High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10661/2021dismissed

Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. And ORS v. Shyam Lal And ANR

2022-11-02Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj41 pages

" #$ %

)**#$%

# $%

! &

# $'( +,-

! ) !

* .

! !

# +,

! &

# + /+

) !

# + 0/

! !

! ) !

+ -

! !

# ++ +

! !!

# +- ,

! ! !

# +. .

+ - 0-,

# 12 " 3/

12#3 41 6"

177"

)61812#3 41 "

&9%,..%,:

&9%%,2 #

06&616172#3 41 "

&9%,..%,2 &9%-$.+%,1 #&9%,...%, ;1<

062#3 415

1 ;1<812#3 41 6 "

&9%,.*%,1 # &9%-%,

5 "

&9%,..%,2&9%,.-%, &9%+%,2&9%$%,:&9%*+$%, ==== 4

6>?

@6 461

6" A146 5"

1 @66681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 ( 3 #@ 6 6"

@ 01

8 #

1 1""7 41

?A8 #?

%& 560173 4 ?6

42*$'6

155# 1 C64 5*$D( 1 #4 ?

71""1

A6175 56"1 1 611 14

571@1 5 #8

1 A146

26 42177641 41 A#4 ##A<14

- 6514 < 55 426514 613A F14#5 &9

,.. 5, 7#1 C

57< ?881 G#26514 56

1 41 1616 1 1<1 1

;7 1

018 #'6

15 A5#1 C

D(61 5 7#6

1 @ "

0146177 0 6 # #1# ,, '

F? %+( "1 # A< 6 81 B #171 '?A7 4 <3 4 (2 18?

1 1012@6A<681 B#171 '?A7 4 <3 4 (61 # 4#1 ?

#/%

! "#$%##&'

) "641 ?"

2 "

%1""7 6<1817 1770#

"1<

0674 <A 77 1 #17

177 @

56 ?""7< 574 <1 #

1#61 A

A ?4

0 1 # 61

0 6 17 5 6 "

% # A?

4 @ 6667" 5688A 56)

674 < 861#A #471##1#@5?

,$1 #8

8?84610 @ A

01 41

#1 #613 6 1 #8

8?84610 @

"1 # 144 ?

566?011 144?8?71# @1# 64

?8"

. 4610 1 #144?8?71#4610 6?"

21A 775 1 ?8 5 2,.2.$*H% @1 ?# 6 8

6 54 A2,,5 618 ?

776 6 18@1

## "

< 5671 #1" 4 A#6

44 #

07<2 1 #81 #

4 #1# ,,, '

F? %H ( @1 3#?"

6 85 1 18 ?

5 2,*2$-H%64

@1 # %

$,, 5 51 7? 5 "

? 1 #

011 61

1# 5471

0611 5A 772 "

% 1""7 8 3#1 1""7 41

F?%(A5 681 #171'?A7 4 <3 4 (2 18?

1 10125 78 @ 66 "

1 #17 ?A8 #1 1""7 41

5 01 5

1770

06168@1 #54 31 #61661#81#1 1""7 41

78 ?

# 878 4681 "@6 466@1 >?

# #"

1 18 ?

5 $2H%1 #61##"

#1 ?8 5 +2-,,H%

,,*6A171 418 ?

4 ?7#

A#"

144 ?

?A1B 5& #I*"1 #8 426 @326@1 77 3#@ 66 0<4

?8"

A 77

6 54 A,,1 #6 >? 5

56 18@1

144"#

4@1 ?#A<681 B#171'?A7 4 < 3 4 (2 18?

1 1012 6 "

# A?

7 4

-,,>?

068 1""1

,,6 1 # ?88

@1 #7 3#

,, 6 41

61# A 1#;

,, 6 "

# A?

7 4 1""1# A5 6 81 B #171 '?A7 4 < 3 4 (2 18?

