High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/79/2022dismissed

Parveen Sidana v. Paramjit Singh

2022-05-06Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj37 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()*)

+ )))

,, +

-) ( .,

) + ) /) 000 123!456(

" # $ % & '# & & &

()! !

* !!

*+ ,! !

* -. / .

0 1

2 #

3 45

()!

)7 ( %

% 6 ' '

8 !!!!!+5

9% '

) :' #

1 ()7" !

8"!!!!+5 '& 2 ; & # ' # '

1 1 ' '

# ;

9' ;<= % > !

9 '

' #

1 ' ) 6 '

# (

5 ) $ # !

' 3 &?5

#4 1)") 78%5% !&$1%9 %"'"#4"$3:!'

@3& &1 1 @3& 2 ; ) @3&) A ( @3& ;' & 9 @3&9 . 9

)!, !

"% '

6 ' '

;''' ;1

* # ; #

' # 53 # # ' 1 '

# 6 ' 6 1 1 ' #

+ # #

@3C % '

53 ' ' '

+ #

8*9!!!+5

# 5 ' 1

)

$ = & ' ' ' # & 4 DE ' # &

DE '

8 !!!!!+5'

' # :' 3 ' ' '

' 6 DE ' # &

' 3 &?5

53 '

' 6

+ ! ! !

' 6 '

8*9!!!+5' # ' 6

DE & #

8*9!!!+5' # #

@3C

8 !!!!!+5 #

# 9 ;

' # $ = &

1 '

( * A

# &

# # 5

1 1 %'

7 ' ), ( %

' # : &

' #

# " %

& ' , 7

# 5 # 3

7+ ), ( %

( ,

), ( %

' 3

1 %

53 ;

1 ' # ' 1 F # '

1 3

53 #+ #

@3 # 51 1

! %

), ( %

' 1 # '

!" #$#$ % &# !'&#!#( #! &) * * ? '

), ( %

& 45

! " #

$ %

' & & %

' ! ( %

) $*

#$#+!,'(-& % +,$ -#+&. +! ( +/& + &# % ( % 0& %/10 +! ! 2 &. 3#% 4( & ( 5#3/#$ ,#% % 5+& ( &# % !- +5 ( 0& %/10 +! (#' , ! %#,$ %( ' %#

%/0

% %

/!$ %% ( #33/% ' #''/3 % ' !3 %(+4 !- ( & #%+!#,$ 0+%% , $ . +5 ( !+! % !3 +5( 0& %/1 '5#3 # &

. &

(

$ &%

& ( . & .

. %7( & 5+& ( & ,/#$'+ %!+ (#2 +, 3+!3$/% 2 $. %#,$ %( ',/%/3( 2 ' !3 1/% , #''/3 ', 5+& ( +/& !%/00+&+5( ' 5 !3 (# ( +/&1/% ( &, $ 2 ( ' 5 !3 + 6 %+&3+!% ' &

% 6 % !3 + , & #%+!#,$. 0&+,#,$ ( %#!'#&' +5 & #%+!#, $ ., !-(#+5( 80&/' !1#!8 2 3

# 9/!'#! :#$ #$$#&#1 2% /%+'

#!;2#3/ "&+0 &. +1,#. * ***

(

'" #

2 4 $

+!% / +! !3( ! (#!2#!&# #$4#!&# %# 2%# +5#(#&#%(&# * (

#'&#% 2% # '.#!#( . & /0&#

( &

% 5

% 4( & #0& %/10 +!

%&# % '/!' &**+5( ;2 ' !3 3#!'3#!!+, ( $' + , '

%3(#&- ' 1 & $. ,. & #%+! +5 ( 5#3 (# ( 60$#!# +! +55 & ' ,. ( #33/% ' % & #%+!#,$ #!' 0&+,#,$ 1/%5/&( &, %(+4!(#( 60$#!# +! %# &/ +! 7( 4+&'% 8/!$ %% ( 3+!&#&. % 0&+2 '8 4( 3( +33/& ! ( % 0&+2 % +!1#= 3$ #& (# ( 0& %/10 +! (#%+, & ,/ ',.80&++58#!'!+,.#,#& 60$#!# +! 4( 3( %1 & $.0$#/% ,$ 5#3 %%# '+, 0&+2 '4( ! % % !3 %'

& 3$. %#,$ %( '+&4( !/0+!( 1# & #$ , 5+& ( +/&5 !'% % 6 % !3 +, %+0&+,#,$ (## & #%+!#,$ 1#!4+/$'#3+!( %/00+%

+!(# 6 %% >!$ %%( & 5+& ( 60$#!# +! %%/00+& ',.0&++5( 0& %/10 +! 3& # ' ,. ( 0&+2 % +! 3#!!+ , %# ' + , & ,/ '% D@

E % '

