Pritpal Singh & ANR. v. The Central Admn. Trib. & ORS.


 

       


   

     

 

       

 

      


 

 !"
 # 

 

 !"
$ ! !"% !"#!"$#!"%&'(")"*#+!,&-'."$"/,$#"'0*#!"'0("+#1 "+



 

 



 







 

 2

  



 

 # 

&

!"3$0#/"#0#0,*"$+3!,40(&$"'5+$"+/,*'"*#+, 65*'7 $"+/"8#09"-:0*#!" $0(0*5-//-085#0,*40-"'.:535*;&)5$5##&."4,$" #!" "*#$5-')0*0+#$5#09"$0.&*5-<4,$+!,$#= => !5*'0(5$!"*8!

!59"/$5:"'4,$53$0#,4 "$#0,$5$04,$?&5+!0*(#!",$'"$'5#"'7  5*'$"90"3,$'"$'5#"'@ ,4#!" "*#$5-')0*0+#$5#09"$0.&*5-

!5*'0(5$!"*8!



535*  ;&)5$  5##&  $"+/,*'"*#  ,   !"$"0*  +,&(!#  4,$ ?&5+!0*(#!"/$,),#0,*($5*#"'0*#!"(&0+",4#!"$"90"3"/5$#)"*#5- $,),#0,* ,))0##""<4,$+!,$#= => "!5+5-+,/$5:"'4,$5'0$"8#0,* #,8,*+0'"$!0)4,$/$,),#0,*.:4$"+!

* 2 77 5 35+ !"-' 5*'  5+ 58,*+"?&"*8"A /"$+,*+3"$"/$,),#"'#,#!"/,+#,4++0+#5*#0$"8#,$ #0+*,#0*'0+/&#"


#!5#5+/"$ &-"+5*++0+#5*#30#!B:"5$+,4$"(&-5$+"$908"5*'5* 4408"

&/"$0*#"*'"*#30#!:"5$++"$908"5$""-0(0.-"4,$/$,),#0,*#,#!"/,+#,4 ++0+#5*#  0$"8#,$  #  0+  5*  5')0##"'  458#  #!5#  *,*"  ,4  #!"  ")/-,:""+ /$,),#"'#,#!"/,+#,4++0+#5*#0$"8#,$5+/"$ ,*2 7735+5 /5$#:#,#!"/$"+"*#85+"

*"$  ;

"!#540-"',$0(0*5-5//-085#0,*."4,$"#!"  ,'!/&$"*8!?&"+#0,*0*(#!"/$,),#0,*,4,*"$

5#!,$"

, $"+,-9"#!"'0+/&#"?&5 
 +"*0,$0#:5$"90"3 35+!"-' ,*  774,$,*-:,*"/,+#5*'$  ;

"!#535+/$,),#"'#,#!"/,+#,4 ++0+#5*#0$"8#,$  $

5#!,$"40-"',$0(0*5-5//-085#0,*."4,$"#!"

  ,'!/&$  "*8!  3!08!  '"8-5$"'  $

5#!,$"  +"*0,$  #, $ ;

"!#54,$#!"/,+#,4++0+#5*#0$"8#,$

,$"90"3#!" !"-'0*775*'775 35+!"-',*   #8,*+0'"$"'/$,),#0,*,4/"$+,*+#,#!"/,+#,4++0+#5*# 0$"8#,$ #0+*,#,&#,4/-58"#,)"*#0,*!"$"#!5#*,*",4#!")35+0* +"$908",$!,-'0*(#!"/,+#,45* 4408"&/"$0*#"*'"*#3!"*77 35+ 8,*'&8#"',*2 77 *#!"$"90"3 7 4408"&/"$0*#"*'"*#+5*'

/"$+,*+4$,)#!"85#"(,$:,4"*0,$C3"$"8,*+0'"$"' /"$+,*+ 3"$",$'"$"'#,."/$,),#"'5+/"$#!",$'"$5//"*'"'5+**"D&$"
B

"+/,*'"*#  ,   !"$"0*  /-"5'"'  #!5#  *,*"  ,4  #!"  /"$+,*+ /$,),#"'!5'?&5-04:0*(+"$908"4,$8,*+0'"$5#0,*,4#!"0$/$,),#0,*#,#!" /,+#,4++0+#5*#0$"8#,$ #0+4&$#!"$8,*#"*'"'.:$"+/,*'"*#, !"$"0* #!5# 85*0**,)5**"$."85--"'5$"90"3 5+*,*",4#!"

