High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/34536/2017dismissed

Jagbir Singh v. Ut Of Chandigarh

2025-05-07Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil4 pages

!"#$"%&'&#() **

) +,-* . -. -- , ****

!

"#$ $

% "

%

&"$' &" ! ( ) . (/""0#1/2&34 * 5 3 *+,

"

-.) !$ / 0" )) 1.

)1+2*

3" 4, / $ " '

!$ / 5$+6 1- )1+2*

3" -, $/$$' 5 5 $ " *),

7 "

$! 5! ' 5 ! ! 5 / 5 &"5

$$ !$ / $ +2 ++ )1+) ! 5 ! ' "/ 8"5 +.

)1+) 5$ 9"5 ' 5 "! !5 +) 1+ )1+:

'

'"55 ! " 5 "" 5 5/ +.

)1+) ! $/ / $$ 5 ; $5 16 )1+:

< "5 $$

- 2 - !! ' 55 1:

++ )1+)'

5! ! !5 !" 5 5/ +.

)1+) ! $'"5/ !:/!5 $ " ' "

-4. = ! !! %"5 +6 1- )1+2 *:,

7 "

$ " " $ " $$/ 0" 5" +6 1- )1+2 3 ! $5 "

-4. ' ' !"$$/ 5 5 $ " $ / 5 ! "5 ! = '

' $ " 5 ! -4. "

$'!"$$/$/ %" 3 "

' '

' 5' / $'

< $ "

-4. $$5 5! = ! !! 5! !5 ! ! = $/ ! $ "%" $ "!5 "

-44>-4.< ' $$ !! $ ! "

$$ "

!< ! $ " '"$ $/ " %" " '"$$5"

!%" / $ " *-,

< $/ !$ / ? 5 5 @ ?

/ 5 < $$ < 16 )1+6 ! " 5 $" !

- 3 - = -2: 5' " $/! / !%" $ " !"

5$ '

" $5 55$! 5"

-4.< $ / " "

<!" " !5 ! /!! ! 5!"

5"!5 ! A< *B,

( )C? 8"5 $!$$/ )1+. " 5 ; $$' 5 5 "

!5 ! "

-.) '"$ 5 $ $ / "5"

9!" "5 "5 *

3" + :, $" / $5

' ! "

+2: *4,

<!" " ( )' '! $ ! $ 5 " ! 5 ! &"5"

+2: '

$/ / $ " "

'"$ "

/ '/5 '

!! "

-44>-4.< 5" *2,

9 $ "

$! *.,

< " $" "5

3" + : " $5 $5 " "5

- 4 - ' ! "

+2: "

5 "$ / "$'

$ " $ "

3 %" /'$$ '

!! "

-44>-4.< 5 " " !5 / "

$ ! %" $ 5 '"$ $ "

/ 5 !! 5"$ $ *6,

" $' "

-2: $/ ! ! ' $$/"

'! D$ '

'$$ ' / $ "

*+1,

8 "5 5 5 $/5 *++,

E $/ 1B )1)B

. (/""0#1/2&3

1/2"

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No