Darshan Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab And Others
!
"
# "
"$%& )&*+,+'-
. . "$/,0$- 1+-20 ......
&%+%+'-&/
3&/,4,
77&$5,8 4-9$:
'%0&/, ......
&,7'-)&-%,
;!< .
1 1 !
/&,&-% /.
10&//= >.
1+-25$8 )?'*$%& 7&%+%+'-&/.
/.
$/7/&&% 1+-208 4-9$:.
/.
1$/94 4/+8 1&-+'/ )?'*$%& @+%0 /.
"+2?+9$= $-*0$-)$8 )?'*$%& .
. . 1 !
.
< .
/$=&/ +-,%$-% *+?+5 @/+% 7&%+%+'- (+5&) /%+*5&, '-,%+%4%+'- -)+$8 +-%&/ $5+$8 +, +,,4$-*& @/+% -$%4/& *&/%+'/$/+ ,&%%+-2
77&$5,8 4-9$:
,0'/% ;
'66+,,+'-&/; &A%&-% @0&/&:=
:&&- "+,%/+*% 10$0&&) !0$2$% 1+-20 $2$/
,0'/% ;'55&*%'/; (/&,0 *'-,+)&/$%+'-.
.
!/+&(5=8 )&6+,& 16%.
4/:$*0$- >$4/8 7/&?+'4,
$%%+ +0$5$8 &0,+5 !$-2$8 "+,%/+*% 10$0&&) !0$2$% 1+-20 $2$/8 7/'*&&)+-2, @&/& +-+%+$%&) (+55+-2
$('/&,$+) ?$*$-*=8 @0&/&+- 7&%+%+'-&/"$/,0$- 1+-20
,0'/% ;7&%+%+'-&/; '2$ 1+-20
,0'/% ;/&,7'-)&-% ; @&/& *$-)+)$%&,.
. &0,+5)$/8 !$-2$ 14:
$2+,%/$%&8 !$-2$ /&*'66&-)&) *$-)+)$%4/& $('/&,$+) ?$*$-*= 75$*&) '55&*%'/.
. <&$/-&) . .
8
$%%+ +0$5$.
.
&&5+-2 $22/+&?&) $2$+-,% . .
8 7/&(&//&) $- $77&$5 '66+,,+'-&/8
47-$2$/ "+?+,+'-8
47-$2$/
,0'/% ;"+?+,+'-$5 '66+,,+'-&/;8 @0+*0 *$6& :& $55'@&)8
. .
8 @0&/&:=
$%%+ +0$5$.
.
&&5+-2 )+,,$%+,(+&)8 7/&(&//&) /&?+,+'- 7&%+%+'-
'66+,,+'-&/8 @0+*0 *$6& :& 7$/%5= $55'@&)8
@0&/&:= '/)&/, @&/& )&*+)+-2 $(/&,0.
.
- $('/&6&-%+'-&) *+/*46,%$-*&,8 (+5&) +-,%$-% *+?+5 @/+% 7&%+%+'- %0+, '4/% ,&&B+-2 /&5+&( ,8 -'%+*&) 0&/&+-$:'?&
.
&$/).
.
&/&8 +% @'45) :& $77',+%& /&(&/ *'67$/$%+?& 6&/+%,
-'%+*&) +%, . . 8 @0+*0 &%+%+'-&/
"$/,0$- 1+-20
&,7'-)&-%
'2$ 1+-20 2& )4*$%+'-$5 C4$5+(+*$%+'- %0 *5$,, 7$,, $%/+* 7$,, <$-)0'5)+-2 */&,
>$-$5,
&*'66&-)&) &0,+5)$/8 !$-2$ 14:
$2+,%/$%&8 !$-2$ .
:$/& 7&/4,$5 $:'?& &A%/$*%&) *'67$/+,'- @'45) *5&$/5= ,0'@ %0$% +, ='4-2&/ $2& %0$- +, 6'/& &)4*$%&) %0$- 0+6.
. ?+)&-%5=8 . .
8 7/+6$/+5= 2/'4-) %0$% 0+, -$6& /&*'66&-)&) 5'@&/ /&?&-4& '((+*&/,8 @0&/&$, +, ,+5&-% @0$% @&+20&) 6+-) ,'
-'% *'-,+)&/ *$-)+)$%4/& 8 @0'
='4-2&/ $2& 6'/& &)4*$%&) %0$- 7&%+%+'-&/.
.
'@&?&/8 $- $77&$5 :&+-2 (+5&)
8 ':,&/?+-2
!
"
!
