High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17231/2026allowed

Lakhbir Singh v. Union Of India,Ncb,Amritsar,Through Its I.O.

2026-04-29Mr. Justice Surya Partap Singh7 pages

# $%&%!'( )* +*

(

,- *. . . !"

# $%&

'%( )*+,%! -+!./!0!0+ Mr. H.S. Sullar, S.P.P. with Mr. Harneesh Kumar, Advocate for the respondent-NCB.

Mr. I.P.S. Sabharwal, DAG, Punjab.

11111 . ./ *

.0 0 % %//20,%!0+ 30 4 -+ /2%,0 4 + ,+) ,!%0 )+, ' ! +!.%+ !%!)0 !.%//20,%!0+ (!.%'0.5& %22+6)% )!.)+, ' !% 7)60!.!.%//20,%!0+ %!%3 + ,+) )0

22+6)%/%&)-+% )0 !.+))%!)898:8# 22%5%2+%)))% )*+,%!-+!./+ ) !;< %'

$ & .0/!0!0+ -+5%020!.-0! /!0!0+ (-02)5&!./!0!0+

),!0+ :=>+-?!. .%%!0&%%4%03 %3.%% .0!%(8>@.0

/!0!0+ .%5 -02)60!.4%)!+%,%%00 4+ !+-<0'+>>)%!) 8A8 -+ !. ,+''00+ +- +-- , / 0.%52 ) ,!0+ =BB>BB9;

BAB8+-!. %,+!0, 4% )&,.+!+/0, 5!% ,

,!(A=(+20,!%!0+ %,+!0,<+ !+2

% (C+ %2 0!( '0!%

0-2& !%!0 4 !. -%,! '40 4 -+' ,+) % !.%! + 8A8%!%'+-+--0,0%2+- +), 0!& +,.% ))+*%/%,3!

,+ !%0 0 4884%'+-?

+0 @/%,3)0 %%30!% +040 ,2+!. 2+ 4 60!. %5+*' !0+ ) ,+ !%5% )( !. , !+)& +- !. !%--0,3 %'2& ?$*00 4.@(?0.% 0 4.@% )?%$% 0 4.@6%%2+.% ))+*!+!. +--0,+-?%,+!0,<+ !+2

% @.

(!.%5+*' !0+ )/+ 6 -+'%22&%!)% )!./+,-+/+) ,0 4!.'5-+!.#%40!%! 6% )!%3 ,,+)0 4!+/+, !0+ + 0 !+4%!0+ ?$*00 4.@% ) ?0.% 0 4.@ +'0 %!)+ /+ %'2&?

%2%@(6.+6%/+ 052-+ ,0*0 4!.,+ 04 ' !+- +0 > !0!.,%+-!./+, !0+ !.%!!./!0!0+ % )!.%5+* %'%,, )%22%''5+-!.%'4+ /0 *+2*)0 !.%,!0*0!0+- '

4420 4+-2%4D % !0!&+-.+0 -+' 04.5+ 0 4,+ !&0%30!% :

%) !.%5 ,+ ! ))+ 5.%2-+-/!0!0+ !.%!!./!0!0+ .% + 7 (6.%!+*(60!.!.,+''00+ +-,0'(% )!.%!..%5 -%22&0'/20,%!)0 !./ !,%60!.+ !% &20%52*0) , ,,+)0 4 !+2% ),+ 2-+!./!0!0+ (!./!0!0+ .%,2% % !,) !(% ) !.%!.0%2%)&0 , !+)&-+%/0+)+-'+!.% 9'+ !.!.%%2+ 5 ,+ ! ))5&2% ),+ 2-+!./!0!0+ !.%!!.0 +%224%!0+ %4%0 !!./!0!0+ !.%!.6%)0,!2&0 *+2*)0 ) 4;!%--0,30 4 /

