M/S Brij Rice Mills v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corp Ltd And






      
 

   

  

!"#$%&&'# ((&& )#  * $+,-.&, ((&-#(#/0'# %(    



 

*# #*#(12&.

#'((&& #%,3&. #0-' '#2.

#'#( 
 



4'((&&5'&& '##  , # #

 3'#+2'3# '#+##'+ ' # ''#+#(# 3 .#+2 '(#. '#+# '# ## ##7

  !"#$% #'#+#-&

'# ## ##7

  !"##&'

8+#  3 '+ #$ 

'#.#2' #0

3# #  00&&#+3'((&&'#(*9,9* ( #+3'(#0&2'((&&'#( :*9,9*  .#& # 0&2  &0

3##&2(20&'# & &  ; ;3+2'((&&'  ## *9,9* #&03''0 3&#< 3      ;  #  ((0      #+##    '#  3   #('((&&'# # &((& #((0  #+##+ #'-.&6 , 0.## 

= '-.&6 , 0#'*9,9*((#+##,' ,

#3&3((#+##+2## = >+  + #' &'. .3#'-< &2,',-12& 3((3'('3#    . # ((&&4'3#3'&& +2'*9,9*+ #'-.& , # #' # ''3#33' #0' .  # ,  >   '     4'  ((& 3   +2  '  ((&&  + #  '  -.&  6   ,# . , # #3'.##   # #'((& &' 0+ #'#6 , # #' # ''' $ ##'((&4'#6 , # # ((& & # 

'&''3# '03+2(# &0'(# 3 4'#6 , # #'&'' ( 3 .#+2(#. '



#.'((&'+ &+2'0&&#5 3#+ ('& 4'&2< '$ '((& 3''#'## &+&+ ('&3'#'

''&''#+##(('(3# #' (#. 

 4'#3''3(#0 & +2'*#

8'

'6 #2

3+#

' #3'

 #0'

;'6 #2

4'#+#-&"&&

3( +2+'?  *#&0#.'*#@

'



 

   0    '  ,   "5    4'  #+#   -&



4'((&&'' # # &0 ; ;'  ##*9,9* 3''0 3&#< 3  ; # ((0 #+##(#,

#+#& (# ( 3 &00'23'#< ' '( +# ##'#+##.+2'#( ,>;

(#'#(&. &   ,>; 

#''(#.

'#+# &((&2#&'#+#&(# 3''00+ #'

0 # &'#3 

#.+2'(#8$ 0##+2', (#0- #

() *) +, - *) .

 /0 *12* 2-342( *) +, - * "###5$' 5-.-3'$$6'+'&'#+#&(# 3 & +0'.003'#<  #'(  +# ###+##.+2'#(8' '  ((&&  '      #<   #  #+#     ;  # ((0 #+##3''3(##0

0



4'# #''#+#(# 3 &

+ .#+2' %&'# #+(& ( '$ 0##

() *) +, - *) .

 /5),7+2' -+ -*8 2*/

+)0 +),)9),+- *) +, - *)5' /:%%$5$'

 5-.-3':&6 ; 4'$ 0#& (+2'&# & #' ((&&#

'+&82 2*282+ * -82;-;-

/ +),) *-<+ )= +):%%>5"%?'@>6  ( # 3''#'3#

''.+( #' 

4' ##+##3(( #' 3'

.#03#3''3 +< &2'&& 4'3#

'#+## 3    '#  3   #'((0   #+##4' #'$ ( &&2##+2'- #3 +'&

'

''(# ' &0' 0(

3# 4' 3 &+((&+& ''#3( ##+2'- #' (# +2' #'#+##3

 8 0 +),)

+3-


*/,) +- )5
*/-2' /"##65"'  5-.-3'

&@&'< + #'?7+&, (#0- #3# # ((0 #+##(#' 3''#' &+((&+&4'?7+&, (#0- #3'&

'< # # ((0 #+##&#&2'&' '#+#&(# '(#00 #'

'0+ '(#. '33 &((&2A. '  $ 0  ##   ,*A2< 

   7 +2 -.

 ,773(  2*/ 2+1

-*8

/ +2 - * /0 +),)9)

-. - 2*/ * +23-33)

;

:%%%5$'  5-.-3':6%'- #'&'' & # 2 0#&'##'3'#< '+0 #((0 #+##+ # ;

3 &+((&+&4' &3.' '((&&

4'

''#6 # '&20'& ' ' &+((&+&'## '3# ( #, 

 +'' &'. #0'0#+5'*#(&-.&- #'. '$ # #'+$ 4'*#(&-.&- #    #, 3''3 &0.& #'.

$ #'<  #0  +$0# # # 0'+ +$0# ' 3'#'  7- #7

#'3

0*#(&-.&- # # & $ ##4'#6  &+0+ 7- #7 #'(#.  '# #'- #' ''& '#6  #('$ # =
#  '  #   #B  '  ((&    &&3  ' 0(

## &. '(#.& '##0#3'&3 ,8,) ":%"#  5
 

'

(#0   C''#(5 !# D C''##(#+&