High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17503/2020allowed

Gurpreet Singh @ Mani v. State Of Punjab

2022-03-17Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl23 pages

!"#$

% & !% '(

))

!'!"#

% & !% '(

% & *+*,-. # (##

!('!"##/,-- ,% '(

0# 1** 1 /* ** % 0# * (2

!"# $ # )) * (2 !' !"# 2" "

* (* 34 5 6

! , ) # 7 " %2# !

( -, )8 # 97%! -: ! , 58, 5) 4% ! , #-/-,))%*!!-/

; * # # (/ # # * # *1 .*. (# # # / # 2 # ( < # * ; ! * # (' # / -"*2,

<*#("</#/ ; * # # # #

(2 =# # , # *. # #(*1

#$#%%#%# %" % ! & ' () "

*+) #,) "* "

%+ %, ( - () "

+ ) (- .

' )

' / - '

+## - - ) )

- $ - -

- / 0

' 1 1 / - 2

' - 3 - 1 3 ' -

", 3 ' / 0 3

-3 "%

1 5- 4 - ' - -- '' ' 1 - - - -' 2

+$ -

' '-

- --1

7 '

- 3 ' / 0 - 3 ", 3 -

4 3 4 1 "%

1 5- - '

- 1 1 /"

/ +$ - ' ( '

1 0

#%#%"

89:& ' 9 ) (- )

- 7 0

) 0 4

"$#%#%")

1 - 3

- 1 - 3

- / 5

- ;

* # * ( * # 8

(2 =# # 0# *. 1## #(*1 2 <=

/ ) 1 - ) 1 - 1 1 1

( 5

/" - +# !& ( -- - - 1 - ' ) -- 0 -- 1 1' > 4

0 - <%#"=++ (0

#,"%%#%" 7 0

(

' ;

=2 " # 1** # , * * # # (/ # # # ( **2 / * # # # /* (<" 4 # ( (/ # *# "# # **" .2 / #

!"# ( 6 "/ # 1# !' !"# # ( # # 1 * / 2"

!"# $ # , # .2 / # //* > 2, #1. # # #"#*"# # # # 34 #1 # # (/ # # 34 " , # / #. ( . # * - 6

# 34 # ( " 6 # # # ( / **" # 34 1## **" # * #, # * ( (2 # # ( / " # 34, 1# # ( ##.21,# >#( 0# "

/ (2 * * # # # 34, # # / # ( . # %* ! - 6

# > # ( # .2 # ( # ( # >, # 34 # ( " 6 # 4 # ( (/ # / # **" # 34, * # # * # 1 # 1 < # " # 34 ( #1., * # // # -?

68 . * / "

# 1 * #1 # # / 2 / #

/( 34 # *2 / # / 0# / "# ( / 1# # .2 // -? %5 # . * / " 5 #1 # / # * (# # / # /, #1. # " " 5 # * / # " # * " # #"#*"# # " 5, # .2 // 1 # 1 # # ( / -?

% . * # / " #"#*"# # #

> 1 * # 1 " 6 # / 1 / - 4 # // #" . # 2

%6 . * # / " 1 * # 1 # / # * 4 , # , (/ # # /, 1## 1 (" # * , 1** # , 1 # 1 ( # // 1 2 # 34 /( # / 1 * 2 4 (/ # # #1 # # // " / # , # # * '

"/ . =# #

"# $ % %$ &' () * + ,-.-/ 0

1//2 0# "

/ * * # # * # // -?

% . * %" 1 * #1 ' // 1 # # # / 1 "., * " # " # # / -!4 ;<#1 !"# 4 (/ # # , # 34, # * # # * ( # , # . ! # 7%! - # (

/*2 **1 "." "" # # / -!4 #/* 1 * #1 # # /2 . ! # 7%! - # ( .* # , # # *

# '

"/ @A(* !

/ *) ! +)1 3)$ !

"# % %$ &' 4$#% $

1 /* - * 5)

)

8 % %$ &' * #%

"# (

&% $ /*- * 8

0# # "

/ (2 * * # # =# # , " # /, 1 * * # / (* .

