High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/629/2023disposed of

Gurwinder Singh v. Gurcharan Singh @ Tikka

2025-08-28Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj5 pages

!"#!$%&

''( )! !&!$%&*+,,

! -! .!&''(

///// "#$%& &"'()"#* +'",-

+&''(&(#&'!''( #!$ 1!

!%!(2(''(%&3' %# !#!##

'#45(!#6 #(%!7(8

3!!8"&!458&!( !&9 #!'# # 3'( #!$ !# "&$1 &.%4( 7! 3 8

!&!8:& ;

<;4($ '!3 ! .% $,$%/012 03"340", 5% 3"3"%$6"'"3 /4* + +'0203",- 7* ! #!4( # #3'!2!'!$0 #0 1 !

8( ##&&23&!%&(''( #!$ !

4!& !$ (2'!&# = #%3 #!

>0 +&!!&42#!! #4(4!#((" ?!(58&23!33 &24( !%&'!!''("&&4! 3!4# 455#'!# 7&823 #!$ & 8 8'5!&&(#!

&9 '!"&& !#&3' &33#45'!"&&!%#& 83(58& #8"&&9 &4 #& !# $#(58&!%&23!33 4 '(#'!"&&!%& #"&& !#28"&83!!%&'!! ''( #!$01&!

'! 2#!3&&!%&'!!''( #!$013!!%&#4% 4=# 5 # $3(!(58 23 !38 "&2! 4 & ! & !38 #((53 &2!%&'!!''( +&!#(58!&!&&-!(3 & %&!&'!2 4 0 "& 3#%5#'!#4 (((# 45 & 23 8 "&& @'! ( ( #&(%(!'!2##23 "&'!!''( &!!58%!#!9 (8 &$8&! %&&- 4(-! !'!! ''(2&3'(#'!! & ''(8& %& ! &''("&&(2 & ! <"2!8("5!5!& $!3'('!!''( A "&

3 23B !%& '!! ''(8 & ,%'((2''(!3& <%& ! #!$0 1&!

" (#4 !!5"&&4##45&-!(345 !&'!2$0 &!

? !&(58&-!(3&3##$ ! 3!4&23B!%&'!!''( = &"&!%!#3'(!&$ (%''( &&!&#8&-!(3& !#&'!2$0 2% '!!!%&!&23'!! ''(&%! #3#&!3'!# 3'(

?&(58&2(23&$!' #!$ & ' 454 +&4 &3'((# #!

&'!2& !'!23'( '!$ &!

#$1& 45@'!!'!&'!2& !

&3!!( &#3# !#!3( +&!!8&3'(8 "&&23#& !&9 3 4 ! #423!3&'!2$ !#"& &#23 #!$

"&!

? !&!8 ''(5% & #! '!'2 2!! (%8 <;4($ '!3 ! 0'$4/8'"/$ $5$31$ 3/$,,0:$34$ 5% "# ;12"'

'8'"

'0203", <<$", 8

)0/& '0203", <<$", 8 = > ($40($(

= > * "&((!5%&

1 = #%3&((4''(4(!!'2(58&&(# #! > +&#(! #(%"& 42 !%&845&(%( !8#!#4'!'2 ( @'!(5 ! 45 !5 3'( 3# &2 !!'2'! +&(%(3@3D.2 ? !?!373'!48.-!!D#% &"(" %&!% ("&(("#& '8!!"&'! 3''!'25#& '! 3'%!((5#'! (&!!5 &" 45 @'! '!2 & ! & !!'25 &!" #!4( &! %& !5 3'( +& 4 & " (# &2 & 9 %2#!

%&83'"4 !#! 3'! @% 4(% <"2!8 "& # !#!%'!%!#&!''( '!2 49 (52!! (#45&#(!%! 4&8&9 &2!! (%!,(5#! #45# (8!!'2 &0% 0% ?$4"1%$ 0/ 0% %$//,$( ,") /&"/ /&$ ,") ($4,"'$( ?@ /&0% 81'/ 0% '$/'8%<$4/05$ "3( 0% 38'2",,@ "%%12$( /8 ?

+&'!"(5# !! (3 4 # "& & = #%3 #1(:2$3/ 8'

($40%083 )&04& 03/$'<'$/% "

%/"/1/$ 8'

<'850%083 /&$'$89 ($4,"'$% /&$ 2$"303:

/&$ %/"/1/$ "% 0/ %&81,( ?$ 483%/'1$( 9'82 /&$ ("/$ 0/% $3"4/2$3/ 3 8/&$'

)8'(%* /&$ #1(:2$3/ ($4,"'$% )&"/ /&$ ,$:0%,"/1'$ &"( %"0( "/ /&$ /02$ )&$3 /&$ ,") )"% <'821,:"/$( "3( /&$'$98'$* 0/ &"% '$/'8%<$4/05$ $99$4/&!!58& !&! ( "&&'! 3#4'!'2 (@'!(53# !!'2 E&(("!3&38&#! = #%3 %'!'(("''(4(((

!!'2&%'#54!#! ! 3"&&4 #&3%& (""&&@#!3&'&!# !'!2 E&&4#(!#4&("&(# 3 4&(#&2("54&("&(# +& ( (3!3&!(&&# 5& !D'! "("4 3# @' #&(#D 3'&### +&!!82"&= #%3!#!#45&<;4( $ '!3 ! $,$%/012 03"340", '! # 0'$4/8'"/$ $5$31$ 3/$,,0:$34$ '!8 (!# $ 6 #%8 !#8 #!#!&'!(2''(''((# #!$ !

#! &3&''!'! !!#'( 3!

%!5#!##&3'(''!4,#& !!#&(!#$6 #%8!#8!&"&

'#8!#%(5 -#%''(858( ##'#

+ !- 7 7

E&&!$',%F # GF. E&&! '!4( GF.