#
$ %& '
%( '
( & %
)* + (,
-**./*- & %0%$
% 1 %
% 1 %
23 4 3
2 $ 4
%&
%
(
(
6 . 77$/&-%5=8 '66+,,+'-&/;, *0$55&-2&)
'66+,,+'-&/8 @0'
7$/%5= $55'@&) /&?+,+'- 7&%+%+'-8 7/&(&//&) ,&%%+-2
(/&,0 *'-,+)&/$%+'- ':,&/?+-2 ,
( 3
( 0
& %0%
& %0% (&
% 7
&
8
-1 %
&
& ,
&
0 %0%$ ) ,
,
:
, 7
&
& %0%$ ( & ;8
6 .
7&/4,$5 $:'?& &A%/$*%&) ':,&/?$%+'-, 6$)&
@'45) ,0'@ %0$% :&&- ':,&/?+-2 %0$% 0$) ($+5&) *'-,+)&/ 6&/+%, :'%0 *$-)+)$%&, 7/'7&/ 6$--&/ '66+,,+'-&/;, ,0'@, %0$% 0& 0$) 6&/&5= ':,&/?+-2 %0$% 6'/& 6&/+%'/+'4, %0$- 7&%+%+'-&/.
. - 6= *'-,+)&/&) ?+&@8 ?$/+'4, ($*%'/,8 @0+*0 /&C4+/&) :& *'-,+)&/&) @0+5& 6$B+-2 <$6:$/)$/8 &-?+,$2&)
45&, 4-9$:
<$-)
&?&-4&
45&,8 @0+*0 /&$) <
;,
;
2 4 8 = > 24 8
24 % > 24
> 24
> 24
, > ?, 8; % ;
% ?! @
-) 8;
-)8
-
-A ., 8;
0 8 8
@
> 24 /-
> 4 6
;?2 4, ;
3
?;;;;;;;;;@
7 -
4,
- > B6 . ?+)&-%5=8 ($+5&) *'-,+)&/ 6&/+%, *$-)+)$%&, @0+5& $77'+-%+-2 <$6:$/)$/8 . .
.
-($*%8 7/+6$/+5= 2/'4-) %0$% 0+, -$6& /&*'66&-)&) 5'@&/ /&?&-4& '((+*&/,.
. % +, ,&%%5&) %0$% /&*'66&-)$%+'-, 5'@&/ /&?&-4& '((+*&/, -'% :+-)+-2 0& +, $775= 0+, '@- 94)+*+'4, 6+-) ,'
$77'+-% 6',% ,4+%$:5& *$-)+)$%& <$6:$/)$/.
5%0'4208 <$6:$/)$/8 0'@&?&/8 +% +, ':,&/?&) (/'6 %0$% 0& 0$) ($+5&) *'-,+)&/ /&5$%+?& 6&/+%,)&6&/+%, *$-)+)$%&, 0+68 %&/6,
45&, 4-9$:
<$-)
&?&-4&
45&,8 +-)+*$%&) $:'?&.
.
- %0+, ?+&@ 6$%%&/8 (+-) -'
*'67&55+-2 /&$,'- +-%&/(&/&
'66+,,+'-&/8 @0'
0$) '/)&/, )&*+)+-2 $(/&,0.
.
&,45%$-%5=8 +-,%$-% *+?+5 @/+% 7&%+%+'- ($+5, ,$6& +, $**'/)+-25=8 )+,6+,,&).
'@&?&/8 *'-,+)&/+-2 ($*% %0$% 7/'*&&)+-2, /&2$/)+-2
$%%+ +0$5$8 &0,+5 !$-2$8 "+,%/+*% 10$0&&) !0$2$% 1+-20 $2$/ 7&-)+-2 *'-,+)&/$%+'- ,+-*& 5$,% 6'/& %0$- =&$/,8 )&&6 +% $77/'7/+$%& )+/&*% *'-*54)& 7/'*&&)+-2, /&2$/)+-2
$%%+ +0$5$ @+%0+- 7&/+') ('4/ 6'-%0, (/'6 )$%& $77&$/$-*& 7$/%+&, 0+6.
. 0& 7$/%+&, )+/&*%&) $77&$/ "+,%/+*% 10$0&&) !0$2$% 1+-20 $2$/ .
. '/ $-= '%0&/ )$%& *'-?&-+&-% 0+6.
.
&-)+-2 $775+*$%+'-
,8 +( $-=8 ,0$55 ,%$-) *5',&).
1 !
"
. .
,9B, 0&%0&/ ,7&$B+-2/&$,'-&)
#&,
'
0&%0&/ /&7'/%$:5& #&,
'