1 1012

,,1 # ?06 8 5 7"7<6 @32@6 71#;

0641 2 6"

# A?

7 4 @1 # 4# ?""7< 574 <

?8 ?A;4 6 #"

0-J 56A 77#18 ?

1770#61615 1 #

8 #61#A "1 #A<681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (2 18?

1 1012@ 6 ?5 @

01 # 8"7<

0@ 66"

4#?" 4 A#?

&'(1 #'+(

'( 560173 4 ?6

42*$ "

%1""7 #"

# -J 5 6 A 77# 18 ?

2+.*H%

,,, @6?"

674 <4

@1 #

$,, 6 1 # # 01

8 # 4

6 "

# A?

7 4 674 <4

101

"1<8 -J 56A 77#18 ?

8"?0 #

6" "

A6175 5 "

%1""7 @1 7# @6

@1 1# 61 6 "

%1""7 @1 0?717<"1<

0674 <A 77 26 @32#? 5

174

264 ?7#

"1<6" #

0A 77 1 #>? #6"

# A?

7 4 616 1#< "1<60 ?

18 ?

1778 @1 3 468 @1 71?

46# 6 ?06 17 & 4?71

%-H,$ #1# ,,*,$ '

F? %(1 # "

%1""7 A

07 A7?

#6 1 # 468 1""

146# 6 4

4 # A< 8

0 1 1""7 41

4174?71

06#51?7#18 ?

64174?71

@1 41 # ?1 # @1 5 ?

# 61 "

%1""7 @1 "1<

7< 1 ?8 $2H%1 #6 418 ?

5 +2-,,H%@1 #"

,,* "6"

4<264174?71#18 ?

@1 A"1 #

67<H.A %

67<

1778 616152 "

%1""7 61#1""

146#6

4 56"

%# A?

7 4 5 #"

5681

5674 <A 7726 @326<5? # 144"6 181 #

$ 8#61

@6<@ ?7#A4 3

06 18 ?

@ 6 ?1 < @1 3 @1 6? 4 8"77# 1""

146 6 81 B#171 '?A7 4 <3 4 (2 18?

1 1012@6

8# 4

@ 47< ?#

# 61 6 771#<1 #@

0 "1<6 4174?71#18 ?

1 #61661 171#<#"

#618 ?

1 # 4# A<681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (2 18?

1 101 1 #4 ?

71""1

A6175 56"

61 10?# 66181 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (2 18?

1 1012 ?7#

613F4 #1 <"

@ 501

1 6 18 >?

# A3 #

1 "1?1 #

61A 4 51 < "4 4"

2 ?461;?

# 4

AF4 # 7 4 "714#

6;?#08 5

#$$%&%'%(%2@6

@1 67#616

17&

5 46#?7#&1 1 #46#?7# A 2 1& & ? 5 7 # "?"

1 # 61

A 4

5# "

@ 01

6731 F14 56 1 #;?#08 7 #?"

A<6 71 #4 ?

71""1

A6175 56"

F14#1 ?

#/% *

- .

-.-

-. -

, . / ,

0 12 3

0 12 $,

-.-

. 3

4 -. -

++*

- 4 - . 5

&&+4

4 7 -

. 4 ! )

61 17 "714#7 4

6;?#08 56 & ?

)* #+,-,.,(#% /0

1 )

"3 ($ ## ,(#% 6 731 F14 5 6 1 # ;?#08 1# 6? /%

98 .

9 5

4 .

9 5 9 5 9 5 . . ;

- < 0

9 5

8 0

8 012

4 9 5 . 8 0

. :

. 8 0-

8 0-12 .

9 5

9 5 /

8 0-1+2

9 5

9 5 5

9 5

8 0-1>2

9 5

5 .

. 5

9 5 5

8 -1+2 -1>27

9 5 .

4 ?