# * (. # # # 1#* #2 / (* 1 * * ( < # / * '

# ; * # # # # #. *2 # #. // 2 1#* (" / (*

4* (/## .*.2# 0# # "

/ (2 * * # # (# # #. ( 2 6

# 1 #/ #. ( ?/ # , # * *<*2 < / 4 # (/ # # 1 " / (* ?/*2 ? /# ( . # ?* , # *, # 2 " (2 # 2 ) /# #, # . # (* , # . #(* ; ! * # #

* (* # (/ # # "

/ 1# // (" ( / * 1 * *2 ( # * * ?/ ?/ B# # "

/ * * # # # # ( .* ! # 7%! -, # ( "

# # , .2 # ( / # < (" / # * # 4 # (/ # # * # # ( / , 1## > ( .2 @ # * (/ # # .* '

"/ 1## 1 * # # # # .2 # ( / / # # *2 (> *2 # # **2 #, # ! # 7%! - ( **1 2 .* # / 1 * # .2 ( ( 4 # (/ # // , ** # # " # / *2 # , . ' //, # / 1 * * # # # B# # "

/ "" # ". (2 -!4 ;<#1 !"# # //, (/ # # , ! # 7%! - *(*, # # * *. B# # # # .*. 2#,#/#.( 0# # # # * * # # # (<

0# "

/ (2 * * # # # *# "# # 34, / # ( .

# * - 6

, # 34 # * 1# # # * # # # > # ( # .2 # ( / * % * # // -?

% . * " , 1## . # , # ( # .2, 1 * #1 # # /( # 34 # *2 ( 2 # / 0# . =#

# # (.

% -' 1

(

) - ') - 1

- ?5 () ?5 .) ?5 ) ?5 &) ?5 ? ?5

( --

- -

1 - 1

) 1 ! 1 - 1

) @ ' 5 1 --

- ) 1 1 5 - 1 -- 1

* 5 16 7 # " % %$ &'

,--8/ 1 9:8

1 1 - 1 1 - ) 1

- 1 - .

) '

6 '

) 1

555 555 % 1 )

1 -

0 - ' 8 )

) (-

) 1 ') ' 1 @ ' ;

- =# # * 5 )0

) # ##* <= - - ' -- 1 -

' -- @ ' 1 ' -- ' '

' '

- 9 A

8 ) 0 - * 5 16 #% %$&'

,--8/ 0

1 9:8 (7;

# % %$ &' () * + ,-.-/ 0

1 //2 (7; 1 - @ ' -- 1 ': '

-- 0

1 <<$ 1 &.=-8 &' ,--8 %%1$ #

! (

% # % %$ &' $1

$>$ &

-..,,-,- ;

??/=.@/?,-.8 7 %%1$ # %# )0

# % %$ &' () * +

$>$ & ..-,,-,-; ??:,/2-?,-.8 7 %%1$ #

#$0

1 # % %$ &' () * + $>$ &

.2-8,-,-; ?? ::8,.?,-.8 %%1$ # A) $$< # % %$ &' () * + $>$ & .=-,,-,-;

??/,9.@?,-.=%%1$ # 6) #% %$&'

() * + $>$ & -2-=,-.=; ??9.888?,-.= %%1$ # % $ # # % # % %$ &' () * + $>$

,9-/,-.8;

/:://?,-.8 %%1$

" $ ! 00 # % %$ &' () * +

$>$ & ,@..,-.8; ?,-22=?,-.= ??

,,.,? ?,-.9 %%1$ # # 0 ! &6 # % %$ &' () * + $>$ & ,:-.,-.8; ?.8@=2?

,-.8 ??,==:? ?,-.9 %%1$ #

& # % %$ &' () * + $>$ & .9-=,-.8; ??

/9@-:?,-,- 7 %%1$ # *

$$< !

A ) # % %$ &' () * + $>$ & ,=-.,-,. )#%6$$0 !

*)$$ # % %$ &' * #%

,-../ 0

1 299 1 1 :

11 "$ )#% 6$$0 !

*)$$

# % %$ &'

* #%

,-.. ,298 1 ' > 4

' -- 1

- 1 ' * 5 16 # % %$ &'

,--8/ 0

1 9:8 (7 1 '

' -- 1 B

' - 1 - '

1 1

' & .

# % %$ &' () * + ,-.-/ 0

1 //2 (7 - ' -- 1

': ' ' -- 0

1 <<$ 1 &.=-8 &' ,--8 %%1$ #

! (

% # % %$ &' $1

$>$ &

-..,,-,- ;

??/=.@/?,-.8 7 %%1$ # %# )0

# % %$ &' () * +

$>$ & ..-,,-,-; ??:,/2-?,-.8 7

%%1$ #

#$0

1 # % %$ &' () * + $>$ &

.2-8,-,-;

??::8,.?,-.8 %%1$

#A) $$< # % %$ &' () * + $>$ & .=-,,-,-;

??/,9.@?,-.= %%1$ #

6) # % %$ &'

() * + $>$ & -2-=,-.=; ??9.888?,-.= %%1$ # % $ # # % # % %$ &' () * + $>$ &

,9-/,-.8;

??/:://?,-.8 %%1$

" $ ! 00 # % %$ &' () * +

$>$ & ,@..,-.8; ?,-22=?,-.= ??

