Harbans v. State Of Ut Chandigarh

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT

CHANDIGARH CRR-1019-2022 (O&M) Date of Decision: 06.01.2023 HARBANS

...Petitioner

Versus

STATE OF U.T. CHANDIGARH

...Respondent

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER Present :

Mr. Pardeep Kumar, Advocate for the petitioner.

Mr. Charanjit Singh Bakshi, APP., U.T., Chandigarh. HARSH BUNGER, J.









  




 



 
 

  






  
 



  

!
"#
"
"$
"$%

"


& 
'

( 

)&'*+


' 
!


!

  


 

 
",


 
- 
!


  
 
 




 







 
 
 

 

.

 

 










 
  


/




  

 
 





 
 


  




12
3  


1 
! 

! 
,%

4 
&



-



 
5

0
5


5



 

 

  






  


 
& 

 
4'.6768

  
 


 

 

 




 

 


 

 

 
 


 




 

   


 


9:
  
:




 

 
 


   ;6

    
    



      !! 

      "!

  

# $ %  "  &  $ 

# 
'() * 

" + "!





,"

 #,

,"



 *  "" 

   !

*  #  -
.  





 /

   *&

 "

!

    0          &   

  

 )1
2334

 &   

* "" 

 !

* # -53





 / '     *&

  "

 !

   ""   *&

"  



     ""   

 *  "" 

  !

* # -5(





 / -     *&

  "

 !

    

!! 

   

  *  *     

   *&

" 

  

* "" 

 !

* # -3






/ 4     *&

  "

 !

   ""  "!

   

   67

        "" 

  !

* # - 





 / $+   :
 






 
  
;6


8
 7 !&  

 !   

 9 "

 "!

             " :+


          !  *   !   

    

      

!! 

         "!

  

# $ % $  $ 

# 
'(

 ) * 

" + "!



  

,"

 #,

,"% #2)4-


;

  < *



* #  *    !

  

 *    !

 0       &   

  

*      1
2334

          !

    !!

    : &         &   "  :

  7

! =  0!

 



"    

 *    "

 * 

&    =        0 

   

<     & *  9 "



 3

    ! & 

&    =    

<   

 !  

!&!

 ""   

 * #   *     &  : &    

 0       

 >9 #1     "    

 >9  # 

 &     ! *&

" "    :

  7

! =  0!

 

 >9 #:

 

!: &   

>9 
#+

  

 ? !      ?  

     :7= =  0!

 

 *  9 "



' !&&     ! :7= =  0!

      

          *&

&  

 &     

>9 #:?50

+

: 

   ? "



 9 "

!& ?0!

>94#+



!  

     "     

  * 67

  &  * 

'-.-#67#>;5 
33 
'   &

 

@   " "

%A
A
 

  * #  *  >95#
   & >95#  !!  : &     

>95#' 5#3

 ! "    # 

 "

% 

' !!*      >95#(

>95# + 

  9 "

   " 9!

 !

 "*:= # B;

 4# 
'  

( 
' >9 5#
      

    !

 ?

 ! ? !  

    !    *  *  #   *   

 *  *&

     "  

 

"  

,"

 # ,

 ,"



 ! "  

  

     "

 *   



" !   !   "

0 & : %:7==  0!

    *  9 "



 (  !&   !

 &   *  .'5#0:..;

% 

"2 %

  #    # ,

! :

 0!

 

>9(#


  "   

   !&   

    "!





,"

 # ,

,"

#2)4-


;

  < *

  !     



" 2 *

 

# 0

  0 " # $  C         !  < * !! *              



     "!

 # 
'(   ) * 

"  +   

 #  $ %   &   $  

  *   *  " "  * #   *  

  !

    !

        &   

  

*      1
2334

         !

  &      

 *  7    

 !!*  &     !:

 7

!= 0!

  >9  #:

 !     

        

    "   "

% 2 2   *  

 -.

.5- D >  

-(

''  

   *    2 !   # 1 &    # 2) (.
 ) )  

0!

  :

  0!

   < * ?

 ! &         &    .'5#0#0:;..;

,   4-
... "

  :

  7

! 0!

