Pawan Kumar v. Uttar Hry. Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd.
!""# $% !#""#
&' ()*&"
+ *+ ** &) ****
!"#
% &'
( !"#
+,! -& . /%01 " )*+
,
$(
"-.
& # $
!
#( //0$
$1 '
# $
$$ 2 .$$$#
3*0445456*/33
*3 /770 )!
*:+ $
.
9 .
#
)/+
# $ /;
7:
/770
$
"
$(
(' 7:
7/ /77< ,
"
7:
/7*7
"
*3 7:
/7/3
(# $ (' . ='
=
(
.
)3+
> # ($
=
-.
#
$
(
>- ( -.!>
6. (( /3 ** *<;:
!
.
= **'
#
& '
. #
=
" (
*3 ** *<<:
&
- 2 -
#
(' = =
5"
' ($( ='
#
'' (
( )8+
$
=
. #
# *<;: # =
##
(#-#( #( # #.
='
("
,
"
$(
"(?
870/$/77/=
#
@
= ((
"
&
$= =
1 "
$ $ $
$
( 9
.
$ & ' ( $
96.
#
)A+
> # ($
"
$( "( ?
*A<38$/77/ '
.
;
/77/ # $"
*A */ /77A)!
*0+
$((.
6
)0+
"
"
*3 /770 )!
*:+
&
#( $
('
#
#('=
9# (# #
- 3 - $
$
$ (' # ""
$ 3 '
..
$ (' '
):+
, . = ($$
$
$ $
=
(#
/0 */ *<;;)!
6*+
B5 5 (
(( '= $ #(.
9.
#
(# /0 */ *<;;
=
# #
# =
6. #
=
# "
(' "("
-. .
$( #( $ 9 .
# # # = .
('
&
.
$ ('
$ '
=
1 #
(' $'
6.
);+
> # ( $
(#
(#
!"# $
%&' #
# "
$ #
(' 6= $(# 3 '
#
# "
$
( $$ ".
9.
#
)<+
1 #
"
"
#
#
=$$# 4
# , $
9
/3 ** *<;: (' ""
='
,
$=
$
*;
7;
*<:0
.
- 4 - $ *: '
*;
7;
*<<3 1 =
#
7/ 7;
*<<A
"(
$= $(# $ # 9.
$
'
$
$
.
$ *: '
$
'
$
$ $ $
# ".
"
$ #
9.
#
1 $
.
*3 /770 '
!
% $% C"
( /773
$
('
='
6.
"#
( *0 )%+ $
/773 #
((=
2
('$
'
((= (.=(
2
$
( )*7+
> # ($
$
"
#( $
$ C"
. .
2
= #
=$# #
"(.
$ $ C"
$ (# $
# (( # ('=
'
$
)**+
(# =
(# (
)*+ ,$
- , # % ./"#
#( (' =
"
' "
# # ## "
"
$
( $ *A '
# = ( = "(
# $!
#( *8*0$
$1#
#
#
$
(
- 5 -
=(
, #
$ # "
.
# #=
# '
$
# #( $
=( ( $
# "
)*/+
( # ( $
.
.
# )*3+
#
$ $ $
(' >-
". 5 1 ! > /3 ** *<;: **'
$.
(
' 9
=
$ $
# .
=
(#
/0 */ *<;;
9
('$
*'
B5 5 ($ '
$(( D(
2
.
.
$ & '
'(= ."
6%
,
6. " (
// *<;;)!
6/+#((
= F. #
$#
@ # =
*< *<;< )!
63+ ((
6. =
'
$
"#
( $"
#
-
$ '
7;
*<<A )!
68+ ,
6. .
## #
$#
# =
='
70 */ *<<A )!
6A+ )*8+
,
/0 *<<0 )!
60+ =
'
B5 5
-.#
#
$ $ $
.
**'
,
- 6 - " (
78 *<<:)!
6;+-.
= # ( ( ". #
$#
$
$ =
$ #
=
=''$$$"
/3 *<<:)!
<+
*G "
'$
. " . (
*3 ** *<<:)!