2% ),+ 2-+!./!0!0+ '2&%224%!0+ +- +-'+502/.+ +- /!0!0+ 5&!./+ %224)2&0 *+2*)0 !%--0,30 4+-) 40 0!2-)+ +!%'+ !!+,+''00+ +-% +-- , . 2% ) 0+ !% )0 4 <+ 2 -+ !. /+ ) ! .% ,+ !+*!)!.%5+*' !0+ )%4 ' ! ,,+)0 4!+2% ) 0+ !% )0 4<+ 2-+!./+ ) !0 !./ !,%(0-!. !0,.%0 0 2++3)0 !+0!!% /0!.%!!.'% 0 6.0,.!.'+502/.+ +-!. /!0!0+ .%)5 )(-+!%520.0 4,+ !%,!60!.) 4 //20%,+!. 5+)( '%3 0! %5 )% !2& ,2% !.%! % 0+ +2 6% /2%&) 5& !. /!0!0+ 0 !. ,+''00+ +- +-- , / 2% ) ,+ 2 -+ !. /+ ) !0 *06+-,+*&+-.

4D % !0!&+-,+ !%5% )(!.0+ +-!.%,!+-!./!0!0+ (E.0,+;%,, )(!% )'%4 0-0)(% )!.

(!. /!0!0+ 0 +! !0!2)-+!.5 -0!+-5%02 9 +)%260!.0'02%-%,!;0!

%!0+ (!./0 ,0/2+-2%62%0))+6 5&!. + @52 !+- )0%0 !.,%+-?0$%&0 4.. !%! +- %&% %@ 8> << 20 < > % 2*% ! !. %5+*' !0+ ),%(!./!0!0+ 6% +!/ !+ !./+!%!!.!0'+- ,+*&% ).6%0'/20,%!)+22&+ !.5%0+-!%!' !+-,+;%,, ) . + @52 !+- )0%0 !.%5+*' !0+ ),%%--+))!. 5 -0!+-5%02!+!.%,, ) = 0'02%2&( 0 !. ,% +- ? )

'% .% % !2204 ,--0,0,!+%!+-* !2204 ,@8=><< 20 <99(%2*% !(6.0 0!.%5 .2)5&!. + @52 !

+- )0%!.%!!.)0,2+ !%!' !+-,+;%,, )00 %)'0052%4%0 !

% +!.%,, )(%!.)0,2+ !%!' !0 +!% 5!% !0*/0,+-

*0) ,%4%0 !+!.%,, ) A 0'02%/0 ,0/2.%5 2%0))+6 5&!. + @52 /' <+ !+- )0%0 !.,%+-?! %'%2!%!+- $%5@(8=:< <0'0 %2A>=(6.0 0!.%5 .2)!.%!!.)0,2+ !%!' !+-% %,, ),% 5 )+ 2&%4%0 !!./+ '%30 4!.%'(% ) +!%4%0 ! !.,+;%,, ) 8 ?+-% 0 4.!%!+-%'02%) @(8:<<%2+(0!

.%5 +5*)5&!. + @52 !+- )0%!.%!,+ -0+ %2 !%!' !+-%,, ),+)) ),!0+ 9+- ,!,% +!5 %)'0!!)0 *0) ,(%%,+ -0+ .,+).%5 / ),%- 22& -!.-%,!% ),0, '!% ,+-!./ !,%%% %2&F)0 !.204.!+-%5+*;' !0+ )/0 ,0/2+-2%6(0!!% /0!.%!"; 0 !.%!!./!0!0+ 0%2%)&0 , !+)&-+%/0+)+-'+!.% * '+ !.G 00 !.%! +!.0 4.%5 2-!!+5,+*)-+'!./+0+ +- !./!0!0+ G 000 !.%!!./!0!0+ 6% +!/ !+ !./+!%!!.!0'+- ,+*&G 0* !.%!!.+ 2&*0) ,,+22,!)5&!. *!04%!0 4 4 ,&D % !./!0!0+ 0!.)0,2+ !%!' !+-.0,+;%,, )6.0,.

6%,+))6. !.%5+*;%0),+;%,, )6%%2%)&0 /+20,, !+)&.

