← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10990/2007disposed of

Delhi Public School Society And ANR. v. H.U.D.A. And ORS.

2024-04-29Mr Justice Jora Singh,Mr. Justice M.M. Kumar16 pages

2024:PHHC:058188-DB 213-a



                          

  !"!

#$%&!'()   *  '*! +,'! - *

'- !

.#/#&  

!

!

# &"    0"  &.# &,# '

%2 # + &!

.#/ &" 

"% #/ # "         )    / &#- *

'#/#&     

!

!

# &"    0" &.# &,# '

%2 # + &!

.#/ &" 

"% #/ # "  4       )45  0 +,'! - *

'#/#&     

!

!

# &"    0"  &.# &,# '

%2 # + &!

.#/ &" 

"% #/ # "  )       67      -**/&#8 '"/+  !

#'- !

.9

8/:#/#&          

!

!

# &"    0" &.# &,# '

%2 # + &!

.#/ &" 

"% #/ # "  6       64     ;'3/*  2*8<#""*&!

,'

- !

.9

8/:#/#&          

!

!

# &"    0"  &.# &,# '

%2 # + &!

.#/ &" 

"% #/ # "  3$ =;3 - -;-;;    =;3- -3    

    

!"

 $

 "

&''

!"  ( ) * !"

 

 !  , !"

 $

 ,   ( ) !"

 ( . /0

/1  

 2 $

#  ) & !"

.13 

 !)  

!"

  , 4 !" ,

55555

;-;;( 

6 

,  (  . .13 /0

/1  



!

7"  " %  )



 #  8  

  

,

,

 

 " 

 /  , 9

++  :2 ;7 <" ,* !

 2

:;<! "

*, #  

1



 %  , " *# 9  

> ?  

*,



  

++  7   ( 

%

@,

:2 # " A +

-#

 !  7 %  

   , "

*#

 :2   7

 %

:;<!

+* 2 0 3

,

     7

 

.

%   

   1 :2 ;7

<" ,* !

 2 ! 

 C:;<!

!A %?%

9

++  :;<!

#  %

C( A

#



 

2

2  >

 %   

 %

 



# %2 ..1.

*, " 

<" ,*  +  2  " 6 !* 

:;<!

 -,   ) @*  

 "

 , ,)   ) 

..1.   *, 

   1 :;<!

!

 2

 %  %

/  

/

9

++  :;<!

"



*, # 

/  ,

 

 

 ,

#   (

,*  +

/ 2 +*  +

  %

 * 

,

, ,"

:2

9 

1

 C1

A   

  2 2    

*,  % , # %

 

*,  +*   /  

 0 

, " 2 2

*,  +*

   3 0  2 "



   , 

 

 %

:;<!

 

2 (  2 9

++  :;<!





( ( 



#? 2 * 

,*  * ## " +* #% :2

# " A +

 ( 

+ % 

..1. *  % /  7



, 

78  , %

%

*7  %



3

 %







 

  %



,

*, # 2   9

++  :;<!

     

, 

( "

7

2   )

*

( 

  2

++ "

, +2 % , *

+ :2

9 

1  % ++  ,"

  



 ,

 % ##

0 %  % " 

   %

  .3  ,

 



, 

  ,

?  2 

0

< "

&     7  "

 ,

 " 

 . .3 #% 

, 

 % ,

.

  "

*2?:

   " @



(

(  > 



D.

6



 ,



  * *



,  7"

  7 

9"  0 

   ) E

2F

! 0

*

*

" G    #

* 

%)   2 +

# H"* %

# +*  

* 

 G #2 I )%  @

, ,



   ? 

 

*  , 2 7

, *

*    2 * &  !" #

*!#8 !#  ''

#  '

&" <*! * 2. /!"

!#8+!"* 

>%& ""!

# &!2&. #/ !8* - *

' & 2 *   & #+&"

&.?+&"

&.- *

' *, 

/ >   *  "  

7+ ,   ,



  , , ,, 

* %

* % * * ,,

  

#

, , *2 62   



&

9  >   

9    ,, , +*

 

"

2

6 " ,, ,#**

)  

,  > ,)

/  , 

   ,

,, ,  2  2

 6 +   % +*

 " ,  2 @

,

7" >

  %

  7

7 %    ,





*,

+*

2 1 6

#*  %  + #*

" 6+

%

%

7 2 ,,

1

* * 7%   3 >  





2 "

  * 

,

 ,"

! "

 2 ,  

2 " @

 

,     7'  2 #  "

  *  * *

1 6+ 2 %

,, +*



,



,

@, E, E

3 <   # *

 ,  

, " )  

 , #

 %2

>I

 ( ..1.

,  78 

% >

,  *  ,

   :;<!

%   ,

 *, 

,  , ,    ++  :;<!

"

@  ,% 7 

7

+

#

7 2   2 %  



 

  " 

 ,

2





,,  %

,*  6 , , 

 

1J



> 

   

, , 2? , 



 < "

&

 * 

D ! 8

7"  %   

"

%  "

, *2?

   " @



,  !

*, #



,  /  ,

9

++  :;<!

 72 

%

# 

2?, J



 .

.3

+*

   

2



 

, %  ,

2 2

 %" *  "



" 

 .

 , ,







 



# 2

2

 > 



!

, 

+ 7 % , ,

 ,





# 2

2



 

 

,

 

@  7% :2 ;7

<" ,* !