,,.,? ?,-.9 %%1$ # # 0 ! &6 # % %$ &' () * + $>$ & ,:-.,-.8; ?.8@=2?

,-.8 ??,==:? ?,-.9 %%1$ #

& # % %$ &' () * + $>$ & .9-=,-.8; ??9@-:?

,-,- 7 %%1$ # *

$$< ! A ) # % %$ &' () * + $>$ & ,=-.,-,. )#%6$$0 !

*)$$ # % %$ &' * #%

,-../ 0

1 299 1 : 11 %# 1 ) 1

' ' -

: 9 :& '

9 ;

!/**2, =# # *

$$< !A ) # ##* ) - - ' 2 1

! (

% " % %$ $1 0

1 <<$ 1 & .=-8 &' ,--8) 5 ' -- 1

1 1

* 5 16 " % %$ &'

,--8/ 19:8 (7 1 1 1 ' & .

" % %$ &' () * + ,-.-/ 0

1 //2 (7 A .

@ '

1 1

- 1 1 -

C??/=.@/?,-.8 %# )0

"% %$&'

() * +;

??:,/2-?,-.8

#$0

1"% %$&'

() * +;

??::8,.?,-.8A) $$< "% %$ &'() * +;

"??/,9.@?,-.= 6) "% %$&'

() * +;

"??9.888?,-.= % $ # # %" % %$&'() * +;

"??/:://?,-.8

" $ !

00"% %$&'

() * +B - ' ?

"?,-22=?,-.= ??,,.,? ?,-.9 # 0 !

&66"% %$&'() * +; " ?.8@=2?,-.8 ??,==:? ?,-.9

& " % %$ &' () * +

1 '

- )5

- '9-:& -

;

C*D ) 2

- ' 9- > ! %% %# %#"$)

(- - 1 -

- 1 - 1

' - E E : 6 1

' %# %#"$)

! %% %# %#"$ 1 ' - 1

1 ' - 1 : -- @

1 ' - 1 ( 5

4G4 1

1 ) ) - 1 1 ' ! ( -

) -

- ' ' 9-

) ' 1' @ 5 ' - 1

@ ') 1 '

C""D

) ) 1

: & ' 9 ) ;

% * # (. '

"/ 1 * #1 # . =# 1** =# # # # (2 * * # ( # 1#* "" "

* (* # # C.

.*." //* > 2, 1 (. # # *2 1 ( 1, , # # 34 1 " # **" .2 ( # /( # 34 # ( # / " (# *2 * # "2 # . # / * # ( # #2 0# =# # *

$$< !

A ) # # . ? * #1 2 1 ( / 1# # 34 1## 1 (> *2 1 (. # D"* " # # 34 /( #." ( /, # * ( / 0# / # ( #

0# 1## # ( # (. 1 * * # C. * # " # // . * " * # .2 //

. * " 5 1 * #1 # # " # / * * (# # / / **2

0# / -?

%5 .2 // . * " 5, -?

% > . * " ,-?

%6//#"

. 2 . * " , ** 1 # 1 1#, # // 1 2 0# * * * # # # # // / 1## # ( (> *2 # .2, # , ( "#*2 ' # #> #21 *(/* ; * # # * # " / # * # 34 1 * #1 # # * # #

# * ( # # // 1 * #1 # # , . # # , 1 ". # " # # / -!4 ;<#1 !"# 4 (/ # "." # # 1 * ( .*. # .!#7%!-

0#@A(*!

/ 4 *) # #(. @ 1 1 +#<"= 1 @ - 1 1 ' -

) @ 1 -) 1

@ - +# 1 ' - 1

' 6/% 6/

6/%

H ) '

6/% 1 '

' )

1 ) +# 1 ( ') 6/% 1 @ - ' 1 @ - +#<"= ( )

@ - - ' - 1 +# )

- 4 # , # . ! # 7%!

- 1 # .2 #." ( / *2 / # (" # ** #, # * # # ( 0# / * *(*#

# # * * # # * # '

"/ # @A(* !

/ 4 (

1##1(. "+ 6 6/"# I

' 9 J 6/+ 8 !)

) 1 1

- ' 1 6/+ 8 ! '

6/"# I

)

) +#<"= !& ( 9 J ) @ ) -

) 1 -

6/"# I

1 ' 6/+ 8 !)

) 1 1 '

6/+ 8 ! 6 5

' @ ' 5

' 1 6/+ 8 !) 1 .

6/"# I

1 +#<"= !& (

1 1

+#<"= !& ( 7 )

) '

6/"# I

6 ) )

+#<"= !& ( 1) )

' @ ' >

H 1

) )-; 4 # , %B !4 E # # ". # # # ( # ( %B + !

