Bhajan Lal v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
-
0#1
------ %$*$*&,%2
3%2+4+ 5$#$% 4,/#6 &$.%2+ ------
%+7&,(%,$+ 8 0
5 5
2%+%,$ 23*9%:
5.#2;#< (9&)#$%
7%$*$*&,%2-
2- #272%%$ 5*,=.< 4,/#6-
- - 5 <
0
- 2#>%2 *,+$#,$ )*9*1 ?2*$ 2$*)1%
&,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#< *,$%2 #1*#< *++4#,)% # ?2*$ ,#$42% )%2$*&2#2* +%$$*,=
&11%)$&2<
47,#=#2
+.&2$ 8&11%)$&28< ?.%2%6>
6%%, #77&*,$%( 9*11#=% 5#9.#2#< %.+*1 52* ,#,(742 5#.*6< !*+$2*)$
47,#=#2-
-
'42$.%2 72#>%2 6%%, ;#(% +%$$*,=
--
77%#1+< 4,/#6
+.&2$ &;;*++*&,%28< ?.%2%6> - A-
A< &;;*++*&,%2<
47,#=#2 !*9*+*&,<
47,#=#2
+.&2$ 8!*9*+*&,#1 &;;*++*&,%28 6%%,
6%%, 47.%1(-
2*%'1>< &, (%;*+% 5.2* ;#2 5*,=.< 72%9*&4+ 9*11#=% 5#9.#2#< 72&)%%(*,=+ ?%2% *,*$*#$%( '*11*,= #'&2%+#*( 9#)#,)>< ?.%2%*,
?%2% #1+& )#,(*(#$%+-
- $ #77%#2+ $.#$ '*2+$ 2&4,( 1*$*=#$*&,< )#;% 6%'&2% $.*+ &42$ A<
5*,=.B ?.%2%47&, $.*+ &42$< 9*(% --
< &2(%2+ ?%11 #77%11#$% 2%9*+*&,#1 #4$.&2*$*%+ 2%;#,(%( (%)*(*,= #'2%+.-
7&, 2%;#,(< &11%)$&2< 9*(%
#77&*,$%(
&6+%29*,=
!"
#$%
%
&' ($
% )*
% &$
+
, %
%
,
% , &'# - .
/
,
-
0 1
2 -
%%1*,= #==2*%9%( #=#*,+$ &2(%2<
72%'%22%( #, #77%#1 6%'&2% !*9*+*&,#1 &;;*++*&,%2B .&?%9%2< +#;% #11&?%(< 9*(% - A-
AB ?.%2%6> 2%;#,(%( (%)*(*,= +#;% #'2%+.-
-
%%1*,= #==2*%9%( #=#*,+$ !*9*+*&,#1 &;;*++*&,%28+ - A-
A<
72%'%22%( #, #77%#1 6%'&2%
&;;*++*&,%2< ?.*).
6%%, #11&?%(< 9*(% *;74=,%(
--
?.%2%6> !*9*+*&,#1 6%%,
#77&*,$*,=
0#;6#2(#2< 6%%, 47.%1(- - , #'&2%;%,$*&,%( )*2)4;+$#,)%+< *,+$#,$ )*9*1 ?2*$ 6%'&2% $.*+ &42$ +%%:*,= 2%1*%'
+< ,&$*)%( .%2%*,#6&9%
%#2(-
- 0%#2,%(
&;;*++*&,%2< ?.*1% 47.&1(*,= &2(%2< #77&*,$*,=
.%1(
"
3
.
454&&$4&
.
6
!$
4$& )*
&$ 7
!"
(# 3/, &8 $($(&$4! !(4&8!)
) ,
4&$4&$4# &$$59(:// 8$8&$$"9!://!4!
1
6
-
1
.
.
&#$'&$&#
6
3/, &8 $($(&$4!
% ;%
&844&$&!
% <%
&'44&$4$
=
.