/"$+,*+/$,),#"'0*7735+8,*+0'"$"'5(50* #0+90$#&5--:54$"+!

0*3!08!$"+/,*'"*#, !5+5$0(!#,4."0*(8,*+0'"$"'/5$#08&-5$-:

A
."85&+"!"."-,*(+#,8!"'&-"' 5+#"85#"(,$:

!"$"4,$"!"!5+/$5:"'

4,$5'0$"8#0,*#,#!",440805-$"+/,*'"*#+#,8,*+0'"$!0+85*'0'5#&$"5*' /$,),#"!0)4$,)#!"'5#"!"."85)""-0(0.-"4,$/$,),#0,*5+++0+#5*# 0$"8#,$5(50*+##!"$"+"$9"'85#"(,$:/,+#.:8,*9"*0*(5$"90"3

30#!5--8,*+"?&"*#05-."*"40#+

@

!" ,'!/&$"*8!90'",$'"$'5#"'A 0*



, 27,477'0$"8#"'#!",440805-$"+/,*'"*#+#,8,*9"*"5$"90"3

4,$#!"/,+#,4,4408"&/"$0*#"*'"*#5*'++0+#5*#0$"8#,$5*'8,*+0'"$#!" 85*'0'5#&$",45--#!"#!$""/"$+,*+*5)"-:

5#!,$"

!5$#05*'

;

"!#54,$/$,),#0,*#,#!"/,+#,4,4408"&/"$0*#"*'"*#5*'++0+#5*# 0$"8#,$$"+/"8#09"-:5+/"$#!"+"*0,$0#:40D"'0*#"$)+,4'0$"8#0,*+0++&"' .:0#

+  /"$  #!"  $"-"95*#  *+#$&8#0,*+  0++&"'  .:  #!"  ,440805- $"+/,*'"*#+  #!"  $"90"3    )5:  ."  !"-'  30#!  #!"  5//$,95-  ,4  #!" 5//,0*#0*(&#!,$0#:#,$"8#04:&*0*#"*#0,*5-)0+#5E"+" (  5> 3!"$""-0(0.-",4408"$+3"$"*,#8,*+0'"$"'F,$ .> 3!"$"0*"-0(0.-",4408"$+3"$"8,*+0'"$"'.:)0+#5E"F,$ 8> 3!"$"#!"+"*0,$0#:!5+.""*$"90+"'30#!$"#$,+/"8#09""44"8# $"+&-#0*(0*595$05.-",4#!"+"*0,$0#:-0+#/-58"'."4,$"#!"  F,$ '> 3!"$"+,)"/$,8"'&$5-0$$"(&-5$0#:35+8,))0##"'.:5 ,$ "> 3!"$"5'9"$+"$")5$E+0*#!"

+3!"$"#&$*"'',3*54#"$ #!" !5'8,*+0'"$"'#!"85+"

&##!"/$,8""'0*(+,4$"90"3 4,$#!"/,+#,4++0+#5*#0$"8#,$!"-'5+

2
/"$  **"D&$"  
@  3,&-'  (,  #,  "+#5.-0+!  #!5#    ")/-,:""+  3!,+" 85*'0'5#&$"4,$/$,),#0,*35+*,#5#5--&*'"$8,*+0'"$5#0,*.:#!",$0(0*5-  3"$"8,*+0'"$"'.:$"90"3 5(50*+##!"5.,9"'0$"8#0,*,4#!"

,'!/&$"*8!5*'#!"$"-"95*#*+#$&8#0,*+0++&"'.:#!",440805- $"+/,*'"*#+5+$"(5$'+8,*+#0#&#0*(#!"$"90"3

+/"$ "8$&0#)"*# &-"+4,$#!"/,+# ,4D"8&#09" 5'$"

$,&/==4,&*'5//"*'"'0***"D&$"
A,*-: 4408"&/"$0*#"*'"*# 5*'"?&095-"*#30#!5#-"5+#:"5$+,4+"$908"0*#!"+85-",4
62
7 450-0*(3!08!&/"$0*#"*'"*#+30#!:"5$+,4+"$908"5*'B:"5$+8,).0*"' +"$908"5+&/"$0*#"*'"*#5*'++0+#5*#,$"?&095-"*#0*($5'"+5$""-0(0.-" 4,$/$,),#0,*#,#!"/,+#,4++0+#5*#0$"8#,$