# '

' ' # 53

' 3 ' &

# H

3 # H # G G

8 #

9/1#& ;60+&% % (#&1# #&0 % * 3 45 #

& ' $

& &

' $

/0 &/0

&/0

&/ 0 & / 0

&/ 0

/ 0 2 ! $

' & &

, 1

6 # 4 $

$ & &/0% %/

0& /0 %

% /

0 / 0 %

0 7

* . &

% % 8

& 8

% 99999999999 - 2 4 $

7 7

;: %/ 07 :< $

( & &

/07

:< $

(

% # (

& (

# (

= ' $

! $

& & &

4 $ ' !

$ &

& & . &

' ! $

& .

& & $

. ! %

% ' $ %

% ! $ % % %

% 2 4 $ &

>7( #33/% ' !#& #$/!' & 3 +!*<+5( 3(#% 4++0 +!% 3#! ( &%(+4(#3+!% ' &# +!#!'' , '

'!+ 6 %+&(#/!' &( 0#& 3/$#&3 &3/1%#!3 %+5 ( 3#% ( !+! 6 % !3 +5 3+!% ' &# +! #!' ' , % %+ 0&+,#,$ (# # 0&/' ! 1#! +/-( + %/00+% (# !+ 3+!% ' &# +! #!' ' , 6 % ' 7+ & ,/ ( %#/+&. 0& %/10 +!%#!#33/% ' %!+ 60 3 '+0&+2 ( %' 5 !3 , .+!'& #%+!#,$ '+/,#% % 60 3 '+5( 3+10$# !#!

!#3& !#$& #$7( #33/% '1#.#''/3 '

& 3 2 ' !3 + 0&+2 (# ( !+ ! ?/ % +! 4#% !+ %/00+& ' ,.

* 3+!% ' &# +! #!' (# ( & 4#% !+ ' , +& $ #, $ . + , '

%3(#&- ' ,. ( 1 +4 2 & ( 3+/& ! ' !+ !% % ! 2 &. 3#% (# ( #33/% ' %(+/$' '

%0&+2 ( !+! % !3 +5 3+!% ' &# +! #!' ' , ,. $ #'

!- '

& 3 ' !3 , 3#/% ( 6 % !3 +5 ! -# 2 2 ' !3 % !

( & 0+%% ,$ !+& 3+! 10$# ' $ & . &

+1 ( !-4( 3( %0&+,#,$ (#%+, ,&+/-( +! & 3+&' 5+& - !- ( ,/&' ! +5 0&++5 %( 5 ' + ( 3+10$# !#! 7+ '

%0&+2 ( 0& %/10 +!% ( #33/% ' %(+/$',& !-+!& 3+&'%/3(5#3%#!'3 &3/1%#!3 %/0+! 3+!% ' &# +!+54( 3(( 3+/&1#. ( &, $ 2 (#( 3+!% ' &# +!#!'' ,'

'!+ 6 %+&( &!+! 6 % !3 4#% %+ 0&+,#,$ (# # 0&/' ! 1#! 4+/$' /!' & ( &3/1%#!3 %+5( 3#% #3/0+!( 0$ #(#( .' '!+ %$

2 4 $

' ! $

& &

* ' ! $

' '

3 # 3

# 1 '

# ' # # & # 5 3 # 3

3 '

' & # 3 53 ' '

# 3

) %

#!-#00#%& +(#!**** :G

), ( %

45 ?-# .

! $ .

@ 3 / 0 A &

A &

= ! $ .

< ' $

A &

# &

' #

8 &

@ &

7 & .

& $

+(! 9 ,&#(#1 % 1+! ,&#(#1 !'

!+( &* :G

& '

7 ' ), ( %

' DE 1

#+ 1 DE 1 #

# # ' DE ' ; # ' 1

;

' ' ' ' #

' #

45 -< .

8 (3 )

( &

(

(3 ) ; 07(+/-(( & %0+!' !#%"

*' 0+% '(#( #33/% ' & 3 2 '( 1+! .#( %(+/% #$%+%# '(#( '

'!+ & 1 1, &( '# 4( !( %# '%/1+5 %* @4#% 0# '+( 1 0 $

+&,>&>>>B:&

& +,>&>>>B:& :

7(+/-(( & %0+!' !%# ', 5+&

* ( +/&, $+4(#( 4+/$', !#0+%

+!+0&+'/3 ( '+3/1 !% !%/00+&+5( %# '%#!' 4#%!+ '(#!+ '+3/1 !%4 & 0$#3 ', 5+& ( +/&, $+4 0# :.