(!.0%D !0+ '%360!.4%)!+ %)'005020!& +- %5+* ' !0+ ) )0,2+ !%!' ! 0 *0) ,G * !.%!!.+ 2&%224%!0+ %4%0 !!./!0!0+ 0!.%!.0'+502 /.+ 6% )0 !.,+''00+ +-+-- ,5&!.,+;%,, )G *0 !.%!!.!0%2% +!2032&!+5,+ ,2 ))0 %- !

*00 !.%!!./!0!0+ .%,2% % !,) !G *000 !.%!!.)! !0+ +-/!0!0+ 0 $ )0,0%22+,3;

/0 +!2032&!+ *% & - 2/ /+G 07 !.%!!.0 +!.0 4+ ,+)!+.+6!.%!0-2%)+ 5%02(!. /!0!0+ '%& !%'/ 60!. !. *0) , + 0 -2 , !. 60! G 7 !.%!!.0 +!.0 4+ ,+)!+.+6!.%!0-2%)+ 5%02(!. /!0!0+ 6022 +!,+;+/%!B/%!0,0/%!0 !.!0%2 > !./ !,%(!./0 ,0/2+-2%62%0))+6 5&!. + @52 !+- )0%0 !.,%+-?%!%%'* !%!+- !!%%).

% )% +!.@(8=><<(%2*% !(6.0 0!.%5 +5*)!.%! H%- )%' !%2/+!/ 2%!+-,0'0 %2$ 0/ ) ,0!./ '/!0+ +- 0 +, ,('% 0 4!.5&!.%!%/+ 0520*)!+50 +, ! !02 -+ )4 02!& +6*(!.%0 !% ,0 + ,0'0 %22%66.%* + .%5 /2%,)+ % %,, )60!.4%)!++'/,0-0,+-- ,5 !

!.%!0% +!.'%!!% ))+ +!)!%,!-+'!.- )%' !%2/+!

2%!0 /,! +- +!. +-- , I! % +!. 0'/+!% ! -%,! +- + ,0'0 %2 $ 0/ ) ,0!.%!!.4% !+-5%020!.4 %2 2% )/ !!0 4%/+ 0 $%02+0 %/0+ +0 %,+,!0+ .+'6.0,.*7/0+ + '%&60. !+ 0% 7,/!0+ -+!

%!2&(+'+-!.5%0,/0 ,0/2%//%!+ .%*5 2+!04.!+-60!.!. 2!!.%!'+% )'+/+ %50 4 0 ,%,%!)% )-+2+ 4/0+).0)+ +!)+% &4++)!++ ,0'0 %2 $ 0/ ) ,+!++ +,0!&.0 +)+ 5!!.%!!.4% !+) 0%2+- 5%020 !02&!.)0,!0+ +-!.$ )4,+ 0)0 4%,%5 !* +(!. 7,0+-$ )0,0%2)0,!0+ .%5 ,0, ',05)5&%2%4 '5+- ),00+ ))5&!.0<+ !% )5&*& 04.<+ !0 !.,+ !&I!( +,,%0+ %22&!.0% ,0!&!+0 !+/,!6.!.) &0 45%02!+%

%,, )/+ 0!.04.!!.0 4!+)++ !.-%,!% )0 !.,0, '!% ,+- %,%J : ./0 ,0/22%0))+6 5&!. + @52!. !+- )0%0 !.,%+-?%! )

'% !02< !%2

% +- *!04%!0+ % ) +!.@ 8 8 << ( % %2+ 2*% ! 0 !.0 ,% !. %5+*' !0+ ),%(0!.%5 +5*)!.%!H!.%!+-,+ *0,!0+ 0 ,0'0 %2,%0 )0%0%5&'%22&2+6!%//%!+ !.%!!.0-%,!+604. + !.'0 )+-!.<+ !6.02),0)0 4!.5%02%//20,%!0+ 0 % 4%!0* <+ !! )!+!.0 3!.%!!./+05020!&+-%,+ *0,!0+ 50 4 %!+ %0!&(5%02%//20,%!0+ 6022.%*!+5),0))!0,!2&(,+ !%&!+24%2 /0 ,0/2K,% +!'07 /,+ 0)%!0+ +-%5%02%//20,%!0+ (6.0,.0 +! / 0!0*0 %!

