High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/33778/2015allowed

Naresh Kumar Etc. v. State Of Haryana

2018-11-19Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan35 pages

#$#$%%&&"$ !

#$#$%%!(%$ !

( $% &

#$#$%&)"!$ !

( "

#$#$%& !'$ !

(

# *+# , -,,. ()

*+ #

,- *.

*+ .

- *.

1- 2

% $3- *.

/ 4

. - 5*6- "#

-,,./

8 , 9:

- 2 4 : (& /! - ;:(;0- , (& < - 6, /*= (

&# && /*= (10 +

/0 & ( /! - ; ( ;0

8 &3 !

.&.

&& !

- 3+# & +

3 # & 3 & + ,

/0 ( -

3 ,

"3.- > . ! + , = !

< !

, 9: 3 , 3 & , . +# <&> 5.& (# '!!

- - 6,

9 # !- 9: ) ?

"# $ % "&'() *+"*,"-*'- $ $$ $ . /

" ! "

$ % % & "'( )

% $ (

% "

&+,%!-./ (

, 0" " " !

% !

(

1 " 2 " " $ ! $

( 3

""0 $

" ) " 2 ! 3 . 4 5$$

$!-

. , +

/0 ( , @= *%# ,.

/0 (

: -

+ !

& A(

- & ?.

, .

"# B-

# , !!

& > &,&

& # , 3

03 3 3> , 6 . # 3 #

3 +#

, !&&3 , ) ?(

$ 1 ""% " '

% ! " $ ( % ( 0 4$ ( ( ( !"! ""% !

% " 3

( ""$ %( " %6/

$ ( ( 8(( ( "%" ("

( 0 4 $ 3 ( ( "

99""

( * 3

$ !" "

% #

% "

% %

( 0 4

% %

%3 !

( ( (( ""

( ""% ! %

( 0 4$ ( 1 ; ( % % ! #

( '( )

$ 8

5 (

! 3)< '( )

% "$ =5,4 % %

&+ ,%! ( 0 (( (

0"8 5

( % !

< +> >

* !

"8 5 "

( " %

& ?

- % "8

5 "

( 4 $! (

(

%.(

(

"" & %

(

3 %!

!"!

% "

( 0 ""%" ( 4 (

8 "

%$ @

$ ( $ (

' !

$ . (

( "( ( & #

% "(( ( 8

$ "$ ' !

" )

% ""

% ! ((

%( % #

"" $ (

! "

! " "

"$ ,% (

!- * & 5 # - 6,-

8 # ,

8 #- !

8 #

# & ! , ,+, 6 (#- <

& & ,-

& & & C (#

+ &# , 3

& , 3

&&,

$ * & 5 # - 6,-

2- !&&3 , !

,) 7@

"( $ * 3 .(

%(( ! * * 3 (

( "

# ( "

% ! !%

, 2" !

* 3

! "6/

6 7 *

% )

2 -" "

23 ("

2 ///////// "

2 ///////// % $ 8

(" $-

3 6 (#

&> !!

"3.-

- , 3 + #

&&,& +# &&

C &

! +

@= *%# ,.

3 3

, 9: !

! -

- D

6 (# 9

$ @= *%# ,.

&&# !

& .

+! *

&& * #

/0 "# (#

%- *-

/! - ; *;0- &&, , .# 3 ,

& - +&

C &

+ ! @= - 3 ,

# + & .

- , !

.# - D !

& #

& ,

# 3 ,

& !-

, ,

/*= ( (40

C &

! +

- + & , . , @= - 3 ! < !

. , 3

- <&> 5.& (# '!!

- - ,.

! "'- <- 6,

"+ + *- 3> F @,

<&> '!!

- !

3> !

3> ! *, .+ 4

#+ 3> ! 5+ 4 F

&&#

3 3 ( 3> !

- & 3!

3 & , .

: &- <&> 5.& (# '!!

- ! 6 . 3> (# <&> 5.& (# '!!

$!- + !

. , - +# 6 (#-

& +

&# &&

/0 ( /*= (10

C &

&# && 3 ! , & !

/0 (

+ , *%# ,.

/@= 0- &

8 # +# 5 # -

3 ! !

3 -

3 +

8 #-

3 & !

.&.

9:D!! &, *%# ,.

&> &# +

6 (#- <

$ .

&& ) 7........

! %

) *

% '

% ! % (

(

$ ( #

" % !"( $ ! ""%$ "

- % * !

B%! (" C

3 * 3

%/$ "8 '!"( 3 *

% '

% ! % (

* 3 $$ 8

?- "

* !