9 5

8 7

@4 -

) 6 15 1 # ;?#08 @1 5 @#

&9%-*$%,,2 7#1 K!'& 5*$16 &$"

'6 6

&$&1*$1 * )'# 7 48 &$" #'6 2L#4 ##

,, 7 "714

0 7 4

6 15 1 # ;?#08 2

##6161#;?# 41

4 41 A

1#A<681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (

7<154

55 613 7# < 7#1 < ?71 #61"1

0 51

8 #@ ?7#18 ?

01 1#;?# 41 <"

@ 4

# 61

61A 4

01B 4 ? 6"

4 54

26 8"?0 # # ?7#

613A "1 #681 B#171 '?A7 4 < 3 4 (0 "

@ 51#;?# 41

7<15655 5 78

0 6"1 61351 7#1 #

11 <"

6 5?6

"7161 A 1 #61471 8 56 "

%1""7 @1

A1 #?"

1 <4 0 M?

# "?#1 # 1#8

A73 # 41 #6 @1

<5 1 < 78 18

0 6"1 5?6 ?A8 #616 1<1 1 0?71 <&

'!74 <?""7<& #( 0?71

2,+ 8"

14 8"7A1

574 <4

41#

61 A 41 # ? #?

%"1<8 5A 77156#?#11 #1 ?46281 #171'?A7 4 <3 4 (2 18?

1 1012 ?06 6131B

6 1? <"

1 # ?06

613"1 #1 < # 61@1

# 01

56 1? <>?

8 4

12 71 # 4 ?

7 1""1

A6175 5 6 "

%1""7 61 10?#611 "6;?#08 56

DA7 ?"8& ?

681 5

4 "56 7 860868 9

#$$%&##',-2 61 A 67#61@66 ?A 1 3 "

@ 61 A 4

5# ?"

1 & ? A?

172177

# 17 1 # 771<"

@ 4 1<5 @61 1 554 3F4 56 ?A 1 3 "

@613 A

5# 615 1 #3 @61 A 1#A<6

DA7?"8 & ?

681 57 2 !

,((:&:'-##6731 F14 56 1 # ;?#08 1# 6? /% ,$,@

5 A 3 .

8 +1#2

. 5 . 8 >

B ? . 4 4 . .

. .

C0 @ 0 12 8 +

. 0 1#2

8 +

B ? . 8 >

. 5 0 1#2 8 +

;

1 2 8 >

B ? . 4 + 4

4 /

. ;

# .

3 >$(

1 2 8 >

8 .

+ $

. .

)

#7 8

2615 1 #41 #17@ 66317 # <

? "

5 6 4?

1 # 4

5 E

1 # !

48 5 4?

< 42 ,, '5 6 C6 E!4D(1 #681

46177

06"

56 4@1 61

41 E

17 ?

61#A 3 #@ 661A 1< "

@ @ 6 ?1 <0?

5 F4 1 #17 @ 6 ?"

<1""

11 #1#>?18461

8 #4 #6# "? 01#

06 31 4 561""771 2 317 # <1 #614?1718 ?

?06 A 4 3#5 86A

@ 7F18

031

? 1 "4 56 E!41 #6 "

*'( 56 E!426

DA7 ?"8& ?67#616 A?

17 61776131771 771<"

@ "1 < ?46

8 # ?A;4 4

1 81<#85 5?6 5 4 17 81# 6;?#08 56

DA7?"8& ?

6 81 571 7 )

",((:&,'::+6 731 F14 56 181# 6? /% D.

5 3

E D.

. . 4 ;-

. 3

/ / .

4 . / /

188 -

6 .@ ?&A8-**2

. . 4

/) E?68 2

681 5

4 "

56 7 860868 9

#$$%&##',-26

DA7?"8& ? A 3# 1 ?

#/% K4

8 12 12

0 1#2 1$2 1A2 8 +

! -

. .

8G 4- 9 H

I ?1&A#28-&$ &+$J4 3 - ,

. , 61361#671 #4 ?

71""1

A6175 56 "4 3"1 1 #6130

6 ?066"71#

64 #1 @77 1 6;?#08 7 #?"

A<671 #4 ?

