High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/36861/2013dismissed

Central Excise Commissioner v. Vishal Gupta

2016-05-26Mr. Justice Krishna Murari12 pages

!"#"$% & '

$( )*!"# ++"##"$ ( ' , - . ""$ ( /# /"#, )01 . #1$2 $ % 34 55

( # $% (50$"#,"$2)"#,'26!

(, 1 ""$ ( (55, -, '26!

(, ( #1$2 $ ,"#"# 1 ""$0$2 (5 !"$89:

;( (# "$< #"2 , (2 (<( $"$<= ")( #1$2 $=&5 ##"$#0(' , -$0<0#

"$1(! 2"$<#0$2 (5 !"$9, $( )*!"# !'988'( #,( >, !3' !) "+"$< , , ( #1$2 $ 7 # (( # 2 $ 0<0# '

"$, "! 10$"#, =) 0$2 (5 !"$9, ! $27 #1(20! 2 = ( , $0<0#8'

7 #( + $2 2?02"!"

)!0#2& "))0<0# '

, = ") 11)"!

"$7 #2 !)"$ 2=&'6"2 (2 (

20<0# '

$2?02"!"

)( + $27 # * $2 2"))5 1 += (8'

, ( #1$2 $+6 2, 5 ##"$#0(' , -(<( $= ")"$ 7,"!,$"! 7 #"##0 2(0<0# @'

1)&7 #") 2"$, = ")

11)"!

"$6 $7(" $#0=+"##"$#7 ( + 2 "$, 11)"!

"$, 5 ##"$#02< 6"2 (2 ( $$ *0( , 2<( $ 2= ") , !

$! )) "$= "), #= $1( & 2($, <(0$2, , "$6 #"< "$7 #1 $2"$< , ?0$!0( 7, $= ")7 #<( $ 2 $2 $ $0+= ( 1 (#$# 7 ( $ ?"$"$< "$A0"(" # 2 #1" #0++$# 0$2 ( 5 !"$8, !, 0(2"2$ 11( !"

, + <$"02 , ( 02!++" 2, 5 ##"$#0(2"2$ 11( !"

, , $! 7 # 10$"#, =) 01@& (#B, ( #1$2 $7 #"$6)6 2"$ # ("0# !$+"! $! B ) (< $0+= ( "$A0"(" # ( #")) 1 $2"$< !(0!"

) # < B , ( #1$2 $ "# )"- )& +1 ( 7", , 6"2 $! B $2 , 5 ##"$# 02< 7($<)& 11)" 2, ( ", ?02<+ $!" 2=&=,, 1 (" # (50$"#,"$2)"#,'!0$# )(, 1 ""$ (, # (<0 2, , $! 0$2 (, $( )*!"# !, #= $+ 2 $$= =) =&7 & + $2+ $7,"!,!

+ "$ !7 & '

, ?02<+ $ , 1 *0("$

@ ;4 :5;', # , )2, $! #0$2 (*!"# 7 ( $$!<$"C =) '= =) $270)2= 1 ( "6 1(#1 !"6 )&7 #0(< 2, , + $2+ $"#$+ ( )& 1(! 20( ) !, $< ( , ( # + 7 # , #0=# $"6 ) 7 6"2 7,"!, , $! 7 # + 2 !<$"C =) $2 $$= =) # #0!, , $ 0( , $! !

$$= !, $< 2= =) 7 #0(< 2, , = ")!0)2$=

<( $ 2 #=& $ + $2+ $, $! 7 #2 !) ( 2$$= =) 4 ($ 2 !0$# )(, 1 ""$ (, #0(< 2, , $)&<(" 6 $! , 1 ""$ ( "#, , =# (6 "$#+ 2 =&, 5 ##"$#0("#)"- )& !, , (!

# #"$7,"!,, 1 ""$ ("# !+1) "$ $4 ($ 2!0$# )(, 1 ""$ (, ##0=+" 2, , "$2"$<, 5 ##"$#02< "$(2 (2 2 0<0# 9'

,)2"$<, , ( #1$2 $70)2= <6 ($ 2=&, )2 1(6"#"$#1("( & '

'#,0)2= # #"2 #, 1(! 20( ) 7 !

