← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3190/2003dismissed

Municipal Council Bahadurgarh v. Pehlad Singh

2018-09-28Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma10 pages





          !"#$"%&# &'

'(&)%"%%(* +,- ,. /./$01.!2!0 '''

// 3!.

0/1 20+0!

'''

 1 "'

'(45("%%5* +,-

'

.6 '''

// 3!. ,. /./$01.!2!0 '''

 1 ('

  '&()7"%&(* +,-

'

.6 '''

// 3!. 01 '''

 1  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$ ++++

!

,!' .0/8' 0!$16! ,!','9'

0!$16$ !0

//

'(&)%"%%(+ !0! 1  '&()7"%&('

,!'.0! 0!$16$ !0! 1'

,!','

'

',$16$ !

/

'(45("%%5' ::::: )(*$,& 0  !1!      0//  1     ;  2./!  1

/ !2'(&)%"%%(1(45("%%51  '

&()7"%&(0<./;16/61'



  '(&)%    "%%(  /1    =,. /  ./$ 01.!2!03!. 0/1 20+0!>0!.01 !1!1    6/  .  '&"4    &))?  *0!!  //1  .  '&-$ ;0! 

  '(45(    "%%5  /1    = '  .  6  3!. ,. /./$01.!2!0>.1;6/ . !2 '&&&&))?* ' .63!.,. /./$01.!2!0- 1")&))?*,. /./$01.!2!03!. ' .6- ! !@.$;0!  '&()7"%&(* ' . 63!.01-

'(45("%%50 /1!

6/!1!11&#'&%'"%%5$61;001 ;A1 0 !00!0,. /./$01.!2!0 !1!2!B;//0/1;11 1! .2 ./12!/' 0.200!1!$ .0!6!A6/61 00 2./! 1

/$0.$ 0! 2111 20!'

0/1 2010! 20.16/ .'&"4 &))?* .'&-C2 !@.2011$''$ ,. /./0 !00A;! !!D ;1!

 2 #  ;   3//2 01.!2!0$ 0/  01.!2!0   ! /1.!2# 20( ;3//201.!2!0! !!20! $.0/! /1 '

;6!!100 ;/10!0! 00//110110/10; A/!0

/$  .  0  11  0!1    1   A  C2  ! /

'



//B11,. /./10. A 1A2  0  /      ;!        0  .  /1$  /A$/.1$.0/!6.1!  7"0!A,. /$&)5(' !$;100

/01!;00 !AA!0/1  !180;'#))D#&($80'&77)180! '""(5  *&B&4-$  80  '&74#$  80!  '"(%  *%B&#-  1  80; '&(7#D&&)#$  80  '""#7  $  80!  '""()  *"B%-$  / .!2  4  20  &"  ;  .1  ;0  0   1    3//2 01.!2!0;;11 1 A0 !! #; 01.!2!0 !@ 1!0A!&)#)B)%180!'""(# 2 $610,. /./'0!1/1; 210,. /./61211'&?&"11%5'%&'&)75 1 ;/0116!' ;.!0!6!!100 !!01.1 6/. !2'"##&)5&.1! !1!& ./#6/ !1.! 1  /1  = .! ' 3!. ,''01.!2!0 '>$;00 ;  !110211;11!./2;!0 1

011' !00211$,. / ./;!. !C0!&7%%<'A!110 !2/1; .1.B2!'!0 !$;00  ;!C /0E !10211$ .//1/12! !/101 !.!11B! @. !E!00!'0.0 / 2

!! #;;/11'

0 0 /120 !$0!/.!

-

!10//;2. .'&"4&))?

=    

             





     



 

     

    !"



  

 







  #$%





&' %    





   & ' ( 

    

    "

 

 &' )    

  

  * +

    &' ,     

 

 "

   -  ,%.



/



! 

 01(&'$ 2      



+   &' 1  

     

  -  (,* !$$!$&' 3 

$4 6/ . !2'&&&&))?/1 .63!. ,. /./$01.!2!0! !@.01 /1 0!.20!A0 !00;;!  / .!2  7?%  <'A!1  .    80!  '4(?%    !  0  .1! 1! 10 /$;00; .!01 A0!0! .C0 !61 !2!1/11'(?4711&('%"'&)#4101   0. !A'60 /. 10,. /./ ;  1$  .  0  ,. /  ./  11    C      1 0 /$0!!$0.!1;/1' 1B,. /  ./  1  0  !1 .1//1.!/C2  A200A 06 0;!/1.!24 20&" ; !2

.

11'&?&(11%5'&&'&)751/26 !./!;0!2!10  !'

0!/.!$0 0 /12 !.20!!1$ !10//;2.6/ .'&&&&))?

= 

  "



      &' % 5    #$    6 

  

 6  "  

       

 

+     &' (  

 "

   



 



  

    & ' )  5    #$(    6 

  

 6  "    

          "



 

&' ,    





   & ' 2 

   





  &' 1 

$4 0!/.!116/ .'&"4&))?$0;6!

0

/C A0 / !09;!

//.! !2 '&?%"%%&;//;1'0!.$0,. / ./0/1

'(&)%"%%($;0!6/ .'&&&&))?

;1!1 A0!/.!$ .09;!

//.!!6!10 121//;10

/0,. /./1$0!!$

.6

/'

0  0 /11.!20 1A

2./! 1

/'(45("%%5//226/0! !1!  11  &#'&%'"%%5$  ;0! A  ;0/  .2      $

/

1 0 /;A1' ,!' .0/8' 0!16!,!','9'

0!$/!1 ./ ! 0

//    2./!  1 

/ '(&)%  "%%( . 10012!!61 A09;!

