High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/35119/2016allowed

Kuldip Singh v. State Of Punjab & ANR

2017-09-18Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan6 pages

"#$ $%&'&() * + "#$ $%&'&() * + "#$ $%&'&() * + "#$ $%&'&() * + ,-./&01&(23 ,-./&01&(23 ,-./&01&(23 ,-./&01&(23 $#&#&($4 $#&#&($4 $#&#&($4 $#&#&($4 5$4'-'

5$4'-'

-(6"7"(/"(#3$4 -(6"7"(/"(#3$4 -(6"7"(/"(#3$4 -(6"7"(/"(#3$4 $'0(/$(#'

$'0(/$(#'

) ) ) ) 89 1 1:

89 1 1:

4$'$(#) 41"6;"< /=%"#$ 4#3$0$#&#&($4 '"6(&-0#"<1$(&4 $0-#> /=%"#$$($4".<

-(6"7 ???

(-0&(/$41&(234$;".< 4".

(-0&(/$41&(234$;".< 4". 3&'0$#&#&(-(/$41$%#&(@+4$"/;&#31$%#&(@* #3$/$ 4&A&(". 4%$/-4$ 4'34#B#3$4 C3"'

7$$( &.$/ 4/&4$%#&(2#3"#'$(#$(%$'";"4/$/##3$0$#&#&($4 &(#34$$%A0."&(#''3-./4-(%(%-44$(#.> 3$0$#&#&($4&''#"#$/#3"=$0-4%3"'$/ -.#4>$$/

4A4$'0(/$(#"(/&(/&'%3"42$ 3&'.&"7&.&#><3$3"/ &''-$/'$=$4".%3$D-$'<;3&%3;$4$/&'3(-4$/("%%-(# 8('-

&%&$(# -(/'8 $'0(/$(# '$(# " (#&%$ # #3$ 0$#&#&($4"(/-0(3&' "&.-4$#A"E$#3$0">A$(#;&#3&(#3$ '#&0-."#$/0$4&/<#34$$%A0."&(#';$4$ &.$/"2"&('#3&A3$ 0$#&#&($4;"'%(=&%#$/&("..#3$#34$$%A0."&(#'7>6-/2A$(#' "(/ 4/$4' /"#$/

3$ /$#"&.' #3$ %A0."&(#'

&(%.-/&(2#3$/"#$' #3$&4&('#&#-#&(<%3$D-$'"(/#3$/"#$' 6-/2A$(#'"(/4/$4'%(=&%#&(2"(/'$(#$(%&(2#3$0$#&#&($4 "4$'$#-#3$4$-(/$4)

! !

#$% "

! !

9$"4($/%-('$. 4#3$0$#&#&($4%(#$(/'#3"#"..#3$ #34$$ %A0."&(#' 0$4#"&( # ="4&-' %3$D-$' &''-$/ 7> #3$ 0$#&#&($4&(/&'%3"42$ 3&'.&"7&.&#>#4$'0(/$(#"(/< #3$4$ 4$< ;-./ 4A 0"4# '"A$ #4"('"%#&( "(/ ".. #3$ '$(#$(%$''3-./7$/&4$%#$/#4-(%(%-44$(#.>('-004# 3&'%(#$(#&(<3$3"'%&#$/6-/2A$(#' #3$1-04$A$-4#&( #3$%"'$' 1#"#$ -(6"75'"/"(9".< -(6"75'"/"(9".< -(6"75'"/"(9".< -(6"75'"/"(9".< 1 *< 5,"('".5'1#"#$ "4>"("< 5,"('".5'1#"#$ "4>"("< 5,"('".5'1#"#$ "4>"("< 5,"('".5'1#"#$ "4>"("< +1

"(/13>"A 13>"A 13>"A 13>"A

".5' ">";"#&$'>"<

".5' ">";"#&$'>"< 1+ 1$%#&(@+ #3$4 &''$#-#3$4$-(/$4) B@+ 1$(#$(%$ (

$(/$4 ".4$"/> '$(#$(%$/ 4 "(#3$4

$(%$ :3$( "

