High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1767/2008dismissed

Sumitra Devi v. Ranjit Singh Etc

2025-05-26Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi10 pages

#1#

!" #$%$!&'()() *+(*,+$- .$

&/$*$&01 -%

' 23

( ***

!"# $ % &

' ( )* +++ **4( 3 * ( *- (.

) / ( !!0##001

*- (

& 2 , % *-

( ( ) !1!##004

*- ( & ( 3 % ((% # 5 0106#0#6

! "# % (-% -

, *- ( *- *

#2# 0106#0#6

* *(

!"# 7 , 25 * #!0#!889,) %

!1!##004*- ( & ( 3 ,

( ( % ((% !!0##001 *- (

& 2 , 3 *- /

! " # ((( , % (0901#001

( % #8 - 25 4 ,* :%% 3( $;1!6 ;73 : ; 3 (% (70!!889<=:

( 3 (( - !887

) % '

(> (( ?

;

@ (( ( 3

(( ( -% -

, (

%: @ ,

(( 46>( !6 ( ( (( 2* -!887@

= # ( (

46 >( !6 ( (

((;

- ( % (- /

(- *- (

, % (

#3# > ' %

( % ( 1.8 ( %

( (A>( !# ( (* > ;#8..#- !88#; ( * & ( ((? * *- (

( (

##!886 (

-% ((%

(

( ( ) %

(- ((% 6 (% : *- 3 / - % : - 3( 3 * % (25 ;64 #!0#!889 <= :.! % 4#0.491.4A!.!#0@ 5(: ;63 ,5 ?

!9!

-(: <=@ - <= B ( )* > ' % <=<2 <=C6.C6.@ 9 2

- % 4#05%- ( (- ( ( A 5

* =; > 3( C! @* C # : ( C6 > $(/ % C6* ( *- ( 1 C!;> (( (

#4# ##!886!A#!886!17!886 (= :*-

) '

(> %

-*- ( - <= $ - <= % *-& 8 C# > @* ( %

##!886

(9 (

7#0600. ( : $ *

= ( :

* * *-% $( -% / *- (

!0 C7 : ( *

- !887 ( ( -% -,

% % *

%: @ -* /

- / = -= - !886/ 67.4 (

7#0600. 1.8 %

( ! ( ( ( ( ; ( *

( **-- (( *

(<=: @ %

(%%

#5#

*) !! C4:

- !886 % 2

3 ###!889 %

!9! $ % *-

- -<=

- ( ( <=@

C! ; > $ (

((% *-$?; @$? (: ;63 !# C6 5 @

#!#!889 25 (<=: :: ; 9 $ - 25 =:.! !7 C6 > $(/% !87!886 ;A!1#A!17* <=C6.C6.@= *-'

(> ) /

( ( :%% 3($( ( (* % % (% 46>(!6 ( !4 , % %

7!7 % -(((( ( ( ( !6 @ (

* *- ( & (

#6# ) !1!##004 "" &# % ,&5 -* #$!& * & &#

6* $& 5 "

,7 !" 9+ &!""$& 4#05

5 0# D

#000.

5 0! !9 ,

! " #

( % *((%*- (

& 2 , 3 ) !!0##001 *-/ !A , ) / ( (( ( !1 , ( (.

(% (

!"# ( ( ; ( * #9!!!88# ( ((% ( (.

<=@ C % = (

% %

- ( - ( ( ; ( ,

- ((- . ( ( - *-

( (

. (%

( (

!"# ,

4#05 ( (- , ( (-

/ ) * % - * % $

) / (

*- (

& 2 , (*( * ) , (

!"#*

!8 ,

! " # %

(

#7#

( , * *( *- * (- (.

- (

! " #

(* %) (%

(( (*(*

#0 5 ( #! ( (( * = ( ( (

/ (: = % *-( *- % - % ,

C# > (%

% %*(%

% % - % C# > ( =

(% = ##!886 !6 - , ( (% =

%- = (@ ( <= @ 7!!!886* - %** ##!886!A!#!886

(-5 <=DE ( 7!!!886 7!!!884, ** C#>

* * (% $ - %

= ( , =

<=@ * = *- @ ( *

% ;% (= 3

#8# C!;> ( *

*% ( =*- ,

= (C4 : ( (-

(

= ( <=B= ; ( * *

( %

= C4 :)

((* *- (% - / -* (( *- ( C!;> (

( (

* ( (*- $

C#> % ( *

% $

( 4#0.49A.4A!5* 25 ;708.!819 : ;63 (( = ( ( 5 ( <=: ( ( = ( ( *

7#0600.

C! ;> (% ( = * = (

!#0000.

* ( ( - $

= (

#9#

#( * *-

7#0000.? C#>

7#0600. * % *- (

( 5

=%* -

*- (

$( % % % / , ( / % *-

= ( $% % *-

(

7#0600. F

(- (( %

( ( (

- , (- * (

* (

## &* - !88486<=< > ' %

!889<=2% (% % ( ( *-

( (* > ; #8..#A>(!# ( ((* ( ( ; ( * (<=B#9!#!8865

( ( A >( !# ( ( * > ; #8..# ; ( * (% ( * (C6 > $(/% % ( =

#10#

( #7 - #9!!!88# <=B (( * = *-

; ( * $%

* - (%

% =,

= * ( * > ; #8..#

A >( !# % *

( - % , = ; ( - -

( (

* , = <=B ( *

(-*

(<=B

* #4 5% *

5 *- *( *

94)