← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/41/2021dismissed

Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Central) Gurugram v. M/S Maharishi Markandeshwar University Trust

2024-09-24Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth11 pages

-1- 

     

   





     !!" #$ %

&'

&(

( &) (*+

%

,!

#-     





     !!" #$ %

&'

&(

( &) (*+

%

,!

#-     





     !!" #$ %

&'

&(

( &) (*+

%

,!

#-    ! 





     !!" #$ %

&'

&(

( &) (*+

%

,!

#-   " 





     !!" #$ %

&'

&(

( &) (*+

%

,!

#-  "   





     !!" #$ %

&'

&(

( &) (*+

%

,!

#- 

-2-

 # 





     !!" #$ %

&'

&(

( &) (*+

%

,!

#-   $ %&

 ''(

)''

  %&

 ''(''  & +% ( (!"".

.

"!

 (  & -( ).! .

$% 

/, &$/(

%0 "$%   & 

).

"$% (        (  %  *( ((%/ ) !"( 1!  2*%(  (%/ ) $033  (  

  

         

!!"( (  "

(343 

/,(  $ /!

( 5 (6 70*(

*(/, ( 

((



     (

/ 6(7

!

89(  $ 383  (6($ 7 (

"( 

/,($

/ !

1!

(

 (-% ! 

"  

($

" 

 

",($

 ;3 9 5   *( ( /  1!  ( (  !,  

         <   %      9338



 

"(  =&'

&(

(  &) (*  +

%

,  !

  !       &! 

 $/  (6&&+!

7 *(/, 

(

/,

-3- 1 

"(   (

  

"   !!

3>?("

    !(  !

  @ ( ! 

 

  





  

 

 



!"#   

 

  $

 %

 %  

&

'     

( )*)* $  $   +   , 

$  

- )*)* &

.

   

/          ,   0

1  0

1 

 % $ %

%

$  

2 2,  3



 0

1  $ $

 9 (

%)

" * !

89($  %

(

  (

 !

  @5  

         /     

+   (#

0   ,1

#

0  "    

"   0

    

  +   1   # 

 #  -   %

! ,1



/   ! 01

/

   %  / 

 70





-4-  / 1 0 (

%

!

 ,   

    (



!

89($ (

*(  ,  /,($

 

(

% " *( (*  

 "(/,(

"

  A !

 

 ( "( "(  /, (  

 (    

   

.

(

" ,(!

/,/)

"/"!

  !B / (   (

% "  / %(( (

 "



 (

 *

!/!(

 

* "

 (, /, &&+!

/"!

  /

*2!" ,/

"  (!

 /,&&+!



"

   &&+!

(

/ (/,(  %

"

-  

% ! /, &&+!

( / (/ "

$ 

"( !

0-C!* (!0- !

 ,  (/* "! (  (&&+!

% 

"(%

&  !

 ., ( ( ( / ( "

 (*

% !

$

 ; /,( "

"

33>38( 

/  (( % "

"*( (*  ( "/(  $  /!

( *("( ($(

 343 

"

(

/,((

"(( $

( * (%   , ( /!"( ,(

"  %

(

" , (!

/,/)

"/"!

  !

(

 (" ,     *( (



-5- > D  !

(-% !(  ( "( ($ 

"((

/,(!

89( $   *  ,

 /,($ ((  

(

% " (

 *( (*  

/,( $

.(( !( !/ ( ((

 (    (/ !

*( (* 

"

((*  

!  .

(,

(  !

*!!  8 D  !

(-% !!( !/ (( 

 (" * !,   (!

( /

( 

! 

 



( !/

(($  %

/(! (

% " /,(

 ( ! 1! 

"( .((   1!" .! !  

  !! "# #$#%9$- . 3>B  & ' !() %*#)# +% , %

%

 % +% , % 388    .-  94B  -+   .    (   

/#0( ! %#384 8E -4B #  .(( * !

/#0(  !)## 3E9 .4B  %

5 (1!" (

!



  )3 9 ->E

!(  

 E D   .

  !

    (    

  (

(*%!( !/

  !

(-% !(

/ (( $( !

(

% " 

-6-    ((      "/ 

 (  !,/ !

!

"

% " *((% !/ 



!

( ,   /,(

 * * (" ( 

/

"!

  "

, 

("

  (&&+!



(   *((* ,

(

" (!

*   !/ (($(  ( C!

* (  "   ( % !

 

    /% *  

 /, ( $

*((

%,  



"(  (   !

"

% " ($

"

:  

"(   (  ((  !

*

/,( % !

,  4 D .

 !

(

  !/ (( * !