0$4'( ".4$"/> -(/$42&(2 " '$(#$(%$

&A04&'(A$(# &' '$(#$(%$/ ( " '-7'$D-$(# %(=&%#&(#&A04&'(A$(#4&A04&'(A$(# 4 .& $<'-%3&A04&'(A$(#4&A04&'(A$(# 4.& $ '3".. %AA$(%$ "# #3$ $G0&4"#&( #3$ &A04&'(A$(##;3&%33$3"'7$$(04$=&-'.> '$(#$(%$/< -(.$'' #3$ -4# /&4$%#' #3"# #3$ '-7'$D-$(#'$(#$(%$'3"..4-(%(%-44$(#.>;&#3 '-%304$=&-''$(#$(%$)

4=&/$/#3"#;3$4$"0$4'(;33"'7$$( '$(#$(%$/ # &A04&'(A$(# 7> "( 4/$4 -(/$4 '$%#&( &(/$ "-.# -4(&'3&(2'$%-4&#>&'< ;3&.'#-(/$42&(2 '-%3'$(#$(%$<'$(#$(%$/# &A04&'(A$(# 4"(

$(%$%AA&##$/04&4# #3$ A"E&(2 '-%3 4/$4< #3$ ."##$4 '$(#$(%$ '3"..%AA$(%$&AA$/&"#$.> :3$( " 0$4'( ".4$"/> -(/$42&(2 " '$(#$(%$ &A04&'(A$(# 4.& $&''$(#$(%$/( "'-7'$D-$(#%(=&%#&(#&A04&'(A$(# 4"

#$4A 4 &A04&'(A$(# 4 .& $< #3$ '-7'$D-$(# '$(#$(%$ '3".. 4-( %(%-44$(#.> ;&#3 '-%3 04$=&-''$(#$(%$C 3$1-04$A$-4#&(#3$%"'$ 1#"#$ -(6"75' -(6"75' -(6"75' -(6"75' "/"(9".'-04"< "/"(9".'-04"< "/"(9".'-04"< "/"(9".'-04"<;3&%30$4#"&($/#/&

$4$(#%3$D-$'&''-$/7> #3$4$'0(/$(##3$4$&(# #3$ %A0."&("(# 4 ;3&%3 '$0"4"#$ %A0."&(#' ;$4$ &.$/<3"/ /&4$%#$/ "..#3$'$(#$(%$'&(#34$$ /&

$4$(# %(=&%#&(' # 4-( %(%-44$(#.> ( #3$ %"'$ 5, 5, 5, 5, "('".5'1#"#$ "4>"("'-04"< "('".5'1#"#$ "4>"("'-04"< "('".5'1#"#$ "4>"("'-04"< "('".5'1#"#$ "4>"("'-04"< #3$"%%-'$/3"/7#"&($/ ."( 4A="4&-' &("(%&".&('#&#-#&('"(/&#;"'3$./ 7> #3$ 1-04$A$-4##3"##3$%"'$'0$4#"&(&(2#&''-"(%$ %3$D-$'

