Sumitra Devi v. Ram Phal And ORS

 

 



 




 






















!"!"#
"
$%!

$
& *+, """""
//00


1- +

,
20

2-

""""""
 /

"
$%3

$
& *,"
*+, """""
//00


1- +

,
20

2-

""""""
 /

(  45
("
 *
6 5
*  -  7 (-"
-+
* 809
. 9
-
2
//00


:2
2
//0 (-"
"

"
6/-9
. 9
-

,/;


:2
2
//0 "

<22-
2
/--

0 0
= //-
,;
:
00=


2
>+8,
?

"


:
---

2
/--
-
"

%"

<22-
2
>+8,
2+0
:
-/-

2
 8 
?

7"7 7"7 5
* 9
"

;
2

,,
>+8,9

= 00


/ 


"

$%!

$
 0






    

"
$%3

$9
 0







     
 0
:;
2
,'//00
8


2
=- 
%"3"$9
/


:;
2
(-



,
- :+09  /
& 2-
42
- :+04)9
=2
2//

:
2
,2-


77  
1 
6+,-

= =

 
,
6-
@
, 6-


9
A 8
2 ,

"

,,


2

-
2

"B"9
1  6+,-
08= 2
2

2-
,
6-
@
,
6-


=

-.00 

-9
:- 8
-8

- 
"
7C77B3"

2;

=-
8 8
-,
 /



"

<2
2;
- 2
-
.

008 (-9


$!9
:- 8
-8

- 
"
7%7333%9
- .

- 2

80 8
,-
:;
- /
"
7,
20
, -,




2 
2
-"

,
6-
@
,
6-


 

2
/9
=2-
1 
6+,-
+  
,+0 /0
8- .+

>+-

=
-,.

-0
 / 09


"



=.-9
2 0 
+

+,:

2
>+-

,
 
"
$


=
 0
:;
*,"
- ,
@ +
= =

1 
6+,-9
2-
=
, -
0-9
,0;9
*+:2

&+82-)

- A
& )

*+, -
.

9
,2-

2  "

2

,
 
"
#


=
 0
:;

*+,
= =

,
6-
@
,
6-


"


= 
2
1 
6+,-
=
3
;-

8"



,20;

,
=
 "
9#9'7"


2

9
= ,
2
,
6-
@
,
6-


=
#%
;-
 8

2

,20;

,
=
 "
%#9'7"

 /
"
 &- .-)
 

//-
:-
2
- :+0

2
=
/-  8


D7/-9
=2-
2
=-
&- /
"
)
,  2


9
:+
/0
2

=
: + 

2
80 8
- .

7%7 
1 
6+,-9
- .-

(-+ -"

2

,/;
A 2
/0
2

=
2

00


:=
2
-


$!







- :+-;
80 8 "

-,
2
/0 9
00=

+
=-
-,
7 E"

<22-
2




F+ 
A
/0 
+

- 
80 8
- .

8

- /
"

- .-

 "
$!
:- 8
-8

- 
"
7%'333%
 =22-
1 
6+,-

,
6-
 



+


>+-
- .
:;
2,

2



9


008
?

"



+
"


/-.9
=22-
2

-  0

- .
;
9

9
2=
,+ 
-,
=2,
?

%"

<22-
2
- /
"


20 8

.0  - .

8
0

9

9

 
?
 $"

<22-
2
/
-


,  :0

2 /- 
-,

.

=

"

"
A

2
=- 

,
?
 #"

0 "G 2
- :+0
20
2
2



A
/0 
+
 - 2

80 8
- .

8


$!"


=
:

-.
2
- , @
+
= =

1 
6+,-
2
-7,-- "


=
+
-, 2

,
D
-+-
2
2


:

-2

1 
6+,-
=

$"%"B!9
2= 8
2
2
=
%
;-

8

2
 ,

2

7$7 2"


=



2
2
8-

0-;

1 
6+,-
-,
('

*2-
* 820
*/ -
."
5"
= 2=

:
 "
C9'7

2


,
;-
7
& D")"



,,



= 2=

:
 "
%9'7"


2


,
;-
79
2

0-;
= 2=

:
 "
C9'7

,,



,
=

2=

:
 "
!9'7"

2
/

--
& D"

D"#)9 /


:;
2
 9
 /9
=-
0 
/-+ 9
2= 8
2
2

,
D
=
/ "

2--9
-
+ -
+ 
 "
9'79
2

,

1 
6+,-
=
A

:
 C!9'7"

-
+ 8
2
/- 0
D/ 9
2
/ ;
 2

=
A

:
 "
$#9'7
/-
+,"

2 ,+0 -

!
=
//0 

2

=
=-A
+ 
:
 "
!9C#9'7"

 "
9'7
=-
+-0

0 
- 

=-
0 
00=

2


 "
!9!#9'7
=

00="


2

 0
:;
- ,
@
+9
= =
 
6+,-9
=2 0


8
2
2
2
-7,-- 9
 "
99'7 =-
--

:
/ 

2-"

 "
9C#9'7
=-
--

: / 

*+, 9
,2-

2
 

 "
9#9'7 2
=-
--

:
/ 

2
, -
0-

2
  
6+,-9
,0;9
*+:2

- A"

8- 8
2
2

,
6-
@
,
6-



=
20
2
2
=
##
;-

8"

/-
2



:

-29

2=

2

,
D
-+-
& D"$

#)9
2



:

-2

7#7 =
- -

2

,
D
-+-
=
%"#"B$C"


