Ram Gopal v. State Of Haryana

   

       

!"#$#%&'&()
 !* +!, #-&'&(&'"

.#/'0'

1"!"#!/2!(!

#'+($#("

)  34  1 5 41  /#'#(")6 /1!($7!8!9$-%!"#9//#-&'&(&'" /5!::!$9 !/2!(!  ;7#"7#/"7##+/"#/',%!,(#8'+!+#/*!2<#!,,8#$" '##"7#=0$>*#("?

 <#/##//#$""7##+/"#//(" @ ;7#"7#/"7#=0$>*#("'70,$<#/#+/"#$&("7#$&>#'"? 66 66 41 

4

0'"$2%#/"&&%!"#&,#$&( 0/""$!2!($'!*#&'"!:#(( /#%/$ 7&'/#-&'&(&'$&/#%"#$!>!&('""7#=0$>*#("$!"#$

 
 +!''#$<2"7#,#!/(#$$$&"&(!,1#''&('0$>#9!/&$!<!$9!&/*&(>"7# =0$>*#("%(-&%"&(!($/$#/'#("#(%#$!"#$
9+!''#$<2"7# ,#!/(#$0$&%&!,!>&'"/!"#'" ,!''9!/&$!<!$9-&$#87&%7/#-&'&(&'"8!'

%(-&%"#$0($#/1#%"&('
A9@@!($@6 !($8!''#("#(%#$" 0($#/> /&>/0'  &*+/&'(*#(" / '&B  *("7' 0($#/ 1#%"&( 
A   /&>/0'&*+/&'(*#("/'&B*("7'0($#/1#%"&(@@ !($/&>/0'

&*+/&'(*#("/ (#2#!/0($#/1#%"&(@6  !($&(#'
9 69  &(  $#!0,"    +!2*#("    &(#9  "  0($#/>  0/"7#/  /&>/0' &*+/&'(*#("/"7/##*("7' 8#-#/9"7#/$#/'#("#(%#0($#/ 1#%"&(@@ 8!''#"!'&$#<2"7#,#!/(#$$$&"&(!,1#''&('0$>#9 !/&$!<!$9-&$#=0$>*#("$!"#$

 
 

6
6 #!/$7#,8#/ 0/"&,#+#/0'#$

(AAA9!"!<0"
)90/!(4!, ; 8!'$/&-&(>!

=##+9<#!/&(>/#>&'"/!"&(C6@A !($>&(>"-&,,!>#!(%7!/& /*!,8!, ""7!""&*#9!(<&/9</"7#/%*+,!&(!("917&-!*9 </"7#/&(,!8%*+,!&(!("!($"!!*8#/#!,'"/!-#,,&(>&("7#=##+ "!<0"
)C9=##+/#!%7#$(#!/-&,,!>#0*'!/!<0''"!($!($8!' '"++#$ ( &"'  %//#%"  '&$# 7#  +!''#(>#/' 8#/#  $#<!/$&(>  ( "7# *#!(87&,#9! <0'<#!/&(>/#>&'"/!"&(466
A %!*#/* <#7&($!"!7&>7'+##$&(/!'7!($(#>,&>#("*!((#/!($7&""7#'"!"&(!/2 =##+'!/#'0,"9!(<&/9878!''&""&(>("7#/#!/'#!"=##+9/#%#&-#$ &(=0/&#'(<"77&',#>'!($,#"7!($4!B*!('( &//!=!,'/#%#&-#$ &(=0/&#'!(<&/8!'/#*-#$""7#7'+&"!,&(!("7#/+/&-!"#=##+87#/# 7#'0%%0*<#$"&(=0/&#'  ("7#'"!"#*#(""!!* B;
 9!

%/&*&(!,%!'#8!'/#>&'"#/#$!>!&('"/#-&'&(&'"!* +!, '0++/""7#%%0//#(%#90/!(4!, $/&-#/=##+ !++#!/#$ !';!($"!!* %*+,!&(!(" !++#!/#$!';
(&%&!,/*"7# $#+!/"*#(" 9(!*#,29 77!""!/1&(>7!,'!++#!/#$!';

"+/-# "7!"!'+#/"7#$0"2/'"#/9/#-&'&(&'"8!'($0"2('!&$<0'!'!$/&-#/1 !/!'&$#("&"2/#-&'&(&'"&'%(%#/(#$9&"&'+/-#$/*"7#!%""7!" /#-&'&(&'"8!'(!*#$&("7#!($!'+#/"7#$#+!/"*#("/#%/$'97#8!' ("7#87##,'" <0'!""7#"&*#!%%&$#(" 7#,#!/(#$%0('#,//#-&'&(&'"%("#($'"7!"<"70/!(4!, !($"!!*7!-#'"!"#$&("7#&/'"!"#*#("'"7!"<0'%!*#!"!7&>7'+##$9 <0""7#2$&$("'"!"#"7!"<0'8!'$/&-#(&(!/!'7!($(#>,&>#("*!((#/ #7!'!,'/##//#$""7#'&"#+,!("'78"7!"=##+8!''"++#$("7# /!$"70>7"8!/$',#"'&$#7#/#/#9=##+$/&-#/8!'!"!0,"!($&"8!'

