M/S Ranam Industries And ORS v. M/S Chugh Plastics
!"#$# CRM-M-34237-2015 M/S RANAM INDUSTRIES AND OTHERS ... Petitioners
Versus
M/S CHUGH PLASTICS ... Respondent 2.
CRM-M-34238-2015 M/S RANAM INDUSTRIES AND OTHERS ... Petitioners
Versus
M/S CHUGH PLASTICS ... Respondent 3.
CRM-M-34239-2015 M/S RANAM INDUSTRIES AND OTHERS ... Petitioners
Versus
M/S CHUGH PLASTICS ... Respondent 4.
CRM-M-34240-2015 M/S RANAM INDUSTRIES AND OTHERS ... Petitioners
Versus
M/S CHUGH PLASTICS ... Respondent % &'% # () (# *
-2- ) (# *##+ ,-.
!" # $ ! % & '
( & ' )*+, - )++) . - " . . !
)/#0#)0 *1" . - ! " .
" 2 3 4 2 ! ! 5 ! . - "
" 4 " ! 4"4 678 9 )*+ , - )++)" . !
" * 2
-3- ! 8 . .8 " $ *)) & & )0:* ;6& & < . .8 ="
!. " ! & " " = & $" ". " !.8. =
" .8 " 8 *)*& & " "
!. *))& & 8 ( = ! 8 , / " .
/ - ! ! .
"8 ( . $ " " ! & " .
& ,
-4- )/>>0.#1)/ ? % & % - @ " - " " 1A 1+ #1)> $ 8 ".
!
"#$#
%
%
&&'(&'"( )* $ (+
% # > -. ! " " 4 ! 8 ! & .
!"! " 5 78 &B#%) 78 &B#%# ! 78 $8 C 78 &B#%* 78 &B#%/78 &B#%+* 4 78 &B#%+/
-5- 78 &B#%)0+ 78 &B#%)00 78 &B#%#1:
$ " " !. "
" ! = & & . .)/>>0#1)/1A 1+ #1)> $ "
! '
( & ' )) #1)> " ! % " ! " 78 &B#% ! " " &B.#" ! 8 4 78 &B#%)00 78 &B#%#1: &B#%/ 78 &B#%+* D$ !78$8 CD$ " " !. 2 ! !'
( & "1A 1+ #1)> !& " ! . " " ! 8 " " 4 " ! " 8 ! & . . != & 1A 1+ #1)> :
= & ".
-6- "
4 " ! 4 ! " ! 4 =
" ! " 4 = 4
" ! 4
!
-!
! 5 ! ! .
" ! - ! !!
'
=@
&
!! " # + - " " -
! . "
4 $ " ! " !
-7- = & . " " 4 , = & "58 8 $ 8? 4@"
$ " " . 8 !
$ " ! !
- ! .8 .8 $ "
8 .8 ! !
, 4 "
%% 4 ! " $
!
)1
" !
*))& & !
$
! =
-8- . ! -" " ! ! ! & 1A 1+ #1)> )) ( ! ! ! !'
(& ' )) #1)> 4 78 &B#%)00&B#%#1: 78 &B#%/78 &B#%+* " 4
8 $ ! +) (# *. %!"/ ,! B4 % E%, B E%,F