High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/991/2019dismissed

Kamlesh Rani v. Vijay Munjal And ANR

2023-01-18Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra16 pages

"#$% #& ' $ ( (

) *+(+ ) *+(++

!!!

+ ,(

" #$

%

&

' #$

%

" ' ( )

*

"

''

( + (,

,('

+

+

- ./0* #1*2

- *3#

( .123.1/ 4+

"

5 ' (

0

#$ 1* #1*$( + #

"(

('

(

- *6* - + ,('

** 1.

#11$

( 7 ' (5 ()

'

*$ #1*1 9 ( '( '

#:

1.

#1*1 "

12 #1*8

81 )*: **

'

(

'

"

' '

'

4' 1$ ** #1*8 - * ' ( ,(' (

'

; ,

<

'

; 0 % , '

;

< ** ** #1*8 0 '

- #0 '

< ) %" < ,(' '

( % ' 4 ' 0 '' % '

'%

(5 % '

0

'

'

('' ' (

'

( "

'

0 '

( 5 )

0 (

( '%

< *$ 1# #1*2 7' ,(' '

" %

-

< (

(

*$ 1.

#1*.

( *#10= 2#1 2/6 2/:

26* .12 .1/ 4+ " ''

>0* 7

>0#

+% (

,('

>027 ( ' >08 4 ?) >*@ )

?) >#@= ' )(

(7 >#@+ )

?) >#@, )

?) >#@? '

( ) (

0

?) >8@ ((

?) >8@= ?) >8@+

(( ?) >8@,

.

*8 #1*:

' 0

( *#10 = 2#1 2/6 2/:

26*3.1/ 4+ " /

>02 7

' 0)

( ?) 0$

#* 1.

#1*:

+

- *2 #1*/

?) 0*1

+

- *2 #1*/ ?) 0

.

**

1$ 1.

#1*6

+

- #81 #1*2

?) 0*#

(

?) 0 *8

+

- #81 #1*2 ' 8*8 + + '

(

)

,>* 4

' ?) ,>*@

'

( ( ( 0 '

#* 1/ #1*/

?) ,*

&4 - *$.*8 1/ #1*2

0 ?) ,0#

&4 - *$.*8 1/ #1*2 ?) ,08

%A '

(' (, 18 ** #1*/ %;

:

(( + 5

( @

%

$

4' ( +

5

" (' (

" +

"''

/

'

(%

( %

(

' ( ( 0 " '' 0

?) >#@? (

( "

(

" '

( + '

( ' (( '

('

*1

>

( (

B (

=

( '( ' ('

5 ( + 4 0

$"0#1'3(+"

"#$%4

"

C#116D2 ++ 2*.

9 E( ) + ( (

5 (

1'"67

(

((

( ( + F'

+#&$

5

'% (

( + "9 E(

)+ '

' +'

'

5

'

'0

+ ' '

' 5

" + +

) '

+ ( '

( 5 '

+ (

5 (

4 ' ( ( ( + (

5 ( +

**

( "6#73(+"

"#$%(( *$..+:16G0#1 40 9 3(+"

"#$%+ :1 '0"1

4 *$./+ #*6G 9#'0

;:6 6 $'0 3(+"

"#$%:8 "

*$$/++C+ D$6#G + 0:+

+ <03(+"

"#$%((

$"0#1'

#1*/C#D + C+

D 8*$3 +"

"#$% '0"1 3( = 6#09

;:6 #1*2C6D++ C+

D* '

'( '

'('

5

+'5 % '5 '

+'('

(

( 4' +

5

'' ' ( ' +( ((

5 +'

' ) '

*#

-' %

(

'

( '(

5 (' H" ( @

'

** ** #1*8 % " < ,(' )

'

( % ' '% (5 % '(

'

( '' ' '

(

'

( " ( 0

( *#10= 2#1 2/6 2/:

26* .1/ 4+ F

5

2*. 4+ ' (

(

G

(

(

' ' G

( ' %

(

*8

2#1 4+'

'(

G% G' ( G

'

' (

( -'%

( '

(

H < ''

>0*7

>0#

+ ,(' +% (

,(' >0*7

?) >0*@ ?) >0*@9 '

(

- *6*'

'

(

'

- "

F >0#

?) >0#@ (

- *6* > - $

*1:

88

** 1.

#11$ ?) >0#@=' '

( )(

>027 (

?) >0#@+#:

1.

#1*1)(

' 7

'

-

.2 */ (

- *6* ?) >0#@?** ** #1*8'

()

(

.2 */5 (

- *6* " (

- *6*

*1:

88( ?) >#@

.2 */

?) >0#@+

.2 */5 ''

( ?) >0#@?

" '

(

(>027 " >02

'

( ( '

' ' ?) >0#@?')

0 ( ' ' )

( (

( ( ) *2

&

( (

?

'

' (

,(' *1 ** #1*8 ( )

('

"

( ( ( (

( )?) >0#@?

" ':

('

9

' ?) >0#@= ( (

- *6* ?) >0#@ (

( (

- )' ?) >0#@=I

(7

,('

(

' ' ( (

,(' ) ?) >0#@?'( (

( %

** ** #1*8

" (

' (

( %

' (% ?) >0#@?

'

( (

'

'

9

'

( ' ( (0

'

( ( "

'

(

( (0

4 ' '

' ) ' 5

'

'

'

( 9 6

#<:9> ?"01$:<0*1'3(+0 9 $0(> ?"01$:<0*1'(

$"0#1

#1*$C*D + C+

D8:6'

9 E(+(

)

'

' )

'

'

'' '

1#9+ <0

$"0#1'3( 1;

6

$"0#1'

#11/C8D + C+

D8:* 3 ;:6 0 9

$"0#1'3(+5(;:6@ ;

1

$"0#1'

#11$C#D

)+ C+D.*:

( A 9 0

0#3 1&0

$"0#1'3(

"5

"0 8$$ #11$ C#D + C+

D68:'

'

'

4 '

( '

'

(+:6

+ <03(+9"( 64 :1 #1**C#D F #.$'

'(+

= +

(

'

( "

(

(

,('

( %

?) >0#@?

(

,(' (

( ' % '

' ' (

"( ' (

' ' ')( < ( ' ( (

"

'

(

'

((' ) ?) >0#@?

*.

( 2/6 2/: 26* 4+

2/8 4+ 4 E E

4 (

( ( */

4 ' ' (

"

' % ( ( '

2/2 4+

4 '

( )(

-

'

( )

( B( G G(

(

4 '

) '

(( '

)( ' % ' '

) ) ?) >0#@?

' '5 ' '

2/2 4+( (

9' (

*6

" ' 5

( 2/6

2/: 26* 4+ "

( 2/6 2/: 26* 4+

2/6 4+ ( ' 2/: 4+ '

'

26* 4+

'

(

( (

)

.

(

(

"

( 2/6 2/: 26* 4+ (

+

(('

(

*:

.1/ 4+ ( 5 "

*$ 1# #1*2

(

( ()

%

4 '

9'

.1/ 4+ '5 '

G '

' ' ( "

.1/ 4+ '

4

"( ''

) '

? .1/ 4+ (% '

( '''

4

(

/

' ( 0 ( 4 ' '

( )

( %

( ( .1/ 4+ ( ( +5

( .1/ 4+ ((

(

*$

-

( (

#1

"%

(

'

+

'

(

( +

'

( &

> ?

>+ ?

( ( >%

@ ;@- >( ;@-