)&'(7/0&$,1 +*37=&$13*,*+%0$%*<&&C*:&,)*&+- &$=+' +/>3*%%&1  %6$%  +'  ($0$+ %6&



$==&:$%*','( 3$=$(*1& 7&0%$*,*,:%'%6&($)%%6$%%6&7&%*%*',&06$+>&&, %0$,+(&00&1',=5%'$1E/+%0&+7',1&,%'-*+)',)&0,&1;%6&$==&:$%*',*+ %'%$==5<$:/&&<&,$+7&0%6&7=&$1*,:+3$1&*,%6&@0*%7&%*%*',$,1,' +7&)*(*)$==&:$%*',6$+>&&,3$1&*,%6*+0&:$01-&(/0%6&0+/>3*%%&1%6$% &<&,'%6&0@*+&$=+';6$1%6&0&>&&,$,5 3$=$(*1& ',%6&7$0%'(%6& 0&+7',1&,%A.

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



,,&C/0& @6*=&*%@$+7/0&=5$,1+*37=5>&)$/+&'($13*,*+%0$%*<& &C*:&,)*&+('0@6*)6%6&7&%*%*',&01'&+,'%6$<&$,5<&+%&10*:6%-%*+$ +&%%=&1=$@%6$%%6&0&*+,'<&+%&10*:6%%')6$==&,:&%6&%0$,+(&0'($, &37='5&&/,=&++%6&0&$0&+'3&&C)&7%*',$=)*0)/3+%$,)&+'0@6&,%6&0&*+ <*'=$%*','($,57'=*)5'0*,+%0/)%*',+@6*)66$++$,)%*%5*,=$@&*%6&0 +%$%/%'0*=5'0'%6&0@*+&-

,%6&70&+&,%)$+&;$+7&0%6&+%$,1%$?&,>5%6&.%$%&;%6& 0$,+(&0  '=*)5  ,,&C/0&     6$+  ,&<&0  >&&,  *37=&3&,%&1  %*==  1$%& >&)$/+&*%@$+ ',=5 $, ,=*,& 0$,+(&0 '=*)5 @6&0&$+ %6&  *37/:,&1 %0$,+(&0'01&0<*1&,,&C/0& *+,'%',%6&>$+*+'(%6&0$,+(&0'=*)5- ,$11*%*',%'%6&$>'<&;%6&0&7=5@6*)66$+>&&,(*=&1>5%6&.%$%&;%6& +%$%/%'05  70'<*+*',+  '(  $05$,$  /,*)*7$=  .&0<*)&+  ,%&:0$%*',;

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

=$@@*%6*,$7&0*'1'(',&3',%6- - -   . .  6/3*?$   " - 6&%6&0+7&$?*,:A0&$+',&1 !&+A'

- 6&%6&00&7'0%$>=& !&+A'