$ = + 2 1 ( "6 ( (#1 !"6 )& , + "$ !$ $"$ ) ($ 2 !0$# )(, 1 ""$ ("#, , + $2+ $7,"!,7 #+ 2 6"2 ")) @

+ -"$<, $! $$= =) '#,0)2= !$#(0 2= ( (#1 !"6 "$ $ 0( $2 " #,0)2 = , )2 , ( #1$2 $ 70)2 = 2 + 2 = $ !!0# 2 "$ $$= =) $! 2 #1" , ! , , $! !++" 2=&,"+7 #1("( & '

' #, 20& 6 #"$

)) < 2"$, !

# "# (+ $0 (&

1(")

$2 20& *! 2#

#D ) !# , !$ $"$#) ($ 2!0$# )(, 1 ""$ (, 6 = $

$#7 ( 2 =& , ) ($ 2 5 ##"$# 02< =& + -"$< , ))7"$< =# (6 "$#% ED $, "$# $!

# '=&7 & "$ $! + $2+ $ "$!@'7,"!,!

+ "$ !$ D

', $! 7,"!,7 #$$!<$"C =) $2= =) , #= $ + 2 !<$"C =) $2$$= =) ", 6 #"$20& *! 2# #D

) !#

" , ( ( ' 1("( , + $2+ $ 7,"!, !

+ "$ ! $ D

' , ("<, , !!0# 2

11)"!

$ 7 # = $) (< 2 $ = ") $ !!0$ $! = "$<= =) "$$ 0( $2 (, + $2+ $ , $! , #= $+ 2 $$= =) $2 ##0!,, )0 =) ("<,, !!0# 2F 11)"!

$= ( ) # 2 $= ")=&, (( #"$<"! (, #= $"$("$< 2 $2 # #0!,, + $2+ $6"2 !@!

$$= # "2=

1(! 20( ) + $2+ $( , (, # + , # ! 2, )0 =) ("<,, !!0# 2 11)"!

$ @ , $3=) 1 *0("$,"( + ) ", +"!

)# 4"+" 23#!

# :#01( ;, #2 )7",, #0=# $"6 $2 1(! 20( ) ) 7 $2 , # !+ , ))7"$< !$!)0#"$%

$ # % &

( # ) * +,-.

-/0 (

# ! '

1 2+,.-3 ## 5/0 6 '

$& ) *

1 ) * 2+,,/3 /

## 1" # (

9 ) * 2+,,,3 ## +78 )

: ) 2400+3 ## 4/

;

, ( ( ' #"$! , $3=) 1 * 0( "$ +

(- #,3# !

# :#01( ; , # , )2 , , $! = =) $ 0( '=0, + $2"$<")) @

, # 2"6 # 2, !!0# 2 11)"!

$,"#("<,= ( ) # 2 $= ")=&, (( #"$<"! (=&+ -"$<, $! # $$= =) "$$ 0( $2 ##0!,, # + "#)"

=) = !$#(0 2 #1(#1 !"6 "$$ 0( "# 1 ("$ $ + $"$ , ( , , ( "# $ # 6"$<!) 0# "$, $ 7)& + $2 21(6"#"$#(, ( "# $ + $" # "$ $"$ , , + $2+ $ 7,"!, !

+ "$ !70)21 ( ( (#1 !"6 $2 ##0!,", #

$ = , )2, , $ !+ $7,"!,!

+ "$ !7 # 1(#1 !"6 "$ $ 0( $2 $ ( (#1 !"6 $2 # #0!, , !!0# 2 11)"!

$ 70)2 = <6 ($ 2 =& , )2 1(6"#"$#" 1("( D

G $ 6" 7 , =6 =# (6 "$#' , ( #1$2 $ , 2 = $ <( $ 2, !$! ##"$= ") , 6 !$#"2 ( 2, =6 # "2=# (6 "$# $2 -"$<"$ !$#"2 ( "$, !$ $"$#) ($ 2!0$# )(, 1 ""$ ('2$ "$2 $& "$"(+"& "$ , =# (6 "$# + 2 =& , 5 ##"$# 02< "$

11)&"$<, 1("$!"1) 1(#1 !"6"&"$, + ("$ (1( "$ $

+ $2+ $ 6 $ " ( , # - (<0+ $#' " "# 1( #0+ 2 , , $! A0 , ( #1$2 $"#$$= =) $2!<$"C =) ', ( "#$= ((

0( <( $ !$! ##"$ = ") "$ $$!<$"C =) $! ' # 1 ( , 1(6"#"$#, ( 5 !"$8@( ( 2# #))7#% E8@H, $ = ") + & = - $ "$ !

