Mahabir v. State Of Haryana
!"# " $"
%!
& '% (
) "* !
" ) $"
) + ,-
./ 0/
) +
)1 1- / 0/
) 0)
- "234 / (5 1 $5,1 167 $144 "234 / (5 1 //7879
!" #"
$% &" '( ) **+,-*% *.//+ )*.-01*.//.
* 2! ) **-301*%*.//.
4 *
5 67" '( # ! 7" '( )*.-01*.//.
//7879 (/ -
%&
"& (
9
9
) 0)
9
.
!
62 6!('(-, /:
.//. (-;
/:
.//." ) < 6" (" " 2! "
( != ) **-301*%*.//. > & ('( (
(+/3" *555 ) &(+35 )& ( 6 6 !
! ' ( 1//4*("6&
%
(?
" ( !
= ) **+,-*% *.//+ 9
& " 2! " 2!"
!('(( (+/.5 ) ! "
@ "&4'(!( ! ) !' = )*.-01*.//. >
!@6!
+
(( ( "! ) & 6 ! # "" 2 6&!(*6A! ( ?" )" 5& !
( @&62 B( "( !
!@! &' " /0 +1 -/ /1 .///"
! "2 &( !@! B!!
& ( "&( 6 C5DA
<4. ( B!! ) (& *
!
"# !$
%
!&$ # #
$!#
' " ' $' # # '!
(!
&$ $
%
!
!
&$ !#
$ ) !)
!
!
') #$ ( *!# (!
!
$
! +,
-
, !
+
. )
) !) )
6 C5"( '6& ( ( ( /. // -- /1 .///"! (( !2 !6 ! !
A!&6( ( ( ! 2"(( & ! (("&( & 6 (!!( ! B " & 6 (' %
!&(&@ ( 2! (2' !!"!& @ ( E!" '6
(+/.4+35 ) &(+35 )&6 ((
(!!"( ( !6! & @( B ) B ) & ! ('&( (+3-"+/.4+35 )&! 6(( !( 6*& !6! B ( 6&A (( "&( 6 (!
6( " ( A!
6"( ( "#' ! ""&!(*6 A!! -/ /1 ./// 5 "
& &
&-./
%
&0/4+/# &62 *
/ ,
0
1
2 3, !, !1, ,! 4 , , !1, ,!3, ! 5 , !/4, 0 !
6+ 3&
24,
/&
)$ 4
!4
2
34 , !14, !1, !14, ! 4, 0 7&
$
2 7, 8-
2
,7 54 ,7 5
2 5,/ !4,3 !7,/ 9(
&
2/,
0
&
24, 0
1
23,
3&
7,/
/&
27,/
7*-" 2 = -"+"0"-/"-- -. & & !62 & & & "
DA )4-" ( ?
DA )" &
!@! ( ( ! !A! ! -- /1 ./// !"( &! 6 (@ '!2 &(& *! ! (( ( 5 ( *A!"2 = -1 !
& 6 ! @"&( *' !A( ( 6 2 = 3"
( & ! ! 2 = 0":"-+-3& A6 !2 "&( *' B &A 2 (2 = ; ! ! 2 !'A( ( 6 " 2 & !
5(2 = -/"---." 6!6@ 2 & !
!2 = -+"1"0-/ -.& 62 ! 2 ''!2 ' !(" A('62 6!"
%
!(!&0/4+/&& & 6 ! !" !6' '' B ( A!
" "))"= 7*."& 'DA )4.
! &!@!/0 +1
-/ /1 ./// B
( A! 7*+")2 "& (
0 DA
# B ! 7*3" ) !
! 7*1"
)$& ! 7*0")"<6 6 ' ( ("& " 7*,"<6 6 54 (-,+)
) B ( A!! "! ! (("
7*:
& (( (
(
( "!C5 6 ('( 6! " B( & ?
! ! & !' 6!6 ! ! @ ( 6 (!
! @6 6 ! &6' 2 (( (( 5 ( *A!"! ! ((&2 /+ ! 66 &@&( ! & ( !!! & !( & !
