← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/34833/2015dismissed

M/S Rexor India Ltd And ANR v. M/S Sakata Inx. India Ltd

2015-10-13Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi14 pages

       

 



!

"#$#%&

'

'

($ )*

%!#

+ !'

%!

%*'

'''

# #% *$ ,$'

($ - .

%)'

/ %!# + !'

'''

$1%!

%

& 2+ '

-  -3 -  +  

  

         

 !"#$%&

'

(     !"#$%&

) 

   

 !"#$%& ***** -3 -  + '

 





 # +,'

- -     ./-  - / 0 1 

    '3 4, '45 

  #   7  .

8  9:0

 

    )4 4, '4+ .

8  950        

 # ; -  - 

 <         9     

 # ), %  = 

 ./% = / 0   

    % '

#      .

8  90

 ) 4+ '44 "

  

 , 45 '4) 

   '5 45 '4)    

 # )) -  - (    

  

  5          

   - #     

   ) 45 '4+   >

    



   





    

 

 



    8 



   4 4, '4+ >        

 # ; -  -   # <1   < #9 7       (  

  

  

   )4 4, '4+ 7    %    

    

  #  



    '3 4, '45 >       ?      

  

 

 

       

 >     



     

     

 # ; -  -      

 

     



   >    

  

     

   

    

  

        =        

  >

-'

6 $.

* ,$'

7

6 %!

*#5  / 0  

8'

>   

   

 >

              

         

   1

      

       



    

 8





 

 # +,'

-  -  

    <     @           

 

     

  

      

    !

  

 "



     #$$%#$!

 & '          (  ) *+, -.

 #/$/#$!

 

 

     0    

 "

&1    

   2

 

  







 

 3 ,        



  

  2

   4 4 "

       !$!##$!





             

 4  

 ,    

4        *+, -.  #$!!#$!



     +   

        0    

 +  

 5  

  

   2

 +  

 

  

    3       

       

 

 6

 +   

     

 4 4       .

      2

 

      7

 +  

      

  4

 

      

   2

  

 

 6        4   $8!!#$!  



 3 ,           

    



  

  2

   4 4 ' 

 +  

 

  6  9     ! $!#$!:

 6      4     *+,  .  !$!##$!



        

  

      0  

 +  

   "

9     6  

 +  

 

2  '   9    6  

 +  

      4      !%$##$!:   *+,  .  ! !#$!:



             0    

  



 +  

   '

  

  

      

  

    6  &  * .   "

 

  3       

  4 "



  

  

   &  * .   "

 !;$##$!: "

9     6  

 +  

    

 2   2   4 <     "

 - ::8    

       64 "

 

4    2

<#/$$$-9 6  4 <    

   .   

  4 

       !;$##$!: .  9   

 +  

     

8 2   *+,  .  !%$##$!:



        

 +  

       0    

  

 4 <               

   

 +  

  

         

   

6 <#/$$$-9  

  4 3       

  4 4 <    

 <#/$$$-9  

  4

  

  4   

 

 "

   

  

  



 *    ! #$!: .  9    6  

 +  

      2   *+,  .  !;$##$!:



        

  

       4  

    4     0  

 +  

       0    

  

 4 <    6   !;##$!:

  

  "

9     6  

 +  

    

 2  2  '   9    6  

 +  

     /:#$!: 

  

 

   

    2       4  

9   =  *+,  .  ! #$!:



        

  

       4  

 

 +  

       0    

  

 4 <    6   !;##$!:

  

     

 4 "

9

    6  

 +  

    

    "

  "71   6  

 +  

  ##:#$!: "

   4     

   2 3  

    4   6  

   2   *+,  .  /:#$!:



        

  

       4  

 

 +  

     4 <    6   !;##$!:

  

    

 4 3 

    4   6    !/#$!: "71  6  

    

 

  

    

      6  9    '

  - >#  

  6  

    2 "

   4  

4  7    

 "

     6      

<!$$$$-9   4     

    2   *+,  .  ##:#$!:



        

  

       4  

 

 +  

   4 <    6   !;##$!:

  

    

 4 3 

    4   6    :8#$!: 

   6  

 +  

  

4   

   4   6  

 $:#$!:             4 

 ,  

  $ 4 

 

    



  

   

  



64 

 +  

   4     ,     6    3?

  ?  7-1  6  4    

   "

  -   6  4    2 "

 

 

 :8#$!:

 & &1      

 4   *+,  .  !/#$!:

: 

        

  

       4  

 

 +  

   "

      ?  @   

         !8$%#$!:

      4   6  &1     

 4  

     ,   

4     ( =  ) *+,  .

 $:$8#$!:



        

  

       6     0  

 +  

   

   !$/#$!:

 

   2

 

  

  

  4  



 3 ,          

          4 4 "

&1       

4     @ 3   "

 

 

 $!$>#$!:

 &1 &1       

 4 ,      

 &1   

   2   6       

 4 

  ( =  ) *+,  .  !8$%#$!:A

     @  

  

 1  

 

  

  #      

  

   - #



      % 9-   % '

      &     9 

     

    9  % '

    

   

        @   >

              

      

1



      

   

  

    - #     % 9-



  

       

    

    

1

        

        (                 &   

      

           

 (         



      

 # ; -  -  

        

  

   =

     

 # ; -  -

   

    =    

  

     

  

    6 4 

 (    

)    4  !;$>#$!:

  6      

 4  4 

6 ,       

    

 4

7,    6 6  

 +    

   6 

   

          

    @  6 4 4   4  

      2      6         



  1  

  4   

     ,   

       

 4            6       #$$%#$!     

 + +  

    

 

   !$/#$!: &6     

   

  4     $!$>#$!:         



 ,    4       

   

 4     , 

    ()      6     4       6   

   6  

 

   "

     

  

      

   ,  4       

        

  

  

   ,  

4    

  

  4 

6           4     4  A # 

  

   

 

    

   >       

        

  

  

       8              

 

 #            1

   >/ # 

!7 ;$;%!*

%!

% * ,$'

-

7#< !;

%!

*$5   /0 -

'

  

          

  

9

  (

         (  



       <1



  -<=

     

       

      

 

   8    



   

   

   

                  

 

 # ; -  - 

        <1

  

1  = 



 9 

  

 

  1            8      

 =

      - #     % 9-   % '

     1 ) 45 '4+ %         

  =          

    

 

   

=   

           

  

           

     

1



  

 # +,'

-  -             

     

 





        

  1 

>    8      9    - #



  

     

   

    %   

  -              

    

 



  

   

    

    % 

    B 

            

    = -3 -  + > ) 4 '45