71""1

A6175 6 "4 3"1

5 "

0 5?62 @ ?7# A 731 81B 1 5 4 41

560173 4 ?6

42*$ 6 181F14#6

15A7 @/% ,, )9

2 )

2K 124 9 5 9 5

. -.-

-. &*1$ &*2

L 12

. L 1 2

. L 12

L 12

12F

0 12 . 9 5 9 5 .

1+2

9 5 9 5

&+ &*

- 1#$ *A2. 9 5 9 5 -.-

8 &$- ''<

- - &>+ 1 &>#2 ,, 0

3 K /// /// /// 12 . )K 12

. 12 12

L 1.2 . L

1.2 . L

1.2 .

$ .

% .

- ,, 1;

)

2 K 12

9 5

C .

9 5 .

C .

9 5

/ 5 C .

% .

0 12

9 5

. 5

1+2F 9 5 0 12 K 12

L 12 3

L 1 2 .

1#2F

. 0 1+2

9 5

5 5

1$2 4 9 5

0 1#2

1A2

9 5

, 1>2F 9 5

9 5

1*2F

0 1>2

9 5

,,0 )

)

2 K4 9 5

6 "6 " " <

-. &*1$ &*2

*>1 *>2 ,, 9 )

2 K 12D.

9 5

12D.

9 5

1+24

9 5

1#2 D.

9 5

/ 1$24 9 5

) 670173 4 ?6

42*$23 6 18"

@ 1 13 #

6& 7& ??

#6& # 5& 7 4#?2*,$ @6 71#;?# 41

01 1""7 41

1 #177"

0 A5 681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (1#8# A;?# 17"

@ 6

681

0 5 # 17& #1 #681 B#171

#8# A1& 7& ?5 6"?"

*-1 #&61"NN

56& # 5& 7 4#?2*,$4

'(17 8"

@ 6 81 B#171 "4 5< @ "

4#?5 #8

51 < # "?4

0A5 4

564 5*$2? 41

"61 @6 461 4?77# ?1 #F14#1 ?

#/% (i)

1 1

( 1

6 " '

( 6 " '

" '3(

< (vi)

6? 5615 1 #71 0?101 #F"

6? #

F 571@

60 71?61

615 1 # 1? <"

71 # # @ 60?

"7 A5 @#A<681 B#171 '?A7 4 <3 4 ( @6 74

#?4

064

#4 #

01# "?1 #

16 8 54

0 16 8 5#4 #

01# "? @ ?7#17 A 17 4

#216 ;?

4?2 1

0 60?

"7 61613A " 4 A#A<61? 615 1 #F"

613

A #5

641 #1 ?462 5 4 81# 6 #

1<81

0 85 8 5 6 9&):; 8&< *)'*#$& 32,6 !#

2#5

6@ # C

"7 5 1?17? 4D1 ?

#/% K6"

"7 5 1?17;? 4

1 8"78 16

8?8 1 #1# 0?

@6 4661?6

6 ?7# @

#4 #

0681 L "681

0 6 @

66& '#$; 8&< 8 =*)#$7 +'6 "*'*#$26@ #C 6 D61 A F"71

#6? /% K 1?17;? 4%61 8 56?7 5 1?17;? 4

4?;? 4 "? 01 37< "3 8 10 ;? 46 ?7 41 "1

4 3#A<1 < 71@317 #7<81# 6@ # 6< ?""71 6?7

1?17;? 4@6 461

8A # #?7 961"1 4?71 ?7 5 1?17;? 4 6 ?7#1""7< 141

0 3 41 8? #" # 101F

6514 1 #4 4?8 1 4 561 41 26518@ B 5671@?

#@6 466 >?

< 67#

#64

56 A?

17"

#5 6"?"

2 > > &*?&: 4 $*#$ #( $"*&7 0/ 5 +L @ ?7#17 A 17 4

#216 ;?

4?2 1

0 60?

