← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRERA-APPL/58/2021dismissed

Apex Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. v. Sachin Kumar

2022-04-26Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal23 pages



!"

# "

$%  & '  

! & 

(

& ) **+ ,( -(

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 4!

5"  &  ( ((1 (

6

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03   '&0  &  (

((1 7(

,

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 0"

"

$  &  (

((1 -(

,

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 4"

&0

 &  (

((1 (

, 

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 54  "  &  (

((1 ,(

,7

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 & 5"

 &  (

((1 8(

,-

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 &"

 

 &  (

((1 (

,

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122

  03 4 & 0

 &  (

((1 6(

,,

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 0



0  &  (

((1

(

,8

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03

5

 &  (

((1

(

,

.

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 

 '&0  &  (

((1

(

76

94 .

%"

&/ 0 ( &( ((1122 03 5 4

5" 4!&0  &  (

((1 !+  :% ( $"4

! 

54    

             

   

     

   

           

   

   

   "

  "   #$  %& "

' ( )*+,&        -   )*+,  -(              

7  .  "  / 0    %  "

 

  &      -0 %

-(   / / 0 %  !/ & -!/ -( 1 / "    " /   2 "   )*+,   "    "

 " 3  !

 " /             

 !

 ""       /       /    4 5 6,$7  8 3   

    

      

      

              

   !"# "   

    !"

  

 



    

   !"    

   !"   

  # $ %   

 

       

    

   

    &    

      

# '      %(%         )



 &    

   



 *$%(%& !"  

-     

 





     

   +  !$    %(% &  !"#, 1 /  6$ )*+,   0"

2  / /4   +**22 +7*$  " #$ )*+,  0"

2  4 /   /4    

)   #$ )*+, 8 3 -$.!/ 

 

    0  &

&    

2 &

   

        

        

           0  &

&    

      ! 22  3  &!' $4 3   1

2 

 



    

 

  & 

 

          

    

           

 (  50    

  61

  2 6

1

2   +  7   

     

  ./8    

 

   

 0  

   ,  4 /

 ."     9 /0 ":)) *) )*+)    )+ *) )*+, !

   /"5 ;6;; <!3=   0 "

 -= 0 -;>

 "  "6$4    +,*****.3 !

&(   +#)****.3 3   

 

  - " &  -  -(8 / +) *> )*+;

1 ;&(      /  ;,   ",     

= "2 ;&(  ;,   ",   / / "  !

 8

3 *39++(++:98

/9 

4 0  



2  *&   3%0;(80900((.+/   

  

  

  

    

 

 

    



  

 & 

&  

   

  &    &       

             <(=(93(%3%0;(80900((.+/ 

&

   <(=(93(%& <(=(93(%    

 3%0;(80

    

.*"/

 &



 "      

    2                  

    > 

     

          ?

  +   < &  2    

  < &  0   < &3 2 < &

   )     

 &          

2   

 &

        >  & 

                 



 @A >0 

  2 



 

         B  



      @A>0

     



 /8

    

   &      

  

 &        

      C

/  0         

  9

, 29+0>??9%<@(  D%973  197+:8D  3%9E(20

 3%0;(80

  

F



       >          



& 

        

 & A &AF   

   

 

     

    ) A    D  

      <(=(93(%   &  8 &  9  &  %    8        D    >      3     2      

   

     

       

    >G

 >

        

   <(=(93(%&   3%0;(80  900((.+/       <(=(93(%   



  



3%0;(800 <(=(93(%

     

    

             

      

          



 <(=(93(% 

& <(=(93(%

     9 29+0>??9%<@(  D%973  197+:8D  3%9E(20



    





   3%0;(80900((.+/



 

         

   9 29+0>??9%<@(  D%973  197+:8D  3%9E(20



 

/:

   

 





  

     %&  %      9           

 

  > 

     D              ;                 

         

              

   &  <(=(93(% 

      

          

3%0;(80&<(=(93(%

&   

&  &   

            &       >    

&%&9           

2  &0  .

/ >  : 

 & .

/

 3%0;(80  900((.+/          

 &         

 

   <(=(93(%      3%0;(80  900((.+/

   

    

     

   

  &        

 

   

      

   2 .

/>0  .

/> .

/,

8 1                "

   1 /                

   &       

/ ?2 )&(   /"     "    / "      /       !

                 / 2 >    8 3 H    

 :

   

 3%0;(80 900((.+/   3%0;(80 900((.+/    

      

  )           

 

 

     &         &    F  

 

   

       

  )            )

    3%0;(80 900((.+/&               

     4

/ ?

    

A    

     

 

  +3  

   

  

& 

  &  

  

& 

  

   

&   



 

  <(=(93(%&   

&



   <(=(93(%3%0;(8090((.+/  



 &               +    

    !&      

       

           

  C / ?

         3%0;(80  900((.+/I  



   

      

&  &   



     / ?

      A    

    

 3%0;(80    

 

  <(=(93(% 

  1 2

   / ?