* 3 $ $ 8 $ * 3 $ "

+ ! % $

%(" &""! " "( "" 8

* 3 "

(

* 3

$ !"( $ #

( & " '( )

% " %!"( $ % * 3 ( - #

'( )

" % #

$ "8 '

% #

!" % #

& "'( )

$ "

% !"( $ * 3 BC

* 3 " %%

3 BC

(

" % " !"( ! ""%BC

(

" " %

" " ! ""%B2C

" %$ ( ("

((" ! ""%&

, 2"

!"( $ % * 3

( ! " " (" "

* !

?-* 3 $ +

! % $

%- #

" ( " ( "(

! ""%5 ! % !" %

"! " %!"( $ ! ""% * 3 ( ( - #

)

& "'( )

$ $ (

* 3

$ !"( $ " % * 3

% 8

* 3 3

! (

$ # 3

= * !

( $ * 3 ! 3 # !

$ !"( $ 8 %( # * !

% " % $ ( ?- ( ( !"( $ " %

8 ( ( " %

$ ""$ %(

!"! ! " %$

&+ ,! -./ ( * 3 D

& 5 " >

?-3 '( ! ""% , >3% '

<$( "

0;*" < (

% D1 >

, + % * ! 3 '( ! ""%=9 "(

% D > > ! , * ! 3 '( > 8 3A

$ D 2

% 8 ) -./* ! 3 '( ! ""% (

3 (

% D,+ 3"

%-./< 3 ! ""% 3 '

% 0 &9 ?% "

-.< 3 ! ""% 4 " " $

%-./<

3 ! ""% 3 '

% ;,8 A""

, -./<

3 ! ""% 3 '

% D+(" >

3"-./<

3 ! ""% 3 '

% D $ 8 %-./ < 3 ! ""% 3 '

% D >

$ * "

> -./< 3 ! ""% 3 '

% D *9 % -./< 3 ! ""% 3 '

% D+3" ,+3") ,+( -./< 3 ! ""% 3 '

% D2< 8

%% , -./< 3 ! ""% 3 '

% D B ""% "C0), 8 -./<

3 ! ""% 3 '

% D4'") 5 , -./ < 3 ! ""%

3 '

% D ; ) A" , $ -./< 3 ! ""% 3 '

% D "'!

$ 3 "-./< 3 ! ""% 3 '

% D

$ % %-./< 3

! ""% 3 '

% 1 $

$ "8' &' 2 2

-**& -*'* 3 $

! " %

$$ $

" 9 $

$ $

'(,6:7 / " "/"

;

< / " &"

$ %

(

"" %

& 5 " > ?-3 '( 1 >

, + %* !3 '(

> > ! , * !3 '( '(

(

% ! $ " ( "

"" $

" :

C &

! +

+! , !

. , -

! :&&8 ,

/0 (

3 >

* (& - - 6,-

C &

. !

*- , , !

= , & + & # D( 3

) &," = $

BC -! ( GHHHHHHHI 3 * 3 "" " " "

$ / ((" * =

( ( " % % * 3

$ /(("

# %" $ "$ % ( @3 ( 3

BC "8 '!"( 3

((" * 3 $ "

$ /((" * =

( ( " % %* 3 % !

%# ((

( GHHHHH HHI 3 .("

$ %

$ /(("

* =

( ( 8

( ! BC & (

%% !

BC $

(("'

! '

( !

(

((" "" "

B2C $ % %

BC*!

((" ! "$ ( . ""

( % $ '

(

/ BC (

(

% " "%" ( (

(

" 6

! *!

"" (

/ ( + " (

$ % !

% "((

% BC $ % %

(

"" "" ( .(" $ "

8% "

$ / ((" .( $

% ( GHHHHHI 3 $ ! " B0C

( GHHHH HHI 3

! "%"

. ( (

+ !, . +

@= ( 3 & , &- 3

& 6 (# 9

# #

<&> 5.& (# '!!

&- 3

& 6 (# 9

# ! , .

, 8

# ( # +

! +

! , . ,

/20 * +! 6. ! & &

. & ,

&- & & + & # + ! @=

C &

! +

2 *-

) 7!

6 BC

"%"

( % ! "

""" %

3 BC ( < ) 1 ) 1 /3 (

& :

= , & + & #

- 3 6 .- F @, @= (-

& + & # 3

3- !

* ,& + & # !

& 6 (# . .

& . + 6 (#- !- & & + & # + !

