Rattan Singh v. Financial Commissioner & ANR.



 
   
   



 !"#$ % & '( ( )!%*+,",% &-( (


 

  
   
  


 

 

  
.& /0.(1
.1

 0 0 
!

 
 
"
 


#

$








 
%

1 &
'

"

 
 


%

1 (
!

 
 
 

 

 
) 
%
1

 
#* +
   
,
"
    +
-  
) .
 +  
+/
,
"
 &




   1
$ 
  


" 
 
 
&&23&&4
"


  
"
1 
"

"

$ 

 

"
  5
 
 

&2 &66
 7
(

#
   
 
) ,  
 

 
 

6( 6 &668  7
4

#
  
0   
  




#



 
 
 
 


&

&9 6& &66
 7


#
 

  

     

: 



 - "
"
"
 


 


"

"
$  


: 
"
,  
- 
'  
;


)  
 

  
$
, 
"
 


#
/ 

 

 
,  
"
  
#
 
"
 
1
" 
"
 
8
 
 

  

  
0 &
 
  


  

'

 
"
 
 
$

, " 
"
  

 # $
"


"


 

0/ 
: 

  "
 
 
$

"
 
<5
$

11
.  

1
. 
 
 

"
  
 

" 
"
: 


'



"


  
 
  ,  
"
 
 
"
  
 




" 
  
 

, 
 

&9 6& &66
 7


 


: 
"
,  
- 

 


 ,    
0 &
"



"
 
  
  ) ,  
$ 
 
 


=

 
 
 

&9 6& &66  7




 
  
0 &/


 

 : 
, 
 

&2 &66
 7
(

 
  
  
"



"
  
0      

1
 
$  

 
,   
 

6( 6 &668
 7
4
<
 
$ 

(

   1
,



"
  


  :

"
   
, #
  
  
 



7, 

<

,



#
"
(4
#   


  
 
   0 &
 &


,
,



  
 " 
"

: 

'



"
  
   ,
 
"
 
 


 
 
  
 : 




$
 
  
"
 


 

#

 









"  &
, #



 
 
"

 "
   




 
 
 

'

#
  
 &


  
 
   
   0 &

# 

 
 
   



 3-



 &
$

#
 

#

 
 


,
 #

<


#

,  


"
" $/

& 66

+

<

"  
 

: 
 


 
#
 
  

 #

 
#   3  
  
,   #
"
  
0 &

 ,  
$ 


,
,


  ,
"

 

: 
$ 

 #

 

, 

<

>


, 
&


8
 $
"
 
$ 
  

, 
#
( / 
"


 &

 

"
 : 
 
"
$ 

 

,#




'


   

$

1
,
,
#
 

"
  

 
 ,  
"


"
  

"

 
,

8

4
"
  :
,




 

 
"


 
"

  
< 
$

"  

 
 
,# 



 *
 







 

 


 
 












 

 
  



 




 






 


 
 






 



  

 

 
 





   


 








 



 


 



 



 



 


 

 







         



 



   

! 







 

  
 




8



 

 

 



 


 





     



 
 

 
!"  


 
 



 
 

 







  


!"
 
####  $ 





 

 





%








!& '

'


: 


,   
< 
 


  
"
,

<


" 7
 

$

    
  
"


 

 
"
:  

 
  
5 "  
 
7  

$/ 

"
:  


 #
 
  #

" 
"   

'

, 
: 


( 6> ??9

 "


"


 
"

: 

  
 


(6 &666
 #

 
9
#
,   
 "
1




  

 
 


  0$
1
$

$ 
 
  ,
 
"


  

 (

, $
"

8

4
"
  :
,




 

 


"
" 
, 
 &

 #
 

@ $ 

  #  





 

 
 "




2


, 


 



 
"

: 
7 $ 
 
 

5
1
 
  
 



  " 

#  $% 
?4>
:
24




"

,
 
  
 



, 
(
/ 
"

$ 
 &/


 


, 

&


8
 $
"


'

  

 
 
?
  $ 
 &


  

"
  
$  
#
'   
;




) ,  
+  ;


"
 

"
: 
$ 
 
.
 #  
 

"
 &



"

, 
  
 

#
 
 
 , #

#
  
" #
  
   
,
 #
"
(4
#
$,
 
 

 $
 
  

0 &

 
#
, 

 


"

 
"
 
 

 
 
 
"


 
 

"


 


"

,   
#
 
 

#
  
"  

 
 
, 

" 
"
1 

 
 


", 
#
"


  1



$
 
 
 


"
$ 


  
 
#
 


 

"


 
"

: 
,
"
$
, $

 
1

#
   ,
"




 
 
 
"
 
 
"


 
 
"
: 

 


 
 
"



4

#


 
"
 
 
""
"
  #

, #

 


 
  


 

"  
 
 
 
"




,

 
"
 
 
 
, 

5 "  
 
 ,


 
#
 


'

  


 
 
 

#
 





 
 &



 

,  
 
; $ 

&
/
$#
"
,  
- 

<


 
$ 


  
 


?