"5$*"'8,&*+"-5//"5$0*(4,$#!"3$0#/"#0#0,*"$+'$530*(,&$ 5##"*#0,*#,#!"8,).0*"'+"*0,$0#:-0+#,44""'"$85'$"4,$#!"/,+#,4 ++0+#5*#  0$"8#,$  5+  ,*   77  4,&*'  5//"*'"'  5+  **"D&$"  
 +&.)0##"'#!5#+&44080"*#:"5$+,4+!,$#45--0*+"$908"!5'.""*"D")/#"'4,$ #!"3$0#/"#0#0,*"$+ 

*  5  /"$&+5-  ,4  #!"  5.,9"  ',8&)"*#  3"  40*'  #!5#  3$0# /"#0#0,*"$$0#/5-0*(!%,0*"'#!"+"$908"5+5*++0+#5*#,*-:,* 7B6

48,&$+":"5$+@),*#!+="D")/#0,*#,35$'++!,$#45--35+(09"*#,!0)

!",#!"$3$0#/"#0#0,*"$*5)"-:*0-;&)5$%,0*"'5+++0+#5*#,*-:,* 7B@ "!5+.""*(09"*A:"5$+@),*#!+="D")/#0,*#,)5E"&/#!" +!,$#45--0* +"$908"

"+/0#"+&8!"D")/#0,*(09"*#,35$'++!,$#45--,4 +"$908"#!"/"#0#0,*"$+!59"*,#8,)/-"#"'#!"$"?&0$"':"5$+,4+"$908"5+ ,*#!"'5#",4,$0(0*5- 3!08!35+8,*+#0#&#"',*2 77 

!"-"5$*"'8,&*+"-5//"5$0*(4,$$"+/,*'"*#, 0*#!"-0(!#


,4#!"5.,9"!5+$0(!#-:8,*#"*'"'#!5##!"3$0#/"#0#0,*"$+3!,!5'*,# "9"*8,)/-"#"':"5$+,4$"?&0$"'+"$908"4,$/$,),#0,*#,#!"/,+#,4 ++0+#5*#0$"8#,$5+,*#!"'5#"3!"*,$0(0*5- 35+8,*+#0#&#"'3"$"

8,*+0'"$"'4,$/$,),#0,*0*#!"$"90"3



"5$",4#!"8,*+0'"$"'90"3#!5#$"90"3 !5+8,*+0'"$"'

#!"85*'0'5#"+3!,3"$"*,#"9"*"-0(0.-"4,$/$,),#0,*5##!"#0)"3!"* #!",$0(0*5-  35+ 8,*+#0#&#"'

 &$#!"$#!"$"90"3 !5+ (,*"

.":,*'0#+%&$0+'08#0,*#!$,30*(#,30*'+#!"*+#$&8#0,*+0++&"'.:#!" ,440805- $"+/,*'"*#+ 5*' #!"+/"80408'0$"8#0,*  0++&"' .: ,'!/&$ "*8!#,8,*+0'"$,*-:#!$""85*'0'5#"+4,$/$,),#0,*0*#!"$"90"3

"+/,*'"*#  ,   !"$"0*  !5+  /&#  0*  $"?&0$"'  +"$908"  4,$  /$,),#0,*

"*0,$0#:-0+#,4#!" 4408"&/"$0*#"*'"*#+5-+,!5+*,#.""*40*5-0G"'.: #!",440805-$"+/,*'"*#+ !"$"4,$"#!"-"5$*"'  !5*'0(5$!"*8!!5+ $0(!#-:/5++"'#!"0)/&(*"',$'"$#5E0*(0*#,588,&*##!"-5/+",*#!"/5$# ,4#!",440805-$"+/,*'"*#+0**,#40*5-0G0*(#!"+"*0,$0#:-0+# ,4 4408"

&/"$0*#"*'"*#+5*'#!"/$,),#0,*+0--"(5--:(09"*#,/$095#"$"+/,*'"*#+ , 2#,@0*#!" $0(0*5-//-085#0,*40-"'."4,$"0# !"$"0+*,)"$0#0*#!"

3$0#/"#0#0,*5*'#!"+5)"+#5*'+'0+)0++"'

  # 

  $%

  &(&+# $ ! !"% &-5#0  $%