C &

- 9: 3 ,

&# , &- ! 3 , +# <&> 5.& '!!

*%# ,.

@= &&, 4 /.

3 3 , . .#0- +!

&& #

= # ,

/20 *

C & ! ,

&& # @=

& !

, !

& &- @= +&

!- , 9: , *%# ,.

@= ,

# #

& 3 +&-

2 * 3 . & , &,& #

C & ! + +

& 9: 3 <&> 5.& (# '!!

"'- (& <

, , @= - + 4 !- !

- !! 2 4 :(

3 . & , # #

C &

. ! + . !

/0 ( 3 + &# , *%# ,.- @= - , #

&# 3

8 # 3 ! <-

! 3 , ! <&> 5.& (# '!!

, @= -

6 - F @, 3 & ( 6 (# # && 3 - 3 & + ,

/0 (

+ , .

8 #

, &

!! 2 4 :(

C & . !

/0 ( - 3 &# &&, ,

3 & 3> , 6 .- # . , 8 & ,

# .& 3> 3 3> , % , 3 ( 6 (# 3

C &

& & !!

3 &

- 6 .- 3 3> *%# ,.

3 =

, , &

"# .

& .

/( *

&0 &-

4- 3

- & , # . #

&&,& #

,& #

C &

. &&# ,

, & & D9:- <&> 5.& (# '!!

& !! , .# ! @= ,

3 #

&&,& # +

C &

. & '>>(6-7 = '+, $ " ?

3 ";+& .

< & ) =

! "

( % + % ( (

* 3 ( ! ( ! / (( ( %

" !

(

" ( ! $

( 99"

, ( " ( (

* 3 ,

" " (("

: C &

. & '>:&

"+> @ " 9 $ ; 3 & ) 7 (

/ BC * 3 " " " "

((" ( ( " % %

$ (("

# %" 3 % "

" (

% "8 '!"( 3 %

! $ ((" " $

# %" ( (

( " % $

3 (( ! "

( %

, 22;$ % $

( ( ( " ( (( !

% .(

"( ( "" "

-! ( ( $ $ " "8 '!"( 3 $ (("

( < "

( ( "

(( !

( %

$ ((" 5 "" " $ ((" (( ( (

% "

)

(( !

%.(

(

" ( !

""$5 # ( % &

F'F &((""& B&

F-FC ! 45 $! (

3 ""$:

C & . ! & -*'(6-7 !

"/"

"7 +-( "3 .

3 " $ ?

3 ";+& .

< <+# "

, & ) ?

!( $!

. ($

2;) 3)

( J

( ( % =5,

(

"$ "$ "

( $"" $ " !! $ $ %

( 5 .(

""$(

( $ /

! " " K

" 5

"" ( % =5, "%

* 3 " ! ( ! "

" 5

'( - % "- % ,

"J (("

' !

$ (

(% ""%

(( (

;( " %

( ((

" ! ( % =5, ! # . ( 5 % *!

$ (" (

# " $ 8 ( (

" ! "

8 %

# ( & +

( % ( "

" "%

( $ (

! $ "$ $ ( ""$( # ( % =5, . ( / 8 "

' 8 J 8 "

! ( /

". "( ( ( ""

" !

! ; =

$ ( ""$ , "

( "

BC ( % =5, # J ( ( %" C &

. ! & -*'&6-,7 / 6/

7 -,* . B " $ C 3

3 ";+& F> "

, - & ) 2

=5, 5 ! /

3 ( > < 3 !8 "(("

"8'!"(

% ! , L/ (("

( $ $ ((" " "8'!"( $ ! , L/

(

" =5, (" " ""% %

3 !8 /

(> < ?

- % & 8 > $$

( !

$ 8$ . 3 !8 "/ ( ( ""% $

(

)>?

B ( C "

" ( " 8(

( ! $

$ ( "%"" " $

$ ( !

( "" ""

( !" &(( " "

(" ! %

( % % (" ( ""% & $

( $

% "

"! " "

% %

% % %

253) $ 253) %

( ((

$ =5, (("

! "

&335

" "

( $

( %

2 $ 2 3 ") ( % 4

# ( ' >

C &

! & .

< %,

'>>(6,7 / 6/ 7 -,+

. " $ ;

3 - 3 & & , .

& ) 2 5 (( !

$ ( $ "

" "! ( !

&$ ( "$6// ..

M 4'

# "

//BC(

"" ( @(/ ( 3 * 3

3 N " 3

$/ ..

B C "

(

8 * 3 3 N "3

3 3 N "3

! " $ )(

( !