 2 6+

 





,* 



, , 2?     2

7

* 2 

, "

  1 2  

 2

 

#

2?, *2?

 ?2  2

"





:2 %

*

# 2   

* * :2

9 

1

7"

2 C

A % + 1.1



 

# 2

2



 *

#  , 2J



 .



#

 +

% , :A7

,*

 

 "

!,,

( /0 3 

 " 

  

, 

#

>   ,, , % 

,+

+ +* 7"

2 *  

,'

  ,2

(  ,   , 

 + ,,

 

2 %2 ++ 

+*

 (.3

%

. 6 * < "

& , ,

* * 2 %

  ,, "

" "



+ ) "# "

%

6+ %   +  #  

*, #

 7

  6 *

*   +   ,



%

*  ,



 ,   . 

 

6 ,,  ,

7" *J

1

>

+

* @ % " 

7+

'

 

.

I  

7*

 

 < "

&

.3 



 *2    7% @,

+* ( 2?(  (2  #2

,* 7



2

 %

"

#  ,* (  

,

# %

, ?  2

  *  

"

   7



, %



2 7

"  ,

% %

" * % ++  "  #

  * *

*2  "

7 ,,

 

  6  " ## 

( +* #  

@ ,"





"

 ? 2?  2

"  >

,2

 %

% *  #2  %

 .

.3 *

/

I  

,  * +7 *,

7*   7%

2

) ,, + % 

* 

," "   

* ( 2?(

* "

 

1

 >

,2  % * 

3

 " 

  

, " # 

7  

 

>  %   , %

9  

>   ,

*, # /  9

++  :;<!



*  >



,  ## %

%

  7" &   

, , .  %

 ( (  > , 

 

   

,  ( (  7

*# 7  

) *

( ( %

 2

,  %

* % *  # K 

+ 1

%

,,

7 2

* + , 



 

,  ( ( 

  ,  ( ( 

   1



0

>    , 

   

" 

, * %



 * +* *

  .

.3   

"

 %

%2 7) 7% 2 03



 @ 

 2 <

A  K

 ,



 





? "2 78  @  7% :;<!

" 



, %  ,   



(

 (

!

?<

?<

"2



K

 ,



* 

?<

I?<

"2





-!>3?.

13



0



1. / 8

2L0



10 

8 2

- 

2



.

-!>>> 3

0?11

030 <

I

.1/



01 

 ,

 



:%"

, 



C:

#

2

A

1

.13

-!>>> 1? /3 /

1.

< I

/

/1/ 

.

/0

-!>

/?>? 3

/

!

/ 

/

/1

-!1

0/?11?01

< 3 0/

< I

3

.

/ 

! ,



%

<

I

 7

C:

#

2



<

% 7' * .3

, 

. 

,

  



(



K

 ,



* 

?<

I?<

"2



./

-!>>>1?1

.01

< I



(

!

?<

?<

"2

/

/0300



13

8 2



./

-!>>> 1?/313.

..

< I

0/.

0

13



//3/

1

.3

* ( -!>>>

/?0

1/

 

.

.1

-!>>> 1?/ 

0.

< I

 0



/.0. 1



/

.1

-!>>> .?1

3.

< I

 



/  8

2

3

.1

-!>>> 1?//3

 .

< I

 



.1/ .



111 8

2



.1/

-!>>> .?//

 .

< I

./

3!

..



0

/

-!>>>1?1030

31

< I



.3.0/0



111 8

2



/ 0

-!>>>1?

11 <

I

.1

0

. 



/ 

-!>>>1? 3

01.

3!

 ...0



*2?



/

-!>>>.?//

3.

!

//3/



*2?



/

-!>3?..

/33

< I

3/

&

/ 

!

,



C:

%

<

I

 7

C,

#A

1

/

/0.

3  <

I

0

(

,



%

<

I

 7

C

.

/.

-!103?3.1

03

1



1

8

2



M



!

,



C

%

<

/

 

-!>>>1?./.

/1 <

"2

 0

!

/1 3



3333 8

2

"2

 7

C





 

,

7



7A

3

 

-!>>>.?/3/

..

<

I



! ,



C *2?

%

<

I

 7

C 

6*

7A

 

 1

  / /

 30

!@  

 -!1 0/? ?03

3 0/

 -!>>>1?/ 

..

" < I

1/

1/./



..33 8

2

 (

,



 30

 ! ,



3 0/

 

C+

,

A

 ! ,



..

C+

 2

H A

" <

I

 7

C 

3

?



.

8

2

! 

 

! 

.



2

0

1

-!>>?100

3  <

"2

 

<

.0.

8 2

! ,



C

%

<

"2

 7

C





,

7



7A



11.

-!130.?011

/0.

<

I

1

3!

30 



6

*

# *  

  

,



 ,* 7



2?  2

 @

 ,*  ( 2?(  6

+  , ++ > # "

+

* @

  

:;<!

7 2 "

%

"# +*  @,

.

.3

%

'





+

-  7  

,,

7

+ 

, +

* @ %





4,

"

% +  * 7"



 "

? 2

2

, *

 @  1

 @



( ( *2? 

 >*, #  /  , 9

++  :;<!

     %

 

( 2?( 



  ,  2

1

 ,,

 

2   , +

9;-;;:                       93  :          %&!'()         -

 ,) #?



N?(

 ,7



N?(