High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11571/2007dismissed

Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti v. N.K. Bhalla And ORS.

2015-08-26Bench- 4,Registrar-Judicial5 pages

# "#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 $-

$ % ,.(&4.,-2)$&$)52$6%#$6&2%1$%2%2.,47,,.%0$)2-+2--$)72,8&(4%(.(-'(-%0$47(-$%#$&$-1.,)$,%-.7,)#75$-(1$&7,,(7%$) 8&.+-$&524$2,7-+(4#7-%#$1$%2%2.,$&#7-&72-$)4.,%$,%2.(-2--($-%.0$ )$%$&+2,$)2,%#$6&2%1$%2%2., #$711/247%2.,-%7,)-)2-+2--$)

$-1.,)$,%.75.)7:7 2):7/7:77+2%22,%#$.&2*2,7/ 711/247%2.,0$8.&$%#$ $,%&7/)+2,2-%&7%25$&20(,7/ #7,)2*7&#$,4# ;8.&-#.&%<&20(,7/<=7**&2$5$)0:%#$.&)$&17--$)0:%#$&20(,7/2,875.(& .8&$-1.,)$,%. #7//7#$&$2,>(7-#2,*%#$-$,2.&2%:/2-%;,,$?(&$

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

,71$&(-7/.8%#$82,7/-$,2.&2%:/2-%.8 8824$&-2,%#$*&7)$.8 &2,4217/7-.,9@@2%2-8.(,)%#7%&$-1.,)$,%. #7//7#70$$,-#.6,7%.C@%7D2,*2,%.4.,-2)$&7%2.,%#$)7%$.8#2-'.2,2,* )(%:.,)2&$4%&$4&(2%+$,%.,@B@7,)&$-1.,)$,%.

#7&+7 #7-0$$,-#.6,7%.@98&.+@@%#$)7%$.,6#24##$&$-2*,$)#21.-2%2.,0$8.&$744$1%2,*%#$1.-%.8&2,4217/.,)$1(%7%2., ,52$6.8%#$70.5$)$5$/.1+$,%2,%#2-47-$6$7&$.8%#$ 4.,-2)$&$)52$6%#7%82&-%/2+0.8%#$&$/2$8*&7,%$)%.&$-1.,)$,%.#70$$,4.+1/2$)62%#0:%#$6&2%1$%2%2.,$&#$&$8.&$%#$6&2%1$%2%2.,>(7 %#$82&-%&$/2$8*&7,%$)%.&$-1.,)$,%.#7-0$4.+$2,8&(4%(.(- #$&20(,7/#7-*&7,%$)7//%#$4.,-$>($,%27/0$,$82%-52-7 52-4.,-2)$&7%2.,.8%#$4/72+.8&$-1.,)$,%,.8.&1&.+.%2.,%.%#$

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

,71$&(-7/.8%#$.&)$&17--$)0:%#$&20(,7/2%711$7&-%#7%2%#7- -2+1/:0&(-#$)7-2)$%#$-$&2.(-7&*(+$,%>(7,.,2+1/$7)+$,% %#7- -2+1/:.0-$&5$)%#7%&$-1.,)$,%.#7-78%$&7//4#.-$,%.2+1/$7) E&$-1.,)$,%-.C%.F ,%#$70.5$074D*&.(,)/$7&,$)4.(,-$/711$7&2,*8.&%#$6&2% 1$%2%2.,$& 5$#$+$,%/: 4.,%$,)$) %#7% &$-1.,)$,% . )2) ,.% 4/72+ -$,2.&2%: .,/: 7*72,-% &$-1.,)$,% . 7,) %#$ 4.,-$>($,%27/ 0$,$82%- 8/.6$)%#$&$8&.+A1$&-.,-6.(/)0$788$4%$)284.,-$>($,%27/0$,$82%-%. &$-1.,)$,%.7--.(*#%8.&0:#2+2-*&7,%$)2%67-8(&%#$&-(0+2%%$) /$7&,$) 4.(,-$/ 711$7&2,* 8.& &$-1.,)$,% . 4.,%$,)$)%#7%2%67-.,/:&$-1.,)$,%-.C%.2,%#$6&2%1$%2%2.,6#. 6.(/)#75$0$$,788$4%$)0:%#$&$/2$8.84.,-$>($,%27/0$,$82%*&7,%$)0:

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

&2*2,7/ 711/247%2., #$ 47,,.% 0$ 7//.6$) %. *$% 767: 62%# -(4# &$/2$8 .

4.,-$>($,%27/0$,$82%0$#2,)%#$074D.8.%#$&$/2*20/$1$&-.,-#$&$8.&$ %#$-$4.,)/2+0.8%#$&$/2$8.84.,-$>($,%27/0$,$82%-%.&$-1.,)$,%. )2&$4%2,*4.,-2)$&7%2.,.8#2-4/72+8.&1&.+.%2.,%.%#$1.-%.8--2-%7,% 2&$4%.&6$89A@@7,)$1(%:2&$4%.&6$8@@8&.+%#$)7%$- 6#$,&$-1.,)$,%.67-*&7,%$)%#.-$1&.+.%2.,--%7,)--$%7-2)$ C

.,-$>($,%/:%#$6&2%1$%2%2.,>(7%#$82&-%&$/2$8*&7,%$)0:%#$ &20(,7/-%7,)-)2-+2--$)7-2,8&(4%(.(-7,)%#$-$4.,)/2+0.8&$/2$8 *&7,%$)0:%#$&20(,7/2--$%7-2)$7,)%#$6&2%1$%2%2.,>(7%#7%&$/2$827//.6$)

(*(-% "

# (/7%2