//.!! . /0A/;6;00012!!61 6/ .'"##&)5&/10! !6 A$0!

; !110.021111%5'%&'&)75; C;/121'  0  !/  .!  !  6/.2  0  61  !20/A 110. A0/1200 /1011;! .1 A0@.1211!11"#'&&'&)54$!$/1/; 0A12!!61./1! !6 A;./1  12    //  0  !!'  0  /1  ;  2  .1  !  

.!

$  ''$  ;B1.2$  C.!1$  C0.!!$  C0!$  !C  1  C0/  !

1!C2;!!0/1.B2!'$0.$0120 00    C/A!0 !$  . /'0 /   !11 0. B0!!'

0,. /./;E/.61$0!!$0. !@.; /1$0.$.!210.!!2B 10@.1211!09;!

//.!' ,!'  .0!  0!$  /!1  ./  ! !2  0 ! 1B / 0/1 2010! 20. 100 12  1/;!!61  A09;!

//.! !

!/A/2/1@.1E'

(@ 10;10.!0 /1  @!C1'0211 !1/A//!0 @0/120 !!10.0,. /./ ;./1 B0!!1$0!!$0@.2!1 A09;!

0

//  .!    !/A  /2/  1  @.1  1  0  !1A  /1 /;0!'

;E1100!/!.; / ;/1 A//0 !! . A;1//0

!!; 1$0!!$0 !;./1 062 12' !6 !1!& ./# /6!1.  009;!

//.!E10 A0 !6. /$ ''$6/ .'"##&)5&E'41 !E'71 1 0;26//0B0!!0! !!0!.20

. /$  0!!$  0!  ;     /    . B!./  *4-   !1 !6' 1!02!  !1! A6!. 211$0,. /./  !1C0  62;0.C2 !'

,!','

'

',$/!1./

!2 0/0 

//

'(45("%%5. 1009;!

// .!1//2/A1 !6!A!6!20;//!1 @.1211!0!/.!11 0!2.,!'

.0! 0! A. 200,. /.//0

    0       A  !  6    0  2  11  ; C;/121  0.20  11    1  0  .      B0!!    0

!!A  1A'  0!      !  !  C2  !  2  0

!!'  9;!  

//  .!   /1    

!  0  80; '4(?%;!.F2!0&? 20/1$ ;0!0 .212;/!!'0!;0//20 /110 A1/!1 000.!

/;/1!C2 '0211;E.1/A A

1

 !!<.0!0!/A0@/10620/12 &4%%%<'A!11 

/1//0 !!A 1A'0! /1 ;!!1175%%%<'A!11

//G0!; 20;0210/1$0!!$0! 11

!6!A'

!!$,!' .0/8' 0!. 1009;!

//.!!20/AE!10 ;! 20/.!1 /;1.100 /; 0. !A 0/1162100 ;C$ .610  /1!!10;00 ;6!C'0 20 /;./1/00.0 /

.6  $!$;6/1! !1A!$ . ;!C!!.' 00!01$,. / ./  01  /!1A  !1  0  .1!A  ;//  1   !C  1  ; 20/1.!1$0.$.!210.!!1/ 0

/'

 0    $ ; !2.1  0  0,. / ./01C C0 1 0061 !1!11&#'&%'"%%5$0!;@.<.1 '0      A  

/  !  6    A  !  /!$  0 ,. /././1 .0 ./12!/0/11$ 0.$ !A!;1!C2

!'

060!10/!1./!0 !$

!10

 ! C$ .21@.1211!$!!10.! /; 106;00121/;!!61 A09;!

//.!

'(45("%%50!!6;$!$



11/A021111%5'&&'&)75;/A A !!$ ;0!0/ ;75%%%<'A!1'60/11/

!1 !./!0!$0.20621 .2061

 ! A .1!'.0!.$//0 . <.61;./1<.!!20B;!0 !!A 1A'

,. /  ./    !!    C      0  A ! //0 !!A 1A;./1  !.1 @'!1 .00!  ! 0 !!A 1A! /!00/1;1!.  .!

1;0E2!'0,. /./   !1 /;01/1010A1 0 /C;20 .6;;!$ .00!$/1 0 0. !A A;A.!/'

!  /;A C!B /01!1 01 /$''$!!2!.!A!$ .

 C0!1111 6' /2!001209;!

// .!6BB6B /0 !6. B!./*4- ./#  !1!& '0!1.1!

=*4-  !0/A.0.0//  11 .1!. B!./*&-$1.0.0// ;01!;.1! . B!./*(-$ ./&  !1!HH1 2!$  !!0// !!11A.0.$ .1! ./(0 !1!$./0.!026$0

/GE $// !!10 ! 1. B!./*"-'>



0!!$012!1!16/ .'"##&)5& 61@.1211!11"#'&&'&)54./1 0/1  12 .

//0 !!A 1A'

.

0A12$2!.1!!! 1  .    2./!  1  

/  '(&)%    "%%('  0     !12/A11' 0@.1211!!1!1 A09;!

// .!

'(45("%%5B1'0<./;!1 61!1!11%7'%"'"%&%!;!16.!

// .6 120! 1B,. /./'0@.1211! 0!/.!!!1'

0 !0// / !AC !  !1;0/;10,. /./!!1!C2 ! /  0. !A A .2A!/0   !'

6;0!1 !6$   /1 1'

  )(*$

  &'23% 4561,1 578 *84879:

;7

 <7;

*848 46 <7;