  
0 &





 
"
,  
- 




,

'


 
 
 
"
 &
#

 
 




,
 #



"
#$ 
$  
 
 "
 
 "


""  #
,
  
"
 
,  
: 

1

 

 

 
 






  
,
,

: 
1


$
 
"

., ,



 


: 



 

: 
$  

#
$#
"

 
  
"

 


., ,


) ,  
-
"
 


!&



 # '

 (   
??(


?



 * () *








 




  
+







  




 , 




- 
 





- 

 




  








 
  

9

. 
)!!


/  




 


 


 



 


 

  
 


 

 - 
 
 
 
 
 


 




- 


 



 




- 
 






 






 - 





- 



 

 


 


 



 
 
+ 





   

 %


 1
/

  
.

 


 





 




-  




 



 




  


 
 


'
'



, $


"$
#

) ,  
-
"
  

)

   # '

  (     )

 ** &666&
:A
>82
$  





 * ()

  
  



 




 
 




 - 


 



 

!"


 


-  

% 
2
 



  


  


  


    






 , 




3 


  

  

 
 





- 
 


 
   


 

 




 






4 


5  / 



/

  


1
/

   







+

  


2


+

 




 
+

2




  
+

 

?






  

  



+


 
6 
+

 
 
 

. 
778 



'
'


-

! (

  #  $% 

 
&6(

   , 
66


 


$ 
 $/ 







"


  
:  



 #

,
$ 


 
 

  

 #


  


,  
 




,
7
"
! (

+,!

-  

 * (9

      

          

    



                     

                   

                        

      

             

           

!

                 

 " 

     #$ % #&   '   (           (  ) 

        

       

                          %       

6



    



)     

                       

     

    
         

     

    

  

*     

 

&

     )   



 +% # 

   % 
 ,

   &     

        

     % &  

       % (-  % 

  % &  
    



  &
  

        &



 *    

                

   % #      #  $   +&         .

'






 
   

: 
 
 



7, 


,
 
 
1


 

 
 
 
"
"
  

 
7,  #


,
  

/

, $



$

 

"
   

/
"
,
 

"



/ 

,
 
 


1
 
  
 



 



#'

 (   

 
&6&
(
:

1


 

 

 
  
  

$
2632&
#


 &
$
(4
#


  
"
"  
"


  

@
 

"
 
  
 
48
#

  
0 &


8(
#

'

  


 
 
 (
 
 "

#

  




"
"
 
"
: 


'

<B
 



 # 

#"

 ./0 &66?
 
 , 
484


 
 
"

 

, "

 

"


 

 
"
:  
<B  

" 


 # 

+,!

-
 
  
 
5

 
 
(2
#
$


#


 
 : 

"


 
 
2&
# 
"
  # 

+,!

-

5 
  

 
"
"
  

'


,
"   
 
#
 
<B
 

  # 

+,!

-


 * (!&





 


 

 
% 
  
  






 - 




:6




 
 




1 &)"

#2 !$

34561  17 89
 

;

&

<


 


 


 #




 



 
  

 % 

5
 

 8=


 <

"%

#$

348:1 17 ;;9


1
/

  

 
 / 

2
 




>



 


 


 



 
    


 





 


 
#  

1 .#).34 1 17 849


 



;
• <

*





  
 
   


 


 


 / 



 


 

 

/ 

2



 


    

 
  



  <
#######

###### !?

+




  
  






 
 
 




 
 
 


 


 
@


  








@
/ 
  






  


/ 
 



0
06

< .#  $  
  3,4:;-8 ((5589








 





 
+
@
/ 

 




%


   
  # 




6
 

# 

  6 
+
  


 





(

 


  
%






 

  '


'




# 
 
"
 
  #
  
"
 
 



"
$  

 

"


 
"
: 

<$,


5#

 
 






!


  

#
 


"


"" 
"
   #

, #



,
   
$

$ $  
  
   

 
 
 

#
 
)    


/

  

 
"


 
  

: 
0
  
"

 
"  #


, #

'



$ 




  



#

#
 
  

  
   $ 
 
 
 
 




 
"  

 


 


"
 
, $
 
 &

   
 
      
  
"

 
"
 
 
,
 
$ 
 

"  
 


"


, $
 
 
$ 
  
,


 

@    # 0
 


 -( (

 2)#) 3!1, 44)5,6)57

,
/