# $$ = =) $! I:; H, $ $& 1 (#$ !!0# 2 ' ( #0#1 ! 2 ' , !++"##"$ $& $$ = =) $! "# (( # 2 ( 2 "$ 2 7",0 7 (( $ =& $ "! ( "$ !, (< 1)"! # "$ ( (# ( "# =(0<, = ( 0( , ( , $ , "<, 0( ( 0(5 ##"$', + &= ( ) # 2$= ")'=0 :"; #0!,1 (#$#, ))$= #( ) # 2", ( ( ( #$ =) <(0$2#(= )" 6"$<, , , #= $<0")&

$ $! 10$"#, =) 7",2 ,("+1("#$+ $( )" B :""; #0!,1 (#$#, ))$= #( ) # 2"#0!, $! "# !<$"C =) $! $2 , , 2 = $ 1( 6"0#)& !$6"! 2 $ $! 10$"#, =) 7", 2 ,' "+1("#$+ $()" ("+1("#$+ $(# 6 $& (#( +( ' ( , , 2 = $ 1( 6"0#)& !$6"! 2 $ 7 ( +( !!

#"$# !<$"C =) $! 10$"#, =) 7", "+1("#$+ $ ( ,( & ( ( +( =0 $ ) ## , $ # 6 $& (#%

(6"2 2, , 0(+ &2"( !, 1 (#$( (( 2 "$!) 0# :";(!) 0# :"";= ( ) # 2$= ")"#0!, 1 (#$"#0$2 (, < #"* $& (#("# 7+ $( "##"!-("$"(+%

(6"2 2 0(, ( , , 0( + & )# 2"( ! , 1 (#$( (( 2"$!) 0# :"";= ( ) # 2$= ")"""# # "#" 2, "#?0# $21(1 (#2( $&, ( #1 !"

)( #$%

(6"2 2 )#, , + ( !, $ !!0# 21 (#$ + &= ( A0"( 2(= "$<"2 $"" 2=&7"$ ## #20("$< "$6 #"< "$#, ))$= #0"!" $<(0$2(( 0#"$< <( $= ")", "#, (7"# $") 2= ( ) # 2$= ")

$2<"6 # $0$2 ( -"$<, , #, ))!+1)&7",#0!, 2"( !"$# #+ &= <"6 $=&, 0(

(6"2 2 )#, $1 (#$#, ))'", $! )) < 2 , 6 = $!++" 2=&,"+"#10$"#, =) 7",2 ,' "+1("#$+ $()" ''("+1("#$+ $(# 6 $& (# (+( '= ( ) # 2$= ")=&, 0(0$2 (,"##0= # !"$ 7",0 <"6"$< $ 11(0$"& , ("$< ,

0=)"! (# !0( :

; " (##0!,"! ((0( $&# < , "$6 #"< "$'"$A0"(&(("

)' #, !

# + &= ', , ( ( $ ( #$ =) <(0$2# ( = )" 6"$< , ,

!!0# 2, #!++" 2 $$= =) $! '=0, , ( ( #0"!" $ <(0$2# ( 0(, ( "$A0"(& "$ ,"#<0"), !!0# 2#, ))'#0=? !, 1(6"#"$# # !"$ 88 $2 1 $2"$<#0!,"$A0"(&' = ( ) # 2 $ = ")J( , 2"#!( "$#0!,"! ((0('$, * !0"$ =& ,"+ =$2 7",0 #0( " # ( ,"#

( $! #, ( "$ (1(6"2 2 :; H, $ 1 (#$ !!0# 2 ( #0#1 ! 2 , !++"##"$ $ $! 10$"#, =) 7","+1("#$+ $ 7,"!, + & * $2 # 6 $ & (# ( +( ( $ $! 0$2 (, 1 (/', 1 (K/(, 1 (K/ , $2"

$ $ )2 ( = + $'(!$#1"( !&(

+1!++"' $&#0!, $! '"#( ) # 2$= ") 0$2 ( #0= # !"$ :;' , 0( #, )) "+1# $& !$2""$F :

; , #0!, 1 (#$ #, )) $2 "$ !!(2 $! 7", , !$2""$#, =$2 * !0 20$2 (,"#, 1 (' :=; , #0!, 1 (#$ #, )) $ !++" $ $! #"+") (, $! 7,"!,, "# !!0# 2( , !++"##"$7,"!,, "##0#1 ! 2' $2 :!; , #0!, 1 (#$ #, )) $ 2"( !)& ( "$2"( !)& + - $& "$20! + $' ,( ( 1(+"# $& 1 (#$

!A0 "$ 2 7", , !# , !

