Suresh Kumar Kataria And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ORS



   




 !




   

"#$ '$()*)%+

,, -./$*0 1.2"/ 1"#"/)"

"+%#0$/ ,,,,,, $#)#)%+$/* 3$/*.* -#"#$ .+4"5 %#0$/*

,,,,,, $*6%+'$+#*
 78 ,

-
 -  /$*$+# /,"0.9 "9):;

/, "/*)2/"# -)+<0 "+'0"=";

'>%("#$* 6$#)#)%+$/*,

/, ">+$$# -)+<0;

-$+)%/

 .+4"5,

, , - ;

,

 8

, /"?$/ )+*#"+# &)9$'

/#)(9$ 
%+*#)#.#)%+ +')";

)+#$/ "9)";

)**."+($ +"#./$ ($/#)%/"/) %/ "+?

%#0$/ "66/%6/)"#$ =/)#;

%/ ')/$(#)%+ "++.99)+< *$##)+< "*)'$ )+(%//$(# )99$<"9 $+#/)$* /$(%/'$';

2.#"#)%+  @ ,@,

 >)99"<$ "'5"*# ;

$0*)9

"9"9"5"';

)*#/)(#

"B)9:";

5$)+< (%+#/"/?

C ,

,

&./#0$/ 6/"?$/ 2"'$ D."*0)+< 9$##$/ ,,

;

)**.$'

$0*)9'"/;

"9"9"5"'

&./#0$/ *$##)+< "*)'$ @,,

;

9$"/+$'

$6.#?

%22)**)%+$/;

"B)9:",



, /)$&9?;

 0$/$)+;

+"2$9?;

-./$*0 1.2"/ 1"#"/)";

"9%+<=)#0 *)59)+<;

"/$ (%%=+$/* "+($*#/"9 6/%6$/#?

2$"*./)+< @ 1"+"9* @ "/9"*;

*)#."#$'

>)99"<$ 1"#0<"/0;

$0*)9

"9"9"5"';

)*#/)(#

"B)9:",

"&%/$*")'

6/%6$/#?

)+0$/)#$'

&/%2 #0$)/ "+($*#%/;

+"2$9?;

"?"9
0"+'

*%+

0"+'"

"2, , "66$"/* #0$/$ ="* *%2$ ')*6.#$ /$<"/'* *0"/$* 0$9'

>"/)%.* *.(($**%/* "?"9
0"+';

9$'

&)9)+<
)>)9 -.)#   .9#)2"#$9?;

2"##$/ ("2$ .6 5$&%/$

C;

("2$ '$()'$';

, , ("*$ =0)9$ <)>)+< $&&$(# "&%/$*")'

C;

/$>$+.$ ".#0%/)#)$* )99$<"99?

"/5)#/"/)9?

$+#$/$'

*"+(#)%+$'

2.#"#)%+  @ %+ ,@,;

=0$/$)+ +"2$* /)<0#&.9 0$)/* )+(9.')+< '$*($+'$+#* %+$ 1"/"2
0"+'

") $>);

)+(9.'$* "9*%;

=$/$ %2)##$',

,@ #/"+*6)/$* %+ 5"*)* $+#/)$* 2.#"#)%+  @;

($/#")+ #0)/'

6"/#?

#/"+*"(#)%+* 0">$ ("//)$'

%.#F "66"/$+# &/%2 5"/$ /$"')+< 6"/"



  

     

 

  

   

 

!

   

"  

 # $

 %

& "

& 

@

#  '

 ("

)  ) 

  *"% +"  ,&

- 

  $

 

 %

" 

 # . 

 -)     # 

"&

&   

) # #   #    

 

 %     

 

&

& 

 

  #

&

 )  "   % )  "   #    

 ) (

 

"

%

"  

$ 

 #     

   

! 

")  

"

 

 &" "

/#  %



)      



  % $  & %

 



   

% " 0" 1 2 "& # 

(  # 

!

) %  "  "

  

"



"

  3 , "66$"/* "9/$"'?