! &
& 6 B 6 & !
! ! 6 & 6('6 & !! !&! '6! "&( (./ ! ! '6 !) ! !6 6 ! 2"(( 2 ! !!6!!
.
!! & '6=' & ( 6 6 "&& 6(
B ( A! 7*;")
! "& 'DA = B ( A! =%6
7*-/"& ?DA (")" B
( A! 7*--"'
! " )5 "<"& ( ('6 ( 5( *A!" !
( @ 6
'
''((! ((& "&& B ( A!
7*-." 5 )"& !(& ( 6 ( '6 ,
'( ( &" ( '(&(" ( !6'(&
(( ! (+-+)
)& ( B ) (( !
( ( 5 (" (( A! < 6" = " ( = 7*-"& 6 ( 6C5= .,/ -;;3"C5= -:--;;:"C5= .33-;;:C5= -,0-;;; AC5DA )"DA "DA DDA C BC5 & 6 6! "(( :
$ ( ! ("( &!! ((! & ( 6( B ) "B )
:
&6( ! ( ' ! " & ('( & (( (@! & *! & (& (' ! (( D'( ' & ( !('(! ( !
' ( ! 2 (
(( (("! (( 2 !( ( !
= ) **+,-*% *.//+& ('( ) $ (
6 ( ! ' = )*.-01*.//." = - 3 ! ('(( (+/.5 )" (+/3
*555 ) &(+35 )
/;
" ?
! ( !
= ) **-301*%*.//. >&&(( 4
! 2! 6 (
) " "
= -A
?
! )?
" (
6
! 2! ( !
= ) **-301*%*.//. !
'' ( (
&((&(!!( !!
( " (( ( @ ( -/ // -/ /1 ./// ?& -- ./ B ( ( /- .1
& & !
!(!
"& ( (
$ "( (&!6 /0 +1
"
!! "(!
& ( ( ("B ) ( ('! ! "2 6 2!& '' ( $ ( (
(" (( '('(6 ( "&(&6!! "(( (("!((! & ( ( ''!! (66 ( &((( ("( &(!
$ ( (
'' (!(?
-/
7'( ' !! ( ( ( ( & --
5 (" (6!"&( &!! -/ /1 ./// 6 !"C5 (& 6 ( B! (! ( (( & "&& '6 (( (("( '!! ! & ! ! !
! & ( ! &' "& *6 &6 ( B ) 6 5(" ( 6!DA <! "
!( DA )4+& ! 7*."
D'
( /0 +1 -/ /1 .///" ( ! &!@! B "
!&!! "&(6! ' 6( !( -.
" ("B ) ( ( ! &'6( !(@6 & ( '( ( D' 7*--"'
! " )5 "<" (
( @ 6
'
''((! ((& "&& 5
! ! 6 "(( 5
&'6 ! 6 6 " 2! (@! "(( " (" 66!( DA )4+"!! & ( "
&( 6 !!
'( 5 ("
' 7*:" ! ! ! ! ! ! @ ( 6 (! ! @6 6 ! &6'2 (( (( B " &!' 2! ( 2 ! D' (
6 !! 6 ! !
! &! !! &
! 5(" !!@6 !"! &( (!6' (( ( 5 ) 5
!!
DA <&
!
!
!46 & @ ! &' " 6( "C6 DA &A! !(5#" " !!
& !
9 F 9 %F C6 DA !
9%F&'
6' 9 @ FA.4+ 6 &' " !6 !
&( " 5 ) ''(( ( B " & ( !! ( & C "'6 ( "! 6 /0!6 &' " !! 7*:" "
(6 6 @ ( !! (( ( B "&! "&&(6 ( !( 6' (" ! 6 G6 ( 2 ! "(( )?
"&
6 ( B ) 6 6''! 2! ( -+
5 (" & ( ''! 6 ' 2!& '' (6 (( B "
& 6(?
( 6 &' "& (
6 ! 5 (" ' 6 ! !! 2!!!