# # # 2"##0 2 ,"+ (+ 2"#!)#"$< #0!, !# , 0( ( $& 1)"! "! (( +1 (7",, 6"2 $! ' $2 + & )# "+1# ' "$ , "$ ( # ?0#"! ' #0!, , (!$2""$# #"!$#"2 (#$ ! ## (& :8; $"! (( 0(( ) #"$< $&1 (#$$= ") 0$2 (#0=# !"$:;(#0=# !"$:

;'#, ))( !(2"$ 7(""$< ,"# ( "# L( #$# ( #1 !"

) # #$#J ( # 2"$< :D; $& 0( 7,"!, , # ( ) # 2 1 (#$ $ = ") 0$2 ( #0= # !"$ :; ( #0= # !"$ : ;' + &' " " !$#"2 (#"$ ! ## (&#2'2"( !, #0!,1 (#$=

(( # 2 $2!++","+!0#2&

:; '"$ $&!

# ("

=) =& <"#( ', ("

) 1 (#$ !!0# 2 $& $$ = =) $! "# $ !$!)02 2 7","$ 1 ("2 #"*& 2 &# (+ , "(# "* 2 ( -"$< 6"2 $! "$ , !

# ' #0!, 1 (#$ #, ))' " , "# "$ !0#2& 20("$< , 7,) , # "2 1 ("2' = ( ) # 2 $ = ") , # "# !"$ , <"#( '0$) ##(( #$#= ( !(2 2"$7(""$<' , <"#( , (7"# 2"( !# :@; ' $&"+ (, !$!)0#"$, ("

) 1 (#$ !!0# 2 $$ = =) $! $2 = ( ?02<+ $"#2 )"6 ( 2', 0("#1"$"$, , (

( ( #$ =) <(0$2#(= )" 6"$<, , !!0# 2"# $ <0")& $& #0!, $! ' " #, )) ( ) # ,

!!0# 2'", "#"$!0#2&'$, * !0"$=&,"+ =$2 7",0 #0( " # ( ,"# ( $! , ( ?02<+ $2 )"6 ( 2G 1 (0# ), =6 # "21(6"#"$#"$2"!

#, 6 $"""# 1( #0+ 2(, # - (<0+ $#, $! A0 , ( #1$2 $"#$$ = =) ', ) ($ 2 <"#( (, 5 ##"$#0(!0)2, 6 (2 ( 2, ( ) # $&1 (#$$= ")0$2 (#0=# !"$#:;(:

;5 !"$8@ ( =& ( !(2"$< "$ 7(""$< , ( #$# ( 2"$< # , ) ($ 2 5 ##"$#02< , # * (!"# 2?0("#2"!"$"$ !!(2 $! 7",) 7, ( 2 # $ ( = $& ( #$ "$ ( ( "$ , (2 ( 1 ## 2 =& ,

5 ##"$#0(, ( 2 #$ (= $&( A0"( + $ 2?02"!

$ , A0 #"$ ( "# 2 =& !0$# ) ( , 1 ""$ ( , $! 0$2 ( 5 !"$ 9 , ! #,0)2 = , )2 $$= =) $2 !<$"C =) 7", ( (#1 !"6 !7", $=? !"6 + "$ "$#("$< $!&<( $= ")# "$ $! #0$2 (, *!"# !, 17 ( * (!"# 2"#!( "$"$$$ = =) $! #"#<0"2 2=&, 1(6"#"$#) 7 $2 02"!"

) "! ("# ( A0"( 2=? !"6 )&!$#"2 (, !"(!0+# $! #!$#"2 (7, , (, 2"#!( "$= ")"#= * (!"# 2"$$$= =) $! "$ 1 ("!0) ( !

# ($ $6" 7, =6 !"(!0+# $! #'$<(0$2"#+ 2 0 !

$! ), = ")<( $ 2( #1$2 $ "#+"## 2 & '

:5; # $?