Housing Board, Haryana And ANR. v. M/S Comfits Marketing And ORS


   
   
 

    



    

     !"# "$#%" &&'' ("  )*+", #%" -&# 

  

!

  " ." " ',/#0 "%&&''  " $ %1 +"2%"00#0" " 3%$4 &#0 ""&#   55555  "# !

6%&&'%3'#, %'' %"#"

## 

 &#3$%##' "/ .%, '7%"3$ %%''7#%&&''# #"2

%"3"# *'

8"%"9%9" #%"3"'

7"###

7%%7&#0 "%&&''  73"%"3#%"##

 

:7''#3$%&&''0 ""&# "

&"0# #; #"&"$"##0"'3'#%%# '# %&&''.%, '  6%7",''#7 +&'#7%%&#+7%%'#%&&+ "3""7% 0%7"###

0 "%&&''

%" &"%7"#+ 


:)
'$ 7%"&#  73" ##%&&''' 7% <+&'" #' ;&#
)


"0# %# 7"#"&# %'' #%+3$7$' 3=

#"2

%3"%##' "/ .%, '7% #%7"#3$"#"## 

 7%%"#"%3 '#%&&'  " ',/'"#  '&&" 3%'% &&''#%%7"#&#%#,#" %%"&# %#+&'#%7","#"&'# & 7%'' %::<#0&$+%#'"#$3"'#   0 "    "&#      >  7  #  %  7",  '$  7"%
 

::)
%#3; ##%""%"3""%#" %'$ %'#%%3'+ %#0&$+73" ## ' 7% <"  >'"

#%%##' "/  .%, '%#""# #%7"#'% " #% &&+%"3""73$#%&"#'+  > "%" 3+#%"&# '7,+&'% 7",7 '#3#%7"##%"3$ '#3#%% &'%'+#70# >7 "%""

#%"&#    %"  '#       "  &  &""+  7%%  7 '#  '  3%%7,+&'%7",''# #%""%7",''#%#3+&'#"+% #"%&&''%"7 '#3'#" #%3'% #0&$+  >'"

#%"&# %"%#

"#%&''+3"%"3""#%""&&# "+7# "+" %&'%&''+ +;#?

'7# > &&"%"

+%"'# & = +"#"#%
       >'##%%"%%#3''# 0 ""&#   707%%"%   !"#%+%37"##7% 0 &3# #7 #%%"7"0"' 0'3';  %7",'7"&""7+#" %"+&"

*'  %"7%%& '#%%+ 7",3 "###"## $++#" 3 #  ."  "  "  $ %  1 +"  2"00  '"#   '

&&"    3%'    "&#     %"  "

  %  %"     "+$%"#"%##' "/ ''7 %3= "%&''+"# >"

#%0% &''+7"#% "%
&7"# %7"#%# " # >%" "# '&'"' & = +"#"#     !"#""$

  %

$& '( &
"')  >"

#%%"" +&' %7",7%+7 %%%7 +#0'3' "0""%"+##%#3 '#%&&''%"+#0"$&3'+& "&#  "# %" '"#$'#37%+7%% # "%"#'$  > "%""

#%%"3""%+# # %+' 0 # %%"'%#3'' ''$7"##

"&# 77%%& "07 0& %0'#$%"  :

>%0%"# '"%&"#7%%"

%"

%%&'# %#%""#0'3'  >#& %7",7''#"&#  %""%& "&; #"&"$"##0"'3'#%%# 3 '# %&&''.%, '0#'"##  

:

&"%'"##  

:'' 7",%+&"0##"

+&'%7",7&"#7+%"+%#  '"  3$  : 

: &"%# +7%%"0'3'% ""#    &&"  %  "&#     %#  ##"#  '"    % @; 0@ "   !"# "$, %!"#+ %+%"#%"+7%"%3'#7"3''# 67   %  '"    0'3'    %  ""#  "  ##  

8  # 8  

A#"&%'"##8  

A%@; 0 @ "0#%'"##A  

A7"3, % 



 
 

 

 



 


  
      
 



 


 



 

     
 


  

 

   !


"!$%'"##

 

A%@; 0@ "'"# #& " "# %#"&"$"#7%%%#3&"0##% %*%"+#%*%#+""9"+3$ %%7" +&'"# % '#3#%%7",0"'3'#%# 3+&'# %#7"+ -&#  "&'# "?

 ""+%"+7%%7"3+&'#3$

:
 %%$7""#$+&'%7","3  '##  #'$%# 0"%"+  &"'"##

 

B  ;

"  -
  %  @;   @ "  7"    '"   "&# #"  $%&&'($'

)%*+ ,- .! !/0# '

7%%&"" "+7 '#3, "&#  7%%7''7#3$ 1(%23'* 4'22'* 512'5 ! !/0 #"

%)%*+ 2% ,'

$%&64'2'5 )7237( 6'*7%5 %8 /.

51-9

7!'!

,-  ! !/0  #& %0 ""3""7&&#3$% *%#+""   !"# "$.%, '0#'"##  ! !/!

 >&&""+%""#%*'  870,#

 

3$%*%#+""   !"# "$.%, '  3?

7%%"3""7&&# &"*'  8% " "+"3""73&&#7%7 '#'''

#& #*'  8  &"0##"&"#3" '+"

"3" &"*'  8 &"$7 '#3'#3" '+ ""3"7%;+%"+%#3#+%7", !"## ''    "# 3$ '"%&&''% ?

7%%"%"3"&"# 7 '#%03 3' 3 3$#%&"#'+

%3###"  %  "&"&  ##%?

