High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10744/2021dismissed

Gurdev Singh And ANR v. Joint Development Commissioner (Ird) (Exercising The Power Of Commissioner) And ORS

2021-10-12Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma8 pages

!"!#!$% &$'()(*!(%+((( !(*#(%!

*, *-

# ./ ,(

'*.012223*3, ,4,%*3 5,6, %1 %(-7 !8)9"%'$/ "($#$/ "#"%#"(/! !8)9"%'$/ "(/!::$(% "%( - #4,03/(.,; ,5/ 3(., 1 ( # 1,3(.,

,.,71<=#,2, (/!::$(% "%(3' 7> ><77

,,110, 0 ,22 ;1 & , 3,00;(2;1 ,?

,.,11, 1 .? @,,4 ; 5 (0

, ? B , 2 21 ,

C < (@ 7 . ;

1 D00

, ,4,9,3**.012,, ,4,

3,,0, , ,1 1 / 5,6 00,229, % 0,(3CA 3E ( CAF 0641 <7#,2 , ,4,3 ),06 , ,, 1 , 21 ,<

(@ 7<.;

17' *.012 22 2 ,11,0 0 64 1 ,, , C <(@ 77

!,. 0, 1,176?3 ,1 1<7#,2, 0,1 / ( CA 52 1,0; /,1/ 2 0,21:

;, >G3:

,, C> 3:

,,A==C A7C3 2<7A3 G7 3 ==A 7C3<== G7 3CG7 3 G7 3 CG7 3

7 3A==

G7 3,0 :,,0 ,0,3 ,,.00, ),06 ,3)0?/, 3 0,*,,0, 1 / ( CA3 ,,. 0, B ;,6 221 1=6 ,6, .00, ),06 , , 1 1 , 00,004 14 ,0,,, 4,0,60 .=52

2 0, 1 ( , 1,3 . ,

C < (@ 73 1 700 ,2 0 ,4,; 0,1 , 1 ,., 1 ,0,,, 1H. 2 0,1 , ,6

, ;

. , ,? 1 , I04 0, #,2, 2223 ,6 ,?, .4 21,=,,

< ?1 1 0, , 04 (. ,, , ,3 0,,11,0;

,,062 .,<

(@ 7<1,64 22 !3 ,.,11, ,00 21 , C <,<

(@ 7,7< < 9, 0 13 . 204 62 , 21 , ; , 00,0 9, 0 62 , 1 2, 1 7/,1 / , 1 , 0,1 21. ;3,2043),6 / , . ,0, C G , G (@ 7<,7<(, , 3 11 , ,0, 21 2,1 7/,1/ ( 1,6, 1 , 0,1 ,,004 ,01.,, . ,21. ,4, ; 0,1 9, 0 1

62 21 ,,004;,,, 0,;, ,2, 6,5 , 2

,3 0, 0 1 <7#,2 , ,4, 62 ,

,0 1 , ,. , ,,; 1. ( CA%1<7#,2 , ,6 6 ; ?,,0 2,0, 0,! 62 , ,0 , , ),6 / , 0 1 ,, #,2 , / ( CA 00=*.,0 *1 4 * , ,4,3 ,,0, ;

;, ,1 ,. .,

CC ,1<7 #,2, , 0,11,0,, ,6 '

*.012 22 %* ;

;, CCA

,. 1<7#,2, ,4,, ,,

CCA ,6 04@ 6,,?(7 6 00;

,11, 2 21 , C < ,,

CCA3 ,6 0 ,4,;, ; 0,1 , ,0, ,6.0,, , %<>1,),6 / 64 ,4,;

2 ',2,6, 4,C G7 C,CGG7GC(.,, , , , CCA 1, 64 ' *.012 223,),6 / 0

> CC 0, , , / , . ' *.012 22 %*3 5,63 ,, , 6 ;

7 C>

, 6 0 ; ,;,0 ; 1 , ,2 ;, 2,; ,;., > G 1,64

30, 0 1<7#,2, ,4, 62 , ,, CCA1,64 22 0 0,1 60 ,4,001,, ,2 ,6,,, ,, ,04& 0, ,4,,60641.,1, 1., 19, 03 3 62 00, ' *.01222 ,. 04.

