Malkiat Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"#"$%& ' ()"
*"$+, - ""$ . * /$0 1 - #2$3 $
.
4% $51( ./#"! *6 ("
. # $% . 0"$3 . (*"$+,738!
., 2 ""$ . .* .
10 *"$+,7 7/$0 1 999
# "# 1 "$+ ) $ /2 . , ."$+ ,./+, :"3
$ . $!"$+3/ 8"32 $3 4"! .
; ."$, 2 ""$/$3 .* !"$< . "# .+.
$ . +/( .1 "(, 2 ""$ .3/."$+, 2 $3 $!; ."
("$!
# '3 3< &. +"# . 3/$3 .* !"$7*!7& ("! * "$ , ."$3 7"#."!4."# . > .$ 3!/$# (!$ $3#, , 2 ""$ .?
.. # 3"$ ,
. 4 $"$ 3 !
# $ < $3 , # 1 $ "$ !/#3; #"$! , $7, /
(# 1( #. !8 . 37$(; 1( #? . # $ . !, 4"!
"$7, !, 1( !$ "$ 3'4+ .
3( ,;3.!,(."3 # (7?",$ ? "+, !, , 1( #1 "$+& 4+ < > .$ 3 !/$# ( . (" # /2$ , 3 !"#"$ "8"#"$ $!, ,"# /."$ !
# "( 3 # A
57
!$ $3, "$, 1# $! ((
1( #, 8"$+1 $# $, *>7"?/(3$1 2 $, 2.# !/"$2. #/4 , , . 4 "$"$+& (# (#!$ "$
' 4+ .
3( ,;3.!,(."3 # ( 2 . 1( ("
$! "# (# 2( ! 3 1; ( .$ 3 !/$# ( /2$ , 3 !"#"$ .3"$ $!, 3 "$ "$ !
# "( 3 A
5 > .$ 3!/$# (!$ $3#, (B/ $"; # ( , 1( ## $ .!, 4"!
( $ (;#"#7?.)#/'4+" #4 (( B/ $"; $3 /., ., "$, 1# $! ((
(# 1( #, 8"$+1 $ # $ . !, 4"!
( @ "$7 " "# $ 2 $ , 2.# !/"$
2. #/4 , , . 4 "$"$+& (# (#!$ "$, # 4 # ( ' > .$ 3!/$# ( /., .!$ $3#, , 2 ""$ ., #1 $ "$!/#3;#"$! < $3/ 2.# !/"$?"$ ## #7$(; 2.# !/"$?"$ ##, #1 $ @ 4"$ 3 $3, ."
("#$(") (;1 !$!(/3 3"$, $ . //. "$8" ? , !".!/4# $! #2. 8 "("$+$
!!/$ .$ :"./# $3 4"! = , 2#""$ # $ 3 18 , # $ 1 $ !$.8 . 3 1; ( .$ 3* /$# (7?,!$ ".4#, , $/41 . (# 1( ## $
.!, 4"!
"$?
#$(; $3, .
3(,;3.!,(."3 # (3 ! 3"$,
. 4 $"$ 3 1( #?
#'4+> .$ 3 * /$# (, #$1 $ 1( 3"#"$+/"#,, 0/3+4 $ $51( , "8"#"$ $!,"$ 5#!
# C#/2.
D7$, 2"$, "$ !
# $(; #4 (( # 42( .4 4$+# , (# 1( # "# # $ . !, 4"!
( @ "$7 ""#$ 2##"1( 2. #/4 , , . 4 "$"$+ (#!$ "$, # 4 # ( & !!.3"$+(;7 ?",/ !44 $"$+ /2$ , 4 ."# , !
# 71/1; )"$+"$ !!/$, , 2 ""$ ., #1 $"$!/#3;#"$!
< $3 # 2 . 3 !"#"$ , "8"#"$ $!, ,"# /. "$
5#!
# C#/2.
D""#$2##"1( 2. #/4 , ((. 4 "$"$+ 1( #!$ "$, # 4 # (?, . $(; #4 (($/41 . , (#
. # $ .!, 4"!
"$ (#"$8" ? ,
!, / 2.# !/"$?"$ ## #7$(; 2.# !/"$?"$ ##, #1 $ @ 4"$ 3
$3, ."
("#(") (; ) !$#"3 .
1( 2 ."3 "4 !$!(/3 "$8" ? , !".!/4# $! #2. 8 "("$+$ !!/$ .$ :"./# $3 4"!7, 2 ""$ .. +/( .1 "("#
$3, 2 ""$ ."#.3 . 31 . ( # 3 $. +/( .1 "(3/."$+, 2 $3 $!; , ."
($,"# /.$"#,"$+1 "(1$3
$3#/. ;1$3, # "#
!"$ , ( .$ 3."
( /.E ,"
/3"!"
( +"#.
E/; +"#.
!$! .$ 372.8"3 3, "#$. B/". 3"$ $; , .!
# ? 8 .7""#4 3 !( ., $,"$+# 3, . "$ 18 #, (( 1 !$#./ 3 $ @2. ##"$ 2"$"$$, 4 ."# , !
# "# (# 3 !( ., "$!
# , 2 ""$ .4"#/# #, !$! ##"$ 1 "("$ $; $$ . ?, # 8 .7 , 2.# !/"$ ?/(3 1 ("1 .; 48 $
22("!
"$ . !
$! (( "$ 1 "( +.
$ 3 , 2 ""$ . "$ , "$# $ !
# ""$ ((? 3"$,
. 4 $"$ 3 .4#
! "
!"#$%&'
(!&! )*% +"
,
-"
(!&! )&.
,
-"