6@6 ("!/!'7!($(#>,&>#("!%"("7#+!/"/#-&'&(&'" !*"7#-&#8"7!"#-#(&0/!(4!,!($"!!*$&$(" '"!"#"7!"<0'8!'$/&-#(&(!/!'7!($(#>,&>#("*!((#/978#-#/9"7#/!'7 !($(#>,&>#("*!((#/&'"<#&(#//#$/*"7#%&/%0*'"!(%#'7#=##+ 8!'  +!/:#$  !"  "7#  <0'  '"!($    -&,,!>#  0*'!/!  !($  +!''#(>#/'  8#/# $#<!/$&(>;7#("7#/#&'!<0''"!($("7#8!29"7# <0'%*&(> /*<#7&($%0,$'##&"/*!$&'"!(%#!($%0,$',8$8("+!''"7# =##+#-#(&&"&'+!/:#$#&"7#/%*+,#"#,2/+!/",2("7#/!$ :!"%7!+!"7 '&(%#&"8!'!<0''"!($8#-#/9&"&'!++!/#(""7!""7# <0'%!*# !"!7&>7'+##$!($8&"70",:&(>"7!"!-#7&%,#&'+!/:#$!""7#<0' '"!($7&""7#'!*#/*<#7&($987&%7&"'#,&'!/!'7!($(#>,&>#("!%" 7#/#+/"*#%7!

(&%'78'#B"#('&-#$!*!>#""7#<0'987&%7&(%,0$#' </#!:&(><"7&"'/(">,!''#'"7"7# 0/"'<#,87!-#/&>7",2 <#,&#-#$"7#'"!"#*#(""!!* %*+,!&(!(" !($0/!(4!, $/&-#/ =##+ 7#/#&'(&,,#>!,&"2/&(&/*&"2&("7#&($&(>'/#%/$#$<2<"7 "7# 0/"'<#,8 7#,#!/(#$%0('#,//#-&'&(&'"%("#($'"7!":##+&(>&( -&#8"7#!>#/#-&'&(&'"97&''#("#(%##&"7#/<#/#$0%#$/7#<#/#,#!'#$ (+/<!"&(#,&!(%#7!'<##(+,!%#$(!0"7/&"2&(1!"&'7.#/'0'1"!"# !/2!(!!($!

/&*&(!, A@9$#,&-#/#$<2!

%/$&(!"#  <#(%7    "7&'  0/"9  87#/#&(  "7#  =0$>*#("    +#B  0/"

$#,&-#/#$&( 1"!"#&*!%7!, /!$#'7.#/'0'!*!,9
C
 

/&*&(!, 
8!'/#,&#$0+(7#<'#/-!"&('"7# 0/"'78'"7!"&( "7!" %!'#9"7#1"!"#7!'%7!,,#(>#$"7#&(!$#D0!"#'#("#(%#<#/#"7# (3<,#10+/#*# 0/"!($"7#(3<,#10+/#*# 0/"":"7#-&#8"7!"

0($#//"&%,#@"7# ('"&"0"&(($&!9&"%!(("/#6!++/#%&!"#"7#

66 #-&$#(%#&("7#!<'#(%#+#/-#/'&"2/+!"#("&,,#>!,&"2<#%!0'#!$&#/#(" -&#88!'!,'+''&<,#7#/#/#9&"$#%,&(#$"/#6+#("7#%//#%"(#'' %(-&%"&(/#'+($#("8#-#/9&"&(%/#!'#$"7#%*+#('!"&( !*"7#-&#8"7!":##+&(>&(-&#8"7#!%""7!"!<0"*/# "7!(+#+,#$&#$!&,2&(($&!&("7#*"/-#7&%,#!%%&$#("9!'"/&%" -&#8&'"<#"!:#( ("7#'#%&/%0*'"!(%#'9$("&($!(2>/0($" /#$0%#"7#'#("#(%# /#-&'&(&'"&(+/#'#("%!'# #(%#9/#-&'&(&' $&'*&''#$   #-&'&(&'"9  87  &'  (  <!&,9 <#  /#!//#'"#$  "  0($#/>  "7# /#*!&(&(>+!/"'#("#(%# 

41   


 '=:' ;7#"7#/'+#!:&(> /#!'(#$ ) #' ;7#"7#/#+/"!<,# )