89($   /

%) ,*(( ( (

/,($

/ !

 ! (

!*( ( !

1! (

 (-% !

!/  ( /( !

(( "

% ,

"

   (( $

(   !  C!

   

  !/ /, .

 !

(

 (*( 

"(!

89($ (   ($

) C!

 (*%(   *( C!

 C!

/!( /,( .(

!/ ((

/,(*  "(,(/% 

* ($ *  ,

 0 !/   C! *

(

/,($ (* 

,  */,(

!

-73 D   .

  !

    (      (     

1!"    (  2 "(  ! 

      

 

%)# 

1#( %%#(- +$#% 3 93- 34B

! )   33 99>- 49B

), )#$#% 33 99 -38EB

 ( #* 23$#%

3 9>-39>B$03383 - ! 

*.! 0  #.!-# # $#%  >E3B1!" (

!

 

.- 1 ## ! 3 9-33B $0> 3

2# !3$)%   

2% 3  3

!( !/

 33 F(% !, 

( !/

 (*  /% 3 ( + 

 * ((

!

 .  89($ * (($

(

  !

B  / (($

7 *( (

 !

(  !

 !

"1! (

 (-% ! (!

 

 (  C!

,*( (* ,  ! (  /  /,($

    ( !

((

 !

2*% ($

(

 ( 

% "   ! /,(

   (  G!*

!

394($ B( 

!

C!

(

  



"(,(%  ! ( (   !

! (  

/ 

,

-8- 

/ !

&,/ !

(,(  

 (  %  (    !  *!  ((  /%

(*%

 ,   (  *((( /

 !

,    ) *(  

,/) /,( !( ,

* *(,  ( "

( ($

*! / 

 39 F(%   (

/,($*( ()

 

  ( %,    /%5(  /!

( -% ! ! (

% "  /,(

 (  (  G!((

 * !

/,( /!

  (  ((  !

((

"

(*( (  (

 7  "%

"(    /

" "

  

  !

    /  * "!     !  * (  ( $

"  : 7   *(

(  (

 ! (%

"/  /,(      *( (( /  ( "(!

(%

"  (   * 

 , !/  C! * *( (**! 

(   3 (

"

($*(,  !,/  (    *(       (  ,  (%  /      (  

  ( * 

( !



-93>   1!"  %/,!

 

 %(  - .##- !1%) 7$#%  34*(%( !

  8 9 #  1  



,

   

         0 

       

,1 

2!2 

  

:;2 

  1  0      ,1 

  :;2 

      

05   #,   /

 - 

%

! 2  # - 

%

! ,#7,1

:;21/ 





  

,1

!

05 

 



    <  

  



#   2



    

  0# 0 

    +  1  /     ,  

05 

 #  =/#   /   



  :;2    

     

%

%  

/0,  #  6  8>>  1 

1 



#

0 (+  1  ,1

!

0 5       1 

     0

#  



(    0 

      

 1           

   1   (    4

  



 / #

0  +  1       ,1 

  !

0  5  ,  

0



   2

  , 



  

  

38 $

5 ((

!



2% 3

!

( ( !

 

-108 2   

    

 - 

%

!

/    ,   16 )*   

!

05 

, #   

 )*    <  

  



?#    & - - 0; 



  

,1

!

05 //



,

@  )* - 

%

! 

,                   /   +  1   #    /      ,1 

 !

0  5  ,  

0

  

& ;  

      

 /   

+    #  / 



#,, # ,,1

!

0 5 

      7

     /

@  

  - 

%

! 3E ( $  ! 

 

,   %)# !    $#%   4#

 *  .E34( ((=    <  

  



 #

 , <  /

 

  

 ,1 

  !

0  5  @# 1  

   #       +   !

05  ,     <  

  



 #  /  6 5  



 

, /   

 

 #  /   /#/

 

,

 5   7#//

/ 

;

   0   ,  

 

   <  

  



 #



  #/  7  ,1 

  6   5  

,/ 4

-1134 (1!" /,  !

(-% !*

(((

!

89($ *

 , ( "/(2 "(! (.!!( (((** % /* ((

 ( 

 (1!

*( (* % 

 3 (   (*%* 

"(  * !

89($  )

"

% *(1!" 



,  %)# !  $#%

!  *   

 (, / !

( "* ((% *) /,($

"

: *(( 

!( C! (

  

/

((

 !

(($





* (!  

$  % * 

/,(

/, ( .  89 ($( ( "(, 

((!(

"(($

F ( 

 ,  

(    (  

",



 3 $

" 

 

  

",  0   '(

)''



  # '(''

%

  F(( )

"'  ; '0 F((/ ; '0