High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/34150/2017dismissed

Shiv Lal @ Sholly v. State Of Punjab

2017-10-24Mr. Justice Krishna Murari5 pages

! !"#$#%& " '!( ) *+#,-./*+..0 1 ! # #%!( 2$ * ! 3%4' 1 !$5%6!% & 7- **

(!$!% & (2#%6+#)*(6," !8# + (*!+%6#( )6," ! ( +!5! # #%!( $%4(#!+(393.)66.) 3%4' (* *#%%)6," ! ( +!":5.#%% 2#6! (6!( 6 !6 " '!( ) ;) +! #($ 5! # #% 3%6!( *!" #%<( (=(% (!=3.('#.63(#%= +!5!%6!%"0 +! (#.

#.!6'0 +!5! # #%!(8$6#$:#$$!6==(#!,!6'0 +!6#$:#$$. +!'#. 5! # #%) +! 5! # #%!( +6 #.!6 *- >(.? @ ; ; 8+#"+ 8$ 6#$:#$$!6%3.0) $ =!8+!%8# %!$$!$3 @@8# %!$$!$ $ 6!A:#%!6%,#!8 +!$#6"+%=!6"#("3:$ %"!$)# 8$6#(!" !6 + +!5! # #%!(83.6 #.! (!$+55.#" #% ('#.'!

(! +! (#.3( 8+#"+ 83.6 '! "%$#6!(!6 8# +3 '!#%= #% .3!%"!6 '0 +! !(.#!( (6!( 5$$!6'0 +#$3( ) !("%$#6!(#%= +!$3':#$$#% +!5( #!$

+!55.#" #% #.!6'0 +!5! # #%!('!

(! +! (#.3( +$ =#%'!!%6#$:#$$!6,#6!(6!(6 !63=3$ ) +!5! # #%!(#$%""3$!6 "(#:#%."%$5#("0 :3(6!( +#:%B.%=8# + +!(""3$!68+8$..!=!6.0!(.#!(%!:5.0!! +! 5! # #%!( '3 . !( % $!,!(!6 +! 8(B (!. #%$+#5 ( 8+#"+ +! 5! # #%!(+6..!=!6.0=(#!,%"!=#%$ +#: +!$ (0 +!5($!"3 #%#$ + %!"!:'!() +! 5! # #%!(+6+ "+!6"%$5#("08# ++#$%!5+!8:# 6%6:6! 5+%!".. 6!"!$!6+#:%B% +!5(! !A + +!6#$53 !$83.6'! ":5(:#$!6+!6!"!$!6.%=8# +3(4% *#%=+/#% 8!% +!

(:+3$! +!5! # #%!(8+!(!+%6$)8(#$ $%6' + +! !! +#: %B8!(!"+55!6

'0 +!:!:'!($ 3%.8 3.$$!:'.053($3% +!..B('0(5(!! *#%=+#% +! (:+3$! +!5! # #%!( % +! #% !(,!% #% 3(4% *#%=+)+#$+%68$.$"+55!6

%((#,. $5.*#%=+/+.#% +! (:+3$!)%.(:8$(#$!6'0+#:%B %63(4% 8+!%.. +!:!:'!($ 3%.8 3.$$!:'.0(%80 (: +! $5 +! (#. 3( 8+#.! 6#$:#$$#%= +! 55.#" #% ( '#. +$ '$!(,!6$ ..8$& C@ +#$"$!8$(!=#$ !(!6% +!$ !:!% %4# *#%=+ +#$ $ !:!% +$ '!!% $#=%!6 '0 40 93:( $% 493:('!#%=4#% ":5.#%% % +#$"$!) +!(!(! 8$! 8# %!$$!$)%!$! '!.%=$ #%43(!6 #!3(4% *#%=+/% D$ :#.0%6 +! +!($! #$ (!. !6 +#:%B6!"!$!6D$ :#.063' ) +! 8# %!$$!$ '!.%= 3(4% *#%=+ / #% #%43(!6D$

:#.0 #! 3(4% *#%=+ +#:$!.

) %4# *#%=+ ":5.#%% >'( +!( #%43(!6 3(4% *#%=+? %6 +#$ : !(%. 3%".! $5. *#%=+ +,! (!$#.!6 (: +!#( $ !:!% $ $ ( $ ""3$!6 *+#, -. 6 %6 :# 6 (! "%"!(%!6) '3 +! +!( 8# %!$$!$ '!.%= +#:%B6!"!$!6D$ :#.0#!93$+.0!,# E ) *3%#. 93:( E; %6 40 93:( E +,! $355( !6 +! "$! +! 5($!"3 #% $ ( $ +! ..!= #%$ "(#:#%. "%$5#("0 =#%$ ""3$!6 *+#, -. 6 (! "%"!(%!6 ,!% %! +! : !(#. 8# %!$$%:!.0B$+$% 4#%6!(93:(#$0! '! !A:#%!6+!:#%""3$!6 +#$"$!+6"+55!6

%! +%6 3(4% *#%=+ %6 .$ "+55!6

' + +%6$%6' + !! +#:%B8# + +!(!$3. +!+6 6#!6 % +! 80 $5# . ..!= #%$ =#%$ +! 55.#"% F""3$!6(!$!(#3$#%% 3(!%6+!+$'!!% "+(=!$+!! !6 ( +!"::#$$#%

!%"!$ F F ;F F FF F@F< %6 $!" #% > ? *F*" 3 8+#"+

!%"!3%6!($!" #% #$ +!#%3$"(#:!+!(!

(!)B!!5#%=#%,#!8 +! (!$#6

" $G"#("3:$ %"!$ +!"$!)5( #"3.(.0=(,# 0

!%"! %6 $!(#3$%!$$ +! ..!= #%$ =#%$ 55.#"% ) +#$ "3( 6!$ % #%6 # # "$! =(% "%"!$$#% '#. +! 55.#"% F""3$!6 !%"!) +! 5(!$!% 55.#" #% ((!.!$#%= +!55.#"% %'#.#$ 6#$:#$$!6 8# +3 +,#%= 5(!436#"! +! 55.#"% F""3$!6 % :!(# $ +! "$! 8!,!() # #$ :6! ".!( + #% ,#!8 +! (6!($ %D'.! #=+ 3( '08+#"+ +! (#. +#$"$!+$'!!%:6! #:! '3%6)..3 !

( $8#..'!:6! "%".36! +! (#.$ 6#(!" !6 '0 +! %D'.! #=+ 3( ) '0 =#,#%= $+( 643(%:!% $ 5!($ +! '#. 55.#" #% '! ==!6 8# + +!:#%"+..% #.!5!%6#%=#% +#$3( H

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

%"! "%$5#("0 .!$ # $+3.6 5(!436#"! +! 5($!"3 #% =!%"0 ( +! 5! # #%!() $ +! (#. #$ (#5! ( #%.

55(!"# #% !,#6!%"! (6! !(:#%#%= +!"3.5'#.# 0 +!5! # #%!( +#$5!%3. #: !$ =!:0

!" +! #%.6436#" #%$ +! (#.#$'!#%= 3%6!( B!%%60 60'$#$3%6!( +!6#(!" #%$ +!#=+3( %,#!8 +!',!) +!$!"%65! # #% ('#.#$6#$:#$$!6$ 6 % #%6 %0 "+%=!6 =(3%6 =(% +! "%"!$$#% '#. +! 5! # #%!( " '!( ) >*? $%40 E+! +!($5!B#%=F(!$%!6& !$F E+! +!((!5( '.!& !$F