(" ""((( !"! !! 2 ("6( ' &"! 2 ''6 (
!" 2!& ! ('! ! " & ! ( (( ( 7! !! "& ! ! ( ( ! ( *A!!& "(( & ! 3/431 66 6 ( ./@! ! '6 ! 6 ! 2"(( 2&! !!6 !! !! & '6 =' &( 6 & 6( B "
2&'6& ! "&& '6=' ( 76 & 6 ( B ) ( &A ! ''&!! 2"&& ( "!(( D' &"
6 ( ( '' ! !! " & ( ( ( ! B " (?
! 2B )
-3
" ( & ( (!
'! 6 (( & ('(
(+/.5 )" (+/3 *555 ) & (+35 ) BB ) ( ( !DA < !! 6 ! "2 4( &6@"@&! @
@! "
& '( A (( @!
&' "
&( 62 ! " ( 2 @"@&! '((! ( 7! ! 7*-"
6 6 ( 2 = -1 ! & 6 ! @"&( *' !A( ( 6 2 = 3"
( & ! ! 2 = 0":"-+-3& A6 !2 "&( *' !2 = -/"-- -."&(& " !6@
!2 & !
!(" !"
!6' '' B "((( & 2! (!!!
! B ) ( (('( 2!
(+/3 555 )
-1
7 (6 (& (+/.+/3
55 5 )" H
! ) !
!
"# $%& &'& *
/-
+
: $ :
:
:
:
:
:
: :
! :
: :
:
#( )* +, "
- %.$$ ./- $
!
4 0 ** ,# !
-/1'$&.. /9 ;
:<
!
! )
)
=
)
) - )
> >
!
:
7 =
! ?
@ ?)@
$
)
)
) $
) ! ?
@?)@ =
- A
)
=
)
) ! 3 / "B
) ,
"B :
: :):
,
- !
!
3
,
)
!
" 3 3
"B! $
! $ $ -
B ,(2( )34)3 * ,
!
'$ - ;
:- ! = ! ! 3 1 3 /" 3 /"
+) ! !=
! $ !
C ) ! !$ -
- !
0
& !
3 1!
3 / " !
!
3 1- ! !
;D E FD
E
) FD
E
FD E
$ FDE
=
FD E
FD
E
F D
E ! ! F D ,E
FD,E
$ ) FD, E
-
!
!,
= (
8-
B ,#)4,* + "
-/%5$$& & +
$
3 /" + 3/ "B
)
.
3 / " + 3/ "B -)
!
B =
,
3 /" + 3/ "B ;
:18
!
B !
$ D97G98 )E
1* ! 995>.
B
= 0
!
*$ <
! ) + ! )
B
-)
*
994
!) !
=
,
B :
5 #* +, # "
-.%.$$
.
B
:
)
!
)
3 1 "B 3 /" "B
;
8<
!
)
-
!
) !
!
I11
. ! )
! -
) ! ( !
+ !
) )
5
!
! 3 1 "B
3 /" "B
B
!
- =
B
& & !(('((
-0
5 ( " ( &
!( (( ( !
! B "(&( 6&! (+/3 555 ) BB ) ( ( !' ! "( !"& ! 6 "&(!6' 6* (6 &
!' &! 6'!6 '6 D'" 2! 2& ( 62 ! B "&
('( 2! "
= . (+/35 )6 ( B ) 6!('(
-,
=&"' 6 (") (( (&'@( 66 '6& !66( ( !( ( 5 (" ( ! (!! 2! "
= . ?
6 '
' " !!) (' ( (66 4
(! .3 D' "(*(( A D'! !6( 6.3 /:
.///6& .0 6 1/ ('6 &' '' ( !
-:
)?
"@ 6'&(( ( !(
("(!
(
B! !!
-;
5 '& '" ( !
=
B#&++ /74+(+1
1 &!
62 6! ('(-, /:
.//.
"& "( !
( "! '! !
./
5'&'6 ( B#&++ /74+(+
1! B#&+'+38 +'(&+1
3!
B##+1 74+1
1(!
! !
.-
6
(""
$%; )# $"
$ <<
(%)$#
//"#=">!
(%)$# / 0/
7 @64 I4= 7 I4=