   < *

 !& *  

  %

"  , !  *&

 &   

 

 

"  2 %

   #   "    "   D 7$

   

  

"

 
5
... &  !  '
4  

 &     

"

 *&  

      



 *  !

0   

     &   

  

 * 

1
2334

             &      "!

  "

 

 

 ,"



# ,

 ,"

 # 4-
 

;

     "!

# 
'() * 

" +  

 #  $ %   "  &  $  

 !   *                 



  E 1 

 


 
  






  
  



 

!
"#
"
"$
"$%

"
&'


' 
!


!

  
:
 
- 
!


  
 


 
",






 
 
  



   


&



  





 
 
 

 
-  

 



 


- 





 
 













 









7
 



   






 
 
 


&
  






/&<
 





8


  


0

0  




&





"





 


   
& 




 
 
  










  





 

 




  


=

#

 

&






 


  
 
,
(  
2

 +


 
 



(= 
+

#
 





&






 
>



 
 

9:
  








 




 







 2 
 
 



 

 

 
7  
 
 

9 
:

  





 

 
 



? 







  

@

! 

' 



9:
  

 



  
! 
!-!
4 A






    







 
B&  
  


#CD


  




&

 
 
 





 
 

 










 
-

 


' 





 
 









 

  
 

 
 
 

 








! "#
"
"$
"$%

"
&'


-

 



  





 



:



 




   

 



 
 



  





2 
 


  
E



 
 





 



  



 
 

F
F 


 
:  

  



1 

 



 
 
  






  




  ;6


 






  
"#


& 
'

:
 
 



 


"


& 
'

:
 
 



 


 

< 806
&
 


 

  
 






  ,
"$


& 
'

:
 
 



 


 

< 806
&
 


 

  
 






  "
"$%


& 
'

:
 
 



 


 

< 806
&
 


 

  
 






  8
"


& 
'

:
 
 



 

&



  



 



. 
 




 






F 



 

7*

- =



 


  




!
=   
 

G
  






 
 


 


;6
 "   !

    *    7  "

 

 

*"

 

 *    

 &  7 *;       

;

 * & 

*  *     ** ;  G   7    !      &  

  

&   "      7      



&  !

"     !



& "  7 "

 

 &     

  !

   !

 ! 

    "



  "  ""  

  ! "

 %    *        

  "

      2   !  



H "H  %   !&     "

  

 *         !  "  ! 

       "

     !

 "

  * &   " <  "     "  " "  "!& "

"    "!&* 

<  F &
"  

#
 $ %%&'

(
 ) 


H'

! H

=  

  


 

=





  
 
? 
   
F 








 

 


  
! 


 





 
 
I 









 


=

 


2
 
 
@  




   



=  
 


   &

* +
 '," #( % -'

(


  
  





 

! 



 
 
 


 






 







:
 








 


 

 


 J

 




 



 



 


  

 




 
 
:





   


 
 
 
 
:

 




 

 







 

2


 
:
 

 




 


&
./*01 ++
 2 %

'

-(
 &&


 
  
  






 
 










  




 J 




 

 
 





 

 


 

 
&
+ 
/#+
  %




!!
7K
!




 

 
 








 
 





 

 


=
/


 
  


 
 

 


 





 





 


 
 


 





 
   


 


 
 

 
/






 


 
 


 




  
 
 

 

 
& 








  


 

 

 









7*

- =




 






2

 


  

 

  

 
? 
 





  
 

 

 









 


-







  




  
  
 












 
   



 
 

6





 



  


 


/&<

F 



8A

  



0

0  
  


A


"





 



 






 
 
 
 9 
:


  



 
 
 



  


=

#
 A


  


  
 
,


 
 



(= 
+

#
 







 



 
   


 


 


 


  




 
 

 

-  



 
:
  


 
7  




 


 
 
  






  

 
 
 
- 
!


  
 


 
",

  




 



  






 
 

 
:


 


 
 

  
:






  
' 
 

  0 

 
  




 


  
 January 6th, 2023 (HARSH BUNGER) gurpreet JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes/No Whether reportable:

Yes/No