60!.!.%!+-%/+052%)$ )0,%!0+ 5&6%&+-!0%2 !. ,+ !%&(% 2!0'%!%,D 0!!%260!.,+ !0 ), !+)&6+ 2)5%,%+-4%* 0 $ !0,J , !2&( 0 !. ,% +- ?%/%

'% %20! !%! +- <..%!!04%.@(8<< 20 <>(!. + @52 !+- )0% .%+5*)!.%!H0-% %,, )0!+4!%-0 %2*)0,!%-!0 ,%,%!0+ +- 07!+* &%0 $%02%% )!0%2/0+ (!. ()-0 0!2&(0!,+ 2)5 %0)!.%!.004.!!+.%*%/)&!0%2 ) !0,2+-!.<+ !0!

!0+ .%5 0 -0 4)J!.%%2+5 +5*)5&!. + @52 !

+- )0%0 !.%5+*' !0+ ),%!.%!H)2%&%5%)-+!.%,, )% ) 7!'2&5%)-+!.*0,!0'(-+ )0% +,0!&% )-+!.,)05020!&+-+ $ !0,&!'(6.0,.0*%2 )L )4%!.'%!+-!.0<+ !++'% ) !.<0'0 %2+,) <+)/+*0)'% &!++2-+!.L )4!+ 0 +)!+ !.%!,%/+,)--0,0 !2&J

+2 ,0)%!- !.(!.0<+ !0,+ ,0+ +-!.5%0,% ) - )%' !%2/0 ,0/2+-2%6!.%!04.!!+/)&!0%20%/%!+-%+ %52( -%0% )$ !/+,) .0 ) ) !0,2+-!.<+ !0!

!0+ +- )0% .0,+ !0!

!0+ %204.!,% +!5) 0)!+!.%,, )%'% )%!)5&

+ @52 /7,+ !0 H %260 )0 4.* !%!+- $%5% ) +!.J( 8:<< 20 <:>: 9 - !. , '

2%!0* --,! +- %22 !. %5+*' !0+ ) -%,!+( 0 *+2*)0 !.0 !% !,%(0!%3 0 !+,+ 0)%!0+ (0!2%)!+%,+ ,2 0+ !.%!!./!0!0+ 0 !0!2)-+!.5 -0!+-5%02(% )!.%!!./ !/!0!0+ )*!+5%22+6) =

,,+)0 42&(60!.+ !,+'' !0 4% &!.0 4+ !.'0!+-!. ,%(!./ !/!0!0+ 0.5& 11!2 #./!0!0+ 0.5&+))!+ 52%)+ 5%02+ - 0.0 4/+ %25+ )% ) !&5+ )!+!. %!0-%,!0+ +-2% )!0%2<+ ! +6*!.%5+*%0),+ ,0+ .%225 5$,!!+-+22+60 4,+ )0!0+ ";

0 !.%! !. /!0!0+ .%22 +! )0,!2& + 0 )0,!2& '%3 % & 0 ) ,' !(!.%!+/+'0!+% &/+ %,D %0 !)60!.!. -%,!+-!.,%(+%!+)0 %).0'!+)0,2+ ,.-%,!!+!. <+ !+!+% &+!.% !.+0!& 00 !.%!!./!0!0+ .%22%!!.!0'+-7, !0+ +-5+ )(- 0.

!.%))!+!.<+ !,+ , )% ).%22 +!0-&!.,.% 40 %))!+!.!0%2<+ !(!022!.-0 %2),00+ +-!.!0%2G% ) 000 !.%!!./!0!0+ .%22 +!2%* )0%60!.+ !/0+/'00+ +-!.!0%2<+ !

. .

)* +*

K.!./%30 4B%+ )IB+ K.!./+!%52 IB+