← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4940/1999dismissed

Hari Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

2023-12-05Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

 

 !" #$!%&'( &")&& & &* &"

  

+,-./01.2343/566 ,733589 6666::.;;,5- <.74=4 -,-./0,7>,5,,51 -9.74 666.4:/51.5-4  "&?@

A'B ?"C%!D &?& &!* &") EEEEE 7.4.5-

46F,7,GH..-9,7G,I1J/2,-.KL.8,;31/=54.; 0/7-9.,::.;;,5-

76M,81349 ,529,51,I11;6N,7>,5, EEEEE &?& &!* &")C%C 6 9,;;.58. 35 -9. :7.4.5- 7.8=;,7 4.2/51 ,::.,; 34 -/ -9. 2/52=77.5- 03513584 /0 0,2-4 7.-=75.1 O> O/-9 /=7-4 O.;/P 35 0,J/=7 /0 -9. :;,35-3007.4:/51.5-35,4=3-03;.10/7:.7G,5.5-35H=52-3/56 6 Q9. O73.0 0,2-=,; G,-73R /0 -9. 2,4. 34 -9,- -9. :;,35-300,::.;;,5- P,4 ,5 ,4:37,5- 0/7 ,::/35-G.5- ,4 4=O/7135,-. M=18.I 0/7 P9329 9. :,7-323:,-.1 35 -9.  .R,G35,-3/5I   I =51.7 -9. 7.4.7J.1 2,-.8/7>I P9.7.35 9. 42/7.1 6S G,7T4 35 -9. P73--.5 -.4- ,51 P,4 -9=4 1.2;,7.1 35.;383O;. J31. 7.4=;- 1,-.1 KU66 I -9. O.529G,7T O.358 S6 Q9.7.,0-.7I /5 6U6I ,5 ,G.51G.5- P,4 G,1. 35 =;. /0 -9. ,7>,5, 3J3; .7J32.

M=1323,; V7,529 P9.7.O> -9. G353G=G W=,;30>358 G,7T4 0/7 429.1=;.1 2,4-.4K-73O.4 ,51 O,2TP,71 2;,44.4 P.7. 7.1=2.1 -/ S6 Q9. 7.:7.4.5-,-3/5 03;.1 O> 93G -/ 2/5431.7 934 2,4. ,4 :.7 -9. ,O/J. ,8,354- J,2,5-  :/4- O> 7/=51358/00 934 G,7T4 -/ S P,4 7.H.2-.1I;.,1358-/03;358-9.4=3-0/71.2;,7,-3/5,51G,51,-/7>35H=52-3/56

  

!" # ! #$ %$#!!

"! !

!' "! !

! ! ! () #!#

 (( )) ! "*+$

"" & $," !  -.#$

!." % " $#/!)0 +! "

*!

!

1 % " +! (()#* 2)

+$

3 &# !#+ ($#+$! !+ 

!$# ) +.$!

$ &#/ ! #"".

$#/ ! $/.& !"'

#"&#""

! " & 20 +2"

$5#/ ! ! ! () #!#

% " /+5

20 ! *+ #!#+" + &##&.& -. )# 0#/ & $,"

+$ 2+! /

$ )

 * "' " ! " & % " #

+$* ! !#& + !

3 &# !#+' %#*

+! +2! # 6.$! ! ! ! ".#! % " !#& 2 $$

#! % "

#)

( $#+ + &+$ ! 

+.$ $"

$+& !

+ * ."

+ *!#+ ! ! **$.

+ 1' % !

! ! , () *    )+% (( )) !

+.$!' !+./ $"

!

#/" + #"".

7+ # + )#&#! !#+' #

5+.$ + ! () #!#

20 +) #/ ! ! ! * ."

+ *!#+ $+"

+ !

+ "

*!#+ + ! ) "! * # /

$ ) * !

/+$0' +% $'

#"&#""

! (( )' + ! /$+.

! ! ! 7+!# #* !#+' 83 * +! +( $ !

%#!$ !$+"( *!#5

*! #"& $,"+ 9* +!2 $+.

+

"9 1

*+."

)

+$ ! (( )) ! %+.) ".2&#! ! ! ! 7+!# #* !#+

1 % 20 ! &##&.& -. )# 0#/ & $," !+ +2! #

# ! *+&( !#!#5

3 &# !#+ %

.*

"+.)  5

(()#* 2) !+ ! * "

+ ! () #!#

 (( )) ! % ))' # $&" + ! :.

/& # ! * "

+  ;<=> ?@=A> B<C DA>A@ EF GHIJ>K >IL ;IEA=@M   N 

 

!." % "

!#!)

!+ ! $+.

