Union Of India, Through Secretary, Ministry Of Defence And Others v. No 04175174 P Ex Nk Ts Janak Raj And Another
!"#" $ $%
!" &% '(& ))
) *
'(& )( * #"$%& '#()*(*+",-* ./!0 '*,"! #/+",-**" ' / /*1*+",-* ./!" )
) *
+, (- /#/ / * 3 !+ / ! / !*%./#*"./""*"4456789 *!*"$%/(*"1"- $*(--"+3/$% / !" 3* #*" / $. . "# ..+ / . -1!#/"*$(%(1,8*8,"*$(%!
!
.
/ !012 .$3 4
!"3*(("/1%4::5 *"3*"-/*#".1,-3.;::: <=/ "-/*# .1 / ,-+ / !" 3* #*" .((3# "*$(%$.*(#3//"
; /!".("+$./ $*(--" */./#*.$..$*"$*"#0"#.."*$(% (1.14> > /*"*!!(-*3**((3"," ""*"4456789 /!*,!*./*" "7*-"/*.
! " #"
$ %
# &
# #
'
#&( )
* " +, (# *##," .1 / *. "+ / !8 ."*/*.("/*#*/*3! ).45"##" $# /
2$ 3! .$# / 2 7
"
" $ 2#
/+/(*"-(./!8 ."*./"69.,*?"#1$%/ @$( !7<+3/$%+
./$1/*,3.
/7!(*.(*31*"/+/(*" $*(--" /("/*,-"/#*.**/!"./ %* A *((%+*.-="$1*"!**#*!/ *"A./,"-""$%/ @$(!7<-* ("*
!""""#
$%&'#(
) ! )) *
+ ,*
*-.
/
1& $.+"-"";545 /*"!**#*!/ *"A $-17*-"/*. % ! "## # ( # - "
* # " + # * # "
&# (! " +.$
"
" / ( #
"
( 0 # " ## "
" " "
-" 1" $ $ (
# ( (
2
""
# 3 $ #
" # 2$ #
1" #((
" #
" #
4#
5" (
" 4 "
( & 5" 67"
5"
#
" 5"
#
! 6 7"
-"
#
" (
# #
(
" (
"
"# ,
*"#.!**#*!/ ./,"-6!*9-(*(% "-/.*-/*-**%-(*1/$%/,-."(*% *"(*-/+/(1*(%*..-#/*!!,"".*$( #/=*/*1%!(+$(*#(%!*%18.7* . !*% !+ /$%+ / *" "(*%" -(*1+ */ /* $-1#*#/3*%?-"+/+="$*((3"+$3/ *./*/**.!$#-"!*!"./ %*!/"*..(#./3! 5 /*"-*!**#*!/A/.+/!7< "-(*"/*/ #/<3*?.""-/(*. **.!-,#*!".A%**"/*3/ : /*",3*(*!!*/*,$*--!"* ?"#1$*#
! #
$%&' #
(!2( *
&.
/ + ,*
* -.
3*4 ** /(,*!**#*!/3/.* 7*-"/*.
"
"
" ###! (
"( 0 " "
,
* *
*
.
. % %* 54.
1
4. .
4.
4%*$
*
* %.
!67" $ # #
"
# " ("
" ( #
" "#
## 67" #
" #
"
"#" % $
*64* $.
1. * .
/# 0
($
#
8 #
#
# 67" "
" #
!
"
).45"##" $# /
2$ 3! .$# / 2 2 #7 $3 $ ///*"+/(*"-(./!" $1/*/*.*"?"#1**!!(-*$(/* -*+ * / 11$ . / ".- -1$** *$(/1 3* *(*"%-!./"*$(%!*"/*/"31. /*!!$./-/#/1*B#."#69..+/ 3("(%(*?.*$(-*! !!./*#1+/!(*-"(*-*/ "# C-/ ?"#1 !*" $% / @$( !7 <+ 4:4A+-*("* 8"$3 2)"$169# $" $ $3"
$3
2#+3/-/ "8"/77
/ ::; ; *#" / (,*!**#*!/./*","-*7*-"/*. ! " . 9
& #3 ! " ' 1
2 7 .&:
" !! "
(
#
"- -"
# #" #
#(# ! "
"
$$$$ $$$$ /
#
! " $
! " ;
<8
"
#
"
"- -"
# #" ( #
/ "
(
: , $ $!