#":$+ /$(%./*$ /$2$')$*;

6"/"*   /$"'

  

" 

"   

 &) 

""



  

   &

 4 #

  ," ) 

 %&

&  # /

&

 

   &  ) 

"  '

 1&& )  

) +'  ++5) & #  



 

 6    '

 1&&

7)     



)    '

 1&&

8)    ++5) 9 (

8)



   +'

:7  

  ::  

'

 1&&   "       ;  #

&



) 

  8  

&

 &  

 # "

   " % ++5) 9 (  9<=  8  8  5 + * %   9<=

   



&

 )

"

)   " 

 ) "

 ; >1 "?) ;7 >9"

?) ;7 >9"

 

. %

+

?) ;7: >9"

   5

1 "?)   4 >1& 1  ?  <   1

 

 

 

 ) 

 # 

 )   

 &

& 

 

"  







3 , &./#0$/ #/"+*6)/$* 0"'

*$/>$'

9$<"9 +%#)($ ,,@

 *.5*$D.$+#9?;

9$##$/ ,,

;

$0*)9'"/;

"9"9"5"'

')/$(#$'

"66/%"(0 (%./# (%26$#$+# (%./# *$$:)+< /$'/$**"9 </)$>"+($,

,

66"/$+#9?;

"66/%"(0$'

&)9)+<
  ;

("2$ ')*6%*$'

%&;

@, ,

@ %5*$/>)+<
 <  #  %& &

%





 

) 

 

# 



  

      '

 1&& ) 9 ( 

"  @

 

8 >,  5/:?  

 

# # # 

 

& & 

 



   

 

  #

% %   "

 " 

 



)   



# 

3 , + (%269)"+($ "&%/$*")'

')/$(#)%+* )**.$'

%./#;

$6.#?

%22)**)%+$/;

"B)9:";

'$()'$'

9$<"9 +%#)($ ,,@

;

*.52)##$'

6$#)#)%+$/;

@,,

+$+A./$ ;

/$9$>"+# $A#/"(#* /$"'



)  

" 

%

)

 &

) < ,&

 - + ) <,+) '

 1&& ) 9 ( 

 

   &      

 %

& #  %  ) 

 

    

  & 

% ) 

) 

 

    52% A =

 )  #

 %

 

%

       &    & $ &  

7 

)  #

%

 

 

 

8: %

 

 2   

 "  3 ,C + "&%/$2$+#)%+$'

()/(.2*#"+($*;

6/$*$+# &)9$',

@, ./)+< (%./*$ 0$"/)+<;

D.$/?

="* /")*$'

9$"/+$'

(%.+*$9 =0$#0$/ "+?

$A$(.#)%+ 6/%($$')+<* =$/$ )+)#)"#$'

/$*6$(#

C )# ="* %+$



$A$(.#)%+ "9/$"'?

6$+')+< (%+*)'$/"#)%+ 5$&%/$ (%+($/+$'

(%./#,

, 1$$6)+< >)$= &"(# $A$(.#)%+ /$*6$(#

C;

"9/$"'?

6$+')+< (%+*)'$/"#)%+ 5$&%/$ (%+($/+$'

(%./#;

&)+'

+% (%26$99)+< /$"*%+ $+#$/#")+ =%.9'

"# 9)5$/#?

/")*$ "99 69$"* /")*$'

0$/$)+ 5$&%/$ $A$(.#)+< (%./#,

((%/')+<9?;

)+*#"+# ')*2)**$';

9$">)+< )# %6$+ /")*$ "99 69$"* *.52)**)%+*;

*%.<0# /")*$'

)+*#"+# 5$&%/$ $A$(.#)+< (%./#,

,

$+')+< "669)("#)%+

*;

)& "+?;

*0"99 "9*% *#"+'

(9%*$',

- 

 

,,

*4:* 0$#0$/ *6$":)+< /$"*%+$'

!$*

% 0$#0$/ /$6%/#"59$ !$*

%