+&,>&>>>B: 0 $

& .

0 0

0 (

999999 !(#%+, %# '(# !+&' &+'&#4( 0& %/10 +! /!' & 3 +! **< & #' #$+!- 4 ( * +5 ( -+ #,$ !%&/1 !% 3 ( ,/&' ! 4#% ( #2 $. /0+! ( 3+10$# !#!+(#2 %(+4!(#( (#'& ?/ & '5/!'%5+& (#2 !-#'2#!3 '( 1+! .+( #33/% 'A(#( %%/#!3 +5( 3( ?/ !%/00+&+5( %# '0#.1 !#'2#!3 '4#% &/ #!'(#( #33/% '4#%,+/!'+1#= ( 0#.1 !#% (#', !#-& '4( $ %%/ !-( 3( ?/ !5#2+/&+5( 3+10$# !#! >@

& .

+&,>&>>>B:

& &

* .

& ( & = 8

A (

'& 3&

. A ( 8

( &

# & 3 A (

& & 8

9 %

#%#$ !-#00#%/'

,#%#00#* *< ' '

' ( %

& 45 23 )" ) $ ) *

@ $ & />>-0 - (( ! '/ 0& ' ! $ &''#

'/ 0 !

D C

D 8

"';:

*< <' < .

D& ?

D C D ( 6 # 1 E

& />>,0 (( &

; /((

>: &

,0 <#

F ? F 2

1 8 G + $

:H:

F .

? F ?

F .

2 4 $ & '=&

& & .

? FD ,# .

+ C D C D 4 $ &

" >; < >$

C DC D

'/ 0 $ &

& ( & , $ 2 %(#( 3+!% ' &# +!'+ %!+ 6 %+&3+!% ' &%( !+! 6 % !3 +5 ( 3+!% ' &# +! %+ 0&+,#,$ (# # 0&/' ! 1#! +/-( /!' & ( 3 &3/1%#!3 % +5 ( 0#& 3/$#& 3#% + #3 /0+! ( %/00+%

+! (# ( 3+!% ' &# +!'+ %!+ 6 %I

* 4 &

D -7( %+/&( $'(#4(# %! ' ' %+&# % #0&+,#,$ ' 5 !3 5+& 4( 3( % !+ ! 3 %%#&. 5+& ( #33/% ' + '

%0&+2 ( 6 % !3 +5 3+!% ' &# +! ,. 4#. +5 '

& 3 ' !3 #!' 2 ! ( 2 ' !3 #''/3 ' +! , (#$5 +5 ( 3+10$# !#! 3#! , & $ ' /0+! J

" ;: <

D = # @ 3 * J

E A& />>'0 2 (( ,2& (

. A I

1 " ;: < !#33/% '5+&'

%3(#&- !-( ,/&' !+50&++50$#3 ' /0+!( 1/!' &#%#/ ! '!+ 6#1 ! ( 1% $5 1#. '

%3(#&- ( %,/&' !+!( ,#% %+5( 1# & #$%#$& #'. ,&+/-(+!& 3+&' !#33/% '(#%#3+!% / +!#$& -(+ 1# !# ! % $ !3 #!'#&' +5 0&++5 +! ( 0#& +5 #! #33/% ' #!' (# +5 ( 0&+% 3/ +! ! # 3& !#$ 3#% % '

55 & !D '(

C D # " 2&

;: < 2I &

D , < ( '/ 0 !& K

(

;: /05 .

! $

/0 7( 0& %/10 +! /!' & 3 +! * % # & ,/#,$ 0& %/10 +! #!' ( +!/% % +! ( #33/% ' + &# % ( 0&+,#,$ ' 5 !3 7( %#!'#&' +5 0&++5 5+& & ,/ !- ( 0& %/10 +! %(#+50& 0+!' &#!3 +50&+,#, $

% /07+& ,/( 0& %/10 +! %+0 !5+&( #33/% '+ & $.+! 2 ' !3 $ ',.( 1+&#33/% '3#!#$%+& $.+!( 1# & #$%%/,1 ',.( 3+10$# !#! !+&' &+&# % # 0&+,#,$ ' 5 !3 !5 & !3 +5 0& 0+!' &#!3 +5 0&+,#, $

% 3#! , '&#4! !+ +!$. 5&+1 ( 1# & #$% ,&+/-(+!& 3+&',.( 0#& %,/#$%+,.& 5 & !3 +( &3/1%#!3 %/0+!4( 3(( .& $. / 0

& !

# :.

1<&

+,&>>>B:

1< 1<

!!= +'

# >>&

+2&,>&>>>B:

+,>&>>>B:

"! >

4.J&

# >>:>&

J :.