   

 

         <(=(93(%         / ?

  ;

   >      

  

&

       

 &



<(=(93(%

>   

  >    @   



3%0;(8090((.+/ / ?

 &         )      <(=(93(%&            



3%0;(8090((.+/      



 )      <(=(93(%    



   3%0;(80900((.+/&







/ 



         3%0;(80  900((.+/    

 

  

  <(=(93(%   

        0  2

    

A <(=(93(%   &

  <(=(93(%  



 / <

 >     ).

/

        )

   3%0;(80  900((.+/      



 

/ + >  >



  >

&    

 &      3%0;(80 / ?

              2 >  D  1

 3              

  >      A/      &      

   3%0;(80900((.+/



&

 

              

   

 &  & 





<(=(93(% 

 <(=(93(%

             3%0;(80 900((.+/    

     

<(=(93(% 

 

                3%0;(80 900((.+/ /               3%0;(80 900((.+/

   

6 ;

    1 %

        



><(=(93(%>;:80(882( D(82J       3%0;(80

/ 7  .

/ 

    

  

     ;

    &         

    <(=(93(%

4

/ :





    3%0;(80 900((.+/C 0 <(=(93(%

  

   &        3%0;(80  900(.+/&       



  :<(=(93(%    





 &3%0;(80 900((.+/   .* /         

                <(=(93(%     >        

            7

      3%0;(80900((.+/     &<(=(93(% 

     2   <        3%0;(80900((.+/ 

  1  2

         

   0  3%0;(80  900((.+/

       

  >   

   .* /  &

     

     

        <(=(93(%   

 (  ;

   

  

 

&       &    

&  &  

 F     0  3%0;(80  900((.+/              

  &   <(=(93(%

 

 





  

   

    

  3%0;(80900((.+/   

<(=(93(% 

 3%0;(80   



   <(=(93(%     

 

<(=(93(%

      

        

  

     



 3%0;(80900((.+/

   

: <(=(93(%  

 & <(=(93(%

 &

   

   &   

         3%0;(80  900((.+/    

  &    &          

      3%0;(80 900((.+/&        

  

  

> 

    :



       

&3%0;(80900((.+/  



& &      

3%0;(80    

              < I  



&    < 

     

  

   .

/ 



  

                       .

/  < &   &      

 

" .

/     K!$L          

"

.

/    KL    3         < 

     

  & 

 

    

  

  

         A    



  / :





    3%0;(80 900((.+/4 0 <(=(93(%>

    

           3%0;(80  900((.+/    >   

     

    .H/  :

  

  

 >    3%0;(80900((.+/&

   .H/  &3%0;(80900((.+/  )   K% >F.% 0  9/  ) .      /  <(=(93(%      >    0 <(=(93(%>

    

      

      3%0;(80900((.+/ 

    

          3%0;(80 900((.+/

 !-  03%0;(80 900((.+/     <(=(93(%>

     

  

>      

  3%0;(80          F      >

  0    

       

    

 <(=(93(%



  

   

  2 >&(&( /  +$@   ,*    )6@

=  

2 ;&(&(     +*.34          /  * ;>@ 8 

   1 ""   )*+,  5        )*+,   =    "  ; )*+,

              8  -""  -             

  8)+ *) )*+,

 / /  '!"+6 *;

)*+, 1 

"  !/      %8  '   2 "  &         %'2(        /  "

  !

      "

        '   .5 %    8   %'2 / "

 ?  4   )7 +) )*+, /

8 7    =      "        &(    "    

 " "+#-  )* *, )*+>       = 3    +6 *> )*+>   1      +7#+ )$

 8     "     "  "          ;* *6 )*+>    "    "

"      "     )6 *$ )*+> !

   4  !

"     *6 +* )*+,      / =  "     /;*    )) +* )*+$ "     "   ;* ++ )*+$   " /

*6 *+ )*+7

   )2 !

'!2 "0 +$ *+ )*+7 "     /  /     !

                *$ *) )*+7 ?  *+ *6 )*+7 

                   /   /         5

"  8  " /    !



7  ")$ +) )*+$

A" / 

   /  "   +* >#@     *) *, )*+> 

 B "

   C  "

 4         /  "

""/     



!

 /   /   1        "     )*+>"      / !

       8      "       +6 *) )*+>  

+7#+ )$

/  / "

 !

        4    1   "  " "       <     1              8. "/;) 12 +$>)& - +$>) -(     / /  #, +$>) 

;)#, +$>) 8 3 *  "    #$ %&&#$52    

-

   

          

 

          

 :



&  

   :  ‟ .

/

A  

@@   

   20

   

‟ 

 2   

 ./

A  

@   @

    & 2&   

  &        

  0          



 2     ./   @    @

 2  2  

  

    @  0     -"$ "#"&#' 5    



  

 

              (   ' "#$ #"&#' (5    &

  

&



& &

              

      &

&    



 



"&# % $%!&  "  )('#"&#' (5   

 

   A & &

 

 

&

 A &    

 A &



 

&

   

    

A   

      

      

     

  

   

 

 :  .