6*7+
&
#( $
.#
$
=
E 1
( . (.
=' 7/ *<<;
6.
((
CH
$"
(
- ='
6.
7A 7< /77/ )!
*A+
='
6. #
='
?6870/6/77/
&
#( $
$ #
.
=
)*A+
(
('
$(
?6*A<386/77/ # (( ..
7A 7< /77/ )!
*A+ # (
.$
.
*3 /770)!
*:+" #
6. .
&
#( $
('
.
#
.
# (' = .
9# ( # # $
#
((. ($ .
$
$ $
# #
)*0+
$
= # & ( *:
7;
*<<A $
#
!
($
.
7A 7< /77/)!
6*A+
#
#
(.
#
- 7 - # #(
='
( 5 "
7/ 7;
*<<A
#
*3 ** *<<A
$
$
2
('$ 3'
,
" #( $
#
7/ 7;
*<<A )!
/+
6 !
" #$ % & '& $ ( !!
) '& *
+ , - %&
+ .
+ / , - %& $ $ )*:+
( $ ="
# =
1 # ".$ 9.
(= (#=( #
$
##
$ 7* *<;A ((7/ 7;
*<<A 1
#
$
(' ##
/3 ** *<;:
".
1 #
.
='
#
7/ 7;
*<<A )!
4/+
*3 ** *<<A $((' (#=(
#
)*;+
, 2 $ &#
(#
-. &=4
=
$
I
- 8 - )*<+
, =& "
= $ .
#
$ #
" #( # ' 9 ( ((
#
#= #
( .(
##
."
"
"#
#(.
,
( ". $ #
($
( .(
= $ #( $
('
$
,
$ # # $ $(( ".#
# "
'= )/7+
, $#
= .$ !
#( *0)/+$
1
#
-0
1 '.
%%2
( '
#( $
$
#
.
=
#( # ('# (
#
$ !
#( *8 *0 $
"
# #( #
=(
=( =
# ##
$ ('$#
"
(
"#
#(
$ (
.( # "
# #
$ !
#( *8 *0
( "
$ ('
'$# ='
=
$ ('$#
)/*+
,
3+
-0
4 , 5 !&!! . !2%' ( #
#(
- 9 - $# # # (
(
"(
((= (#=(
#( ='
$ (' =
"(.
#
$
(# (=
=$ #
$#( #
)//+
,
$=
$
J *;
7;
*<:0
.
$ & '
*: '
*;
7;
*<<3 !
#
7/ 7;
*<<A
"(
$ = $ (# =' = ($
.
*: '
$
'
$
$ $ $
5" ('
$ (# $ #
='
/0 */ *<;;
'
$
// ** *<;:
1 = # 2((' # =( =
(
' ='
('**'
$.
= .(- $
=' .
,
# & *;
7;
*<<3# (# *:
7;
*<<A$ #
/'
$
.
.
$*:'
)/3+
, C"
1 #
7/ 7;
*<<A " $
$#(
9 .
#
#( )+ (
#
( = (#=( $ ##
$ 7* *<;A (( 7/ 7;
*<<A
"
( $ #
'
."
('
$ '
=
(# $
1 #
7/ 7;
*<<A
# ' ((K
- 10 - #( "
( $ #
(7* 7;
*<<0
$ '
=
7* *<;A (( 7/ 7;
*<<A )/8+
1
$
##
/3 ** *<;:L
& '*;
7;
*<<3
$
( $ #
*:
7;
*<<A 1 #
(# $ #
='
# = = '
#$
"
= $ '
$
1 #
7/ 7;
*<<A )/A+
5"
('
$
$
#(
2
$ $(( ( '
.
.
$ & '
'= ."
1
#( $# # #
=
$
(
' 9
=' ('**'
.
= . (- $
=' .
((
.
.=( 9
"
( 3'
$ $
, #
6. 2(('
2
=
.
6. - '
((
"#
(4 6 $
-
."
$#
(- $
# ( ,
6. = .
$
C"
# = . #
( '
""
$ ('
#((
. .