& & &

E '

# # '

# '

3 1 ' & #

# 1 :G

# ' % '

# # 1

* = # & '

B --#&4#$2 &%/%# +5#(#&#%(&# * 3 4 </-0 2 /0

(

/ 0 /0

/ 0

& & A(

& A ( L

( &

A( $

( A(

( &

(

& A (

& :

& : K& &

K& .

1 ( ( + 4#&/0 2 7( 9 !- ;10 &+& #!' /& +(#11#' 2 ;10 &+& * "* * /=0 ( & & K

&% (

%; 8

$8 *

1 8 &

0# &

% % % #

. A (

/ 0 2 /0 ( $

A (

G+

%& .

( &

+ 8 A

1 8 L &

& A ( K &

& A( 8

: &

( & # & & &

A( $ -

" # :G

#-,(/%(#!2%# +59#&!##=#* * 4 <

=' (1(

A (

@ />>0!(('!&

(

=' (1( #

!& ; ( A (

< 8

8 :

61/!=,0 ((!& )

/!!>02 (( =& 1

61 />> 0 (( =-& "

)1 />>20 > ((-!!&

61/>>-0!((= &

61 + * />>=0 ((>& + + +/>>'0,((, ,&$

/>>!0>((>-&1 +

$1/>>!0-((!' +

A1/>>0((22,0 # @ 4 $#+! 21(=&

1 ( ;/#$ 2>20C9

A (

L/0

L/ 0 L /20

D 2

( / @

$#+ !,2(&

1 8 $#+!,= ( -& )E $

) $#+ !- (>>&@)

/!=>0 ((2,>&

@ /!!'0,(( 2&

)1/>>02((',

E 8 />>=0 ((=,,0 ,# (

/>>=02(( 2,& ( ; /(( 2 & 20C/0$

/0 ( (

1& !=

& .

/ 0 * .

& & ?

F& ?

F& ? F& ?

F K

/20$

& &

& /,0 # &

D -# EG

61/>>'0>((2,>&

( &

& F

+ 8 " />>!0!(( -'&

( . 8

( ;/(( =2& >0C> 9

D '#

/>>!02((=& (

( 8

A (

;/(( '-& '0/0 A ( F

L /0 A ( F

L /0

8 L / 0A( F8

8 L / 0 ( A( L / 0 ( .

(

A (

D $ ( J

/>>!0>((2> !& .

& 8

0 <

> & ;

<> .

B C

/* + 8 @ @ J $ /!'202((- ,&4. .

:$ $ E "

M !!

/0(( & +M1 ((4 !!2

/ 0((--,&E J A 1 />>0((,>&$

/>>!0>((>-

@ +

$1/>>!0 >((- -0D/

0 # &

( @ ( 1 /!!!0((>&

# *8 )

& />!0 , (( 2 -& ( ='(1(

( ( !, # & ; < $

( 6 3 /!='0((' # ( & A(

A & A( &

( 8

A( & ( > ;/(( 0 C> 5

& A (

5 & A(

D #

@ /!!'0 , (( 2& A (

& & A (

( A (

& (

A ( <

A ( & ( ' ;/(( 2-0C ' < 8

< A(

( + J

E8 /!!-0!((, K

& # & &

L 8

# &

F 8

8 L 8

A &

. 8

D # @+

@ /!!!0 (( >!&

& (

3 ( 3

& A ( & &

( K

(

A (

3 # $

61$#+!,,('>=& ,& ( ;/$#+

'>!:>0 <, #

& A (

3 # &

2= (1(

# ( A(

& 8

& & 8

$#+!,(,L< @

61 $#+ !, ( 0 # &

A( 8

2# @E

$1/!=!0(( ,,&

(

& A(

8 &

8 D /

7 ' '

# :G

I 45 E .' : & '

1 #''

E % '

: &

& : & # '

# & # '

& '

' ' E :&

# J#

> E

' ' ' '

# E/ 3 -

0 - 0-#

0- 0- ;0 3 '

- 0

' ' ' E # #3

# ; +

# <

' >

# # ,

, % # &

( '

7 ), ( %

' '

# :0

& ; # & ' 3

# #

' #

6 2 '#

' #'

% 1

' '

3 #

+ @ '

' 1

' #

# ' # # 6 ' # #

' #

# ' 2 #3 #

@3C5

# 8*9!!!+5' 3

@ ' #

8 !!!!!+5

8*9!!!+5 # 6 ' ' 6 1

8"!!!!+5 ' #

# ' # 8)9!!!+5

# 1 #'

% # & # # '# &

F & # # ' # 1

1 53 # #

; #

" # $ % &

+ ) /

6< &#) !' & < B OB" < OB"