High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/907/1999dismissed

Baldev Singh v. Punjab State And ORS

2016-06-10Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal10 pages

% #% $$ &$"

#& $

#' ('))**'+,

'*--.. (' (/0!#12 4 #.

.+,5** .+*5.'+ --.5''1+56++'-+2/ * 7' 2.8 +65 * ' +.' *..55 * '+' '6 * ', 8 9 : 34 #.

.+ '+.'*

** #'-. +'. $'5 +*.+ 5'+' '6++ 9 :*2

7*'' + + -' + 2/ -/

766' ( 8 ..5. '2''/ 6. + + 5*-'-. '.1#.

5*..* ;. ', 2 #.

1+ * -

7*80+' < ' .. + '6. " 8 .+2/+ + '*.+5',8+- '66+ '6 * 6-./6 =*5 ( -.

8+ +/7'++*8'0++ '6+2.6*+*'5*6-.8*,' 86+2//+*8'0+*' *-''$*', *-.

8''6+ 9 :*2 +,'7*''+ '-'+2/*-/766'(8**8 .6+2..5.* 3<4 #.

..5+ * * ', .+ *, 2'6+'2''./8*+5'5.';'/ +'*'.*8-'6./--+*+ - 8...5+*-'+ -'28 +;. ' * ', + '-' '5'+5 * 7*''+88'5#.

.+*,2 '6+ * 2 * 8'5 '-' 8* 2.*5 * 5. -' .+ 2/ * -'

'6+8'++ '55.5.+ +'9 7#7 > :*.6./

< 62 .+ 3:4 ++**5'+ . +62./ 1+' '/-'+* '+' 25 .+ 2 .+ ', 1'-'+$*8'0++ *-.

8' + 2 '/ 5.5 + 212. $* =-. *-.

8..+2/+ + < < : '+5*++'0"8 5,8'52/+ + > :$*' (5' ( 8 ';+ ' -. ,' 2/ + + < :$*'-'+

#. ( * '-' '5'+5 ,'

7*'' + + * -.

* -/ 766' ( : : $* -/ 766'(*'-' :)-5 ,8 * -.

25 -'2 * ', 8' '6+-'-' *--6.'..* ,'6 *-.8'++.5*' 3>4 ' .5 '-. ..85 8'

'6+

! "#$ #$ % ! &

! ' ( 34 #.

5*6.

=6+#?

+.+ *,+ 4 + =6+ 6/ 8 8 6./(0*'5*#'-. $ +*.+?

.85*".-'+ 6 #$ ? 394 $'. 7' ,+ 1+56 + +' ++ > +6+*#.

'6+ .

2 '*.8'--..7'8..8*+6+* --.,+1+56++'++: 9 34 $*5*2.; .8*,2

'6+*8,'0-5*,8*','/,.,+ * --. * 7' -'++ +' ..85 2.; .8

)

* "

" + % #

% ,) # %

4 *,*'+.'+. '*-'+ *,.+'+*''+

4 +6+./-.

8-'2 '/'

*',"8--+7*80+'2/+ + <+8--'2 '-'+ /'-'--6.''5*-'+ /' * 8'0 8 + '/ '*' 8 212. =-. * -.

8 ..+ 2/ + +< < : '+5*+ +'0 + ?'5 8 5, * -.

+ '(5'(8';+ '-.,' * *'' * -.

$* -. ,' 8

+ 2 5, * -.

8 -'2 *' '*',8''6+ 4

'+ . ' * -.

26+ * *'' ,' 8 '-'+ 2/ * -/ 766' * ..5 6 + 8' 6+*' '86-',*-' *'

5*..5'+'2'5*'* <4

'+. '*-.

'*'26+ **-'-.,0+ ''65*', * -.

8 68* .5 . #12 #.. '+. '*-.

26+* =-'- .82.++88*'*',

-'2'8''6+8*665/*5 *'+'=-**',8''6+ *25-',+5+6-./$*'+'8 *+'62*686'./ 6 .5 ' '+' +6. '6 ', * 5'+ 6 + *'682+6 +*7'*.+*,,.*''+' 08*'*'' *'+'$*7'82.5+ 08*'.' *'+'8**'8.0 '

'+' -*6'86'./'62+ + 6-./6 + * 76- *'/**6-./8.0./265+ 6-./ .. * '+ *' ; ' 2 +'+1./*;'' '.+ * *' $* '+' '6 8 2+ '6*5**+ *-.

