← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/506/2021dismissed

Shaheed Bhagat Singh Co-Operative House Building Society Ltd. v. Ludhiana Improvement Trust And ORS And Others

2026-03-25Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri17 pages

    

 

       



 !"#

/+0. !$%&%"'

1          

   

  22!--' +&.

  



               !&2"'3!'

+&.

   ( 

       ) ( 

 ! "#$ "% ! '#( # %   % & & ! )#$ * "% ! "# " % ! +"  % & ) ,

! -- % % ( ... % &

  & 

(

#  

    *+,- -.       &       

"  # &             /

0     1 - 2   34&  

5&&&&&  /

,"&& 

 8   &   9  1  1&   : ;&   4 <

 &    &     &# %&  =

      &   & &8"# & &8

&&8&  5>)

66 =0

&

/

=06

   (  &       && &&8 )&

=7

 &&     1  "&   &   && ?1 "&  % 1 &   ,"&   )

=/  =

==   @"& ,& & 7&

=    &       1  "& && &@  &  &        &  &&            1  "&   7

%& 7&   &   ,"&         7     

  &  ?   &&        //     7  &   ? &    &  4&

  //        ,"&     & $  

==6 51-2A5'-2B           &      &5 //  &&       &      

2   

   

=

== &  ,"& 1  "& (        & &  &     &1 "&

 "&&?&  1 "&   / $  8&(  



  & ,"&  1  "&      & &  &8 4&   5 5    //       ,"&1 % /

034& 5&    //1  "&   , "& ?      

0C

==7)51-5 %        

    5 &       4&  & &&58      4&  D    & &                          4&     &  &     &        5>) /=00

  

  "  *   &    &  && ,"&       1  "&  &  

?     //  ?      

"#4&   ,"&1 4& 

==6&   &   // ,"& ,"&  "&



&   " 5        " * &               &        & &   &    ,"&    &    "&&&#&(         &   

=

==        8 &   ,"&      1  "&      (  

&&&   // ,"&1 &    8 "5    ? "  *  && &   &&   //    &   1  "&   

    &        "5 ,&  ,"&   &&  ? " * && =

  " 5     &   &" *     &  ,"& &    &               & & ?     &   &    & //  "&  & &         " * 

"5 &    ?    & &// &, "&        &  & &   && 34& 5&&&   &  "  *        /

0    34& 5&  

 //,"&

"5 ,  " *  

&&&&   &   //       ,"&   "&(  #?&

4&,"& 1 "&& 

 (          &   "&@1  & 8 //    1  "&  4    && &

(  //&  &        4& &     &             , "&1 "&   &8&? =7 

"5 ,"&&   1  "&   (       &   1  "&   &            "&             "&   &   & & &            "&  5

 5>) /  == & /

+& ?  &&&  " *  &  ? 

/

  " 5        & & 1 "& #&5  & &&  &1 & &,&&  &&,&

 " 5      & =7 ,&@   <& & &        1  "&       &       4& &  4&

 " 5       1 & =7    &    

         1 "&& & ( 

&   &  " *  ?

>      " 5         && &

     &        "& =7 ,"& & &8    =0   &8    ,&  ,&   5    =0

 &      E   &         (   # &          ,&   6  8   &8  &

=7

%    & &8     (  =7   ,"&    "&   D      &&1 "&   7,&   =

==

&  7 &1 "& ? ,"&     ,"&

=   ,"&&& +F"58&  & 5       //    1  "&

/ &   7&  /

 ( #?& &&   &&?

   ?,& &1 '&  ( ?&&&%

   ,&          1  "&    &  &8 &&&1  &&&&      1  "& &  ? 

  &      & & "&   71 / )       &   (  

  &      ,"&   "&             &&   &     &&     &&  &     1  "&   "5&

// /

"534& 5  8           &5 &  34& 5&   1 &"  *  && && @#&   &?     //    &              ,"&     & & 1 "& 7  &  8   &  &     (  && &    ,&   &  

&  67

8 G &1 "& 1 "&,"&       ?         ( 

=7 &  &&8 &

&  ,&1 2 & &

(  34& 58 & &           4&  

/ # & 5    &  &    //   1  "& && &     &  /<  "  *     &  &   && & @      &    & &  &            &       (  

   &               71 &    ( 

&( 

&   /  " 5        <     "&&   &&& 1 &&&& " *  

/6    &      ,& & &&8 & 1 "& 

/1 '  8      (       ,"&&&8&? =7 /0 ,"& &    1  "&  8   

  &      &  &            &    

  &,"&  &          @   1  "& ?  /7     &     (  

               1 '& 

&    &           "&      /=

    (  

   1 "& &  

    &            &          &  +& &1 "&  < &4& &1 

/ "& &&  1 "&  7 &4& 8       ,&  4&  

&             &       &&&  &  &

'&  <    1  "& &  &   

   (   & &    &&   ,"&& 4&     &       1  "&   &&&& & &" *  

&   </ 2         " 5   

 ,"&4&1  &

& ,"&1 "& 

<< && &        ,"&  4&  

/

"&&   +& & &8 &

&, &1 "&      ,"&       ,&1 "&<   &&&&&4& 55 71 2 && &1 "&&  "&&  4&1 "&(   &?    &&  + 5&& 4&        & &      "& <6

&&&"5                &,"&&            ,"&          &  <0 &&&?& 8& 

(  &&4&

/

1 "& &&   1  "& &     +&  @                      "&   & "&    1  "&    &     &      ,&1 "& &  <7 2  & ,"&1   7 ' 7      &  //           4    +     & ?   ( 

4&,&  1  "&     

  &  ,& <=

      &     ,"&     &       ,"&"& &           &        &&& ,&1 "& 5 &  "5

/4

'&

& ,"& &&&&&  &,&34& 5       //   &   &    "  *    

 &    &&& +& &//     #    5 5       8& & %&&   " * 

  34&  5    /

0   //     "&   ,"&        ,"& # 

# &'5

) 

/ 

 &&    +     .  

, /,

6 "( + ) .   >? CG >)