/

@

  

 

0



 4 ./ @ 

  @ 



 

& 

0     ./  

@&   

2&

   

 

 



&  

A 

@ 

   F 



 

 ./   A 

 @   

  ‟  D   

  

            

   0   

    

  ./        

 

   

   @9  

 

  0   

   , = ";)   " "   /     1   /"    ;) +$>)  <  /""   

""8</ )*+, 0 "

       <  ;) +$>)

        / / 

/

#, +$>)  !

1    / 1   " /  !

)   /4  /    /    /4 "

 /   " / 

<  #,    / "   <   /        /#, 1  2     /  1   /3    /             <   "

,    "#         !

    "

  

" /   2  " ##%  *    '# "    %   +,-./+0  

 .,+  1     

"  8-  - ! 5  "&D  2( +7,*       2   !

 "    8-  -8               0       "      /  "

  /8     !

  8        / /  1    /   !    " )*+) !

 8  +) *> )*+;

   /  ;,   ; !

 8  "   5 / " ,         8    

        "  /   

30 %

             !

  /8    <   /"   B 

8        !

   /" "

 /        !

 8         !

 %'2 / "

       '  /""/ '!2 "  4    

" 4 /     / / !/  /  +$ )*+, /

    "    //  +$ )*+, 8 3 +-  " "&#5.!/:     

       

     

 

  &   &5 .

/    



   

 &





&        C  ./

   





    

   

 

     

&  



  & 





 



   &

        

&  

  

    & &  &





&

     

 

           

    

 

 

 

   

4 3         



      &        

&       &                &        

&   

    

 ./0     

  

 

  

   &  

  

& 

 

   

&      

    

    

    

     

 

   .*/:   





  



 

 

     

       

 

    

&  

   

  & 

 

   

,  /3++$  )*+,   )&B(&(  "/ /    /4        //    )&B(8 3 .G /   ,              &





 (  5?   

  5 .

/    

       & 

 & ) 

        

   & 

 C .

/        

         

      

       

 & 

                         



C,

   " /   "    !

 //

+# 0

%& "

' (

)*+>&  - )*+>

-(  8 3 !-   

    

 

 

   

        &   

&     

6    

  !:

& 

   



            

     I 



 

  

    

     

.

/ 

  ./ F   .:/+ !$    





  >    



     

 

 F   ./  !'0      

 

     

 

    

  0                &



& + @ A:



 

     :

&  

    

  

   &  

&   

  

 F  .H/  !'4 3         

    +   @ A    :

  .;2%/

  &

           

A   

+ @ A:



  



     ,

   !/     /   

"  10"

 " 2D" E)@

  /   "  / ""  +*.3 4       !/  " "

    1 " /    / "   4  /"" !

        1    2 >&(&( / /   "  +$@  ,*  )6@ 

       /       +*.34            /* ;>@ 8 

 /   / 1            "  !

    " //" /    2         "     #  1 '         *2# $%34+,/.0

53.

% 6

/#0*% # " ##343+/.0

357 2    "  " "

 / /  / /     2    !

  /8  82    % * '%#%)%% 343+/70

39+ 1 /   "   2 /      "      / / 4     /  !

2   4  

    ); 2 +$>) 2       "

/  /""  /

    1              2             " /"  /4 /"  "// #> +$>)

 <    "  

"  :"  %) *% 3434/+;0  

 7+-  !

    "      /4   / 8/   2  <#$ ""  #  %" %*:% " 3434/+;0

.+3 1)# 2 8 " %= /& 0 1   2 <      !

  2    "    "       5 2  '  2  C "     2    /    ,@ 1   /  /   )*+>



    B  4    /   C " 4   /  8"/     /   /  !

 "  

  " "& #   *# # 3434/+40

5-7 1;>   2    3 75

 

  

 3  %(%:  

    A   2 

  !!F !      @   @             8  &   !*     

&             0                3  

   

 %(%;     

 %(%

   *!!              



       

 :

     

+ !$& 

 A 

    

2 .

/

    !H!! !H    

  

  0  &           2 

  

  

  

@  @   

  

2

, <   ; )*+,   / "" !

     " ""  )*+,  "" <    /  ( %

" &  *1  % 343+

/#0    +499                     !

 2 " #>%)# #$>#*1# # 3445/+30

+,-%#    *"

   # #?6  34+,/+,0

.3,     / "   )*+,  1 / "& #   = /& 0  8 "/

  "

  / 

C " 84  /   2  " ( % " &   /& 08        " "" "   " )*+,



" 4 5 $ /     +$ 

     // 

 +# )*+>

/       

 7   3"      // 

4 /   "  

 " ( % "  &  /& 0

24 "   

 "   

, 1*2;



54   $"&     > 

 4J >8      4J >8