&$ ( " $

" ! ( D ..

'+"

'(&6'76 7

2 $ D

$ 3 D

D $

2 /

$ D2 $

2 $ " = 2

E D

$ 3 D

2 /

$ D" D

D $ "

$ " D

$ 3 D 2 2

$ "

$ $

" -( 8* $

2 D $

$ D 2 2

&, &8

$ $

$ 2

F $

2 2

" 9

$ F

4 @ BC& (

( .(" #

% 8% "

.( .

$ ((" .( $

% ( @(/ ( 3 $ ! " & " #

?%(" %-./ ( "M&

M M

! " M

$ )(

3 !

&, " % ! &

?%(" %

$ )(

3 !

& " "" ( (

+ 5 "

# "

B C 4BC &

! "

$ )(

& ?%(" %

# " ( !

B C 4BC& ; @ )"

BC & (

" "" ( .(" $ "

8% "

.( .

$ /(("

.( $

% ( ?%(" % (

%("

;/;0& + ( (

" "" ( 8%"

$ .

$ $

% ( $ ! "

?%(" % ( L 2$ " ( .

.( $

% (

$""(

&" % ( ! ""% "

?%(" %

+ $ $ (

! "("

! ("

" " ?%(" %

5 "

?%(" % $ ( .

% "

.( $

% ( $ !" 8

- - + +&!

!! ,

# 3 #

# 6 (# . , !!

*- !- . 3 &

2 *

: &#- & &-

! :. , , '!!

+ !!

- !

& +# * (& / 0 6,- !

2 1- ! && 3

, *%# ,.- , 3 ! 3 !

! +8&#- : - <- 6,- !

. , , !!

& & 6 .

6 (# !

(# 8 . +

!. + (# !

, .& 3>

( . & , 8 # . & !! 2 4 :(

012/3456

2 7617212804625792 7537:268469648;$,297<8 =71 13225 7876722/07322=7 92/399:5287::0926 : +8 !!

- !

. , 3 ! 6& (& - -

# !

. ,

: / 0 !

. ,

"3.- + #

! :&&8 ,

/0 ( * :

, +# 3

. , , !!

C & & -**:

6-7 / 6/

7 &:8 . " $ ; - 3

+ & ) 2 & % , (

! $ (

( # %=5, ( !

2 ((" "

( %

( " "

" ! "

( !

"$ 0 5 ( ( $ (

%( "

8("

% % 99"

5 "

( "8'!"( 3 ! " ( 99" '( )

'( )

(( !

% %

( % !

% %.(" ( % % 99" & " $

( 40 !

(

.(" (

""%"

(( ( $ $ " (( (

( &$

6 ..............B ( !C 4 "

$ "

(

((" * 3

( ( " % %* 3

((" $ 3 ( * 3 $

* 3

(( (

" % %* 3

$ (("

# %"

( 3 " ! (

( !

"" " ( (( ( %

( ( "

$ %" ( / $ $ "" " "

3 ")$ %"

( !

& " %"

$ " !

+ .$

% % (&

$ %

< " ""

$ % ( ( $

4B CB C) ( & 4B CB C ) ( &

1 45 ! %

(

6 BC C B C(

) (

$ % "

$ ( $

D J " ( % &(.

)

/ =" " "

/ =2 !

5 "

'>+( / ->&

6 @""" $ $

$ $

" ;

$ 2 $ " ?

$ $

" ?

9 2

6/ '>&+

&8,7" & " (

% !

3 (

(

(( ( 3

+ ((

( !

* 3 ((

8%"

"" " ( L 5 "

$"" "

" ! "" " "

( """

5$ " " &

(( (

< ( * 3 $ % 2 & $

(

"%" ( % ! "

""" %

3 @(/ ( ( < ) 1 /) 3 1 /3 ( %

& ) ! "

( % """ %

* 3 3 N "3

( %

(

& % ( !

!"%"

( & %

& 99" $ M %

$ "

2& % %

( $ "" " "

% "

99"

, ;L/ A "

!$ " %#

"( % )

!8( !

" $ ! ( ( "

""$

(

" $ &(. )

+ % " !

! ) + A"

BC,),B) "C

;B)C )

# "5 (

: :

# +

*! , & &

- :

!&&3 , ) / * .# -

3 , !

, +& ! '! F B

( C & +# & &

: - - 3 3 , . +# <5('

, ,

(# !- ! & - - !- 9: 3 ,

: 3 & +#

, .

, - & - !- 3

2 * + ,-

+ 3

, !