"7 61613A " 4 A#A<61? 615 1 #F"

613

A #5

641 #1 ?462 5 4 81# 6 #

1<81

0 615 1 #"

"7 4

?65 @

01 "4 /% '

(

"1< 6 ?7#A4

8 #?

61#'

(1 # '

(

6 ?7#A1;?#0 56 6 @ 41? '! / ( 615 1 #"

"7 8"7<51

2>?

<1 #>?17 <

6 7<" 4 A ?7101

1 B ?1776 14 61 81< 8"

"7<

57? 41;?#0

011#4

1"1 4?71 41 42 51"

25 @6131

241

1B1 A;4 3 #4

1 8

317?1

564 #2 ?461#4

81<A 8#1 ?55

05 8A 1 6 1 #"

"761 A

?8 17

0611"

?06

A1;?#0 56 @ 41?

4;? 4 ?7#

7<A#

A? 6 ?7#81

5 7<1 #?

# ?A#7<A17 8 A#

26 @32

4 1<216 ;?

4?21 #5 1#;?# 41

56" F18

1 @61 4 1 7<81<4

?1A 1 511 6"

"7 5

4 #2 14

771<##?4#5 86 ?7 <<

" < =

" <

6@6 6177 #4 #1 <6

0@ 6 ?6 6 #A

061#2176 ?06681<613 #4 ## 06261

;? 4 6? 6 4 < 5;? 4

7<A

17 >?177< 8"61 G#A<6 18A

081

5 7<1 #?

# ?A#7<A A #

E?68 26

DA7?"8& ?61

681 0 > ? @ 7

2 "&#$$-'-,A$267#616 "

"7 5 1?17;? 411

017"1 560?11 1 #>?17 < 1 ?#A< 47+ @ ?7#17 A 17 5 6F14 56;?#08

5 6

DA7 ?"8 & ?

6 81 5

&,(##',,AB6731 F14 "

#?4#6

A7 @/% >>

, ,

, , 4

. .

8 4

G 51 2 .

. .

>* 7

1 5" &#$+B' # :(A . G

M .

- ,#*=

00 00

. 0 / .

. / N /

. C

4 O/ E

4/ 0 5/

5 0

, >& 9

7 ! "&#$B#'# %%:

?88 5 M 5

, ,?

. 79 .

C ,?

. 5/ .

/ .:12

12 /

L12

. . 4 00

0 - .

. 0

. 5

. . . 3 . .

0 .

. . /

/ /

/ , 1D 2 *

3 .

. . 3

. .

0 5

. * @

) 7

6 81 5 &C '" 29

=" D

&,((B'

#A#26

DA7?"8& ?#17@ 66

? 5"

"7 5 1?17;? 41 # A 3#1 ?

#/% #

8 #12

, ,

$ $ ? , , 4

, , 4 . .

8 4

> > 4

! "&#$%$', ,%,

. .

. . 4

/// /// /// >

. 7 .

0 E#$%+#,%$

. . . 3

. . . . 3

/ / * ? > 9 "&,((A'% -,#

. . /

C0 #- ? /

/ .

. . . 3

4 / E . 3 E

. E

. 0 .

: . , &4

. . 3

. 30 F

. @

. / .

4 3

) 6? 3 # 616"

"7 5 1?17;? 441

A 8A # #

4 5 1 06;14B#5

"761 A

3 73#?

#64

71@ 464B1A 1<F4 5"

@A<6 1 5?

1 #8? 4 1 7<57451

6 141

F4"

6 1 ## 4

26 @326 1 #F4"

AF"7 #5 1#;?# 41

564

3 <

61 #

4 6@ # A;4 <61

A #5

#6017 3 4 ?6

42*$ 6?7 518#6?

# 6 9&):; 8&< *)'*#$& 37,6!#

2#5

C A;4 <D 1 ?

#/% KA;4 3% 5271

0 2 A1 #

F 177<3 1A7 "6

8 121 ""

# 1

# #?17O "4"

257

0 2

*'6#2' @*& # ?

