Dinesh Gupta v. State Of Punjab & ANR


    
 

 !

"#$ %$&'(')*+,-./ 0

')$(1+2#"


 3 #"#$ +)4"5 

   
*







6$($)#* 16'7'86"9)")%/%3&"#$/ 6#1$2$#'#')$6 ('92,$4$$#:"+6/(('(#")#%3&"#$$)$6",/+)4"5

66$(2)%$)# 16':

"))/%3&"#$ 66$(2)%$)#
  6",!* )%$ $6$)&$##1$6%$6%"#$% ; 0/,$"6)$%
+)($, 6 6$(2)%$)#<&92,"')")#=&'$#-1"(26%+&$%"6$(,+#')2"(($%5- #1$("'%&'$#->1$6$5-16'"(19')%$6 '6')?1/&92,"')")#=,%?$6 #1$'92+?)$%/>11"22$)(#5$#1$6$('%$)# #1$&'$#-1"(5$$) %+,-"+#16'@$%5-#1$&'$#-#2+6(+$#1$,'#'?"#'))'#(5$1",  1$26$($)#2$#'#')1"( 5$$) ',$%5-#1$2$#'#')$6+)%$6 $&#');. #1$
%$ 
6'9')",6&$%+6$/

1$6$')"

#$66$ $66$% #"(A
6
B! 6($$8')?C+"(1')? ; %"#$%  / 6$?'(#$6$%+)%$6$&#')( ./;/;D /;D./;

#1$)%'")$)",
%$/

.D  1$6$')"

#$6  6$ $66$%  #  "(  A
B!  "#  ,'&$  #"#') 
'3',  E')$(/ 96'#("6
'#-))$F+6$ !")%",,#1$(+5($C+$)#26&$$%')?()#1$ 5"('( #1$&9269'($%$$%%"#$%. ))$F+6$!

 7'%$6%$6%"#$%  0/"
6%')"#$ #1'(
+6# 1"(%'6$&#$%#1$2"6#'$(#?$##1$'6(#"#$9$)#(6$&6%$%5$ 6$#1$#6'", &+6#  1$,$"6)$%#6'",&+6#>"(",(%'6$&#$%#($)%'#(6$26#>'#1 6$?"6%##1$3",'%'#-6#1$6>'($ #1$&9269'($"

#$66$&6%')?#1$ (#"#$9$)#( #1$&)&$6)$%2"6#'$( ; )&92,'")&$ #1$"

6$("'%6%$6/6$26#1"(5$$)6$&$'3$%

69#1$,$"6)$% 
1'$ +%'&'","?'(#6"#$/96'#("6#16+?1#1$,$"6)$%

'(#6'&# $((')(+%?$/96'#("6",)?>'#1#1$&2'$( #1$(#"#$9$)#( #1$2"6#'$(1$2$6"#'3$2"6# #1$6$26# #1$,$"6)$%+%'&'", "?'(#6"#$'(6$26%+&$%"(+)%$6* A




 

 




  



 

         ! 

   

"#

$  

%& '
(
)*+++$

(
*'

% 

(   &



    ,( -.$

(
. /

(   

    ,  -   

             

    0

 ! 

   

   1


2 0

      

         +3
4
+4*3 

                
       0        

    

 



"   00 

   

    

"  

  


! 0  0

"            0  !  

   

  (
*35      / 6  7

   8 "  "  



 ! 

"  #

  $             

 

00 



 "

"0 

   
9

0 E$"6)$%&+)($, 6#1$2$#'#')$6&)#$)%$%#1"##1$2"6#'$( 1"3$"9'&"5,-6$(,3$%#1$%'(2+#$")%#1$&)#')+"#') #1$26&$$%')?( >',,5$")"5+($ #1$26&$(( #1$
+6#1$&9269'($/5$#>$$)#1$ 2"6#'$(3,+)#"6',-")%>'#1#1$'6 6$$>',,/(1+,%5$?'3$)%+$>$'?1#"?$ ")%#1$26$($)#26&$$%')?((1+,%5$C+"(1$%(+226#1'(&)#$)#')(/ 1$6$,'$%+2)#1$4+%?9$)#(6$)%$6$%5-#1$)G5,$2$F
+6#')
  





   !")%   "  ##    $ "  %&    

   

  ' ")%",(5-+,, #1'(
+6#')()%  $ " 



*!