"
. ##
- 11 - ='# .
-#-
. $
.
## $ $ $
)/0+
1*
6
(-5 2 #..#'2 =
"
#( $
#
(= ('
, $ ".
#
.
#
=
$ ('
#
(
= "
('
$ ('
)/:+
1$
$.
.
#
=
"
$#(#
($ ".
$
'
#
(# =
? =
.
# # #
$ (' =
# .
#'#
#
(# $
.
#'#
=& $
(#' (
$ (' "
#
# "
'
( =(
)/;+
!
#
2
.
"
( =
$9 $
#
= .
#
,
# "
(-
$#
(-
-
( (' (
$
# (('.
# ((
( $9 $
# ."
(=
"
$9.
- 12 -
( ('$
#
(# (=
)/<+
,
( =("$
$# & '$
"
#
.
?
# (
.
$ & ' .
.
# # (
= "
$
.
-.
#
= "
.
# #
$ (' #
( ( = "#$
.
(9 ('
# ( 2($#
2
$
#
== (
( # # (# #= $( (=
1$ (# =' $
((
$ (' =
-=
9
# $(#'4#
#
=
$# # (#' 9 #
-( .
$ ('('
# (
& '
# #( ( ='
('
(# =
$( = '
$
'
)37+
((
#
9# .
( (
,
"#
#= ('## # !
#( *8*A $
$1 1 (
"
' .
9# =''$##
"# ( ='
#
=(
$ (' $
.
"
$#( #
- 13 - , #( $
#
=
# =( ('
"# (
. #
#
= #
$ $
,
= # ('## #
) $ . $
3 3
)* !&
" .. #!
7 8 $
(-50
4 !& #..
1
#
C"
=
# (( .
" (6 (
$
="
#
2
" )3*+
, $
$
#=
$( 4 (' 4 .(.
#
(( $($((.((
# $
#
"(.( 1 # H
(# - .4
,
$( 4 ('
((
.
('
4.
( $$
( 41 # (= .".
('4 # =(
#((
4. 1 $#
=
"
$ #
#
1 #
7/ 7;
*<<A )3/+
,
- ='
6. "
*3 /770)!
*:+
#
((. ($
( ''
$
$ ('# ""
$ (
'
# "
$#
$ ('
( ((6$ '
#( ,
- 14 - . ."
(.6='
$# =
9
= . (- $
=' .
6( .
$
=' #( -. (=
1
#( # #
=
= (=( '
(=
#( = ( "
=
=( "
.
# ='
(' $=
= $# ='
('
=
=( ""
$
'
, # (
(#' = (' .
#(
. .# # = .$#
#(
,
# $((# $(#'4#
# =
$ ='
$ $$ (' =
& "
# $((
"#
( =
6
$ ('
, " $ $#(
"
$ (' (= # (
# =
( $ #
, $#(
$ (' $
$#(
($
)C"
+ , $" =(
"
#( 9
=& .
= # "
='
( $. H#(
( #
($
&
.$ ('
'
#
. .
='
- 15 -
(
$ (' "
#
. ($ ($ (
"#
011+
,
#
- " .
. #
= # (.=( $ =
#
.
( $ #
*:
7;
*<<A $
.
.
$ *: '
*;
7;
*<<3 1 ('
# 4 # ='
#
(= $ = =
.'"( & $# , "
' $ #
$ (' (
01-+
(
( (#
-. #
='
/0 */ *<;; )!
*+
B5 5 (
#$#((' D 2 $ 3E !
( *0)+ $
/773 ( "
((=
2
('$
3'
$
.
='
(# $ #
= ($ $
)= + (( =
9 '$
'
(
( 01&+
"
=
#
#
#
.
6. #
#( $
$ #
=
# "
(' ='
.
# # # = .
('
- 16 -
&
.
$ ('
$ '
=
, (' $'
6.
)30+
H
$
((
*3 /770)!
*:+
='2 ,
#
#
#
$
(# =( (. ((= $ *3 */ /7/3 4 2+,! -& . /%03
. /
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No