A2"*) B "**$'

" 681

0 6 @

6 6&C@ ' $'2 3

*)'*#$& 326@ #C A;4 <D61 A F"71

#6? /%

3 .

) A;4 <26? 2 177<81 6161?6

< 6 ?7#A

8"1 171 # 6 ?7#

177 @";?# 42A 1 24

4 5

57? 4 51 <F 171 # 3 # ;?#08 1 #616 18 ?7#A"1 #

1 #317?1

563 # 45 < ?46A 1 ";?# 46? 4 1 0

0 # 5A 1 1 #>?

# "1

1 1 8 A1 # ?"

7 417 1

0 1 # 1

5 81 17 8 "681

0 6 @

6 =(# " "!&$) " 8 & $ ;

*)'*#$& 32 @6!#

26@ #C51 "71<D61 A F"71

#6? /% /N 0

F / .

)

P Q /

C0 K

) E1 "71<6? >?

1 1 #1# 551

@6 461& ?8? 8

5;?

# 4

31#5 #1 06@ 6#? "

65 @

"7 41 A 1#7<A 1 # AA1 4

551 "71</% '1( "45 6 ?7 'A( "4 56 ""

'4( 77 @"1 "1

A<1774

4 # '#( A 3 75%4

7M1 # '( ? "4 63 @ 56 "4 3"1 5 5 <";?# 4 A 1 6 81 5

> &"&!

2? &(2 6

DA7 ?"8 & ?17 4

##61 "4 551 "71<

6731 F14 6 51# 6? /% 4

/ F

. .

# .. . 3 3

)

81"? 17 561A 325 1 14 351 "71<2

7< ?7# 8A #<

61 8 1 #

6317?1

1 @771 01 ""

< 6"1 A?17

01737"71<

02;? 1 # 1

1A7 ""

< 177"

D !>?

<101

1"61 61

70177<#5

# "6 81

0 6 @

6 9&):; 8&< *)'*#$& 32 ,6 !#

26@ # C>?

<D61 A F"71

#6? /% D3 0C

F F

) "681

0 6 @

6 =(# " "!&$) " 8 & $ ;

*)'*#$& 32 @6!#

26@ #C>?

<D61 A F"71

#6? /% D3 0

6 91

61 9

= 1 9 ) " 681

0 6 @

6 6&C@ ' $'2 3

*)'*#$& 326@ #C>?

<D61 A F"71

#6? /% D3 0 / 6

, 9

6 "

9 1" 9 71#3

0 6# 4

5>?

<2 81<

146

A#5

#1 1"

5 1?17;? 426 @32@6 7F4

<26& ? 613F4 #171 ?#

0 4 341

F" 7<#17@ 6A<71@C!>?

<D 7

7<? # #

1 < 8

+ ;? 4@6 46 1#8

#A<1"1 4?71& ?

1"1 4?7141 !>?

< 6? 8"

@ 1& ? F4 ;?# 17# 4

5?61 4

5;? 41 # # ?A 1 17;? 418

0 64

0"1 A<1B

0 4B 56 17 < 54 4?8 1 4 !>?

?551 @

087<5 @1 518#<A? AF4 #@61"

8 6& ?H?6

<@ 6471 61 # 1 8 # @61 ?06

@ 61 A;4 5?75

0 A7 01

6? 2615 1 #"

A ?881 G#1 #61 AF4 #2

7<1 41

# 6 44

5 1? < "

8#7 1

6 "

"71 @ 1144 ?

1A7 ?

#;?# 17 4

4 1 #5

;?# 17# 4

85 5 6 "61 C;? 4D 61 A #5

9&):; 8&<

*)'*#$& 32,6!#

21 ?

#/% M 0 4

4 3 + 4

) ? 4@ ?7#>?