/
$5$5&$&(
'
1
&#$'&$&#
/. /
$5$5&$&(
.
/
3
2 -
2&;
# 7%24+#1 &6+%29#$*&,+ ;#(%
&;;*++*&,%2< *$ #77#2%,$ $.#$
'&4,( 6% ;&2% ;%2*$&2*&4+ $.#, 72%+%,$
*,#+;4).
>&4,=%2 #=% ;&2% %(4)#$%( $.#, .%2%*,- .#$ #7#2$< $.%2% # )#+%
<
2%=*+$%2%( #=#*,+$ 7%$*$*&,%2- 0%#2,%(
)&,+&,#,)% ?*$.
?%11 %+$#61*+.%( 7&+*$*&, $.#$ #77&*,$;%,$ 0#;6#2(#2< ).&*)% )#,,&$ 6% 1*=.$1> *,$%2'%2%( 4,$*1 $.%2% 7#$%,$ *11%=#1*$> &2 7%29%2+*$>-
0%#2,%(
&6+%29%( $.#$ !*9*+*&,#1 .#( ?*$.&4$ #,> +4''*)*%,$ 2%#+&,-
- .#9% #1+& =&,% $.2&4=.
!*9*+*&,#1 *,(%%(< $.%2% ,& &))#+*&, !*9*+*&,#1 2%;#,( '2%+.
(%)*+*&,-
$ $.*+ +$#=%< )&4,+%1 +46;*$+ $.#$
4,#4$.&2*C%( 7&++%++*&, =2#;
7#,).#>#$ 1#,( $.*+ 2%=#2(< .% 2%'%22%( %9*)$*&,
< 461*) 2%;*+%+
9*)$*&, ,#4$.&2*C%( ))47#,$+ )$< A-
2&;
# 7%24+#1 #'&2%+#*( %9*)$*&, 7%$*$*&,< *$ ,&$ '&2$.)&;*,= &, ?.*).
(#$%< $.*+ ?.#$ 72%+%,$ (#> +$#$4+
#'&2%+#*( %9*)$*&, 7%$*$*&,- 9%, 2%9%,4% 2%)&2( 2%+7%)$ 1#,( 2%=#2(*,= ?.*).
%9*)$*&,
6%%, '*1%(< ,&$ '&2$.)&;*,=-
.#$ #7#2$<
,&$ *;71%#(%( # 7#2$> +#*( %9*)$*&, 7%$*$*&,- 0%#2,%( )&4,+%1 )&,$%,(+ $.#$ #26.#/#, 5*,=.< '#$.%2
*;71%#(%( # 7#2$> $.%2%*,-
A- , ;> )&,+*(%2%( 9*%?< +*,)% ,&$ # 7#2$> +&)#11%( %9*)$*&, ,&2 +$#$4+ +#*( %9*)$*&, 6%%, 62&4=.$ &, 2%)&2(< $.%2%'&2%< ,& )&=,*C#,)% +#;% )#, 6% $#:%, $.*+ &42$ &, ;%2% 6#1( 71%#
$.#$ '#;*1> ;%;6%2
4,#4$.&2*C%( 7&++%++*&, 7#,).#>#$ 1#,(-
- &,+*(%2*,= $&$#1*$> )*2)4;+$#,)%+< #;
)&,+*(%2%( 9*%?
$.#$
2*=.$1> - A-
A< !*9*+*&,#1 '42$.%2 2%+$&2%(
A
#77&*,$*,=
9*11#=% 5#9.#2#-
%+41$#,$1>< *,+$#,$ )*9*1 ?2*$ '#*1+ +#;% #))&2(*,=1>< (*+;*++%(-
%,(*,= #771*)#$*&,
+< *'
#,>< +.#11 #1+& +$#,( )1&+%(-
5
!
-
+/:+ .%$.%2 +7%#:*,=2%#+&,%(
"%+
& .%$.%2 2%7&2$#61% "%+
&