# 6"# .2 4 /#/+,$(%-**%"(*%"1*"$%/ *##,"3/$%*-/*((#-*"*"-(#"!*" $%/--"+/!+/*#.*"(*%"1$1*B /*1$/$%/,-."(*%*"(*-/ 3,+/ 7-!/*$,!-!(+*("/#/,"--""$% /!7<-*("*+ ,*
*-.
/ 0
1 & $.# %
(*"-*("*&.
/ + ,*
*
-.
# %
(3/*+%/".-!(--"+$-1# ("8.7*.!,8*8,/1+$3/*./" /*/*"$-"(%.*!"./%*.1/ "*..(#./! ; C/**1*%+*./7-!,/!* 7*-"!**#*!/+*--/,"-6!*9""$%/ !7<+/7+/*-**".*$(#/$-1 ,"/*##,"+/!+/*",1.*".*$( #//*##,"+/3(".(*-#*- -* . *- ,8*8, / *##," (*(%+ /$% / "(*%"*#.*-(*1+/3("**-/*//$* .(1*/$%*%!!",-."(*%*"(*-/ 3("..-,(%.
-**1$(#$(-B*#*/#*#. /.(((./*##," "1#3///-*.*-3/-/*--" ,8*8,/!!"/3**-#*- -*.*-$"."1#3//*/,%-!+ *".*$(#/,"/!!"+/$%+ -*%$*1"/.*-1/*+/(,*-*.*- *--"/!!"+!+/1*B#.
@$(!7<-*("*'
$" $ $3"
9#
58
2@+ !") $/"$ <;+"-""44+3/+ *"-(**1*"/7+/*/$.."#..+
*/ /* $-1 "3" / --" / (,* !**#*!/*--/,"-6!*9*7*-"/*. 91 * + 5" ("
" "
# " # " " #
#
" ( # ( "2
! * + "
7 " : * +44=*>27+
" ? = @( #
A
# ( & # 3
> ( " (
& # 3 > # ( %/ ( "
/ #"-"#* +
* + "2
#
! #
# 0 67"
! "
#
/.+-/*"".*$(#/$-*1," /!!"+!+/1*B#./,"-$%/!7 <+-*("* '
$" $ $3"
9#
58
2,#.72 - =(+/"-(**.(*31*"/,"-6!*9+3/" *..-,#/$-1"3",8*8,/--"+/
$," (*(%+/"31./*"#/+,8*8,/ --"+ / $-1 / - . / /.1 "1#+ 3// !1! =( / */ / ! !"*"*-(*1+*"+*"1/3/ A
- / ,"- 6!*9 $-*1 !-" 44*"/!"*"1./*","-+/* 1$./ $*(--"+/%*45 /#/+/ !"1./,"-6!*9""**!1!1 !*-/+$*"*1(%*.*"(*%.*$ ;D %* *B# !(*- 3,+ 3/ / "31 1*" /",8*8,/!!"+$**((%-."* ".*$( #/ =* /1 /.+ 3/ / ".*$( #/ ,"/!!"*//#/,"-6!*9$ --1*(% *( -." * - *" -# -* . *- =* / ! !" (*(% *( /" * ".*$(#/$-*1,"/ !!". / B#=*/*!!"#..$#1*"/.*,
, /3 - / "-(** . (*3 1*" ,"-6!*91*B/*""-(**$*7!(*.(*3 1+/$%+/7!(*.(*31+*1*","- 6!*9*(1*B//"-."$.,8*8,/ ".- !( --"+ + #
+ *( ( / --"+/**%1B/#*#./"31*
1*"/"+*"/*+/.((-1!(1+*!( /"+$"!-,./$*."(*%*"(*-/
"$ / 23 2 6"# .2 5 *.1*/+/<."1/3! *" 3/ / $,* *.*"+ / *1 "1" / 1!#""1**"*"*..1" :
-/1*-*(./*$"-""+/+*((/ !"#*!!(-*69+.*%+*(*"69"!". ,)
) *
- ,( *- B*,#/ 6
2#7
0"$1=2
# $ % #= 6
22 7 2
4/
% #=