616 @6 61341? #618 6 ?7# 8#<64

>? 4 56 51?7641 A ?8 ? # 8

5;? 46"61 ? #A

0C 6"

"7 5;? 4 2D @ ?7#

7<17

47?#"3 3;? 4

- 6 9&):; 8&< *)'*#$& 32,6!#

2#5

K"3 3 ;? 4L1 6? /% . . M

. 8 . . .

. 5

) 17 1 7 K ?A 1 17;? 4L@6 46 #5

#1 8 M

E .

) "681

0 6 @

6 =(# " "!&$) " 8 & $ ;

*)'*#$& 32 @6!#

26@ #CA2'*) D61 A F"71

#6? /% /

F < 1

3 # 610 71?61 4

? 7<? #615 1 # 0?

"7 5 681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (2 @6 74

#?4

0 #4 #

01# "?

8 6? A 1 @61@ ?7#18 ?

6 10@6

?46"

"7 613 AB"

#1 #1 @66 AF4 # 11 < "4 4 10

0 @ ?7#17 1""7<"1 #"

6 10 4

1 #H 1#;?# 41

6 ? 5 6 @ # K@6 7

#?4

06"

0 L K#4 #

01# "?L 61 A 1 1

? "

4 6 1 78 54

01881 4175 8

? #

671 0?10 561?&

#?4

0 54

101

AF18

#5 8

" "4 3C 4 88 4D156A 1#

8 613A "? 6 "4 3"1 1 #17 1 37<

. 81<17 5 1 103 "

#?4

068 54

1 #

0 ?468 6 "4 3"1 1 3 "%4

1"1 54

#?4

0 54

K 4#

0L 61 A #

6# 5 8 "

4#? 1 # #5

9&):; 8&< *)'*#$& 32,6!#

21 ?

#/% 0 4

) #

?46"

10?711 # #7< "

6A?

6& ? 8 4 8"6

361

6@ #K14

L1 #

47?#

0 17 1776 " 1B

81 ? 1# "#

#5 4 51 14

47?#

06 "71#

0 1 #6;?#08 1""7 # 14

268"

081<

47?#65 @

01 "!#3

! <1 2671@ 571#

0 ?

#6 & # 5& 7 4#?2 #!#

% , E

E E

L 12

L 1+2 .

/ L 1#2

L 1$2

L 1A2

L 1>2

L 1*2

L 1&2

/ L 12 / L 12

L 12

L 1+2

, "681

0 6 @

6 =(# " "!&$) " 8 & $ ;

*)'*#$& 32 @6!#

26@ #C"

0D61 A F"71

#6? /% K

) " 681

0 6 @

6 6&C@ ' $'2 3

*)'*#$& 326@ #C"

0D61 A F"71

#6? /% 0 ) 6? 3 # 61 "

0 81<

47?# 177 "

05 8

51 14

1 # 77 4?78

0 F18

# 6 15 1 # F"

? # A< 6 0 71?

564 5*$26>?

@6 464 8 ?"

1 @66681 B#171'?A7 4 <

$ 3 4 (@ ?7#6131 <"

@ "1 1 #@6 46 "4 3#A<6 ?46 B#171 A

5?61 4 5 1?17;? 42 A;4 <2>?

<251

"71<1 #H 6"

"7 5;? 441 A18"# A1 @# 4 6 0 71? 61 46 ? 6 F"

0 L

1# 5#5

06 10@6 ?46"

"7 1 A6 0?

0514 5 681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (26 70 71 3

61 A?

#1 #0 3 554 @ 661A 3 1# A;4 63 670 71 3

@ ?7#613A 4 32 6@1

@6<60 71?@ ?7#

613? #1 1""

1 "61 #5

06"1 4?71 10 K16 10 54

L K1 6 10 51#;?# 41

L61 16246 3 ?46@ #"

A F4 # ;?# 177< 1 #

1 514

5 ;?# 17 # 4

A< 6 81 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (6 1A7

@2@6

# AF4 11 102@ ?7#A ##

41 6

1 ?00 #A<6"

144"#6 18 @ ?7#17 # #516 A;4A6

#6 ?