   
D 1$ "&#+96$?"6%')?&9269'($5$#>$$)#1$2"6#'$(1"(",( )#5$$)%'(2+#$%"#5"65-#1$,$"6)$%#"#$&+)($,E$"6)$%&+)($, 6 6$(2)%$)#1"(",( "'6,-&)&$%$%#1"#')3'$> #1$&9269'($ $

$&#$%5$#>$$)#1$2"6#'$(/#1$&92,"')")#=3'&#'91"()54$&#')' #1$ '92+?)$%")%#1$&)($C+$)#'",26&$$%')?("6$C+"(1$%

(2$6#1$26($&+#')",,$?"#')(/#1$"&&+($%2$#'#')$6/>1 >"($)?"?$%>'#1#1$6$(2)%$)#&'$#-"(" '6$&#6/'(",,$?$%#1"3$ 9'("22626'"#$%#1$ $$+($%#5$&1"6?$%5-1'9 69#1$(#+%$)#(/ #1$6$5- &"+(')?  +),"> +, ,((  #  #1$&'$#-")%  +),"> +,,- $)6'&1')?

1'9($,    $('%$(  #1'(/  #1$  "&&+($%2$#'#')$6  '(  ",,$?$%  #  1"3$ 6$93$%=(#,$) +6&1$C+$,$"3$(5$,)?')?##1$&'$#->1'&1>$6$ $)#6+(#$%#1'9/")%"

#$6 6?')?#1$('?)"#+6$( #1$6$('%$)# #1$ &'$#-/  >'#1%6$>  ")  "9+)#    (;./=  69 #1$  "&&+)#(    #1$ &'$#-  (  2$6  #1$  +6#1$6  ",,$?"#')(/  ")#1$6  "##$92#  9"%$  5- #1$ 2$#'#')$6#>'#1%6">")"9+)# ( /D /= 69#1$"&&+)#( #1$

;

&'$#-&+,%)# 6+&#'

-%+$#')(+

'&'$)&- +)%(')#1$'6"&&+)#( . 69 #1$  (#"#$9$)#(    #1$  &92,"')")#  "(  >$,,  "(    #1$ 2$#'#')$66$&6%$%5-#1$,$"6)$%+%'&'","?'(#6"#$ ")%1$66$26#/'# &9$(+##1"#5#1#1$2"6#'$(1"3$3,+)#"6',-")%>'#1#1$'6 6$$&)($)# >'#1+#")-')%+&$9$)#/#16$"#6269'($/(6#$%+##1$'6%'(2+#$")%1"3$ $

$&#$%&9269'($1$21#&2- #1$&9269'($%$$%1"(",6$"%- 5$$)2,"&$%)6$&6%"())$F+6$

"8')?  ')#  &)('%$6"#')  #1$($  "&#(/  #1'( 
+6#  '(    #1$ 2')')#1"##1$+,#'9"#$&1")&$( &)3'&#') #1$2$#'#')$6"6$5,$"8 1$6$ 6$/#1$2$)%$)&- ")%&)#')+"#') #1$26&$$%')?(>+,% 5$"(1$$6"5+($ #1$26&$(( ,">

 1+(/')3'$> #1$ "&#+9 #1$&9269'($")%#1$,">,"'% %>)5-#1$)G5,$2$F
+6#")%",(#1$+,, #1'(
+6#') #1$&"($(6$ $66$%#"53$/#1'(2$#'#')'(1$6$5-",,>$%;

%"#$%  /6$?'(#$6$%+)%$6$&#')( ./;/;D /;D./;


"# ,'&$  #"#') 
'3',  E')$(/ 96'#("6 
'#-  ))$F+6$   !  ")%  ",,  #1$ &)($C+$)#26&$$%')?("6'(')?#1$6$ 69"6$1$6$5-C+"(1$% #1$&"($ 1"(",6$"%-5$$)%$&'%$%5-#1$#6'",
+6#/#1$)#1'(6%$6>',,5$ ) $

$&#