7" 1# 1 # " 2 4 1 (. (2 # @A(* !

/ # # ". # 1 " # / ! #7%!-# ,## . ; ! * # *# "# .2 .#/*2 "

##.2# *# # .2 1 / # < (" # * # # 1 (> *2, > ( .2 # , # .2 / # < (" . / * ! # 7%! - 4 ", * ! * # # '

"/ # @A(* !

/ 4 % %$ &' () * + "#

1* $ ,-,-. 0

1@= ; * # ( * # (/ #

1* $

# , .2 # ( / # .*. # '

"/ @A(* !

/ 4 *) # #(#'

0# 1 * **2 #1 # . # > 1# *(*2 ! # 7%! - # / ( "

(* =# # ( 2 6

*# "# #

1, #/ #. ( ?/ # , # * *<*2 < / /, .1 # / =# # 1 * " / (* (2 =# # #

#. / # =# # .*.2# ; * # # * #"#*"# # # . 1# .2 //* > 2 1 .*., # @F(* !

/ 1** # #., # ( "

(* # (* * 1** (2 " # 2 # / # , " (*D

!/ # '

"/ (" # 4 /* - * 7 )6 * $$ $ )0

" & &' , # @A(* !

/ 1# **" # #" # 1 1# <" ( 9"':, # , (" //* > 2, 1 * " (* " # # @"# 1# # * " " * (* # ('

- =# # * '

"/ * 6)# )0

! & ) " % %$ &' () * + ,-.= : 0

1 =: # # . ! # 7%! - ? # " (* 1## .*. //* > 2 0#*. #'

"/ 9 555//555//555 .

) , <"= <= <=)

1 -- 4 '

4 - ') )

@ - 1 ' ) -

- ' - ( )

- -

1 ) ') )

' -- 4 '

4 4 !& (4 )

) ) '

' -- '

> )

;

0# ! * ;. % /* 2 7 6) 8 * " # '

"/ # =# # , 1/(2#@A(*!

/ #, .

, =# # " "

* (* 1# 1 .*. 1# .2 1 8 <" 9#:

//* > 2 (" 2 2 /# 0# 1

#* (2 # @A(* !

/ . 8

% ! * ;. - * * 7 8 *

>&%>& % &1 ) $ )"<

&% $ C 0# @A(* !

/ 4 .

/* - * 7 668 * 90% ! & " 0 > 1 (

$# C 1 * " "

* (* .*." <" 8 "/ 9#: /*2 # " (* 2 *, # # # * 1 * *<*2 < / *

4 /* - * 7 * )6

)## " % %$ &' * #%

&% $

, # @A(* - ? . '

"/ 6

1 * * " (* 1# #

> 2#(1//*

- =# # 5 * * 5 )0

) " % %$ &' () * + # /, .

, <" # * ! # 7%! -, 1 * " " * (* .*." //* > 2 1 / # # 1#* "" # (* # 1 #'

"/,1## 9%" >1 ) 0 ' -- '

!& (

-- ' ' -

)

;

#, . =# # . '

"/ 8

8 -! != * 9

< 1 "# %&

1 "$#% % $ >5

&% $ C, " 1# # .2 1 //* > 2 4 # (./ , # . =# # < # "# . 1# D. -*

# 4 1# " 2 * #, # '

"/ @A(* # !

/ % %$ &' $1 " &6$# ,-,. @ 2,: 1 * < # . ! 7%! - 1 # # * ** # 1 /*2 "

# 2 # * ** # * # # # * 1 *<*2 ( # #

1 * / # . =# '

"/ # 1$

!" % %$ &' () * + ,--2 . 0

1 /.9 # .1 < 1$

# 1 **1 4 # (. '

"/, 1 * # # " "

* (* ( " # # 1## . 4 # / # > / ! # 7%! -, . #. < # / # # 2 1#, # "

(* / # 2 * > , # @F(* !

/ 1** . @"# #. " (* . .*." //* > 2 G " .1 # / # * # # # "

(* # # 2 # (* # * *<*2 < /, # **1 # ( * (* # #" (* D 2 ( # # * D 2 " (' #/ ("

> 2 # ., / # (' ! # 7%! -, # / # **1" # # #**((2

0# 1** / 1# # . "

#* 0# 1** H D / # 1 0# 1** ( # * # ?, * * ?/

0# #** // /* # 1## # , // 1###

0# #** *2 *2 /< 2 /, # / 2 > 1# # # #/ / *" # # 2 * / 1##. 4 (# 2 # (. , # #** ( *(2 /. * ** (*,(# #" (. #** ( * ? # / # # * 1 * *2 # (. / # 1## *2 # '

"# (*

#$%&'( )*+,- & E - B## <"D ID7 B## (* ID7