: 3 & &

*- .+& ! 3

& !- !- 3 , 8 9:

'! F B

( C !

; ;

> ! ! !

*- 3-

! &- 3

3 , "# (#

% *

4423 !

* & 2 : -

& , (# . +

* & 29

) )% >3: 2 554279$/ *

&& + 8& !

+ , - + ,- + (# /0

8& !

+# # &3 + ,

& C, & ) (.

&& + 8& !

& 3#!

. # ,-

, 3# #G /+0

8& !

+# # &3 +# C, &

? @8>3207725542

78 7 45 34< 8 7 6>3:56:3?

@/7>3 7::422262763737286 37527+=:32,58/48 :0/9216 73/07:6:=076>3:/597:6 7637372863752:=:32 ,58/48:09216 @.

(%+ (#

% *-

/! - (%+ *0- &

2 *- &

(%+ *

@. ";+&

) "

A &

!) ( A$

; / 0 & .# > & &&# 3,

& 3 +

; ;

(

+ &#

: '! F B

( C &

/ 0/ *-

+# .

& %

'! F B

( C

, 8& !

- 3

( ! &

# # .+&

*- 3

&- ! & .#

. - + 8& !

$!- % ,

/ 0/ 2 * 3

, .

& & & + & #

, ! *

!) /0

<# 3#

3 ,-

+# #

/0 +# *

&& * #

/20 *- & , (

& +&

# &- 3

& 6 9 ! !! , 8

# , ! .# > G /+0 $ (-

/ $ D *

&& * #

* & , & + & #

8 ,& , &- 3

& 6 9 3 # # +

6 9

/0 * .# #

/0 *

/ 0/

( ! &

# # .+& !

* & ,

; / 0I-

- ! &

- + 8& !

$!-

& , -

& -

+ &

& !

&&# +# D*

&& * #

/!0 ' + /+0 /0- , .

, .#

&# ! .

& , .

3& +

2 * 3 9: # & + ,

"3.-

- +

& 9:- 3

, & <5('- 3

& 3 .

&&,& # +# *%# ,.

& 9: ! 3 &&, 3 &.&& , #

* & 5 # - 6,-

.+& !

$!-

,& .# 3

* 3 & , .

, -

& 3 8 .

$!-

+ # &&,

&&,& #-

& 6 (# !-

+ & 3 .+& ! - - 3 & 3> , -

/ *

J &#- , - !

& #

& !

, 9: 3 3 ,

. , ! -

+& , -

&& #D6.

+# , ,

& !

! !

& +&

8 #

@. 3 - &&, ,

3 6 . F @, @=(- !-

. ,

A &

! , # . , 8D& 6 (# !

8 # 3 , &- 3

: .

3 %,

< 3 (F B

( C ' > B

( C-

+ # .

# # &- + , ,

3 # # 3 -

, 9:

&# && + , & +& + 8

/ .0 : .

3 !

&# && 3

+ ,

&& , # ! .

, 3

.&. # !! 2 4 :(-

/.0 $ .

- & <5('

, .

3 6 .- 3 , 8 *%# ,.- @= = &

, , 3

% !

+ &

8 " ' 8 F B

( C

,& #-

& + & # .

& .#

&# . !

' !

- !!

& 9:

/0 (

3 %, ";+&

$ ; " /"! = '>>'6'7 /

7 ,:,

+ & ) 4 8 ( ( !

"! ( !

)

)(

O51 (

(" "$

)

" %. . ($

& "0 ($

2;)$ $! . ( !$% !""$ %

2 % $ ""

($ " . ( !

(

)

% (

""$

( " "

"% "

" % !

8 $

($ " . J ""%

,( (" ! 8 !"

(

8 %

J ""%

,( "

(

% =5, " % 9 " +

% ! % ("

0BC).(

<% $ (

! $ BC) J

! ""%

=5, (" ! ""

(( "

8 %

2 J ""%

=5,

% 9 "

/% 9 " ! % ( (" $ <% ("

BC )

J ""%

=5,

( "

$ (

(

! +

( % %

0J .(

"%" %

( !

)

& B

" ( %

( % L $ ( ( !

)

& ( ! %

% ! %% !( 4 J

" ( % "

$ " L $ ( % "

" ! $ 8 % ! %

$ ! $ ( ( ! (

% $!-

&&3

, 9:

- 2 4 :(- , (& < - 6, 3&&

&# !

/0 (

- 1- 2 4 8- 8

? -,,.@

A > ,D KD

A +&