56017 3 4 ?6

42*$@6 46 1 8# "

#51 #4 8" 7017 3 4 6@1B 4

56 <1 # ? 61

5 4?

0;? 41

# 1 <4 G 5 1

4 6# 1A 6 A;4 564A

0 "

;? 4

6A1 5>?17 ""

<2 ?46>?17 < 5 ""

<41

A 81#?

71A7A<4

& 564 5*$

1 @ ?7#

6 A;4 3 54

64 5*$ 6;?#08 56&

1 46 56 & ?

6 81 5 0

1 )

" )

* * #+,-, ,(#%" ($ ## ,(#% 1

7110

"!8*2

" )* #A$,B ,(,("

,, #, ,(,(2613

564 5*$

6 81

01 # 8"

564 5*$26

%&2

8<3 @2@ ?7#A 6 1 #"4# @ ?7# 6?

0 E?68 26

07 46 56

DA7 1;1 61

& ?

).+%:: ,(($" @ *12

6 >

" #$ (B ,(($261# ?"67#6

8 #"1 #A<681 B#1716731 "1 56 1 #;?#08 1# 6? /% 4

9 5

. 8 0-0B

8 0 B

9 5

. 3

. 8 0-

9 5

) &

0 6 15 1 # 4 4?8 1 4 2 6 "4# ;?#08 531

? & ? 1 17 6514616

DA7?"8& ?

+, 61 "1#7<67#616& ? H A?

17 @ ?7#61361 771<"

@ 01

87 5

47?#

067 5@6 46

6 1? 5"3 3 ;? 41 @771 ?A 1 3;? 4218 563 @611

1 @ ?7## <1 ##"

36"

@ 681 B#171'?A7 <3 4 ( 01 1

87 5@ ?7#AA1 #

4 1#

01 #

%& 564 5*$@6 1#

618

<@ 64

% 5670173 4 ?6

42*$ 6 18

@71# 6>?

1 @666

#"1 #A<681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (

6 " 41 @1 1""

11 # ?06 613A 01 #?

#60 3

4?8 1 4 ""1 7<2641 "71##A<6 "

# H1""7

A5 6 81 B #171 '?A7 4 < 3 4 ( @1

6 06 517 4 4?71

%-H,$"

05 @1 3 4685 6 878 6471 81 #A<6 "

# H1""7

616@1 3 468 7#6A 771 $2H%'

F? %(1 #61 18 ?

5 +2-,,H% @1# 6144"1 4 56 1 #471 861#A

#A<6 "

# H1""7

88# 17<615 17

?A8 # 61 1 ?8 5 2+.*H% 61 17 A #"

# A< 6 "

# H1""7

"? ?1 6

8 # "1 # A< 6 81 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (2 18?

1 1011 #1 ?462 6 1718 ?

#F4# 618 ?

"1<1A7?

#6 878 '(468 6F4 5# 4

A<681 B#171'?A7 <3 4 (6? 8

07<A1 #?"

"7 5 1?17 ;? 42 A;4 <251 "71<2>?

<1 # 6"

"7 5;? 441

+ A 1 # A8

4 3#2

6514 1 #4 4?8 1 4 56" 41 @ ?7#17

A1""

15 6 & ? ?A ? ;?# # 4

5 6;?# 17# 4

F4 #A<681 B#171 '?A7 4 <3 4 (6" "

1144 #

07<# #21 6 10

@321B

6514616 #

@1 "1 #

6<1,,1 #68161 81

#" #

@ 6681 B#171'?A7 4 <3 4 (5 17<@ <1 2

@ ?7# A 1""

1 # 4 81 B #171 '?A7 4 < 3 4 (2 18?

1 1012 #4 #6" #

01""7 41

@ 6

5 F8

6 564 " 564 #4 "< 56 # #!

C@ 7 (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ)

6 966 "1B

0H1

# / H

966"

1A7 / H