7> #3$ "%%-'$/ # 1#"#$ &("(%&". 404"#&( ;$4$ # 7$ 4$2"4/$/"'"'&(2.$#4"('"%#&(;3&.$&''-"(%$ %3$D-$'#

#3$4 &("(%&".&('#&#-#&(';$4$#7$4$2"4/$/"''$0"4"#$%"'$' 3$%(=&%#&("(/'$(#$(%$'4$%4/$/&(%A0."&(#' &.$/7>#3$ 1#"#$&("(%&".404"#&(7$&(2'&(2.$#4"('"%#&(;$4$/&4$%#$/ #4-(%(%-44$(#.> 1&A&."4.>< &( #3$ %"'$ 13>"A ". 5' ">";"#& 13>"A ". 5' ">";"#& 13>"A ". 5' ">";"#& 13>"A ". 5' ">";"#& $'>"'-04"< $'>"'-04"< $'>"'-04"< $'>"'-04"< ;3&%30$4#"&($/##;'$0"4"#$."('#"E$(7> #3$"%%-'$/"(/&''-"(%$ '$0"4"#$%3$D-$' 4/&'%3"42&(2 .&"7&.&#><;3&%3;$4$/&'3(-4$/"(/#;%A0."&(#';$4$ &.$/ ;&#34$2"4/#3$4$#<&#;"'3$./7>#3$1-04$A$-4##3"##3$ '$(#$(%$' &( #; /&

$4$(# %A0."&(#' 7$&(2 0"4# #3$ '"A$ #4"('"%#&(;-./4-(%(%-44$(#.> #3"'".'."&//;(#3$ 04&(%&0.$'#7$ ..;$/7>#3$-4#';3&.$$G$4%&'&(2/&'%4$#&( # /&4$%# #3$ '$(#$(%$' # 7$ 4-( %(%-44$(#.> ;3&%3 "4$ 4$04/-%$/3$4$-(/$4) 3-23#3&'04=&'&(3"' "..$( 4'%4-#&(> #3&'-4#-A0#$$(#&A$'<;$%"(04 &#"7.>4$ $4# ($ #3$4$%$(#04(-(%$A$(#'&(5,"('".=' "4>"(""(/ (#3$4 +1

;3$4$ &#;"'3$./#3"##3-23&#&'A"(& $'# 4A1$%#&(@+ <#3"##3$-4#3"'#3$0;$4"(//&'%4$#&(# &''-$"/&4$%#&(#3"#"'-7'$D-$(#'$(#$(%$'3"..4-( %(%-44$(#.> ;&#3 #3$ 04$=&-' '$(#$(%$'< #3$ =$4> ("#-4$ #3$0;$4'%( $44$/<04$/&%"#$'#3"##3$ /&'%4$#&(<;-./3"=$#7$$G$4%&'$/".(26-/&%&". .&($'4(#&("A$%3"(&%".40$/"(#&%A"(($4#;"' -(/$4.&($/#3"##3$4$&'(%-#"(//4&$/ 4A-." 4 #3$-4## ..;<&(#3$$G$4%&'$ '-%30;$4"(/ #3"##3$6-'#& &"7&.&#>4#3$4;&'$ #3$'"A$<;-./ /$0$(/ ( #3$ ("#-4$ #3$

$(%$ 4

$(%$'

%AA&##$/"(/#3$"##$(/"(# "%#'"(/%&4%-A'#"(%$'

# ;"' 3;$=$4 0'#-."#$/< #3"# #3$ .$2". 0'&#&(

"=-4'#3$$G$4%&'$ #3$/&'%4$#&(##3$7$($ &# #3$04&'($4'&(%"'$';3$4$#3$04'$%-#&(&'7"'$/ ( " '&(2.$ #4"('"%#&(< ( A"##$4 $=$( & /&

$4$(# %A0."&(#'&(4$."#&(#3$4$#A&23#3"=$7$$( &.$/ 3$%"=$"#"';$..;"'#3"#'-%3"%(%$''&(%"((# 7$ $G#$(/$/ # #4"('"%#&(' ;3&%3 "4$ /&'#&(%#.> /&

$4$(#<'$0"4"#$"(/&(/$0$(/$(# $"%3#3$4"(/ "A(2'##3$4';3$4$#3$0"4#&$'"4$(##3$'"A$ @ 3$ &A0$4"#&=$ $''$(#&".&#> " '&(2.$ #4"('"%#&("'#3$/$%&'&=$ "%#4#$("7.$#3$-4# #/&4$%##3$'-7'$D-$(#'$(#$(%$#4-(%(%-44$(#.> ;&#3#3$04$=&-'($;"'#3-'-(/$4'%4$/#;"' $G0-(/$/ "';$..#3"##3$/&4$%#&( 4%(%-44$(# 4-((&(2 '$(#$(%$ ;-./ 7$ .&A&#$/ # #3$ '-7'#"(#&=$'$(#$(%$".($C

