← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/38140/2012dismissed

Prem Kumar & ANR v. Phool Singh & ANR

2015-02-02Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages



      !"# $#%&'&()   *

+#,-.,!+!($!("/#+  #"&"&(#+'

0#+'.'

/12&(3/!($!("/#+  #'4($#("'

)  56  2- 6 2

+#'#(") + 22/!+,!7$8%!"#7 +"/#4#"&"&(#+' + !9#'/6!,:!7$8%!"#7 ++#'4($#(" +!."!,-!&1#7$8%!"#7 ++#'4($#("   ;/#"/#+"/# #4+"#+' 1%!1(#<'4!4#+,!=:#!11<#$"'## "/#9.$3,#(">

 :#+# #++#$""/# #4+"#++("  ;/#"/#+"/#9.$3,#("'/.1$:#+#4+"#$&("/#$&3#'">   - 6 27

6 (  "/&'  4#"&"&(  .($#+  2#%"&(    + 7  4#"&"&(#+'

+#'4($#("'  :# +#  "/#  !44#11!"#  .+"  '##?  @.!'/&(3    "/# &,4.3(#$9.$3,#("$!"#$A 74!''#$:= "/#  1#!+(#$  2#''&('  .$3#7  !"#/!:!$7  </#+#:=  "/# 4#"&"&(#+'+#'4($#("'/!8#:##($&+#%"#$"+#,8#"/#!11#3#$ #(%+!%/,#("<&"/&(*$!=' +,"/#$!"# +#%#&4" +$#+7 !&1&(3 </&%/1#3!1%('#@.#(%#'<.1$ 11< +&# !%"' "/#%!'#!+#"/!" /12&(3/+#'4($#("

 &1#$!(!441&%!"&(.($#+2#%"&(+ :# +#"/#2.:

&8&'&(!1!3&'"+!"#7 !"#/!:!$7'"!"&(3"/!"!4.:1&%'"+##"'&".!"#$

&("/#  "/#8&11!3#7</&%/&'* "C&(%/<&$#!:.""&(3 "/#(+"/<!11 "/#"#,41#7/!':##(%1'#$:=+#'4($#("' !($ 4#"&"&(#+'/#+#&( :=%('"+.%"&(3/.'#'7"/#+#:=%!.'&(3 /&($+!(%#  "  "/#  &(/!:&"!("'    "/#  8&11!3#  !($  &'  !1'  %+#!"&(3 (.&'!(%#  "  &'  '"!"#$ "/!"  +#'4($#("'     !($ 4#"&"&(#+'

/#+#&(  "?  "/#  4''#''&(    "/#  '"+##"  &(  CC   /#  +!,

!(%/!=!"4!''#$! #'1."&((  CC""!?#!%"&(!3!&('"

+#'4($#("'!($ 4#"&"&(#+'/#+#&( /#2!+4!(%/ "/# 8&11!3#/!$4+,&'#$" &1#!'.&"!3!&('"+#'4($#("'!($

4#"&"&(#+'/#+#&(&("/#&8&1.+" /.'7 !,.+"&7"/#"/#( 2!+4!(%/    "/#  8&11!3#  <!'  !."/+&'#$7  8&$#  #'1."&(  $!"#$

A CC7  "  "!?#  !%"&(  !3!&('"  +#'4($#("'      !($

4#"&"&(#+'/#+#&( +3#""&(3"/##(%+!%/,#("+#,8#$

4(("&%#7+#'4($#("'!($ 4#"&"&(#+'/#+#&( /!$'"!"#$"/!""/#=!+#&(4''#''&( "/#$&'4."#$'&"#7</&%/&'

4!+" 

 "/#8&11!3#7 +"/#1!'"D=#!+' :9#%"&(<!'+!&'#$:=!(=:$=/#= .+"/#+'"!"#$"/!""/#=/!$ %('"+.%"#$"/#&+/.'#'!:."D=#!+':!%? .+&(3  4+%##$&(3'7  "/#  1#!+(#$  2.:  &8&'&(!1 !3&'"+!"#7  !"#/!:!$7  3"  &('4#%"#$  "/#  '4"  "/+.3/  .(&+ (3&(##+7.(&%&4!1.(%&1!($.(&+(3&(##+7 ; !($

#4!+",#("!($&(@.&+=<!'!1',!$# +,"/#4.:1&% /#2.:

&8&'&(!1  !3&'"+!"#7  !"#/!:!$7  %!,#  "  "/#  %(%1.'&(  "/!" +#'4($#("'!($ 4#"&"&(#+'/#+#&(/!$%('"+.%"#$"/#&+

 /.'#'!:."D=#!+':!%?!($41!%#&'4!+" 

 /#"#,41#<!'%('"+.%"#$!