#/ +

! & $," !+ 9 !+ *+&

)#/#2)

+$ ((+#!& ! O! % "

.$! *+!

! !

# ! ' ((+#!& + /

$ ) * !

/+$0 * % "

%#)  (+"!" + 2 *,% $ *) "" * "

 



"

$"%& !&&& $ !'

( ( ) " '*+ '  "

" !), $' $,- "" "& "&

) .)

"& ,'$ /) ),

# )// "& 0$ /)

* .)$"

"

" )/  *

),"$ -')% #&"'*

$ $$ "& $,

"&

..''

)" )-"

 "&

, 1,  .! "

# )/ 2(  '

  345667 89:;5< =>4?5<> @ABB5665AC 7CD ECAFG>4 ?6H I9J76G4>> @GAKDG74L 7CD ECAFG>4 +

  ( (  ' !), $')  "&$ 

.,$"&!)( ( M&

..''

# ,-- $&),'$

!)."

"

N

"

/

' ") $!, "&

, 1,  0$ )/ 2( M& .'

"& $ - !) 

"$ )/ "& ,! .! "

# )/ 0$ )/ 2+

)"

/  $,-$1, "'*+ &)% +

N.'

"& "&

.)/,$ )/ O,

,"&) "* "& .).)$ "

"&

,' ) '

%

)" - !) $",

")$.!"

, '$$

" N.$$$

!' )

/$"

" "

") "& !) " *+

&' -* ) P-' "& ,. ),"

 QR<56> @ABB4H ?6H Q6FG7JJ7C @G>457CS

   ( T % 0 )/ "&

-)  "&

- /),

) )

"& !) !',$ % -* "& ),"$ -')% "&

) - / )/ "& U)"

/ "

, ") "& .'

"

// ..''

"( V "&

*+ & $!) (2+ #

# ),

#)// )/ %& !&+

) ,' ) .) !),' - .)

" )," -* "& '  !), $' -," /) "& '

! "& O,#

"& $ )/ E6G7 W>GF7

$,. + %& !& %),'

'$)

)" !) ")

*

/) "&  $) "& / $"'*X

%

)"

 -,"

.$)

+ $!) '*X "& )," !

 "&

"&

) ") %  )//

$!

"

"& !),' - " ") "&

"$ "& . $$ "& )/ "#)* )/ .)$"$+ "& , O - ,-'

 ! ) $$ . "" ),

# )//+ -," /)

 





!" # %

&  ( & "!)!

$$ ( "!# &

!"$ !$  * "$

"% +&$ !$ 

"

, -./012344 526782039

")*  $:(;  )* <  # #$!#

)$#

,,  < =" > ## 

"* $#$ (!$ %?' "!$  

) ,, < =" >  @*;!

!;A <$!

$# ( ?% % B """"<$"

, " <# (A  !; 

$$ ( "!# ( ,);#'  ,!

" **;; 

$"!# # $#

** !#  "< !$

* "* !& $# ;#  "< ( >! ) $A ** $ <!"!$ * !

$

#!"

#

&!#$ % B)"' A &

!&# !

# !"!

$" C)#!

)";A (  $, "$#;>% % B

$ ,!$#!$ "

## (A  ; $#  " (;

> & ($ , )$# ("#

")("$!;

"

$"' >!

 !$

#$  >!  , "

, 

" $# ,);

( , )$# >! $A

!

(" &!

$"% D$ !"

#'

;!$ 

( *;

#

 C)# <$"

  $E (; )* <  !$ -0F82G3 H0.3 I1J K3GL2IG K0M NGFO2

   ' > !$ ! >" ;# ' P * )";

 ,

"!# C)# <$" > );# " >   C) !"#!

!

!$ "

$# **; !" !$ ,  >!  ,!$#!$ "

,



)$#  ,!$#!$ "



$ )"' >&

""

!$@ )"(; 

<A "< (% B ,!$#!$ "

, >!;; ;"

!$ ;)#  ,!$#!$ "

 ("!"

)<$ A &!#$ % B C) !"#!

!

!$ ,  !$  "

$# **; !"

$;A >    !"

!$ ;>

*

#)  $# < ;A

Q)"!

, R D$ &!>

 ( &' > ,!$#   !  

);# !$ ,  >!  ,!$#!$ "

,

## , ** !!

&!#$  < ;A ( )"  !    )    &!>> );#(( &!>%%%%S

  

 !" !#$# %#&

(&$)&!* &++#'+&!* !# &)

'

#, - ,')# ! ,#.$##"  ." !#

$##

#+ &  )#$&! #$#%* ,&)&#, /01023405640789 :56;< =>?@A?A=AB

C)$ D#!#$ #E& 'F$# #,  G#FH D#!#$$# $!%+#  G#FH