=

:

-.
2

/-
2
:0 2
& D"$

D"#)9
2  
=
8 8
8-

0-;

 "
C9'7
/-
+,
-, ('

*2-
* 820
*/ -
."
5"


=
0 
8 8
-0

,"
-
+ 8
 "
9'7
=- -
+ 9 2
0-;

,
6-
@
,
6-


=
A

:
 $9'7
/-
+,"

2
/ ;

2

= =
=
A

:  "
9'7
/-
+,"

2
,+0 -

3
=
//0 



=
=-A
+

:
 "
9C9'7"
 "
9'7 =-
+-0
D/
=
00="


2

=;9

 "
9!9'7
=
=-"


2.
2-
0-
+ 0
-
2
//009
0-

+ 0
-
2

,/;

2.
0 
-+00;
8 2-+82
2
 0"

5-
+ 0
-
2
//00
2
.2,0;

-8+
2
2
- :+0
2

/-/-0;



2

,9


.

2

,
D
-+- "

2
-
+ 

 9'7

-
0 +0 8
2

,
D


:
+  -,

,"

(-.-9

,
-,
2
8-

+0+-

2-

+-
=


-"

 - 0;9

= 00
A
+/
2

-8- 


+

2

1 
6+,-"



+
2
//0
2.
:
 0
:;
*+, - .

0;

2
2-

2.

 0
;
//0"

2

7C7

,
D
-+-
& D")9
 0
:;
1 
6+,-

2
;-
7 
2=
2
2
2
2=
2

,
-,
0-;

 "
$9'7"

2

,
-,
2-
+-
= 2=

:
 "
%9'7"


,
2
2
 

=
8 8
0

0 "


2

=;9 2
0

,
2=

=
 "
!9'7
/-
+,"

%H


: + 


,
D

2

-,

,


 $B9'7
/-
+,"

*



,
2
2
 
=

8 8
0

0 9
2--9
2-
=
0


,8,
0;"

2--9
-
0


,8,

2
8-

+0+-

,9
2 0

0 +0

 "
9'7
/-
,2
""
 "
$9'7"

2 0

,

2
 
2+

 "
!%9'79
+
 =2

2
'%-


:
+ 



+

/- 0
D/
  
""
 "
$9%%%'79
=2

2
-
-+


 "
$9'7"

2
/ ;

2


 "
$B9'7"

*


2  
=
%
;-

89
2
,+0 -

C


:
//0 "

2+ 9
2
,+


=+0
2.
,

 "
$B9 D
C
I
 "
!93$9'7"

2
,2-
=+0
0 
:
 0

 99'7



+

0


0.

 

2

"

*

2
= =

=
, -
0-

 
1 
6+,-
2. 
,

//09

2--9
2
2 


: =-

2
,2-


:

-"

+

2
,+


9
 "
99'7
-
0


0.

 
200 D 0+

.0;
8

,2-

2
 
*+,

+
  "
!93$9'79
2-
 "
99'7
200
0 
:
8 .

2

7!7 ,2-

2
 "

2

=;9


20
2
2
/-  //00
&,2-

2
 )
=+0
2.
:
 0

 99'7"
*


2
2
0-;
:
--

/;
 9C#9'7
+

2

=-
:;
2
- :+09 2--9
2
 0
+,

 "
%#9'7

00=9
=2

2

 :
/ 
= 2
- 
@
!"#H
/-
+,
-,
2


 8
2


 00

-0 J "
=
, 8

2

=-



+
 2

,
6-
@
,
6-


9


+
2

/- 2

,
D
-+-
-
2
;-
7
& D"C)9
2
  2
2=
 "
$9'7


,
-,
0-;

 "
9B'7


,
-,
2+ 
/-/-;

2
0
2=

 "

C9B'79 -,
=2

2
%H

,
D


:
+ 

2
:0 
=+0

,

 "
$$9$$'7"

2
 
2
0 
2=
2
8-

+0+-

,
,+ 8

 "
9%#9$#'7"

*


2
 
=
 = 8
8-

+0+-
09
:+


:
8 8
0

0 9 2--9
2-

0


,8,
0;9
=2

2




 2
-

 "
9'7
/-
,2
""
 "
$9'7
/-
+,9

00="

2--9
2
 .

,

 
,
6-
@ ,
6-


=+0
,

 "
C39$$'7"

'%-
""
 9C3'79
=2

2
-
-+


 "
9!'79
-
A

: /- 0
D/ "

2
/ ;

2
,


 $#9%$$'7"


2
 
=
#%
;-

89
2
,+0 -




:
//0 

/-
2
+2- ;

2
4:0
*+/-,
+-




 
 

      

        
B
&%)
 
&

.

0)
!!"

*9

2
,+ 



 "
$9B39!3$'7"

 "
99'7


+

0


- +,

2
= =
*+, -
.

- 00="

2-
 "
#9'7
-
+-0

0 
- 
-
0 00="

2
0
,+




 C9%9!3$'7"
2
2 

200
:
/ 

2

,
= 2
- 
@
!"#H
/-
+,
-,
2


 8
2


 00

-0 J "

*


2
 8
.2

0
=

+-
= 2
2


,/;9
2--9
- /7

,/;
200
:
0 :0

/;
2
9
=2

200
:
/ 

2
,'//00
= 2 
2-
,2
-,
2 

--9
/


:;
2

+-"
2
2
//0
-


- 80;
00=

2
D


- "

&6 5
* )  

!"!"#

>A