85* 2'@+2/+ +,8 *6 +

+5*++'0++'5-'2 "88'+2/*#'-.+'(5'( 8';+'-''5'+5**'',' $*'-'+ #.''+++,''-' '5'+5*''+ *-.

$*+

*-.

8 +2-6'0+'5-'2 +*'',8 ++,* /6 :4 $*-'- .8*5*.5*+

%%&'

()*+, +-+ . "'

$#$/"/0%& "

"!"$ /!"

()*), (122,))+ /"/0%&

"!3 !$ #$

4$ 14 $ !"

()*),- )*) "5$ 0!

3!#$/"/0%&16"7 ()*,) +)8 %%2 "

$9":#$ %#0!50/%&'

()*+8,-

;<*+5/ "6 '0!."1!#$16"7/"/0"'"%/ 0!

)*+<( , )* 8 * 21 * '+' '6 8 *+'62 *686'./ 6 .5 ''+' +6. '6',

6 +*7'86-,.*' '+'08'*'' *'+' >4 0!

#$/"/0%&"!=""

)**8(), 8< A.. * *7'*.+**76-*'/ +*'572. '6',/68**'

/' *'/',,- ..5

6 + ,5. 62*,'8*-2.'

2 '6+/.+*+*'5 '6', 8*.+*,5. +-..+* 6-*'/.+**2..0./ -',

' 4 0!

$>"$0B-'C8*.+*8 ./*2 -'+.'-' *6-./2 *- *6-*'/ 2+/*'

6'.*68--'-'5*'+'+*'5 *6-./ 8.*.+**6-./* '5**-8**6-*'/ '6- * * ', -2. ' * 2./ 6 + '

/ $'6 *','6 *--6 2'6+2-,'$*+6.++82/A..

* 0!

$>"$0B-'C8-*.+2/*"D2. -=7' /"/0%&16"7"'%/ 0!$#$14 '0!

- ( , -*< + /"/0 %& 16"7 #0!$1$ "60$ .15"!-(), 8*$*,8.++86 "6 '0! ."1!$ >"$0 B-'C 8 ,''.+ + * ,8 02/A.. * *7' 0!

$>"$0B-'C 8-*.+*68 +8**

+ '+'+ 2/ * "D2. -= 7' 120!

/0'0/ %& %:

>0 1'

"" #0!$1$ 9"!4" "$ )**(), -**

'+. '*--..' ''+ "/ "!"

#0!$1$"!=""/"/0 %%20!"/ #020?"4/' )**8(8, 8-8+**'+' '68 6-.''+'E'62*682+ ..5 6 ++*' '*.+5 ;'/8 6-',$*-'-.++ 0!

$>"$0 B-'C8**8' '*'-*.+2/*"D2.-=7' '*6-.8'*'56'+2/.'+ . '*--.. 94 +6+./*-.

8,.,+8 +'&-6 **85'+-'2 +*'*8;+$* '65 - 2/*6-*'/+'5-'2 6-./ , 2+6 6 +2',+ 0!

$>"$0B-'C8

''+ **6-./8.0./265+6-./ +*' '8*65/*56'*'+'

'6 * 6 .+ *, 2 -+ 6-.' 8*'25/*5-,'$*' ''+'

-+ 5 * -.

+'5 -'2 8 ../

'+'+'

'2/*7'8''+ *' '*1+56++'-+2/*7' 2.8 2 .+ 8* $* ; '6.+ +28'+*.5* '++* * '+' '6 8 -, ' * - '6+2/*6-*'/8 8**+6.++82/*7' 0!

$>"$0 B-'C8**8 '*'-*.+2/*"D2.-=7' 14 '0!

$>"$0B-'C+"60$ .15"!$>"$0 B-'C 4 ",5 +'+ * ','/ * .5*

'+ -'+ * 7' * - * * 6-5+1+56++'-+2/*7'2.8 '*'. /6 '+5 ,+'*,5

'+8*/-','/7;./ +56' *--.*6+6+ 10) -)< ( , $% -