 '+ %0"$  *'  8 %""&"# # #"C
 & &#*

+&& & "+,- ." +". &##"&". - +"  "+&&## & / " #$ %&        




8
'(  )    *  + ". & &".+ "&". &/"0" - ".    "1-"&-&&  /     "  ." & &".+ "&"/&" &"

-"&-& &/"0## -+ &" % &                    

 

  






            + 



 *  % &            '( 

'



*)        



  

       







    

 

+    ,  

%&% & 
 
 ) 


 



       

 
 

 *   



  



  
 



  

  




   

     

     




"

6%30' &"%&"#7%7%%%+"  '#3"""#%"3"""#= #$#& %" 37%&"  >% 2 3"

 &

*4
"   3  

 5

&*& & "#&"#"" "

&'((' #&& " &66%2 &"+* "7%'#' 7%%+'"  0'0#%&"%3"0# #"C
   
 

     
 
    



 

-  ./ 0  1)


  

  

 



A
 

! 2 1   *     
   


      
       



     
   





   " >% 7

$.& &".   58*  !,  9  (    ')   %  +'"    #  " +   0'0#%%2 &"+* "%%'# #"C
  )





  

   




        

       
       



      
       


          
  
   

* 

    



  






   

 

     

  


  

 

  

     


 

     
      
 
    * 

 *   
 

 

   
  

    
  

        
   

    
 
 


   
    

   
  (   


 




 


   

  )  


*    
 

     
 

     

    
  




  
       


     

  "  '%#"#"#3$%2 &"+* "%  2 3"

 &

*4
"   3    5

&* & & "#&"#"" "

&#7

$.& &".  

B
58* !, #+,'"%" '' &"0#

"'+3'&"$'# %'+7%%%"# 0'##%&"02 B%*"#&"# '+&""3# #""' A%D+7 '# 3&&'3' %" ''   "%"%'++# 3$%

"0#&"$""3"7%%&"#&#% "% %0 '$%'+%

"0#&"$% " "#7''3#+#%0370##3' '$3""##% &"$ 7%+'+7 '#%03"#%''3#%"

## "'#'''3' #"%""&%'+   6%;?

7%%% "7"%&"$ '"% '+"&$%'+% "3"&"%7"+7%%"%+3 "#&'# #"2

%E>%" "#%  
"


 ,   :"". 9'% &"+* "%%'#%%3"'++$3#"#0  %&'%3&''$"#  D+  "&#3"  "'77%%%"7 '7 '#0'#3  #"3''&+#% D+%3+#7''&#&"&'= "&"

# #& 3'&'$ 2+'"'$%&   ##,4%;#" $

   1 #& -& 2 $

'(
" 

9' %2 &"+* " % %'# % 0 %&''+   &''$"#%"3"&% "3 ##"

 %&'7%'#" & #"2

%#%"

3$70"% '+ 6%#"#"# %      
"


   ,    :"  ".      # 7  3?

'$''7#3$%2 &"+* "%    

!"#""$

  % $&  # 2'"% %&''+"#3$&"$%"3"&" %7"+0%&''+3#"#3$%  "7%'## & #"2

% 

D"# '"%&&''% "

#%%&' '+0'0+;?

'7##% '#3''7# 3"#"

+%3&"&"&'#  > &&" %"

+%"'# &= +"#"#%
       6% "% %"

%% #= +"#"#3$%D"

"!%%2 &"+* "7%" % 0'0#7" "# #'

&""%&"+ #"% .""%&

 >%%  %* "''7#%&' '+3"#3"&" '"'$3$##7%%#0 '#7"+% >%" +%2 &"+ * "3"0#%%7"&"+ "'$7 &3"#3$
 &"$%   70"%  0'0#%%#" %"3"#*' 

8%0'#$" '' ""% & "&" '+3"%"3"" 2%'7"'# & 3$'"# '"%&&''%
    

  # % &&'  % # " +% &" 



6% "##' "/ .%, '3$%+&

# "#"## 

 7%'''7 %&'#3$"&#   #"2

%%3"0#%%&" """"3"%3+#3$#%&"#'+  "# &37%&"%" 

>%&" &"'"##  

B% @;   @ "  "&#     %#    ++  %  7",  3$ : 

B#&"%"'"## 

B%@; 

@ "%7",73+&'#7%&"#:#$  3$

 

B  6%"3""7&&#3$%*%#+""   !"# "$.%, '0#'"##  

&"

*'  8 &"$7 '#3'#3" '+""3"7% ;+%"+%#C 7 %8 1,1(5%(&'(2 %8 )%*+# %*

77"1 -"&-&&  /     "   ."  &  &  ".  + "&  " /&  " &  "  -"&-&  &  /"0    ## -+ &  F#"  % " +' '&"#;+%"+  

B  %# &7%%%7",73+&'#3$"&#  #"

%7""#"%@; 0@ ""3#+7","


+++7%8+%"+%#3#+ 3%+$%+" '#3"""#%"3""3$2%*% #+""   !"# "$.%, '3$  

B&"

*'  8 %""#37%&"  70" #%"3""7&&#3$%*%#+""  

!"# "$.%, '0#'"##  

  3$#% &"#;+%  6%' &"#%"

%'3'$


"&#     "  %  ;&"$    ;  +%    %  '+    % &&''7#+#%0370##3' '$3""## "&# %#3#%"

##"'#"+'''3' #"

%""#37%&"  :

>07%30% "#'' '$"&"0"$ %+&

#"#" 

 &#3$%##' "/  .%, ' "# '$%&&'%#%"3$#+# 

 " :;:92 /#  /

  3
 G%%"&, )"# H) G%%""&"3' H)