← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/488/1999disposed of

Devta Singh v. M/S.Asea Brown Boweri Ltd.

2023-12-08Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

     !"# $%&'%!(%% % %) %! 

*+,-./0-1232.455 *-6,+2478 55559+24,2//::-99+4, ;-<3=3

>33-+?<.@4?.@-<2A,05 555-3:.40-4,

!%BC D&E B!F$ G

%B% % )%!( HHHHH <-3-4,

<555?8+40+<2I06.1+,-I/.<,8-+::-99+4,5

<5J2<K+98+<K+I06.1+,-/.<

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

4 55R5 T8- 19+2K @+3 3=O3,+4,2+,-0 OM 3=OK2,,247 + /-@ +7- :<../3 +40 @+3 <-Q-1,-0-+<92-</.<O-247,..O-9+,-05 5 T8- 3=2, @+3 1.4,-3,-0 OM ,8- 0-/-40+4, .4 ,8- 7<.=40 ./ O-247 4., K+24,+24+O9- +40 /29-0 +, ,8- /+7 -40 ./ 3-<621-5 U4 +002,2.

 

 ! "# #

  %& #

   "

! %% #"# '! # #   "# &$ '(! !& %!

!!) 

# # &  *)&

(# +)!   ! "#!

#* '! !

# &$&, , -  & )  

"

#(  

!!)! #  #(   ()"#! !"

!!   !) 

& #(    

(    #  #(   (  $! '! # 

(  )# *""# &'

)  !%* & &', .)   / !0 * *# #!   %& #

' (0#

  1#)! & 2"%&$"# # #(

!

*/ 3 #  )!/   & )  # +) ! * #  # #   *& "! !"'! 

&   %%%  )" ,,4 )), , (( 0 ( #!    0/   %& #

& # %%&

    &' %%&& )/ '

* *" 

!"

!! '

&  

# #(!   & ) ' 

"

!0 #(     

 '! * '$

*5 # ,,3

) '!

 #( * &&#(  &

#   *   0 #( " #

# !0 *

  )  *!, - )!/   ) &   *& 

& 0#

 

)#&+) *)%#, 3, 4# *)#!& ')& *##     )!

&' 0 '#(&$ !"

!!   !)  !   %& #

 %)* #)( 0 #*  !) !#   

*   '!

# # ,, # #    '

# #   !&$ !& %!, #*/ ! )& # 0

#   # ,,3/ '

* '!

! #    *

#   !0 *

5, .) / '

 !%*   

!!) +) ! * #/ !) !     !) 

&

# & ) *##

!  

# " # # &,  & ! )%#   +)("# #6 &   )%" )

#7 89:9;<=9>77 ?8@A7 B;C7DEF;=>97D9><G7 )%%  3, ,

#     #/ &# *)#!&

   !%## !)   

   

  !" #$  %# & ' ( ) $( *(+  %$

#%# %# ,' $

% # -

!,%$( %$ (% %( %# %% (! %# ' $

%

+#%') ,$(,'

!! %#% %# %

 ($% (%(*'. /#'  (+ %# ! - !+ (%" %#'$  &&''%$

%!!%$('')#'!%#%%#,'  !*'%!'). .  !(!&

!. . 0#

' $ +#%" *(+ %$$ '% ( %# !)" $ ,#(+ $ !% $ * %# $ .. %$ .. *) '(+ % $(%# & $ %$ # !% $

%  (% $( %%((+ %# + $ & (( %$(. 0# &'(%" % %# %  $ -$((+" (%$(! %# $  !% ( # &&',%$( (! %# " ($ !% $%# %#( %#% ,$ '! # *(

,$ !! ( %#  , *$$1. ,,$ !(+')" %#  

 '$

%%( $(  ) $(%#')

+ '&  ! %$ # " % %'' %# &'(% (

!()&'%$,$

,%%# . . 0#  , ,$(!%$( $ %# &&''(%

 +$ (! *) 2(!