"#+"/#%('"+.%"&( "/#/.'#'

"/#+#'4($#("'!($ 4#"&"&(#+'/#+#&(/#,!&($+

"/#"#,41#4#('"<!+$'(+"/'&$# "/#,!&('"+##"/#+# +#7 "/#&11#3!14''#''&( "/#+#'4($#("'!($ 4#"&"&(#+'

/#+#&(("/#$&'4."#$1!($%!((":#%('&$#+#$+"/#+#&'!( &($&%!"&(+#3!+$&(3!(=(.&'!(%#  "/#+<&'#!1'7"/#$&'4."#$ 1!($&'4!+" 

  "/#8&11!3# /#!441&%!("

/1  2&(3/+#'4($#("      /#+#&(  '/.1$  /!8#  &1#$  "/&'

!441&%!"&(.($#+"/# .(9!:0&11!3#,,(6!($%"@.!"/# $&'4."#$  1!($   /#+# +#7  "/#  4+%##$&(3'  .($#+  2#%"&(   + !+#("!$,&''&:1# ("/#!44#!1 &1#$:# +#"/#1#!+(#$2#''&('.$3#7

!"#/!:!$7"/#1#!+(#$2#''&('.$3#7+#8#+'#$"/# &($&(3'/# 1#!+(#$2#''&('.$3#7 !"#/!:!$7/!'"!?#(&("%('&$#+!"&( '#8#+!1 !%"'#/!'"!?#(&("%('&$#+!"&("/# #'1."&( =#!+ CC74!''#$:=+!, !(%/!=!"78&$#</&%/ !,.+"&7"/#"/#( 2!+4!(%/    "/#  8&11!3#7  <!'  !."/+&'#$  "  "!?#  !%"&(  !3!&('" +#'4($#("'!($ 4#"&"&(#+'/#+#&("<!' .+"/#+("&%#$ "/!"!%&8&11&"&3!"&(!3!&('"+#'4($#("'!($ 4#"&"&(#+'

/#+#&($#%&$#$:=2/+&0&($!&(7"/#"/#(2.:.$3#'" 1!''7

!"#/!:!$7<!'"#+,&(!"#$&( !8.+ "/#!441&%!(" <'&"# 41!(' B *!($B D 4+$.%#$&("/#%&8&11&"&3!"&(<#+#!1' "!?#(&("%('&$#+!"&("/1$"/!""/#+#<!'(#(%+!%/,#("!($

 &"<!'$(#'.:'#@.#("1="<!' .+"/#+("&%#$"/!""/#+#4+"

"<#B4#+"<&"(#''#'&#' .(&%&4!1.(%&1!($ ; !($

<#+#("4+$.%#$( &1#"<!'%(%1.$#$"/!""/#$&'4."#$'&"# &'4!+" 4.:1&%'"+##"/#+# +#7"/#&,4.3(#$+$#+<!'4!''#$ /!8#/#!+$1#!+(#$%.('#1 +"/#4!+"&#'!($/!8# !1'%!+# .11=3(#"/+.3/"/# &1#  "#+3&(3"/+.3/"/# &1#7!, "/#8&#<"/!""/# +$#+$!"#$ D   74!''#$:="/#2.:&8&'&(!1 !3&'"+!"#7  !"#/!:!$7  <!'  +&3/"1=  '#"  !'&$#  :=  "/#  1#!+(#$ 2#''&('  .$3#7  !"#/!:!$7  8&$#  +$#+  $!"#$  A

("/#'!&$%!'#7"/#'4"<!'3"&('4#%"#$&("/# 4+#'#(%# "<9.(&+#(3&(##+'!($"/#2.:&8&'&(!1!3&'"+!"#7

!"#/!:!$7<!'/#$

/&'/!($':='!=&(3"/!""/#%('"+.%"&( <!'+!&'#$D=#!+':!%?/#+#&'(#8&$#(%#&("/&'+#3!+$/# 1#!+(#$  2#''&('  .$3#7  !"#/!:!$7  /!'  '4#%& &%!11=  "!?#(  &(" %('&$#+!"&("/#'&"#41!(' B *!($B D 74+$.%#$&("/# #!+1&#+%&8&1'.&"<&"/"/#+#'4($#("'</#+#&('.%/#(%+!%/,#(" <!',&''&(3#!1'"?&("%('&$#+!"&("/# #'1."&( "/# +!,  !(%/!=!"7  4!''#$  &(  =#!+  CC7  +  +#,8!1    '!&$ #(%+!%/,#("/#%&8&1'.&"<!'$#%&$#$&("/#=#!+CD7</&%/ '/<'"/!""/##(%+!%/,#("<!'$(#'.:'#@.#("1=/#+$#+ 4!''#$:="/#1#!+(#$2#''&('.$3#7 !"#/!:!$7(A

&'!<#11+#!'(#$!($/&' &($&(3 !%""/!""/#+#&'

#(%+!%/,#("8#+"/#'"+##"%!((":#&("#+ #+#$&(":="/&'.+"

* 6#!+(#$%.('#1 +"/#4#"&"&(#+'/!'+#1&#$.4("/# !."/+&"= "/#(5:1#2.4+#,#.+"&(      

  

   7CC*2.44  2.4+#,#.+"!'#'7*!'<#11!'"/# !."/+&"= 2&(31##(%/ "/&'.+"&(        

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

74!''#$:="/#1#!+(#$2#''&('.$3#7 !"#/!:!$ %%+$&(31=7"/#4+#'#("4#"&"&(&'$&',&''#$

- 6 2  

  * '9?'