2 0, ,4, > ,.,@ 04 62 0, 0 1,, 1,176? A , 21 ; 62 0, 0 1 ;

, ,.04 2. ,

> 21 1 , ),6 / , 0

> CC ,, 52, CCA1,64 '*.01222%*3 5,6@ 1; 22 ,;1;,2,; ,;. , > G ( ; ,;,0 ,;13 , CCA1,64 '*.01222 , 6,, ,2,, ,04,2,1,.00, ,01 , ,, CCA3 , 6 064 '*.01222%*3 5,6 ,),6 / , 6 . 0, 1 0, 6, ;

2 ',2,6, 4,C G7 C,CGG7GC0 11 0,; 1,6, ,01 23,, ,04, 1,, ,043621,. ,0022,2,00,; ;, 0 2, , ;, 6, 64 , 0,? , CCA3 22 0, 1 60#,2, ,4,71<,, 3 , 0,3 1. 6 60 #,2 , ,4, , 6 064,1.,1, 1.,1 , 1 60 114,6, 21.,1143; 1,11.,0 .2,4;

11460,1 60114 , 6 2,111, 10, , 1., 1

, ,60 , 0, 1 . ; 17#,2, ,4,3 3 1 ,00,1 , 00, '*.01222;

, 04 1. ( CA .

A 1 2 6

? 0, 2, :,,0 ,0, 601<7#,2, ,4,

.; 2,3;,,6. 2 , 3 0, ,66 , 0, 2, , 0 ,0 , , 1 601164 , 0 2,00 ; 164 ;?,6410,4 ,?,2;

0 0 /,1 6

? 1 60 11,0 @ B ;

,,60, ,

, G (1, 2 ,3 2, , 2 1 60 11 , 1 1 ,47647,4 , , 6 10, .012 , !H60 / 12 ? , , 0 / <CA , 0, 1, ,3 .00, 22 0, , 6 ,66 64 0 1 0 1;3 24 1; 10,0 0 @ , 2,4 /, 0,@041,110,4,21 0,I 00,0 0,;, 0 ,. , , 0 0,3 42 62. , ,.1 0, ,4,;, ,#,2/,6 ,=#,2, ,4,0,2 6?1 22 .00, .; 2,3 !H60/ 12 6., -7 !" 2 ,11,0 ,1100,

; 1, ;

00,004 , ,4,0,64 2 01;=24 1;,00 ;

,0,.;

#,2 , ,4, , 1 , ? 60,,00,02 6". ,1100, ,.6 0 0,B 42 62. 3, 1 0,B 2 6 ,6,? #,2 , ,4, % 0, 00,0 6 12 6, #,2 /,6 , 0, ;

2 6?1 22 .00, .00, ### ### ###

") 1,; ,;.,00 /, #.2 4 , 4 0 11, 2 . 00,0= , 1, #,2 /,6 ,=#,2 , ,4,=1,26?= ,20, 0, , 2 6 #,2 /,6 ,=#,2 , 22 .00, .00,& 1 1 /, ,00 /, #.2=$ ,,

03,? 01

#.2 , 2 0 1. 14 . 00,0 1,3 , . 2 , ;7, ,,6 ,9 , 00,0 1,

@1 2,? 10,02 6,,, , 00,0 , 0, 00,01% 0,, 0 04 612 @1,0 , ; 0,

,6, 2.2 , 0,0 0,6 226 / 0 ,=/ 0 63 ;

,0,4 , 031,4 1 60 04 0,F

,11 ,.6,64!H60/ 12 $ %&3

%%.0 C C , 1 ,, 0,; 0,;64 / 12

004,110,60 1, .; 3 ; , ; ,64 1700, ' *.012 22 21 . , ;007 , B 043 ; 2 ; 1 ;

,042B 1 2,0 ;13 ,110,13 ,43 ,00,1 ,04 (/!::$(% "%( ($#$/ "#"%#"(/! '$*#" '$*#"

&: 1,?=, + %1,60 +