% ' 3 &'$) (% %(!(+

! ,%" 4 #$  

+ ! %# %% $ !% $ * %#"   

%#( %# &

 $ ,' $

%"

#,# (!

+#%+ $ 6789:;55 <:=7>:?@A55 B9C55 DEFGH5  

(I(  "

# ( %# +# $

% ! ! %# % $ ,$

,%$( $ !% $ * %# *) $* (+ %#% % #$ '! * '! *$ %# I*$

$

%" % $(J*' %#  &   $

% % ! %#   *) #$'!(+ %#%" K2(

$&($(" %# & (% ,  ($% ,$ ! *) & (,&'  (!   %#  ($'!

'% $(') %$ %# ,$

,%$( $ %# !% $ * %#. L

!,%$( $ %# ,' ,$

%  ($% %!"  %#  ($% ,

'%(+ %$ ($ , (% $

+#% ( $*'+%$(

(! %# 2(!

% ' M& % ,%" .N 0# " %# (!(+ $ %# $

% *'$ $( %#  $ -

!,%$( ,(($% * (%(!.

   

!

# $%"& '(

) &"# ) *

++ ))"

&,%,)  # - ,#$,&

,"

,"

#,

'

,"

&& +

$ . ,)).

&# $ # " )$ !& /

" !

, #  )"

)( * + ,$ *  (  # ," *,),"

+ #,

* ',  & &

$. # " '

-# ,*, '( + ,"

"( &

#" 0" #,!,) )( &, &!# "& $ &# . /

++),& ," * &"

,"

* ',  /# *,)  (  #

,"$& ," ,"

%,& . , /# )$ '( "1')

+ !

 ,"2 3454622 9:;:2 <=:22 ;>6?@5@22 3A>B<5=2 .    CC.

. DE

# , !(. ,"  +,",".

)( * %

/ &$ # ," ++)(,"

*

& & ," *

* ',  ,#

F *&, )

&# *

#+"$ . " /, # "$,"

*&

/# " #+ &,*,& )   $ . * !

 !$ . + #& ,',"

+ ,$ /, ," /,& #& ++),& ," &)$ '

*,) $ ,#

,

," #& #, ," #& " ++),& ," #)$ '

*,) /,& &" '

)$

'

#"')   ++),& ," *,) '(

#+"$  (  #

,# ,"$& ," ,"

%,& . '( " "$ $#. &" '

)$

'

#"') . ! # / "

')

!+ /# !$



F+),"

#,$ )(G H ,"2 I5>J545K522 LM>5@22 NJ8>5=4>MO4M>62 P6<6@7Q?6J42R4S:2<=:2T:;:2U545>5V52 .   ., /# )$  D"#,$ ,"

* #,$ &,#,"# *

,# 

)/ " &"

*$

*', &"'

#!! ,W $#"$  , ++),& ," * &"

*

* ',  &" ")( '

# +

) %"

+ %,#,"#X

) ,"#++),&') Y ,,

,*

,# &

%,$ "& .

#!

&"" '

&),!

$#!

* , Y ,,, ++),& ," &" '

- &

"

"$ * )( "$ ) & # )# ! + ,&) )( / , ,# !$

"$ * %,& "$X /

!+)(

,# '

, "

,","

*#+ "" ,"G   )( ," ,", , ," * )

) + &

$,"

# ,# Z,"

)* ). &"# [ "& # /

*.

)!# &

," 0" ), *

'% $,#&##," "$

 

 ! !"#"!$%& $'" (!!)% ( $'"  $% *"

+& !% (

% $'",

$" $ $'"" *"!) ! %$ ! ( $'" -  $ $ $, $'" $$"

% !- -" '""!

"& $ $'

"(("$ "-"%".  +"-"& $'" )#"!$ $" .. ( $'"

$" $") !)$'""

,! %!)$'"

#&%'""*, '"

. . % (

$ ($'" * -"&$'" "%"!$

%% %" (. / 01213/451675189:/ / ;<=>?=?;?@/ / A67BC/ !D E'"$'"% D!)F"

% !"  G"%FH E'"$'""

"  G"%FH