("A4$4$%$(#/$%&'&( #3&'-4#&( $('(51#"#$ ,$4".""4&'&(2 4A#3$%(=&%#&( #3$ "00$.."(# 4A 3&' 04'$%-#&( ( #3$

$(%$'

04=$/<#3&'-4#&(#3$'&(2-."4 "%#'"'&(=.=$/"(/ 3"=&(24$2"4/##3$/-4"#&( 3&'&(%"4%$4"#&("(/ #3$4$A&''&($"4($/7>3&A<$G#$(/$/#3$7$($ &# '-%3 /&'%4$#&( "(/ /&4$%#$/ #3"# #3$ '$(#$(%$' ";"4/$/#3&A&(#3'$%"'$';-./4-(%(%-44$(#.> # ;"' (#&%$"7.> 4$%4/$/ #3"# #3$

$(%$' &( #3$ %"'$'-(/$4'%4-#&(>3"/7$$(%AA&##$/(#3$'"A$ /">3$7$($ &# #3$/&'%4$#&(;"'"%%4/$/##3$ "00$.."(##3$4$&(4$ $44&(2"';$..##3$7'$4="#&(&( 5, "('". #3"# &# &' /&

&%-.# # ."> /;( "(> '#4"&#6"%E$#"004"%3&(#3$A"##$4"(/#3"#"/&4$%#&( #3"##3$'-7'$D-$(#'$(#$(%$;-./4-(%(%-44$(#.> 4(#<;-./$''$(#&"..>/$0$(/(#3$("#-4$ #3$

$(%$ 4

$(%$' "(/ #3$ =$4".. "%# '&#-"#&( (/$4'#"(/"7.><#3$"00$.."(#;"'4$D-&4$/#'$4=$

#3$ /$ "-.# '$(#$(%$ "' ";"4/$/ ;&#3 #3$ /&4$%#&( #3"#& #3$ &($&A0'$/3"/(#7$$(/$0'&#$/<#3$ /$ "-.# '$(#$(%$ 4 '$(#$(%$' ;-./ 4-( %('$%-#&=$.>C

00.>&(2#3$"

4$A$(#&($/04&(%&0.$'##3$ "%#' #3$&('#"(#%"'$<&#&'"00"4$(##3"#"..#3$%3$D-$';$4$&''-$/7> #3$0$#&#&($4&(/&'%3"42$ 3&'.&"7&.&#>#4$'0(/$(#"(/ #3-'#3$0"4#&$'"4$#3$'"A$3$="4&-'%3$D-$';$4$&''-$/ &(%.'$04G&A&#>&(#&A$ ..#3$#34$$%A0."&(#';$4$<&( "%#< &('#&#-#$/(#3$'"A$/">( @ 3$>;$4$"../$%&/$/ (

3$4$ 4$<&#%"(&(/-7&#"7.>7$4$2"4/$/"'"'&(2.$ #4"('"%#&("(/"..#3$#34$$'$(#$(%$'";"4/$/##3$0$#&#&($4 '3-./4-(%(%-44$(#.> ('$D-$(#.>< #3$ 0$#&#&( &' "..;$/ 3$ #34$$ '$(#$(%$'";"4/$/##3$0$#&#&($4-(/$41$%#&( * #3$ $2#&"7.$('#4-A$(#' %#&(#3$#34$$%A0."&(#'&$A0."&(# '+* <+ "(/++ '3"..4-( %(%-44$(#.> 1:

9 1:

9 1$0#$A7$4 *< + 1$0#$A7$4 *< + 1$0#$A7$4 *< + 1$0#$A7$4 *< + E"(%3"( :3$#3$4'0$"E&(2H4$"'($/I !$'

:3$#3$44$04#"7.$I